HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | rienbdj's commentslogin

Speed and correctness, choose 2

Feels like collectively we are under indexing on LLMs as user interfaces. I use a CLI with an agent to things I once did in a GUI. Your neighbors should never have to worry about zip files again.

Exactly!

I said it two years ago already: An LLM is the perfect user interface.

The problem though: It will make it a lot easier to do harder things which will devaluate jobs.


having to write "hey LLM-du-jour please unpack these files!" os strictly less efficient/more time consuming than clicking "extract" on a menu. I have hard time what usecase you have in your mind. (Unless the user is blind that is)

I'm sorry but if somebody born in the 1980s cannot or will not double click on a zip file to open it they also cannot or will not ask Claude to open it for them.

Claude’s personality is the worst aspect of the product!

Disagree but I don’t think this negates my point

Those cost is one thing but security is a huge issue too. Agents in their current incarnation leak data all over the place.

Seems hard to do well in practice.

Can the agent read the internet for context? What if the fetch reveals a secret?


> The struggle was never to learn programming syntax (most grammar are only a few page long)

I see this as HN bubble. For many on here it wasn’t a struggle, but for most people I think it is. Hence the SWE salaries.


I don't think the education barrier fully accounts for SWE salaries. It takes a particular disposition and other hard things, learned over years of doing, to actually keep do software engineering as a career.

AI changes the dispositions and difficulties, but it still favors a narrow selection of people to do the (still) difficult task of software engineering with agents.


Postman feels pointless when I have an agent plus curl.


How long do you think that is going to last?


yeah every single time I hear someone brag about fully automating their job I wonder, "what do they need you for, then?"


Maybe Python isn’t a language for when performance is a big concern (at least in the user code) and that’s OK?


Why did they call it “humanities last exam”?

Will an LLM topping this bench be the end of humanity? The doomer rhetoric has no place in what should be an objective measure.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: