HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | mcphage's commentslogin

> As in, can they issue the decree?

I'm not the person you're replying to, but I'm assuming that the question isn't "can the issue the decree", but instead "can they actually bring a large number of new soldiers onto the battlefield?"


> who has not found any regulator wrong doing and who has certainly not presented evidence of wrong doing

They have not presented any evidence, yes. That does not mean they have not found any.


The government loves their perp walks. If they had evidence they would have filed charges and had all of the media there to watch them escort Jensen out of Nvidia HQ.

This administration also loves their backroom deals and shakedowns. “Look at what we found out, it would be a shame if this came out, I wonder what you could do for me…”. Hence what Trump mentioned about a the CEO of a major AI company on 60 Minutes a few weeks ago.

> Did they get the midterms wrong

When Alex Karp suddenly claimed to be a progressive after the election, it wasn’t because he got the outcome he was expecting.


Or you are being played.

Honestly you have to be a moron to not have action plans for either side winning. The dude you brought up clearly had.


"Oh I've been in your team all along" is not a convincing action plan.. Maybe if playing cops and robbers with 4 year olds..

Let's see if it will work then

How do you define "work"? What would be your yardstick? Genuinely interested.

In Karp's case you could just look at Palantir's stock 4 years later.

That… uh… is not an action plan. That’s… dare I say it? The concept of a plan.

I’m not disagreeing with the moron bit, however.


I mean, the important part is the 4D chess and the fact you're in on it and smarter than the rest of us, yup, totally dude. How insufferable.

You are also a demagogue. I said the game is dumb and you are attributing to me some claim of 4D chess. You want them to lose, but they won't. The game is dumb and pretty much anyone could play OK, which is what they are doing.

> The hostility from the public is not because of Silicon Valley's association with Trump; instead it is because of issues like higher electricity rates, loss of privacy, job losses, etc.

Why not both? Or rather, all?


> I will say: if she was a spy, she was terrible at it.

We have an entire administration who are terrible at their jobs—who commit crimes and then go onto a news program and tell everyone that they committed a crime. I don't think that's evidence against her being a spy. Not these days.


> Emulators always, without fail assume piracy.

An emulator is a piece of software and can't make assumptions. I'm not sure who you're referring to doing the assuming in your sentence.

> You bought the game but "stole" the console sale.

Not buying something and then not getting it isn't stealing or piracy.

> they need HW sales as well for the whole thing to make sense.

Nintendo has no legal entitlement for their business plan to work financially.


An emulator is a piece of software and can't make assumptions. I'm not sure who you're referring to doing the assuming in your

Ok, fellow pedant! By dumping and decrypting the ROM, one is breaking the license agreement. And these ROMs slip into the wild. You've read the EULA? It's DRM circumvention. You don't need to like it. No skin off of my nose, but this isn't a John Deer right to repair situation.

1. License Grant/Restrictions; Third-Party Content. Subject to the terms of this Agreement, Nintendo grants you a non-exclusive, revocable license to use the Software solely on the Console for your personal, non-commercial use. For clarity, the Software is licensed, not sold, to you, and you may not make use of the Software except as expressly authorized by this Agreement. Without limitation, you agree that you may not ( a) publish, copy, modify, reverse engineer, lease, rent, decompile, disassemble, distribute, offer for sale, or create derivative works of any portion of the *Software;*

NA EULA, perhaps different in your country - https://en-americas-support.nintendo.com/app/legal/a_id/6858...

Nintendo has no legal entitlement for their business plan to work financially.

Their lawyers will craft it. See ya!


> > Nintendo has no legal entitlement for their business plan to work financially.

> Their lawyers will craft it. See ya!

The EFF actually coined a term for this in its analyses of the impact of the DMCA: "Felony Contempt of Business Model". Of course, when they wrote those words they expected the very phrase to constitute a kind of reductio ad absurdum.

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/06/felony-contempt-busine...

Obviously privileging arbitrary business models over others isn't one of the legitimate purposes of the law. So what makes you think there's a public interest in supporting Nintendo's business model beyond what existing laws, which do not prohibit emulation or even the sale of compatible consoles, already do?


> Their lawyers will craft it. See ya!

If lawyers could have, they would have.


> Their lawyers will craft it. See ya!

This is a utterly empty response. What is it that you're arguing exactly, that a company can use the law to be a nuisance and that the actual letter of the law doesn't matter at all?

If so, then why even quote law in your arguments? Because by your own admission, none of it matters.


You merely need to define the term "NinePizza", which is a collection of nine pizzas—and then have your very educated mother serve that. This doesn't present any problems philosophically, since we already have terms like "Solar System" for collections of disconnected objects.

> The fact that this is a "problem" is telling.

> If you can't quickly run the min/max on consequences for pulling a subway emergency brake, you probably shouldn't be allowed to ride the subway without some kind of exception on file.

Welcome to Buridan's Ass: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buridan%27s_ass


Oware is on the first page.

Thanks, I didn't actually look at the page, was responding to the (apparently incorrect) claim about the lack of sowing games. My bad.

If you don’t stand for Sonething, you’ll fall for Anything.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: