Yea it's fine that China builds electric bikes because that's not a manufacturing capacity that the west cares about. In the US and Canada at least we need better infrastructure so that more people are riding them, or manual bikes, or walking.
> Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.
I also disagree that "in a lot of places it isn't possible". It is, actually. Most people live in urban areas and if we slightly adjust how we build and allow for proper levels of density then we don't even have to sell cars (which are a huge burden for the less wealthy).
There is no goal to get to 100% EV sales. If there is, I would support it as long as they're not Chinese. I'd rather buy another ICE vehicle than a Chinese EV because I care more about union jobs, American manufacturing capacity, and things like that than I do muddled visions of "if we just had EVs we would save the planet".
> Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long,
Well we can do it forever.
> and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.
Yea that's totally fine. The profitable customers though still remain in the west so if China wants to sell low priced EVs and follow the Android-ification strategy of gaining low-value market share I say more power to them. But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.
As your articles point out, China's increasing exports particularly to nearby countries which never had American markets to really begin with. I say that's a great thing for everyone. But you also have to acknowledge that the drive for Chinese exports is because of manufacturing overcapacity (this is a fact that can't be disputed) and because auto sales in China are falling (20% YoY) and their internal market is facing quite the challenge. But since we have auto industries we're not going to allow ours to collapse just to save Chinese jobs. It's nonsense.
> But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.
He said, in the thread "Mercedes-Benz to halt 'all future investments' in Germany." and while VW has ~100k layoffs planned. You say "allow it" like it is a choice. You can play to win, or lose, and western automakers are not currently playing to win. Maybe this changes! But probably not. It's easy to change, accept a reduction in profits and invest in EV production. But you're not keeping historical profits and winning, as a legacy automaker, as long as Chinese automakers are willing to make ~5% margins on their vehicles.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50484586 ("This is on the heels of VW also pulling out of Germany (as of just two days ago). VW is scrapping their biggest plant in Dresden and also shifting manufacturing to Eastern Europe and out of Germany for four other plants. German automakers can not longer remain competitive, for a few reasons.")
Certainly looks like the jobs are going away and the industries are collapsing, based on a preponderance of the evidence.
That's because auto sales collapsed in China [1] - did you forget the comment where I pointed out Chinese market sales are down 20% YoY across the board? - not because all of a sudden a bunch of Chinese EVs were imported. Volkswagen is working on building a massive new manufacturing facility in the US even [3].
Of course, the import of Chinese EVs would have an effect [2], and how the EU responds to that will be very interesting, but you're not looking at the broad picture and instead focusing on an ideological argument.
I am looking at the economics and trajectories, I'm unsure you think this is ideology. EV sales continue to rise, and China makes them, no other country is building EVs at this scale, and that is unlikely to change in the near term. Are EV sales globally going to go down? No, they are doubling every 2-3 years. Is China going to slow down building? No, they have to keep their exports humming. The world is their market, and they will sell into it forever (~90M units/year, as mentioned). Some countries may attempt or succeed at keeping them out, but the rest of the world will take the cheap EVs.
Do you disagree with this? My entire thesis is data, evidence, and observation driven. Are you arguing someone will build faster? If so, who? Provide evidence. Are you arguing protectionist policies? Sure, but only a few countries have auto manufacturing to protect, the rest of the world does not. So, where's the disconnect?
I've already explained in my posts above what the picture is. I don't really have anything else to say when you're just repeating what I've already walked through. Maybe someone else has some different insight. I hope you have a nice day!
Yea it's fine that China builds electric bikes because that's not a manufacturing capacity that the west cares about. In the US and Canada at least we need better infrastructure so that more people are riding them, or manual bikes, or walking.
> Certainly, there is a place for mass transit, biking (including e-bikes!), and walking where possible. In lots of places, it isn't possible, and so EVs will be sold to folks who want them. The faster we can impair combustion vehicles sales, the faster we get to 100% EV sales. If you want mobility, electric only.
I also disagree that "in a lot of places it isn't possible". It is, actually. Most people live in urban areas and if we slightly adjust how we build and allow for proper levels of density then we don't even have to sell cars (which are a huge burden for the less wealthy).
There is no goal to get to 100% EV sales. If there is, I would support it as long as they're not Chinese. I'd rather buy another ICE vehicle than a Chinese EV because I care more about union jobs, American manufacturing capacity, and things like that than I do muddled visions of "if we just had EVs we would save the planet".
> Legacy auto and nation states can protect their domestic markets only for so long,
Well we can do it forever.
> and countries without any domestic auto manufacturing are going to consume all of the cheap EVs China will build for them.
Yea that's totally fine. The profitable customers though still remain in the west so if China wants to sell low priced EVs and follow the Android-ification strategy of gaining low-value market share I say more power to them. But we're not going to allow our jobs to go away and our industries to collapse. It's non-negotiable.
As your articles point out, China's increasing exports particularly to nearby countries which never had American markets to really begin with. I say that's a great thing for everyone. But you also have to acknowledge that the drive for Chinese exports is because of manufacturing overcapacity (this is a fact that can't be disputed) and because auto sales in China are falling (20% YoY) and their internal market is facing quite the challenge. But since we have auto industries we're not going to allow ours to collapse just to save Chinese jobs. It's nonsense.