Chamberlain actively fights all attempts at third parties buildnig tools to control/monitor/use their garage door openers so they can sell subscriptions.
Giving them money in the first place is a horrible idea.
I wonder why they spend the effort. It seems like the people willing to pay and people willing to hack are different. With the hackers be a small group anyway
Same reason any other company lawyers up when a handful of nerds modify the hardware they bought and own - it gets some suity dude's nose out of joint.
They're asking for legislation to address their predatory practices about as hard as you can. If I buy a garage door opener I should own access to it without the bullshit.
Had to get a new garage door opener because the old one stopped working. Got a MyQ opener because it seemed like an excellent choice. Now my car wants me to pay for a subscription to open the door and the remotes that came with the damn thing have super-short range.
On top of that I live less than a mile from an airport directly in the descent path so there is basically 0 mobile service at my home. Often the MyQ app fails to function at all.
My old garage door opener got the damn thing open every time without issue. Would love to have it back.
If your vehicle has HomeLink or can get it installed it should work with even the new MyQ garage openers. I had one installed on my Tesla for my garage opener.
I did the first one. AFAIK it doesn't quite work with all garage door openers because they started using special switches that don't just close the circuit.
Sometimes you get what the installer has in stock, I didn’t really “pick” Chamberlain, it’s just what the guy put in when I paid him to “fix my garage door”. For a lot of other people it’s just what comes with the house.
The correct answer is to just let your garage door opener be dumb, and buy a RatGDO, which works with any dumb opener including chamberlains: https://ratcloud.llc/
I like to think chamberlain sells their openers at a slightly lower price than they otherwise would, hoping to recover it on subscriptions. So by buying their opener plus a RatGDO, I’m hurting their bottom line just a tiny amount. It makes me feel good at least.
Unfortunately Chamberlain Security + 3.0 openers are not supported. If I ever need to replace my current garage door opener I will be looking for a non-Chamberlain product.
Unfortunately new chamberlains now come with Security 3.0, which is designed to lock out ratgdo and everything else, probably forever. So you’re kind of screwed if you’ve bought one recently.
I never understand the appeal of RatGDO. You can find other tools like Shelly 1 that can be easily integrated into your existing Zigbee/Matter ecosystem, or part of the Home Assistant via the HTTP interface, and they are much cheaper with proper UL certification.
The appeal of RatGDO is the ability to look at my Home Assistant dashboard and see the exact metrics of my garage door, even when I'm not home. It really solves that "Did I forget to close the door when I left" scenario. I can also issue commands that set it to a specific state. If the door is closed, I can say "close the door" and nothing happens.
The Shelly works as a great remote "I pushed the button to toggle the door" device. But did the door actually close? What if the door was already closed, now I've just opened it, how would I know?
If your goal is to simply replace the remote that you would use and only operate the door while it is in line of sight, then the Shelly is fine. And if your use case doesn't ever leave you needing to operate the door out of line of sight, then that's great, but there are other use cases that do warrant being able to validate the current state of the door beyond just a button press toggle.
You don’t have to buy the expensive official ratgdo device. The ratgdo software is free and you can build a small PCB for a few bucks plus the cost of the ESP32 and a couple of components. My house unfortunately came with MyQ openers so that’s what I’m doing.
there are no workarounds or options for their new security 3.0 models, you are just screwed. Their subscription or nothing. Just dont buy a Chamberlain/liftmaster.
Guess why this happened, to a brand with a previously stellar reputation? yep they got bought by PE.
I have a large woodworking and metalworking shop behind my single family home.
I have a transformer that serves only my shop :)
I use 800 amps of single phase inverted into 200 amps of 480v 3 phase (the rest of the single phase is for the house and apartment above the shop)
I have 200kwh of battery as well.
This is definitely on the extreme side, but most woodworkers (and metalworkers) i know use 50kw total easily within their single family home garages. Once you get past portable tools, they really don't make tools with less than a 5hp motor because it would be more expensive and annoying.
ok but how much you actually use ? Even if every tool is 10kW (which would be pretty fucking powerful), you're using maybe that, few kW for dust extractor and waht else ?
Unless you have employees (and at that point, not really a house but business), how ?
Lawyer here - I actually would bet this is not the case. Whether he came clean or not, the 2nd affair with a subordinate is basically always a firing offense under the sexual harassment and/or code of conduct policy, whether you are a CEO or not.
The lies may be part of it, but if you didn't fire them for the COC/SH violation, you would be in for near infinite liability because it ends up as evidence that the culture from the top was tolerant of violations, etc. THis is not conjecture, it's what has basically always happened in the legal realm when companies try to work around it.
> the 2nd affair with a subordinate is basically always a firing offense under the sexual harassment and/or code of conduct policy, whether you are a CEO or not.
In my company, it's explicitly not forbidden, but the relationship has to be disclosed to HR early on (source: yearly training). That being said, I'm not sure what HR is going to do with the information.
HR will use the information to ensure the two are not subordinate to one another. Example: A is dating B at the same company. HR will make sure that A is not subordinate to B and vice versa. This will reduce conflict of interest.
You have a high opinion of HR. Often one or both are dumped for violating employment agreements.. making HR and the company's life easier with the least effort.
Not disclosing is generally what violates the employment agreements. Most companies realize that relationships happen at work A LOT. Disclosing allows the companies to make sure they avoid any power dynamic issues. I've known many people across many companies who met their future spouses at work.
It looks like there are no laws that restrict US companies from prohibiting romantic relationships between co-workers. (In reverse: US companies are allowed to prohibit romantic relationships between co-workers.) The practicality: If you did restrict it in employee rules, probably people would do it anyway in secret. It is better for HR to know so they can make sure there isn't a supervisory conflict.
If prohibited and they do it in secret, then you have a free fireable offense in your pocket. Some employers like to have a stick ready to use on a whim.
At all of the companies where I have worked, the rule was only about direct subordinates. That means you can date your boss two levels above! If practice, if you started dating your immediate supervisor, HR would just change your supervisor. Literally, this has been explained to me multiple times during HR onboarding.
That said, Kimberly Powell (former Vice President of Healthcare at Nvidia), reported directly to Jensen Huang. That is a big no-no, probably enough to be demoted and/or fired, especially as CEO.
Disclosing your secret affair to HR would be a hilarious move...
HR of course has no particular duty to out him to Mrs Huang. However, on the other hand, anyone with access to this personnel record, so long as the affair remains undiscovered, has an extremely inappropriate piece of kompromat against the CEO of a trillion dollar company. Maybe that's a small list of people but it seems like a terrible amount of power, to the point I don't think I'd be comfortable with anyone having this piece of information in their heads, let alone on a "consensual relationship disclosure form" Docusign.
Not fire you. It gives them the ability to fire the others who aren’t forthcoming.
I suppose this way they can warn you to date people who are not direct reports… which hopefully you are not doing. Or offer you options (being transferred).
Knowingly allowing ongoing misconduct or consciously ignoring resulting harm is considered bad faith
Protecting the CEO for the directors’ own interest is considered a loyalty problem.
Both of these things would make them personally liable in a shareholder derivative lawsuit.
California permits personal liability for directors perpetrating harassment and prohibits aiding or abetting prohibited conduct.
That's the directors.
Company wise - actions by the CEO are generally imputable directly to the company. This leads to potential hostile-environment claims even by employees who never had a relationship with the CEO, and those claims have been particularly cognizable in California.
Non-termination is also likely to lead to punitive damages, because it will be seen as "malice" or "reckless indifference".
Value wise - sexual harassment verdicts - depends who sued, but probably <150 million to start, long term cost maybe a billion very worst case.
Shareholder derivative lawsuits (where directors are personally liable if they end up with a finding of bad faith) - insanely more - hundreds of millions to billions.
In the US maybe. In France there is zero chance for this happening as your love life has nothing to do with the pro one.
If there are professional effects (promotions, raises, ...) then off course there are consequences. Not different from the case where you are a close friend.
I once owned an LP by Dr. John where he sang "Woman is the root of all evil. Money is bad but it's legal" :-)
He of course didn't mean women per se are evil, but that "affairs" with them are. Just his opinion.
Too much money is bad for most people, it corrupts their morality. But money is legal. It doesn't get you fired. You will have many friends because of it. You can get away with a lot of things with high-priced lawyers.
Generally I don't most handbooks have affair with a customer as being an offense. Arguably, that is just good business. On the other hand, having an affair with a vendor would be a problem.
Isn’t musk a clear counterexample here? He has had numerous liaisons with subordinates. Yet I haven’t seen either SpaceX or Tesla (who actually could) move to fire him.
Or is he the exception?
It's entirely up to company policy. Nvidia had no policy barring personal relationships among employees. When it's a direct report it creates some risk that staffers will claim coercion or favoritism. For many companies, that risk is too high to allow, but I've worked for publicly traded companies where that sort of thing happened openly.
Some people get to have affairs with subordinates, others don't. It's a question of if they have the support of the people pulling the levers or not as to whether it's considered acceptable. Universal rules are for little people, once beyond a certain position they are merely tools for selectively shutting out opposition.
Google was a clusterfuck (literally?) of people boning other people they shouldn't have been.
It's not really a counterexample, though, because most of the people in question are no longer there, and lost their jobs over their affairs. As far as I've heard, Sundar is pretty clean, almost robotic, and has a low-profile personal life. He is the polar opposite in that regard of Sergey (who was a walking HR violation) and Eric (whose NDA-bound mistresses are legendary across Silicon Valley). Much of the reason why they have stepped back from operating roles and fucked off to being class-B shareholders only is because their personal lives are a liability to a major company operating in the environment that Google does today.
DannyBee is undoubtedly well aware of that, having been a lawyer for Google during the time period when this went down.
Yes, I was aware of DannyBee's history, which is why I chose that example.
Sundar always looked to me like he used Andy Rubin's similar habits to finally push him out of the door, and then institutionalized using accusations of this nature as a weapon against everyone below. Obviously Sergey escaped by virtue of ascending to a higher level.
I hope you understand the affair with the spy does not strictly matter, but he is in fact being fired because of the affair with a subordinate.
Like everyone, they have a COC/sexual harassment policy, and that is basically always a firing offense in practice.
They cannot place him above it, or else they would be in for infinite liability.
This is why literally nothing mentioned firing until that was discovered, and then it instantly became about firing him.
Because they have other things to worry about. Certainly you realize how privileged a world you have to live in to be able to spend time worrying about whether your TV is spying on you, right?
You put those things in the same sentence but they don't even remotely carry the same weight. People are sick and dying and have to weigh weather or not they want to declare bankruptcy or go to the doctor. Or buy their medication vs buying food. Their TV serving them directed ads isn't even in the same universe.
Ok sure, but if you're going to play that card, then you have to also say that they can and should recognize that those "other" things are often also symptoms of the same disease.
People are capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time (and they are capable of placing appropriate energy towards the walking to not trip because they were too focused on the gum chewing...)
I'n not "playing that card", i'm explaining that the "because the news is in bed with them" is not even close to a major reason why they don't care. You are correct they can walk and chew gum, but maybe not spin 1000 plates in the air at once.
When people have tons of things to deal with, this falls by the wayside, news or not.
When they don't, sure, maybe the news would matter more.
On the flipside, how fucked up the world is that TVs spying on you had become normalized.
The problem isn't with people being too busy, it shouldn't be up to the people, it should be a government regulation problem. There's a lot of 'todo' around potential breaches of PII, so why not do something about the ridiculously large and seemingly increasing trade in exactly that from almost anything you purchase nowadays, including the place you purchase it from. And they're all selling it to aggregators and advertisers and any other shady c*nt with enough cash to buy it.
... and now it's all going to be fed into AI for additional pattern matching and de-aggregation and re-identification, because that's where the return on investment is. And once it's in there, there ain't no cleaning it out again. You're in the corpus, all your personality fingerprints, forever.
Gross governmental negligence across the entire West.
The news? Or the underprivileged? The news doesn’t cater to the underprivileged in general, and might well be “in bed with” companies on this point.
It’s curious this ritual of relatively well-off individuals—and your bio supports that theory—pointing fingers at each other for having privilege. Certainly when they are talking about a topic that affects everyone with a TV, not whatever people of their means get up to that the underprivilged don’t.
People who care could do the work for all of us. It’s not like everyone needs to care about surveillance in television gadgets in order to make a difference.
Or, you know, not necessarily that focused. The comment you are replying to just said that the news are in bed with companies. That often generalizes beyond tech gadgets.
The main thing about LFP is people (stupidly) shove them in a basement or enclosed space because they are "safe".
But the "safe" part is that they outgas hydrogen when in thermal runaway, which, combined with enclosed spaces like basements (where people often have gas heaters or ....), is .... a super super bad idea.
Ironically, in this situation, sodium-ion is worse than LFP in almost every conceivable way - the gas is more flammable, toxic, etc.
People who think sodium-ion is "safer" are being sold a bill of goods.
There are many alternative materials for the cathodes of sodium-ion batteries and for now the industry has not settled on one of them as being the best.
The safety properties depend on the cathodic material. The vented gas can be toxic only for one class of materials (Prussian blue analogs) and IIRC none of the currently existing commercial sodium-ion batteries uses this kind of cathodes.
For the other cathode types, the vented gas is hydrogen exactly like in almost any kind of battery, and it is equally flammable for all kinds of batteries.
In the article linked above, the conclusion was that for one kind of cathodic materials, which perhaps is the one used in most currently existing sodium-ion batteries, the risk of damaging the battery by overcharging and the risk of thermal runaway (assuming that the battery management system fails to prevent these), are slightly higher than for LFP but lower than for other lithium-ion batteries.
On the other hand, mechanical damage by puncturing the batteries is less dangerous than for any lithium-ion batteries.
These conclusions are not definitive about sodium-ion batteries, because other cathodic materials will behave differently, and there is still a lot of experience to gain with sodium-ion batteries, so it is certain that the cathodic materials used in 2030 will not be the same as today.
They really got it right on multiple levels - for those who don't know, roller coaster tycoon was infamously written in 99% assembly and meticulously optimized by the developer to run effectively in 16 megabytes of ram.
A lot of cars companies restrict who can buy parts and what parts. For example if you want to buy the rear quarter panel for a Rivian you must be an approved repair shop and they will only allow so many in a given area. This is not specific to rivian. Lots of car companies do this with newer models. I have a friend who runs a high end repair shop and another who does restoration and the one who does Mercedes restoration won’t work on cars newer than x because he can’t get parts
Sounds like the smart move is to continue to ignore EV only and Luxury brands and continue buying from OEM's of the past that happen to have EV models and better supply chains for parts.
I'm not gonna buy a car that doesn't have a dealer network. Being able to go in person and complain when shit hits the fan is a requirement.
Uh it absolutely is a concern and a responsibility . Different knives are made the way they are precisely to avoid people cutting themselves accidentally during various kinds of cutting motions. Additionally blunt knives are significantly more dangerous than sharp ones which is why they don't ship blunt ones.
Maybe before trying to go off half assed exactly like this outrage website does, you should take 5 minutes to be bothered to see if what you are saying is even mildly correct. Even five seconds of searching would tell you pretty much everything you wrote is wrong.
Lots of things are compromises intended to serve multiple goals rather than just drive one particular goal to the extreme. In that sense knives are exactly like what is happening here. You may not like that. But it is at least accurate, unlike what you wrote
I’ve never made 225k in my life. And I still have more in common with someone getting paid 500k a year than I do with the people who appear literally untouchable
Giving them money in the first place is a horrible idea.
reply