They are contractually obligated to fly up to ISS until 2030 or so. But they are not obligated to sign new contracts nor are they currently selling rides on Falcon 9 to commercial customers (all future flights are booked).
Will they offer launch on Starship to NASA and commercial customers? TBD, but SpaceX is making so much money on Starlink that they have no financial incentive to do so. They make more money launching their own Starlink satellites than anyone else is willing to pay.
RL can't even successfully make a first stage tank yet for Neutron, and they've already said first launch is now in "2027" without specifying a quarter. It's definitely not going to be ready by the end of the year, that's for sure.
At least Stoke is skating to where the puck in going to be.
But I think it's going to take them longer than anyone hopes to make a difference. For starters, their current vehicle is not large enough for major national security payloads and probably not large enough for most LEO constellations.
Their current design, called Pathfinder, has yet to reach orbit. It was supposed to launch in 2025 and now has been pushed back to 2027. Pathfinder is designed to launch 3 tons fully reusable and 7 tons expendable (Starship can launch 50 tons fully reusable).
They have plans for Block 2, which can (hopefully) launch 15 tons fully reusable, but their projected first flight is 2029, which likely means 2031 at the earliest.
Like I said, I think Stoke is doing the right things and going the right direction. But even if everything goes right for them, they won't be a factor in launch capacity until the mid 2030s.
They have a booster they've flown twice. Not sure if it got damaged too, but theoretically they could have flown that booster by now if they had a second pad.
Why isn't there a backup or a secondary deletion confirmation or something along those lines?
Plenty of people have accidentally deleted such things, so it's not unheard of. Not sure we should be overreacting to stochastic agents being used tens of millions of times per day making a mistake. Eventually they won't make mistakes anyway.
It's a computer program. "Rogue" implies autonomous intent, and shifts accountability away from the people using tools irresponsibly.
Imagine you pipe /dev/random to your terminal, and it spits out the word "fuck". Should we then write a headline saying "Rogue random number generator curses at tenured professor"?
Or you step out of your car while it's in gear, and it crashes into your house. "Rogue vehicle injures its owner's child"?
Computers have been anthropomorphized for a very long time. AI is also a kind of anthropomorphism for the use of the word "intelligence". If we wanted to move away from that, perhaps we could say something like "maliciously developed statistical language model", or "malicious statistical language model" to replace rogue. In this case it was merely a "statistical language model", but if the author sees a need to append an adjective, then I think sloppy is more accurate than rogue.
Not because I doubt you but Europe is pretty disparate.
Amtrak from NYC to Philadelphia cost as much as a flight to continental Europe, and the experience was abysmal, truly awful I couldn’t even get the tickets for hours and took a bus instead.
Perhaps I’m “spoiled” by UK and Swedish trains but UK is pretty terible
> Fair point about refunds for delays in general, its so awful I normally don’t do it
That's one thing in which DB - the German rail company - excels: their refund process is easy and often quite smooth. It is unfortunate that this is probably because they have had so much practice running it given than around 70% of their long-distance services are delayed but still, it works and I tend to get my 25% or 50% refund for 1+ and 2+ hour delays within a few weeks, sometimes days.
It depends hugely on when you book--both time in advance and time of year--as well as any sales going on. Which can vary a TON in Europe as well. I almost always take trains within Europe but they're no bargain.
Right. I'm not going to NYC for now but I saw the end-of-year sale in my inbox recently. Pricing varies a lot. (And I usually don't book Acela on my own dime absent a bargain; the transit time isn't much different from the regional.)
A lot of travel generalizations assume you're going more or less going downtown to downtown. There are some limited suburban stations for both NYC and Boston but, generally speaking, a lot of train transportation advantages over air go away if you're not traveling more or less downtown to downtown and become liabilities.
In my case, there's an out-of the way but otherwise convenient south suburban station outside of Boston and I'm basically always going to Manhattan so I train unless I'm just changing planes in Newark.
Oh you're right. I was actually thinking of the airport. Getting to/from Manhattan isn't so bad, but JFK is in Queens so the path of least resistance is generally to Manhattan and then to Queens even if you're already in Queens.
Getting direct service to the other boroughs would be nice though. Acela (Penn Station to Back Bay) was a bit of a WTF moment for me though.
Logan is actually quite convenient to Boston metro in general. But if you're driving in from the suburbs, RTE 128 works a lot better even if, for me, it's pretty much 100% out of my way to travel to NYC. I could drive to New Haven to avoid driving into the city (which I hate doing) and take Metro North but, then, that's more driving.
The year is 2019. I wanted to book a ticket on GWR. Couldn't, site didn't work with iOS. Figured I'd buy a ticket at the station. Couldn't, no staff. Figured I'd use the TVM. Couldn't, most were out of service. After I managed to buy a ticket staff mysteriously came out of hiding.
The trip itself was grand until the train (Class 800) broke down and staff started blaming passengers.
The refund process was quite smooth as soon as I replied to the initial denial and pointed out that yes being stranded for an hour qualified for a full refund under their stated policies.
Amtrak's been more reliable for me and I've never had problems booking a ticket. Never had problems with them while they were running Caltrain either. I get the joke but I think Amtrak does quite well with the constraints they're required to operate under. The UK doesn't really have that excuse.
We don't need EVs. I drive one and like it and want to see more but underlying your comments here is a false assumption that if we don't build EVs we're falling behind or something. That's not correct.
While China has been scaling up it's production of vehicles, it'a also facing a 20% YoY decline in vehicle sales internally and thus has to look to export cars. It's currently shut out of the highly profitable and second largest (by volume, perhaps largest by $$) market and because of these factors and incoming EU action to prevent China from destroying the European auto industry faces companies who have built factories that were geared toward building 100,000s of thousands of vehicle but are only building a few thousand.
> If legacy US auto is not scaling EV production, why are the tariffs still in place?
Because your assumption is wrong. We don't need to scale EV production. Tariffs are in place because the engine and fuel source don't matter as much as having the industry does. While I also am in favor of competition, there's a balance to be had in maintaining good union jobs and preventing entire industries from collapsing due to all sorts of fair and unfair trade practices. It's the same approach the EU has broadly taken with its own products and market. The US is just playing catch up where it can or feels it needs to.
Falling behind in what, is the question. The race to electrify is because we're cooking the planet with fossil fuel usage, and electric cars are the future in which we don't choke ourselves out. Electrify transportation and move the grid to renewal resources. The economy is one thing but we only have one Earth.
See even this is an assumption. We don't need electric cars - we need to walk and bike (i.e. better building patterns). Creating EVs still creates emissions, you still have to mine the resources to make them, and you still use ships to transport then from China which aren't electrified. Using a lot of energy to drive a few miles to get a loaf of bread isn't sustainable no matter whether it's an EV, Hybrid, or ICE vehicle.
But if you think this is a big deal that needs to be solved (and I'm no opponent to saving the planet and reducing emissions or any of those things) my recommendation would first be to get China to release its hold on rare earth mineral processing, and then have them voluntarily give away EV and battery technology to other countries building cars so we can work on this problem together. Unfortunately China lost the trust of the western countries through its action and so we're sort of stuck in this situation because of them. None of the EU, Japan, Korea, or America are going to let their auto industry be destroyed and lose all of those good jobs just for the sake of the environment. It's a non-starter. If you think that's the approach to take you're probably wasting your time.
I'd be a huge supporter of building out more walking, biking and public transit options; besides the environment, those are good for physical health too. However, that boat has long sailed in the US. Current urban and suburban layouts are just way too spread out and can only be traversed by car. It's unfortunate, but if you don't have a car in the US, I feel like you're essentially an invalid.
At this point, even if we could overcome the cultural resistance to deprioritizing cars, we really cannot do so. Hence the only realistic option seems to be optimizing cars to avoid emissions. Even if EV's just move the pollution somewhere else, on the whole they are way better than gas cars.
It hasn’t sailed, that’s a misconception. While in many metropolitan areas the suburbs would be difficult to reconfigure, the core of those same cities are sitting on acres and acres of empty space that can be used for development of housing and businesses and with an expansion of good transportation options can enable a car-free lifestyle or even just minimize the number of trips you take.
We make an impact not with a wholesale big dig style project but piece by piece. When that neighborhood grocery store opens in walking distance you can walk instead of drive. Maybe you still take your car to work everyday but we can still reduce emissions in other areas.
EVs just aren’t the answer to these problems, well, not at the expense of American workers, good union jobs, and our manufacturing capacity.
Oh for sure, I agree there's a lot of space, but reconfiguring all the existing construction to become denser seems like a much longer timeline than transitioning to EVs. I've not really done the numbers on this, but comparing most suburbs with a dense walk/bike/public transit-friendly city like, say, NYC is like a day-and-night difference, which makes a broad reconfiguration seem very far off. Maybe my reference points are too extreme?
Also, to increase density the thing that people would need to give up, in addition to cars, is private backyards. I feel like that is a much bigger cultural hurdle to overcome, since that is like 50% (including the white picket fences!) of the home ownership part of the traditional American Dream.
We don’t need to reconfigure anything, just build. Columbus where I live has 1,000 acres of surface parking lots and empty lots. We can just literally build downtown and reduce emissions and car usage.
We don’t need to give up private back yards. I live in an urban neighborhood and have one. Now some of the building I’ve suggested would be much higher density but not all of it needs to be. I think your reference points are a bit too extreme. I wouldn’t even talk about suburbs or New York in this, they don’t matter.
I drive an EV and I prefer it, but it’s just a non-starter to import Chinese EVs at the expense of union jobs and the American auto industry. Even if that means ongoing negative effects to the environment (overpopulation is another factor too for example).
The world sells 90M units/year of light vehicles, as of this comment. You cannot stop people from buying light vehicles (broadly speaking; several countries have banned combustion vehicle imports already, and hopefully this trend continues). If they will be bought, they should be EVs. If they are not now, they will eventually be, based on current trajectories. 100% within ~10 years I think, maybe a bit longer. Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long, and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.
- “China’s electric vehicle exports continue to break records, and the surge in shipments to ASEAN markets is especially striking,” said Euan Graham, a Senior Electricity and Data Analyst (Global) at Ember. “Southeast Asia is fast becoming one of the most dynamic destinations for electric vehicles, and China is supplying that demand at scale and speed.”
- Singapore, 24 June 2026 – China’s electric vehicle exports reached a record $9.2 billion, up 49% year-on-year, in May 2026, according to new data from global energy think tank Ember. The previous record was in April 2026 at $9.1 billion.
- In May 2026, China shipped a record value of electric vehicles abroad, exceeding the previous monthly high set in April and underscoring the country’s dominance in global EV manufacturing. China exported around 448,000 electric passenger cars in May, roughly 279,000 battery-electric vehicles and 169,000 plug-in hybrids. EV exports have closed in on lithium-ion batteries as the largest of the “new three” cleantech export categories, having grown from under $1 billion a month in 2020.
- Exports to Southeast Asia reached an all-time high of $1.2 billion in May 2026, as ASEAN nations accelerated the electrification of their vehicle fleets. The surge was led by Thailand, which took a record of more than 36,000 Chinese electric cars in May, and the Philippines, where shipments climbed above 33,000 vehicles.
- "To decarbonize road transport, the world must move away from petrol and diesel cars towards electric vehicles and other forms of low-carbon transport. This transition has already started. In fact, global sales of combustion engine cars are well past their peak and are now falling. As you can see in the chart, global sales peaked in 2017. This is calculated based on data from the International Energy Agency. Bloomberg New Energy Finance also estimated this peak occurred around that time. Sales of electric cars, on the other hand, are growing quickly. They more than doubled in the three years from 2022 to 2025." [My note: Rate of change! Doubling in 3 years, and it is very likely the time it takes before next doubling continues to decline.]
Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.
Yea it's fine that China builds electric bikes because that's not a manufacturing capacity that the west cares about. In the US and Canada at least we need better infrastructure so that more people are riding them, or manual bikes, or walking.
> Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.
I also disagree that "in a lot of places it isn't possible". It is, actually. Most people live in urban areas and if we slightly adjust how we build and allow for proper levels of density then we don't even have to sell cars (which are a huge burden for the less wealthy).
There is no goal to get to 100% EV sales. If there is, I would support it as long as they're not Chinese. I'd rather buy another ICE vehicle than a Chinese EV because I care more about union jobs, American manufacturing capacity, and things like that than I do muddled visions of "if we just had EVs we would save the planet".
> Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long,
Well we can do it forever.
> and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.
Yea that's totally fine. The profitable customers though still remain in the west so if China wants to sell low priced EVs and follow the Android-ification strategy of gaining low-value market share I say more power to them. But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.
As your articles point out, China's increasing exports particularly to nearby countries which never had American markets to really begin with. I say that's a great thing for everyone. But you also have to acknowledge that the drive for Chinese exports is because of manufacturing overcapacity (this is a fact that can't be disputed) and because auto sales in China are falling (20% YoY) and their internal market is facing quite the challenge. But since we have auto industries we're not going to allow ours to collapse just to save Chinese jobs. It's nonsense.
> But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.
He said, in the thread "Mercedes-Benz to halt 'all future investments' in Germany." and while VW has ~100k layoffs planned. You say "allow it" like it is a choice. You can play to win, or lose, and western automakers are not currently playing to win. Maybe this changes! But probably not. It's easy to change, accept a reduction in profits and invest in EV production. But you're not keeping historical profits and winning, as a legacy automaker, as long as Chinese automakers are willing to make ~5% margins on their vehicles.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50484586 ("This is on the heels of VW also pulling out of Germany (as of just two days ago). VW is scrapping their biggest plant in Dresden and also shifting manufacturing to Eastern Europe and out of Germany for four other plants. German automakers can not longer remain competitive, for a few reasons.")
Certainly looks like the jobs are going away and the industries are collapsing, based on a preponderance of the evidence.
That's because auto sales collapsed in China [1] - did you forget the comment where I pointed out Chinese market sales are down 20% YoY across the board? - not because all of a sudden a bunch of Chinese EVs were imported. Volkswagen is working on building a massive new manufacturing facility in the US even [3].
Of course, the import of Chinese EVs would have an effect [2], and how the EU responds to that will be very interesting, but you're not looking at the broad picture and instead focusing on an ideological argument.
I am looking at the economics and trajectories, I'm unsure you think this is ideology. EV sales continue to rise, and China makes them, no other country is building EVs at this scale, and that is unlikely to change in the near term. Are EV sales globally going to go down? No, they are doubling every 2-3 years. Is China going to slow down building? No, they have to keep their exports humming. The world is their market, and they will sell into it forever (~90M units/year, as mentioned). Some countries may attempt or succeed at keeping them out, but the rest of the world will take the cheap EVs.
Do you disagree with this? My entire thesis is data, evidence, and observation driven. Are you arguing someone will build faster? If so, who? Provide evidence. Are you arguing protectionist policies? Sure, but only a few countries have auto manufacturing to protect, the rest of the world does not. So, where's the disconnect?
I've already explained in my posts above what the picture is. I don't really have anything else to say when you're just repeating what I've already walked through. Maybe someone else has some different insight. I hope you have a nice day!
This is multi-faceted and I agree that AI is destroying some levels of trust, but many of the publications on the Internet were never deserving of trust anyway so I'd describe it as formalizing or recognizing distrust or lack of credibility and, in a manner of speaking now that the tide is going out we can see who has been swimming naked.
One of the other facets is the idea that trust is now being lost due to AI. It's unfortunate that it seems that publications like The Atlantic (and others) are now going to scapegoat the lost of trust that they've earned over the last decade or so to be about AI when it's actually about bad, biased writing with a default point of view, and lack of intellectual honesty and an inability to facilitate intellectual debate and discussion.
As some of these publications continue to spiral into irrelevancy I think what is a bit tragic is they'll never really understand why. They'll blame AI, which will likely destroy all but the top-tier sites, but in reality the quality of the writing and honesty went down the drain next to their ad-filled garbage pages and other spam.
Good work pointing this out. One of the great things about AI is eventually people are going to learn to stop trusting these kinds of websites “it’s all AI slop” and revert back to paid journalism because while the writing can be done by AI, the research and verification largely cannot.
Or so I hope. More likely is people will continue to engage with low-quality information and come to believe all sorts of nonsense, misquotes? Conspiracy theories, and more as they always have…
Journalism was always the lowest of the low of vocations.
It isn't surprising that a simple robot can do it just as well as your run of the mill scribbler.
There is nothing good to go back to because there was nothing good about journalism at any point in the history of mankind.
These freaks don't actually coldly manipulate you with sensationalist headlines, they are exactly as excited to write pages about gruesome family murder as the text suggests.
Now that they compete with TikTok sending you tragedy after tragedy right into your pineal gland, it has been a rough patch to be a traditional corpse picture snatcher.
Proliferation of something doesn't mean it's dominant. Android has the dominant global market share, but Apple makes all the money.
W.r.t the United States government and its people restricting sales of the most advanced chips form Nvidia there are two realistic conclusions you can draw (neither of which result in SMIC and/or Huawei "obliterating" anyone):
1. China is behind and needs to catch up, and the way to do that is through subterfuge to get more chips imported into the country. In other words, they can't match Nvidia + American tech stack for the foreseeable future.
2. China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already, and so it doesn't matter whether the US restricts the sale or not other than maybe a few billion dollars in lost sales to a few companies which isn't really relevant.
With respect to Chinese electric cars and the American market, the American market is highly profitable and while we don't have great EVs we also don't really need them for anything, and while China maintains a stranglehold on rare earth mineral processing we can't put ourselves in a position where an adversary can effectively shut down our auto industry and leave us in a bad position. Of course there are existing single points of failure, chokeholds, and things like that, but there's no need to add fuel to the fire.
Most Chinese automakers are not competitive, the Chinese auto market is slowing down, and many of the automakers are operating on state subsidies and have built factories which are not able due to lack of demand to produce the volumes of vehicles that were expected. American strategy (and soon European strategy) to limit imports of Chinese vehicles results in a resounding win for union jobs, stability of American, European, Japanese, and Korean automakers, and uses what I'll describe as a judo move (using your opponents strengths and momentum against them) to harm the Chinese economy and their goal of instituting mass manufacturing overcapacity.
2. China can "just catch up", which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already
Have you looked at Huawei Ascend chips? They are on a 7nm process, so at first blush you could say they're not competitive. I think they run at at between 15045% the performance of Nvidia's fancy chips (Grace Blackwell etc) and also consume a lot more power, presumably requiring more power again to dissipate the resulting heat.
On the plus side, though, they're designed from the group up to sit in massive arrays have 4tb of memory interconnect bandwidth. My understandin g is that model providers like Deepseek are doing their training on nvidia gPUs but all the inference is moving toward Huawei.
At some point they'll be caught up, either via lithography breakthroughs, or by building on their architectual strengths.
> which begs the question why they don't have their own Nvidia already
Because they don't have TSMC or ASML and the Dutch can turn those lithography machines off from the other side of the world. Nvidia is likely the least important part of the supply chain which is why governments were not very concerned with the behavior which they would have been aware of for a while.
I remember listening to that and thinking, this sounds like a guy who is primarily focused on selling chips and is brushing away legitimate concerns in a way that, I just did not find very compelling. A little bit too much protest you might say. Not to say there isn't or wasn't validity to his arguments, but in light of the current circumstances it seems to me that those arguments are quite a bit less valid than they were, and I've certainly swung my personal opinion from being on the fence to a hard no to selling these chips to Chinese buyers.
If the Chinese Communist Party are going through such great lengths to obtain these advanced Nvidia chips, it further invalidates a lot of what I've been reading here and elsewhere about China "catching up" or that being the leading models isn't what matters (commoditization). You don't do stuff like this unless you really need something.
I think it's worth remembering that China isn't a monolithic bloc, and CCP doesn't drive everything, that there are tons of private enterprises there that would benefit, even if the Chinese government strategically would prefer to push Huawei to grow the domestic capability. There being a ton of private demand internal to China doesn't invalidate Jensen's view that it's a strategic blunder to let Huawei get a foothold in the market. Within the CCP, there's also a lot of inter-regional competition to show growth in their own regions, because that's the primary qualification for advancement within the party.
That said, I don't have any special insight into the specifics of who was driving the demand backing Megaspeed.
there's a good analysis that says Alice was a fixer and/or white-glove. those are common-in-China roles that have to do with obfuscating big financial operations, not necessarily with any political (CCP) involvement. obviously, CCP approves, if tacitly, everything that happens in China.
Which part? You find it hard to believe that there are private enterprises there that don't always do exactly what CCP wants? Or that there're conflicting incentives inside the CCP, so that "what CCP wants" isn't simple?
Talking to friends who worked in diplomacy - honey traps are extremely common and often tried quite routinely. It makes sense if you think about it. The failure rate on these is going to be fairly high and even if it’s a small success (ie a one night stand sort of thing) you can get a little compromat. The cost is probably fairly negligible, a lot of this will be fairly low risk as far as spying goes.
My favourite honey trap story comes from the cold war. A Russian diplomat in Denmark was the target of Danish intelligence. They tried to honey trap him at a party, but he didn't respond to their agent's advances. So, the Danes supposed that he might be gay, and sent a male honey trap to the next party, but again got no response from the Russian. They shrugged their shoulders and gave it up.
Unbeknownst to them, the Russian was actually at that time trying to make contact with western intelligence, as he was keen to defect! He was just a bit too awkward to respond to flirting.
He did eventually manage to defect to Britain, and died in 2025. His name was Oleg Gordievsky.
> honey traps are extremely common and often tried quite routinely.
WSJ reports that U.S. intelligence says Chinese intelligence approached Alice to become an asset after she met Jensen in March 2024. So, she was an opportunistic info source, not targeted in advance.
also, men are redickulous. And they can go in any number of beneficial direction from turning informant, selling GPUs to the chinese, or just a pee tape, etc. Just like a lottery of fun ways to screw with an adversary.
China catching up does not mean they are not still behind.
Also, China is a big country with many companies. While some may be trying to catch up via local development, others may still prefer getting western hardware right now e.g. in order to get a competitive advantage over those catching up.
I'm a bit out of the loop, what part of what he said is wrong? He said they have more power and the more capability to produce chips, so they can essentially just brute force things vs the US if they wanted to: is that not the case?
That's like asking why China is building nuclear and coal power plants when solar is so much cheaper. They are doing all of the above.
Let's assume for a second that the compromat story on Huang is true, how much would that have cost? It could be everywhere from 10k to 10m $, depending on how difficult it was to get access, but it would still be a rounding error for AI invest.
Chips aren't what maketh SI anyway. The US is ahead because of a trifecta of having the best (most) hardware, best data, and best talent. You might also throw in business culture. But the same way Google is leading from behind in the US AI eco system, China is behind the frontier on LLMs, but laying foundational work in robotics, multi-modal models and integrated factories that might prove a big advantage down the line.
I'm in the EU myself, and while I do believe we (and China) have similar levels of taltent, there are two reasons why it seems to me like the US can extract more from them: 1. In the EU people aren't pushed to perform to the maximum and 2. In China they aren't rewarded for it. The US is pretty much the only place in the world where an IC researcher at a major lab can become a millionaire.
Everywhere else you have to become a founder or manager, and that's not a good path for many talented people.
The writing is on the wall in the United States. The lack of real infrastructure usable by as many people possible currently being built is sorely lacking in comparison to China or Japan or Korea. Within the American borders, there used to be more of a can do attitude that does not exist at the same level as in the past, the attitude today is more in keeping with US steel, IBM, or Xerox…
No it's not the case because if they could do it they would already have done it. Selling them Nvidia chips doesn't change that.
But here's a link to the podcast episode if you want to give it a listen. It will inform a lot to the discussion taking place here and help you understand a few of the things he said that are probably now wrong: https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/jensen-huang
This is good evidence sanctions don't really work. Critical sectors will find ways around them and it only punishes the rank and file working class. If China or any sanctioned nation wanted those nvidia chips, it has ways to get them. So the military and intelligence get them, but the people don't. Same with sanctions on Russia now, which has not significantly slowed its military machine, but in fact its military machine is coming out with constant innovations (new Gerans, better EW, more spy sats, etc). I remember seeing a post mortem of some Russian drone. It had a Jetson chipset Russia was not supposed to be able to get. I imagine the smuggling market is far bigger than we might think and sanctions far less effective than we think.
Same when you sanction food imports. The elites who make decisions will always be fed. Sanctions are almost always an attack on the working class who do not make the high-level political decisions the sanctions are trying to address. Not to mention the idea of "making life hard on them so they revolt" almost never works.
Sanctions should be a bigger conversation. They are almost never needed and especially trade tariffs and such are always used for the most corrupt cronyism.
> Same when you sanction food imports. The elites who make decisions will always be fed. Sanctions are almost always an attack on the working class who do not make the high-level political decisions the sanctions are trying to address. Not to mention the idea of "making life hard on them so they revolt" almost never works.
There’s also the minor quibble that restricting food exports to starve another country are illegal under international law.
Nobody is starving in Russia (at least unavoidably).
That sanctions only harm the civilian economy is not an argument against them. Kinetic sanctions agains oil refining are also primarily impacting the general population and the military have enough oil. But they still impact the ability of the Russians to fund the war. Civilian infrastructure and economic assets are used by militaries too.
But what’s the point ultimately? Delaying their progress by a couple years?
Not selling them chips virtually guarantees that they will learn how to make their own, very quickly. The end result of that is much, much worse for the USA.
(and could leave Taiwan in a much weaker position in the near future)
People are bending over backwards to come to try to find some deep reason, but I think the reason is simple - the people in charge are not particularly farsighted nor insightful. It's simply short-term thinking without consideration of long-term consequences - it's not limited to just businesses.
For another example, the reason Chinese are not allowed on the 'international' ISS is because of the Wolf Amendment. [1] The idea was that if we just allowed them onto the ISS they'd steal all of our elite tech or something. Within a decade they had launched their own space station and carried out various revolutionary space activities.
And of course all of that happened while the ISS itself continues to deteriorate with no replacement in sight. And when China did an unprecedented sample return mission from the far side of the Moon and offered the whole world access to samples, US researchers had to jump through a bunch of hoops to receive them, again thanks to the same law.
> Not selling them chips virtually guarantees that they will learn how to make their own, very quickly. The end result of that is much, much worse for the USA.
Are you proposing we guarantee access to avoid potential access?
This isn’t what China does though, the moment new tech crosses the border they reverse engineer and start producing it locally. IP protections are meaningless there. How many times does this have to happen to sink in?
What needs to happen is that the people who are getting wealthy from the offshoring of manufacturing and labor to China need to stop getting wealthy. Until then any and all excuses to pretend that China will operate in good faith will be levied to try and make people seem like it's in their best interest to hollow out the USA to hand over to China.
The problem is, the man in the mirror and it ain’t just the Chinese that have taken advantage, the Japanese and the Koreans are pretty good too, and so are the Taiwanese and it’s only a matter of time for one or two countries in Southeast Asia to rise up too, and if it wasn’t for Russia’s stupidity, both Russia and the Ukraine would have certainly produced what three or four very, very good AI models to the mix…
Soon, China, if they aren’t already, will be the premier developer of Thorium reactors courtesy of Oak Ridge, Tennessee and they also are now number one or at the least 1A when it comes to high-speed rail, and if the Russians and the Ukrainians weren’t fighting each other, that high-speed rail probably would be already built out all the way to eastern Europe.
No in the Taiwanese part. Jensens Huang has dual citizenship including Taiwanese citizenship. I wouldn't say that he "helps" Taiwan but that foster a stronger trading relationship between Taiwanese companies and the AI industry in the U.S.
The Taiwanese and the Chinese almost certainly talk to each other every day. When money is involved, come on they talk and they share. That’s like saying the border between Mexico and United States is secure. We would like to say it is, but we all know it really isn’t..
Keeping them dependent upon you guarantees that they never surpass you and that you can milk the relationship for all its worth economically and geopolitically. When they have their own fabs spun up it's possible that you are the one eventually stuck with inferior tech, and you lose all sort of revenue + leverage you'd otherwise have from the relationship.
It's certainly possible, but unlikely. Because for some window of time domestic alternatives will offer less for more. And so there's no real market fit for them, meaning they're only going to survive if the government constantly props up the companies which opens the door to all the usual problems of such relations - perverse motivations, grift, inefficiency, artificial cost/time bloat, etc.
So even if the government sets out to surpass you, it's quite likely to just turn into a black hole of money. See: CHIPS Act leading to many billions spent to... remain completely dependent upon Taiwan. But all of this changes when you create a scenario where domestic players are the only players in the market.
Huawei has become a super company basically because of all the sanctions, Wxmt will become the dominant memory maker worldwide in the next five years due to shortsighted thinking in the West.
It make sense. China had X amount of demand. If the demand is met they are satisfied, if the demand remains unmet they seek alternatives. That seeking of alternatives primarily means huge amounts of money, that would go to Nvidia, going to direct competitors of Nvidia to "chip" away at their competitive advantage.
The long term result is the same regardless of who makes the chips but the real strategy is delaying China's ability to surpass the US. It takes a lot of time and money to essentially copy the entire infrastructure required to build an Nvidia GPU. Nvidia has enough demand as is.
China is a trading partner but there is still a serious catalyst for war in the form of the South China Sea. If we went to war with China in 5 years time, why would we sell them the tech they need to match our ability now? Let them figure it out on their own.
If the US wanted to delay "China's ability," wouldn't the strategy be to give them just enough GPUs to keep them reliant on Nvidia (and make developing alternative tech locally seem less critical), but not enough to develop superior models?
It feels like Space Race thinking, honestly. If the US delays China and ends up with an AGI god a few years in advance, that can still be a significant advantage even if China can catch up. This especially would hold true if a theoretical AGI could maximally leverage RSI so the improvement curve becomes exponential.
If the US or China developes an AGI that can leverage RSI, the game is over. It is over in the same way that WW3 is over as soon as the missiles are in the air: it doesn't matter who has the fastest or highest yield missiles, because there is a finite amount of time before there is nobody left to care about the advantages of one side. Except at least WW3 is over in about an hour, whereas an AGI could take years or decades to complete whatever thing it has been misaligned to desire.
AI alignment research is still in its alchemy era, and global cyber security is underfunded and bad. As a species, we simply do not have the tools to deal with AGI that can self-improve.
What stops another power from developing its own AGI a year or two later? Or from catching up once there are two competing RSI AGIs? The Soviets were a few years behind on getting nukes but they still got them.
> What stops another power from developing its own AGI a year or two later?
Well, the fact that we're all gone before then if we're unlucky. If we're on a lucky enough timeline where AGI with RSI doesn't immediately end civilization, then maybe we last long enough for the second to be created at least.
But unless we solve the AI assignment problem, it really doesn't matter if we quickly get 2-3 AGIs: an unaligned AI will be the end of us in the long term.
One would hope that self preservation would be a factor, but it seems hubris has deluded many people into thinking they can control a superhuman intelligence.
AI has been identified as strategic national priority for both the Chinese and United States.
NVIDIA’s commercial interest is pretty clear… it’s beneficial to them. to sell everyone to maintain the dominance of CUDA. That is not necessarily the national interest. And remember that espionage and infiltration is not a one-sided affair, the US may well have the ability to sabotage Chinese development efforts. You just don’t know.
End of the day, corporate CEOs are very powerful, but they’re not as powerful as the government. My guess is that Jenson truly didn’t think that this individual was a spy, and figured that the questionable legality of chip exports to Chinese proxies could be addressed by ingratiating the administration.
Who says we won't just progress as well and they stay behind a couple of years?
Where is the evidence that China is catching up considered a fiat d accompli?
Do you presume that China is destined to always at least catch up in every sector or field ever? That stinks of Chinese Exceptionalism to me.
If they could just "catch up" they would, and whether we sell them chips wouldn't matter because they would want to create their own Nvidia and export chips and make money too.
> Do you presume that China is destined to always at least catch
> up in every sector or field ever? That stinks of Chinese
> Exceptionalism to me.
Suppose you want to build something that requires technical knowledge (a GPU, a fighter jet, ...). You have engineers, but they don't yet know how to build it.
If no one on earth has ever built this thing, you need to consider the possibility that it can't be done at a cost you can pay. Perhaps it violates some law of physics, or it can't be manufactured without knowing some chemistry/physics that we are 100+ years from discovering.
If a company in some other country is already building this thing, you can be sure it is possible to build it. That is a critical piece of information! It means you don't need to discover (much) new physics. It means you can buy/steal a working copy and look at it to learn about it. It means there are engineers you can hire/spy on to understand their design process. It means you can more easily convince a bank/government to fund development, as they have proof your goals are achievable.
Inventing a thing is much harder than inventing a clone of a thing. The idea that China doesn't have the people and organization to copy things other countries make is the opposite of Chinese Exceptionalism. It is the belief that the Chinese are uniquely incapable of engineering work. This is obviously not true.
> The idea that China doesn't have the people and organization to copy things other countries make is the opposite of Chinese Exceptionalism. It is the belief that the Chinese are uniquely incapable of engineering work. This is obviously not true.
Which broadly leads to two conclusions:
They can't do it. If they could they would. If you could invest and create your own Nvidia, ASML, TSMC, &c. you would do that especially if you are China due to its stated goals and actions it takes that we can all see toward those goals.
They can do it and so selling them the chips doesn't matter other than helping to speed up their ability to do it, so we don't want to sell them the chips and thus speed up their capabilities.
But your viewpoint also holds true for the United States and Europe. Anything China can do we can also do, otherwise you're just supposing Chinese Exceptionalism.
Models aren’t everything. You need physical infrastructure at scale for inference, which is where the economic power comes from. Chinese hardware makes double the heat and needs at least double the energy input.
Exactly. And we better keep it this way. The fact that we can block them from copying us today means that they will try that much harder to come up with their own answers. Remember, they are miles ahead in manufacturing hardware and the software is not a problem anymore. Whatever moat cuda represented is gone now.
It's not like the chinese companies came up with their own breakthroughs that allowed their models come close or even match frontier capabilities but can run on your own machine rather than massive data centers. To say that US models are "the smartest kid in class" when talking about efficiency is just silly.
"The end result of that is much, much worse for the USA."
And therefore, much better for the world. Look at what the US has done with its dominance: maintained a petrodollar empire while steadfastly denying that such an empire exists, attacking countries that step out of line, murdering at will. Trump just made it obvious what the US did, and was blatant in his evil, but he was just continuing what other presidents did before him.
No, they haven't. They spent the first decade after WW2 repairing the damage left behind by the Japanese and their Civil War. Subsequently they managed to starve tens of millions afterwards in several missteps, and then righted themselves.
They then spent three to four decades lifting about thrice the US population out of extreme abject poverty, and then in the last 20 years catching up. And catch up they have; they are already the leaders in green technology and EVs, already manufacture some of their own chips, already have indigenous military aerospace capability, which they are now expanding to civilian use. They make almost everything in the average household.
Their view of China is decades out of date, and they aren't paying attention to the recent history of industries where China has gone from playing catch-up to outright dominance.
It's not just about the end product (GPUs or whatever). It's about the entire supply chain, manufacturing capacity, and industrial ecosystem behind it.
And the dangerous assumption is that being technologically ahead today guarantees you'll stay ahead tomorrow.
It doesn't matter if China's products are "only" 80–90% as good as their non-Chinese alternatives if those alternatives eventually go out of business because they've lost the market.
Once the customers, manufacturing capacity, suppliers, and expertise have migrated elsewhere, being technically superior doesn't mean much. And rebuilding that ecosystem is vastly harder than losing it.
We've seen versions of this play out in solar panels, batteries, consumer electronics, and increasingly automobiles. There's no reason to assume GPUs or CUDA-like software stacks are somehow immune.
That's what Jensen is (and was) trying to protect. Not just Nvidia's chip sales, but an entire ecosystem of expertise, manufacturing, suppliers, and supporting industries.
Otherwise, you risk repeating what happened with telecom equipment. Everyone buys the cheaper Chinese alternatives, non-Chinese suppliers lose market share or go out of business, and Chinese technology becomes embedded in critical infrastructure everywhere.
Then, SURPRISE, everyone suddenly realizes the security and geopolitical implications, worries about espionage, and starts demanding that it all be ripped out and replaced.
Except by then, you've already hollowed out the industries that could have supplied the replacements.
It’s difficult to talk about this stuff when starting from 0, but I’ll try to kick it off and leave it for someone else to wrap up.
China adopted an intentional strategy where western companies for benign reasons of profit leveraged China’s immense human capital to produce products and lower costs for everyone across the planet. This was a win for many. China got to industrialize and lift citizens out of poverty, and companies across the world were able to deliver mass produced good (eventually high quality) for cheap. The United States for example was the champion of China joining the WTO.
But China because it’s a communist dictatorship restricted its market and began doing things that were long-term oriented toward depriving others of power and manufacturing capability for their regime’s private gain. For example today we see that China has over-built its manufacturing capacity (like it did with housing) and has used artificially cheap labor, unjust laws, and currency manipulation (among many other things) to prevent entry into their market while running companies from other countries out of business leaving them dependent on Chinese manufacturing. Prominently you can look at Germany today where sales in China have collapsed, and at home their vaunted manufacturing industry is going through what happened in the US in the so-called “rust belt”. The US has smartly enacted tariffs and other measures to protect its market to some extent from China’s strategy here.
So when someone says something like “all this talk goes out the window about competition when it comes to China” you’ve got to understand a bit more about how China has behaved toward other nations and the egregiously unfair trade practices it has enacted to understand why many countries ranging from the US, to Mexico, to Australia and of course the EU have enacted various restrictions and industrial policy to combat China’s embarrassing and poor behavior on the global stage with respect to trade.
> China’s embarrassing and poor behavior on the global stage with respect to trade.
That is equivalent to saying that the Chinese have been as good businessmen as the Americans.
"Embarrassing and poor behavior on the global stage with respect to trade" is a phrase that is equally applicable to USA.
For decades USA had succeeded by various means of bribing and blackmailing to destroy the local industries in many countries, based on the propaganda about a free global trade, forcing those countries to not protect in any way their industries that competed with US companies, because supposedly if they bought instead cheaper and better US products that will be a win-win situation, even if they become dependent on USA, but they should not worry because USA can be trusted as a commercial partner and will always provide those products in advantageous terms.
But in the recent years, USA has made a U-turn, and now it makes desperate attempts to protect its own industries in the same way that it had forbidden other countries to do and moreover USA has invented bogus legal theories that when any products that contain even a few percent of parts with a US origin are sold to someone, the buyers do not own what they have bought, but USA has the right to dictate to them what to do with those products, so that now everybody knows that USA cannot be trusted as a commercial partner and buying anything from it must be avoided.
The Chinese may have used many unfair commercial tactics, but this is really not something that Americans may criticize, because since WWII USA has been a champion of unfair commercial tactics, of which most Americans do not appear to be aware.
As an example, I have seen in USA comments that when NATO has expanded by incorporating many Eastern European countries, that was a favor made to those. Nothing could be farther from the truth. Those countries were forced to buy their memberships with many billions of $. They were blackmailed to accept in exchange for their membership to make contracts worth of many billions for buying products or services from certain US companies at greatly inflated prices, so certain well-connected US shareholders must have gained a lot of money from the NATO expansion.
This was a single example, but it was just typical for how USA has always acted in the global trade since WWII, by using any means possible to gain commercial advantages for its major companies.
If one subscribes to the theory that the only mission of any company is to make as much money for its shareholders as possible, and that the state should assist in this objective, one can see the behavior of USA as legitimate, but then the fact that China was clever enough to also ensure as much profit for its industries as possible is equally legitimate.
As non-American and non-Chinese, I dislike equally their dominance in the global trade. In my opinion, the only way that would benefit to the entire mankind is to not have the production of anything concentrated in a single country or in a couple of countries, but it should be possible to produce locally everywhere any of the products that a human needs, from food and clothes to electronic components. The advantages in avoiding excessive dependencies from others far outweigh any economies of scale of mass production.
A half of century ago, this was not an unusual economic model, e.g. many US companies were licensing their IP to local producers in various countries, so they could produce there things that had been designed in USA, instead of importing finished products and becoming dependent. Nowadays companies are much greedier, so they are no longer content with a modest revenue from licensing, but they want to milk all the profit that can be obtained by being the only source for the end product, without alternatives, so patents and the like are used only for preserving a quasi-monopoly position, by preventing competition.
USA and China are free to act in their own best interests, but other countries should make much more serious efforts to reduce their external dependencies.
> As non-American and non-Chinese, I dislike equally their dominance in the global trade.
Perhaps you believe that, but it doesn't come across in your writing. You spent your entire post discussing and criticizing the United States, but your only mention of China has been "well America did it anyway" and "China was smart". Both true but besides the point - unless you want to continue cycles of mercantilism, in which case your criticism of the United States can be thus rejected. What's good for the goose is good for the gander, as they say.
I'd challenge you if you truly equally dislike the dominance to spend a similar amount of time criticizing China. If you are unable to do that, it's difficult to take your statement and attempt at positioning yourself as "I don't like either" at face value.
In principle, I dislike equally any monopoly, especially when the monopolistic position is obtained by what I would consider as cheating. So I would normally criticize equally China and USA, where applicable.
Nonetheless, right now, as an European, I know about bad past actions of China or suspicions of bad future actions of China from hearsay, as I have never been affected directly from any of them.
On the other hand, by what I consider as cheating, USA has already stolen a lot of money directly from my pocket, by many actions during the recent years, all of whom had only the purpose to eliminate the competition for US companies, to restrict the supply of various kinds of consumer goods and to raise their prices, in order to increase the profits of certain companies. Millions of ordinary people all over the world have lost money because they were forced to pay inflated prices for consumer goods, as a result of the anti-competitive actions of USA. The money lost by those people were eventually transferred to the shareholders of some US companies, and also of a few South Korean companies, which were the only beneficiaries of these US actions.
These anti-competitive actions have started with the sabotage of Huawei, exactly in the moment when it was predicted that it will pass soon from the 3rd position to the top of the smartphone vendors, in front of Samsung and Apple, while using their own chipsets, which were superior to those of Qualcomm.
The result of eliminating the main competitor for Qualcomm and Samsung has been a great increase in the price of the "flagship" smartphones. Before that, I could buy a "flagship" smartphone with e.g. $600, but nowadays smartphones that cost much above $1000 or even above $1500 are considered normal.
The second big step was the sabotage of the Chinese makers of flash memory and DRAM memory, also exactly in the moment when they were positioned to take a significant share in the memory market.
This action has preserved the dominance of Micron-Samsung-Hynix, which has created the necessary conditions for enabling the huge price increase of memories after the AI companies have hoarded most of the DRAM and SSD production.
To top all, the war started by USA has diminished a lot the supply for a lot of materials used in the electronic industry, which has raised a lot of prices. Now even the PCBs have become much more expensive than in the past. I have lived many decades, but today the ratio between the prices of computers, of smartphones and of many other kinds of electronic devices, and the revenues of normal people has become greater than during any other time that I can remember. There are also cheap products, but those have performance characteristics much worse than the corresponding old products, so buying any of those will not be an upgrade, but a serious downgrade.
Like many people, I was forced to make a few upgrades this year, even if I will delay any other upgrades as long as possible, so I already lost a lot of money.
So yes, for the moment, when I look at my accounts, I am more inclined to criticize USA for what they have already done, than to criticize China for what they might do in the future, if we are foolish enough to become dependent on them.
The problem is that you're viewing American actions in isolation and ignoring other players, including both the EU and China, and then saying well the US did all this stuff as if it happened in a vacuum.
Why would, for example, the United States demand that Huawei be removed from the networks of NATO allies? Could you think of a couple of reasons why that might have occurred?
If your concern is only cheap products, I have to assume you're also in favor of removing minimum wages, removing trade restrictions that the EU has enacted to for example protect its auto industry, dismantling labor unions in Europe, and removing other European market restrictions and protections which affect the United States (for example)? Would you be in favor of ASML being able to license out its technology to China? What do you think might happen? That will get you lower prices that you want. Why might you not want to do that? What is your answer for the destruction of Germany's automobile industry (and probably Italian and French automakers - remember you can't have protections in your world view here) and the hundreds of thousands of jobs that people will lose as China exports its cars from China to Europe?
It seems like you're just cherry-picking things to be mad at the US about but not holding a very logically consistent position while ignoring the actions of other actors on the world stage. It's a bit like having blinders on - the US is shining so bright and it's so important to everything in your life that you're neglecting the actions and policies of others, which of course is leading you to more extremist positions (low prices at all costs even if that results in crises in Europe).
USA has justified all its "sanctions" by "national security concerns".
However, what matters are the actions, not the words. The US "sanctions" had major effects on the markets for various consumer products and on the profits of certain companies, but they had little or no effect on anything that truly matters for national security.
Attempting to prevent Huawei from making smartphones has absolutely no relationship with the US national security.
Forbidding the use of Huawei communications equipment in critical infrastructure has absolutely nothing to do with the US "sanctions". Choosing what to buy is an internal matter of USA or of any other country that institutes such regulations and only incompetents will use in critical infrastructure black boxes that may be controlled by another country.
Trying to equate a measure taken against the world and in favor of Qualcomm, by sabotaging the production of smartphones at Huawei, with an internal regulation like forbidding the acquisition and use of Huawei equipment for infrastructure, is a logical fallacy. Only the second of these 2 is justified.
> Would you be in favor of ASML being able to license out its technology to China?
ASML is free to license its technology as they please, but obviously they would be very stupid to do so.
More than twenty years ago, Huawei entered the smartphone market by licensing the technology for making smartphones from Siemens. Siemens sent engineers in China, at Huawei, who stayed there for a half of year or more, to teach the Huawei engineers how to make smartphones.
Already at that time, I considered what Siemens was doing as being incredibly stupid. Of course, a few years later Huawei was making better and cheaper smartphones than Siemens, while Siemens decided to abandon the smartphone market. All that is the fault of the management of Siemens, not of anyone else. The worst part was not the licensing of the technology, even if that was very dumb, but the incapacity of the management to prioritize the continuous improvement of their products, both by becoming better and by becoming cheaper, while Huawei was very motivated to do this, so starting from at most the same position they still pulled far ahead.
I have seen plenty of companies which were forced to abandon markets, or went bankrupt or were acquired by competitors, and which blamed their fate on supposedly unfair competitors, e.g. from China. But in all those cases I have never seen any attempt from those companies to really compete. All were complacent to have products that were successful in the past and now they were making only negligible changes to them, especially from the point of view of the production costs, hoping that those products will continue to make money forever, even without any significant improvements.
I hope that the European car industry will survive, but if anything happens to it it will be only due to mismanagement, not due to China, because what should have been done to make competitive electric cars was known for decades and in Europe there was more expertise in power electronics than anywhere.
You accuse me of being in favor of things that directly contradict what I have said in my first comment.
I have already said that one of the things that I dislike at USA is that it has fought for decades to dismantle all protectionist barriers in all countries, to enable US companies to sell more there, which has lead to the destruction of many local industries. Now USA feigns forgetting all what has been said and done in the past, while trying to implement trade barriers.
I have also already said that I consider the availability of locally-produced goods, to avoid excessive interdependencies, more important than the lower price that could be achieved when all the production for the entire world of a certain item would be concentrated in a single giga-factory.
But protective measures must be chosen wisely. As long as there is no local production, there is nothing to protect. And also, if local production is protected from competition, there must exist alternative legal means to force them to design and fabricate competitive products, instead of exploiting the privilege of being protected.
Until I will see the resurrection of the European industries of memories and of smartphones, I would prefer to buy them cheaply from China, instead of being forced by the actions of the US government to buy them at triple prices from Micron and Qualcomm.
Interestingly, CXMT (ChangXin Memory Technologies) also started with Siemens technology: CXMT bought a big DRAM patent portfolio from Polaris Innovations, a Canadian patent-monetisation firm. The patents were originally from Qimonda which used to be Infineon. Qimonda’s Xi’an R&D center, with 400-500 engineers, was one of the largest Qimonda built outside Germany. After Qimonda’s collapse, their the whole Xi’an R&D center was acquired. In addition, CXMT successfully attracted Karl-Heinz Kuesters, a senior engineer, from Qimonda’s German site to Hefei, China. Kuesters had spent 24 years as a VP of technology and pre-development across Siemens, Infineon, and Qimonda.
> USA has justified all its "sanctions" by "national security concerns".
So what? The EU and China use their own bespoke language when they want to do something that doesn't in the minds of perhaps outsiders have a good justification.
> The US "sanctions" had major effects on the markets for various consumer products and on the profits of certain companies, but they had little or no effect on anything that truly matters for national security.
Which sanctions specifically? The ones we put on Russia which raised the cost of oil and gas and other commodities? I'm sure you are not in favor of those since it caused prices to rise. Right?
> Attempting to prevent Huawei from making smartphones has absolutely no relationship with the US national security.
The US didn't prevent Huawei from making smartphones, the US required that Huawei not be utilized in major infrastructure because of security concerns. The Chinese are obviously adversaries to the United States, Europe, Canada, Australia, Taiwan, and others and so utilizing their infrastructure which would of course have backdoors and permit Chinese spying on allied activity isn't acceptable. Seeing how Russia went on to invade Ukraine (supported by China) it proved to be a prescient move.
> Choosing what to buy is an internal matter of USA or of any other country
Exactly like how utilizing tariffs is an internal matter of the United States or any other country and allows us to choose what we buy. So you can't criticize American tariffs and also hold this view.
> ASML is free to license its technology as they please, but obviously they would be very stupid to do so.
They're actually not free to license their technology, believe it or not, because some of their key patents are American, but that's besides the point. But just to be clear, if allowed you would support ASML setting up shop in China, licensing its technology, and so forth to Chinese companies. If they did that, how long do you think it would be before ASML began to suffer the same fate as many other companies are now?
> I have already said that one of the things that I dislike at USA is that it has fought for decades to dismantle all protectionist barriers in all countries, to enable US companies to sell more there, ...
The US (along with Europe) worked to remove protectionist trade barriers over time to lower prices which you've advocated for. Europe wanted those removed (and then went on to add protectionist trade barriers back in while the US didn't) so they could sell more products to the American market.
> which has lead to the destruction of many local industries.
That's actually the fault of China. But I'm confused because you also support the destruction of local industries as long as it means lower prices. Why pay triple the cost for hand towels which could be manufactured in Portugal when you can get the same thing from China? Europe then allowed the imports of those products and your local industries collapsed or relocated manufacturing to China.
> I have also already said that I consider the availability of locally-produced goods, to avoid excessive interdependencies, more important than the lower price that could be achieved when all the production for the entire world of a certain item would be concentrated in a single giga-factory.
You said that but your comments don't support those claims. For example you want and are ok with the European car industry being destroyed by cheaper Chinese cars, but that would create excessive interdependencies (bye bye auto industry) and would remove locally-produced goods such as automobiles and the factories, raw material inputs, machinery, and parts used to create those vehicles.
> would prefer to buy them cheap from China, instead of being forced by the actions of the US government to buy them at triple prices from Micron and Qualcomm.
Europe chooses to engage with the United States for security. Europe also supports democratic Taiwan. You are blaming the wrong entity here. If Europe would no longer like the United States to support it militarily it can choose to do that. If Europe wants to support China over Taiwan they can do that. Spending 5x more on your military will result in some sort of cost increase or standard of living shuffle, but maybe that will be counteracted by additional cheap imports from China as you stop supporting democratic Taiwan? I guess it remains to be seen.
Eastern European countries begged to join NATO. Precisely because of what is happening to Ukraine now and precisely what is happening to Russian neighborhood countries. And America originally did not wanted then in, because it preferred to accommodate Russian feelings and imperial ambitions.
> China has behaved toward other nations and the egregiously unfair trade practices [...] China’s embarrassing and poor behavior on the global stage with respect to trade.
While EU and the other definitely need to deal with Chinas and its practices, the worst threat right now is USA. Speaking about egregiously unfair trade practices and poor behavior.
> to understand why many countries ranging from the US, to Mexico, to Australia and of course the EU have enacted various restrictions and industrial policy to combat China
Anything but actually stop having a complete dependency on China for their entire way of life of course because that would be too hard. So just do vague gestures to collect votes and move on.
It’s like the coupling with the US, it’s complicated. Complete decoupling is very difficult (if possible at all) and not really desirable. So the whole discussion is how hard, and where we put the line. Saying things like “they don’t actually want to” and “it’s too difficult to actually do it” is not very helpful.
Everyone wants more independence to some degree, it’s just that not everyone is prepared to pay the same price, or is willing to accept the same compromises. So yeah, if you personally put the line somewhere, you will be disappointed if a given government sees things differently and puts it somewhere else. It does not mean that everything is terrible and they are lazy or stupid.
How nice of China to give them the time and space to do that slowly so it doesn’t have to cause a lot of upheaval in their society. Now that’s an understanding and reasonable adversary. If only all national security threats behaved that way, things can be much better. Like imagine if Bin Laden had simply called ahead about 9/11, let people prepare, slowly empty the towers and create a safety zone around it, then the whole 9/11 fiasco could have been a fun demolition watch instead of all the hassle. He lacked class in my opinion.
> But China because it’s a communist dictatorship restricted its market and began doing things that were long-term oriented toward depriving others of power and manufacturing capability for their regime’s private gain.
As other states famously don't do things for their regime's private gain? (Even calling it "private gain" is arguably stretching it in the case of China, the other superpowers USA and Russia are certainly much better at the private gain part)
"Depriving others of power" other states definitively do whenever they can, and they're often better at it. Depriving others of manufacturing wasn't so much China did, as something it said "yes please" to and played along with. Manufacturing was offshored to a lot of other countries than China, this was something western leadership, for whatever reason, deeply wanted.
so many sterotypos in a row. no wonder you people never learn and will fail before you even know. The freedom of press really create a generation of brainwashed people in the 'free world'
We have that? SpaceX, ULA, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab to name a few I can think of.
> Since a lot of the rest of the US space world is struggling to successfully launch
Can you walk me through how you are arriving at this conclusion?
reply