HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | ewild's commentslogin

well im just not gonna write down the tribal knowledge lmao


what happens when your column names dont accurately represent what data is being stored (i know i wish it did but it doesnt at my place right now) and its all esoteric knowledge held by our data scientists? my worry is now the guys above will think its answering their question without knowing that its either A. wrong or B. data they may not be able to use for legal reasons on the project they are trying to make.


This is the key issue. I call it a semantic gap.

Example is a transaction application with a backing database: The users conduct information interactions with the application. The application stores relatively sparse data into the transactional database. The database has just enough metadata to route data from transactions but doesn't have the full meaning.

Example database column "updated_date" with type timestamp: Without looking at the data, how do you know if this column is populated when the application first stores data in a row? How do you know the timezone of the timestamp as a user would see it?

Real world example: Patient height in app and api is SI and both note the units. Patient height in the data warehouse is US Customary with no unit notation. The app and api make elaborate conversions for the underlying transaction database's US customary storage.

I think the promise of an LLM ontology is to read application code to understand the context for any particular database column. The linked software is not that.


I deal with this in a marketing analytics org.

Something like autoontology would help with human enforced governance for "blessed" data sets. You still need the operational rigor and data maturity to build said data sets and drive the transformation to adopt them.

This is effectively a tooling and labeling layer. But it will not magically solve the messy people issues that have always been at the root of this.


In the product I work on, there's a Metadata layer that maps user-supplied definitions, notes and commentary onto the raw table descriptions

These are optional but it allows manual override when schema design is poor


openai has a billion users. Ads and they know it.


The math doesn’t math here. There isn’t enough spent on online ads to dig them out of this hole.

Is that potential source of revenue? Maybe but folks are verbally very negative on AI ads.

Is that a viable business plan for Open AI? No.


What’s with the low quality posts?

Google search ads are highly converting because they are camouflaged.

OpenAI ads are nothing of the sort!


Google search ads used to also convert highly because they were well-targeted and positioned at the point of consumption.

If I'm searching for red widgets, it's a fairly strong indicator I'm way more likely than the average to want to BUY red widgets, so a well-placed ad for redwidgets-cheap.com didn't feel hostile.

Now when it's "I am clearly searching for red widgets but you want to railroad me into blue doohickeys because they're paying more per click", you're one step above a Taboola chumbox.


Google search ads are just highly optimised over now 26 years. There's no reason that OpenAI won't do the same. How successful they are going to be is not clear though.


No clue how it's low effort to point out ads. It's not my fault you and everyone here lacks the product creativity to see the reality that they WILL be embedded in the answers and you will not be able to tell it's an ad. This will result in a literally the best ad system the world has ever seen. They simply need to wait a few years for the general pop to be reliant on them (which if you work with kids surprise they believe everything it says) and then slowly shift this over. They will be the most valuable company in the world bar none.

Do I think it's dystopian and shitty? Yes. Doesn't mean it ain't gonna happen and doesn't mean it's not the right move for the business.


> surprise they believe everything it says

It's not just kids in my observation.


The equivalent model for chatgpt would be randomly getting replies that are generated from a prompt injected with advertiser copy and indicated by a small "sponsored reply" in the corner.

Honestly, having written that out... I'm not sure that's an outcome that's generally avoidable.


Their ads aren’t converting like search ads, more like social


Even social is charitable..


Google, I hear, is very very good at Ads


personally thats why i think OAI is in a way better place with them targeting ads.


for real i hold the opposing view i think openai will be a 5-10T dollar company in the next 5 years, but im speculating just as much as he is.


Just a tad bit more ; it like saying either an event will happen or not so probability is 50%.

Your scenario is certainly possible, that doesn’t make both predictions equally (un)likely.


I still think OpenAI holds on as a Google competitor and Anthropic does fine as a business tool. Do they match their outsized spending with future growth? Well, that I'm not very confident about. A lot of this really comes down to what is the business model of integrating AI with 3rd party systems and I don't see that anyone has truly cracked that yet.


I'm also speculating that they'll kindly donate at least 1 T of that to me out of the kindness of their heart.


At least you admit you're speculating (we all are). They confidently just say its a foregone conclusion.

If they're actually that confident I hope they short the stock long term with basically all their money.


I also speculate that OpenAI and Anthropic will crater, but I also expect that the market will remain irrational much longer then anyone shorting it today will remain solvent.

So yes, I believe it's going to leave a smoking hole in the ground, but I won't be betting money on it.


If you run a traditional short (borrow and sell the shares), you need to be right on the direction and the timing to make any money. One random surge in the price can kill your short even if said surge is short-lived.


ignorance


Used to be a bakers oven was one per town, maybe big precise machine becomes cheap smol precise machine


3D printers are a nice analogy, but the complexity level is orders of magnitude higher for chip making, besides the stability of the environment requirements.


there are mountains of evidence that postgres does indeed scale if thoughfully designed.


I had 20,000 Bitcoin at one point from selling RuneScape gold when I was 9.


oculus didnt ship a single product not owned by facebook.


That is certainly not true.

I had the Oculus Rift dev kit before they sold to Facebook. It was so amazing at the time


“Dev kit”


They called it that, but I just bought it on their website like a normal product. I didn’t write anything for it.

There was a site that you could download experiences that people created, which is what I used it for.


You had to pay for it (Kickstarter), so its 100% a product


Game console developers always had to (and still have to) pay for their dev kits. That doesn't really make them products in the typical sense of the word, though.

The stronger argument for it being a product is that it was available to the public.


I didn’t even get it from the kickstarter.

I just bought it on the website.


Yeah, sure, my point is that obviously the original comment excluded the dev kit in their definition of product, and arguing over it is just splitting hairs.


Non-devs were buying them to play games.


I was one of them.

I mean, I was/am a dev, but I had no plans to develop on it, I just wanted it to play with.


Correct, but you didn't have to log into the Quest 1 with facebook until ~2024. They had "Oculus accounts" at first.


They have Meta accounts now, which are also not Facebook accounts. I went straight from an Oculus account to Meta account. Might be location based, but I most certainly haven't been asked to upload any ID.


> They have Meta accounts now, which are also not Facebook accounts.

How gullible can you be?


I got some hate from pointing out WhatsApp is the same evil corp as Facebook recently. People don't want to hear that


Well, I was going to point out the distinction between products. But I guess if people like you are able to turn HN into Reddit, anything is possible.


And I was pointing out that they are one and the same but the "Facebook" name was so tarnished by their terrible privacy practices they had to change it to save face.

But I guess if people like you are able to ignore that to make yourself feel better about giving your personal information to Zuckerberg's advertising company then anything is possible.


Phwoar! Thank you. It's 2026, and had it not been for your high quality informative comments. I would have not known anything about this them there Facebook. You saved me.

I don't know what conversation you think you're having here, but it's not that.

If you'd bothered to read... and then ready for it... stop, take a breath, and process the information. You'd have noticed I was pointing out you can use a Quest headset WITHOUT providing them your personal ID OR having a Facebook account. Almost as if, you know, I was highlighting that giving the company your personal info isn't required. Woe me though for pointing that out.

I'm sorry for interrupting the indignant rants. Please continue.


Owner of DK2 here, well before Facebook acquisition. It was for developers, but it was a shipped product nonetheless.


Not really. Pre-release baked into the name.


Sold for a full price, so it’s a sold product.


Game console dev kits are typically _more_ expensive than the consoles they're for. So "full price" isn't a good argument. (The fact that they were available to the public is a stronger argument.)


i've never had the luxury of buying a cheaper dev kit. Ever.


It wasn't though, a full price would have been more, to cover not just components and assembly but the cost of R&D.


Game console dev kits usually cost more than the consoles they're for, not less. They're not mass produced at the scale that the consoles are, and they're sold or leased to companies expecting to make several orders of magnitude more back off the products they create with the dev kits.


There isn't a very direct comparison of Oculus products to game consoles like PlayStation, Nintendo, XBox, or those in the distant past. It is interesting, and they have a lot of the same market forces at play, but I don't think they behave by the same rules.


There's at least one way where there's a direct comparison: they both have dev kits.


Pretty sure DK1 shipped pre-acquisition.


DK2 also


Neither qualifies.


Why? They were for sale to the public, how were they not a product?


Because some people find arguing over semantics fun.


Regardless the acquisition took some time to bring down the quality of the products. It doesn't matter if their first few products were sufficiently far ahead that they weren't enshitified immediately when Facebook bought Oculus.


they shipped 3. DK1, DK2, CV1.


4 if you count the Latency Tester.. but yo.. Mark and Andrew.. pour these ARVR $$$ into CZI instead!!!


CV1 was as a Facebook subsidiary. Acquired 2014-07-21, CV1 announced January 2016 and released March 2016. https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/21/facebooks-acquisition-of-o... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oculus_Rift_CV1


> oculus didnt ship a single product not owned by facebook.

The post you are replying to doesn't claim they did...?

They did change the branding in late 2021/early 2022.

Prior to that the product was called the Oculus Quest, after that it was the Meta Quest.

And Meta did start heavily enshittifying the product alongside the rebrand.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: