HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | lpghatguy's commentslogin

A machine-drafted AI news website should not be eligible for submission here.

A good portion of what's on the front page at any given time is LLM output. I think the site explicitly made a decision that this is OK when they banned AI-generated comments but not AI-generated submissions.

I think that most people here just don't mind, or even favor this if they're AI accelerationists. Case in point are all the high-scoring hobby projects that are just "I asked Claude to make me X and then write an article about it".


> Case in point are all the high-scoring hobby projects that are just "I asked Claude to make me X and then write an article about it".

I flag all such articles. I can generate them myself if I want them.


I spend a lot less time on hacker news as a result.

If they couldn't bother to spend the time to write the writeup about a subject they're supposedly passionate about why should any of us bother spending time reading it?

-- particularly given that it's easy to use AI to do the skut work that it's good at, like digging up citation links, without using it to write which its extremely poor at.

I just find myself instantly closing without reading a large percentage of HN submissions these days.


Thank you, Claude, for this write up that seems to be for Claude.

It's crazy how even the intro text to the Fable 5.2 Extra's game still reeks of AI. Like, wow, the models can make a game that almost makes sense, but still can't write text that sounds remotely like a human was involved!

Leaving memory safety up to a model is wild. That's not a sound guarantee of safety for anything.

The AI generated (read: fake) mockup image that's first in the README looks great! This would be really cool if it looked like that, but it doesn't.

When I was writing a bunch of Lua, I was a big fan of having a None sentinel value (Lua uses 'nil' for representing absence) and it was useful for a lot of things similar to Pydantic's MISSING.

This distinction is something that I think is actually handy about JavaScript, and distinguishing between 'null' and 'undefined' is sometimes useful for similar reasons.


I feel like faster exceptions would be a better solution for this sort of thing. Leave functions returning the happy path with excepted values. Exceptional things, like missing values being handled at the level where of abstraction that actually cares to catch it:


The README being so full of AI prose is super grating.


It seems like the developer is Japanese (the dev log is in Japanese according to the readme) so for once I am willing to believe this is a case of “the dev is not a native speaker” - but yes, I wondered several times reading the readme if this whole thing is vibe coded


Actually, his Japanese is pretty strange too. As a native speaker, it doesn't even feel like Japanese-Claudish. It feels more like it was translated from some other language, or maybe he just didn't bother reviewing the Haiku 3 output at all.


Thanks for checking. The plot thickens.


I'm a little surprised there's no data here from the Montréal or Toronto metro systems! I think Canada has the same escalator speed limit as the US, so I expect them to be similar.


If you use more than one operating system, you can't use the operating system browser if you want sync or the same experience. For example, I use a Windows desktop and a MacBook.


Having those things come up in conversation with a friend, who we can probably trust to deliver good information to us, is _way_ different than a platform that is going to potentially profit if they can sway you another direction.

If my friend is involved in an MLM scheme, I'm not going to trust them that I should buy NutriProteinShakeMax! I probably don't want them to tell me about it, ever!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: