HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | westoque's commentslogin

i think the author presents weak arguments:

> AI models were trained on a massive corpus of Open Source

using open source shouldn't require the final product to be open source. that's pretty much most of proprietary software. most of it is built using open source code but the final product is due to a combination of thoughtful product and software knowledge and must be private since it's really the value you produce.

> purely AI-generated code is not written by a human, meaning it should not be copyrightable.

you can say AI generated code is based on human code, and that human code is open source. depending on the license (likely MIT) its technically legal to choose the generated code to be private.

> To make things fair across all jurisdictions, and to honor the open ecosystem that made AI possible, developers and companies should explicitly release AI-generated code under Open Source licenses or dedicate it to the public domain using the Creative Commons Zero (CC0) license.

i somewhat agree here. AI generated code should include the original license of its authors unless it's purely AI generated using original variable names.

i previously released AI generated products/software as open source but come to think of it, in the world of abundant software, i believe there's more reason to actually privatize your code vs putting it out in the public. especially for paid software products.


> It absolutely is a harmless feature that you can ignore. There’s no reason not to have one

what i've learning developing and creating products over the years is that harmless features tend to be the ones that cause the most problems. for ex, now you have to add touchscreen code to the OS vs previously not having it at all. and this code or feature we will support for the rest of the lifetime of that product.


While I agree with you in many cases in concept, I think it's also possible to erroneously avoid features by being too afraid of this.

In the case of touch screens, it hasn't caused a lasting problem in Windows or Linux.


Why would the app developer have to add touch screen code????


from the project https://github.com/antirez/ds4 it was said that:

> It must be more a working template for the biggest use cases, without trying to cover every possible setup.

this is such a great quote about building software in the AI age. given that everyone has a different use case, the best way for open source software to be built is to build it for the general use case and specialization could be done afterwards.


funny anecdote. i was traveling in europe around 2011 and i was staying at a hostel. the hostel had a session where all the travelers go in a circle and introduce themselves. i mentioned i was from "america" and this south american lady got triggered and said "you know there's also SOUTH america right?" and after that i never used the word america anymore and just say i'm from the USA.


not a fan of README's where there's no clear way to run the program, like a getting started or how to build. i think this is the opposite of a docu-monster where AI documents everything, but clearly more documentation is better than lack of.


I came to say the same thing. Zero info about how I would use this once it’s cloned.


It’s a library and there are usage examples.

> but clearly more documentation is better than lack of

I tend to disagree. This makes it very high signal. So far my agent has been successful at navigating the repo.


> But like every habit, the only thing you have to do is to keep at it. And if you pay enough attention to it, something will click in your brain.

a bad habit i noticed after taking hiatus of focused work was me jumping into different windows and tabs and just mindlessly consuming content without finishing them. after noticing this pattern, i decided i will focus on one task at a time and finishing it, like reading the OPs article. it did wonders for me and i noticed i'm now even more focused that ever. the lesson is indeed being aware first, and then practicing the habit.


I have this same problem. I am not sure if medication will help but I really don't want to go there. My brain is a scattered mess. Even now, I am doing 3 other things at the same time. Is it a matter of "getting good" and just focus? I just don't think there's a secret technique to this.


I think a lot of people struggle with this. Technical work already promoted this kind of behavior since it rewards a very heavy "just in time" lookup style for finding information (we've all had hundreds of chrome tabs open at work before, right?)

And on top of that work chat

And now agents, which are basically all designed for you to spin up several different conversation threads and hop between them constantly while the agent works.

It's no wonder people can't focus. Both work and leisure are basically designed to split up your attention into microscopic fragments.


I see the same pattern with people on their phones. Opening up an app, immediately switching to the next app, repeat.


ok. a similar idea, you should put a camera outside your door and do the same for passing dogs.


[flagged]

Please don't do this here.


German engineering at its finest.


my idea of de-brainrot is by going to destinations where everything is new and experiencing everything there physically & mentally. either going to a new city or drive to a new place. i'm not sure if it's anecdotal but there's a feeling of astonishment when experiencing a new place. i find that when you go back you have this new perspective and you feel refreshed.


I have experienced a similar feeling. Often I will dream of the newly "mapped" area once I arrive home (with cartoonish/dreamlike elements that are far from perfect). After I awake from this dream I feel likewise refreshed.


with agent loops, the cost of exposing bugs should be cheap now. every pen tester should be using agent loops and on the flip side, an agent could easily see this issue once filed and a fix immediately done. it's incredible how cheap code is now.


this is exactly my setup! the ipad pro 11 m5 cellular is such an amazing device especially with the 5G. only downside is obv the iPadOS, it's still very limiting and shortcuts and power tools (like easily prefilling passwords) are non-existent. for passwords, you still have to manually click the pre-fill and/or enable full keyboard to be able to tab into it but still annoying.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: