HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | bloppe's commentslogin

There's actually a ton of precedent that points to inference being considered fair use most of the time, unless you can get the LLM to start regurgitating substantial copyrighted work verbatim.

People usually like to point to Aaron Schwartz as the foil here. I'm not trying to say that what happened to him was right, but it was very consistent with copyright law. He was literally copying original works and distributing them.


You can get the LLMs to regurgitate copyrighted work.

I have mixed feelings on it though, and feel IP laws can and should be heavily modified, they’re more useful to big corporations than people.


The cheapness of replication is the reason IP was invented in the first place.

But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication, because a broader scope would amount to intellectual and cultural ossification.

IP does not account for cheap generation.


> But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication

Patents are old too. In both cases it's meant to be a practical system to incentivize publication of inventions and original works (people often forget that a fundamental requirement to getting a patent is that you must publicly document exactly how your invention works) but you could definitely argue that that bargain has broken down and nobody wants to publish original content anymore.

> IP does not account for cheap generation.

Ya I guess that's probably what GP meant.


duh, it's number Astra

We live in a golden age of confusion

Am I the only one struggling to understand why "leaving France" is a viable legal option, but implementing a GeoIP block that applies to France only was deemed insufficient by the court? How do these situations differ legally?

One could distinguish between criminal negligence and forgivable negligence in court. Unfortunately for GP that probably means you can't actually stick charges on anybody who serves malware via an ad network like this.

> One could distinguish between criminal negligence and forgivable negligence in court.

Open source is already expensive from a time standpoint, you wanna make it expensive from a monetary standpoint too?


Yes. Why should you be allowed to be negligent just because your product is open source?

The question is more "why should it cost $50k in legal fees to prove I wasn't negligent in my unpaid hobby".

in theory at least, frivolous lawsuits should be compensated for

In the US, that's quite rare.

Software is already hard from functionality standpoint, you wanna make it hard from security standpoint too?

It is already hard from a security standpoint, only that we ignore security.

Easy solution: Don't use ad networks. That'll likely free your site from illegal tracking, as well as ad trash, and will even improve your lIgHtHoUsE score!

Buy Bitcoin

Why would other forms of personal gain be categorically ignored?

We were getting ready to draw straws on who should join the anthill for some GPUs. Now we gotta find someone else to seduce.

Open source really should mean open training dataset, not merely open weights. There are some truly open source models and you can reproduce their training process if you have the compute. I can't think of a reason why those kinds of models would be incompatible with Stallmanism. Presumably they will get better and more widespread over time, like free software

Here's an example of a model that I believe fits this description: https://huggingface.co/common-pile/comma-v0.1-2t

Actually, this one also excludes nonfree data from the training set; there are probably more capable models that include downloadable nonfree data. I'm not sure if the dataset also needs to be free in order for the model to be considered free.


As someone who regularly gets quoted higher prices than others for the same airline ticket, I totally agree, but given that I know that airlines make razor-thin margins (often less than 5%), it's not totally obvious that this can be attributed to greed or malice. It's possible the airlines that set their prices "honestly" simply do not exist because they can't compete.

This is such a pervasive argument also used to justify a lot of bad stuff in tech ("if we don't do it, our competitors will" / "if you don't like it, you should have asked the regulators to stop me").

This is a small world. The US has something like ten major airlines. Eight if you don't count subsidiaries. Someone at the first one made a decision to embrace an exploitative pricing model. And then, someone at the second airline looked at this and thought to themselves, "you know, we're not gonna organize a PR campaign to stigmatize it, we're gonna try the same".


My point is that it's totally unclear to me that that's how this happened. There were at least a few airlines that did not say "we're gonna try the same", such as People Express Airlines and ValuJet, which explicitly tried to market themselves as fair, cheap, and transparently priced. Those airlines don't exist anymore. They went out of business, mostly because the other airlines used sophisticated pricing schemes to sabotage them. Maybe this was a failure of antitrust. It's certainly much more complicated than "all the airlines colluded together". Given the fact that the surviving airlines were never able to reach a particularly profitable "recoupment phase" of the predatory pricing process, it seems that this did not actually result in unfair prices on average (although business customers obviously get shafted every time).

In other words, modern airlines gouge certain customers, but effectively subsidize others. I would be unambiguously outraged only if they were gouging everyone and making fat stacks.


> Maybe this was a failure of antitrust.

It's a failure of customer protections laws. The same service legally should cost each customer the same. Sophisticated pricing schemes should be just plainly illegal.

You can't put an item in the store on the shelf and charge every customer what you like. You have to put up a price and adhere to that price regardless of who wants to buy. Anything else is illegal. Or at least should be.


This reminds me that flat pricing is a relatively new invention

>> For most of human history, you had to haggle over prices before you could buy something. The Quakers were among the first people to commit to fixed prices — and they did it because it was good morals. Turned out, it was also good business. This is the strange story of the long journey of that little piece of paper.[0]

Seems maybe this is just getting back to haggling, except where the seller has an unfair advantage, and we are trying to eke back a somewhat fair playing field using AI.

It could end up that (maybe wishful thinking), if enough people do it, United Airlines banning AI booking agents may lose them enough business they will need to cut prices or invite in AI agents.

[0] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/02/28/589278258/plan...


> This reminds me that flat pricing is a relatively new invention

It's a huge achievement of transparency and business predicatbility and we can't let companies weasel out of it because of their greed. What's good for some individuals is not good for the market. And the health of the market is a priority.


Of course you can!

I definitely have increased the price of consulting for "annoying" customers doing stuff I don't want to do. Many moons ago, I was doing some contract training for a small airline here in town. I liked teaching but I didn't really want to do the training they wanted me to do - it was a pain in the ass, it took a week, and didn't really pay enough to justify the opportunity cost.

So I kept raising my price, and eventually, they stopped asking me to do the training. It was great because I didn't have to do the thing I didn't want to do anymore, and I made more money. You are allowed to charge different people different amounts of money - some people are just a pain in the butt and charging more pays for the lack of sanity.


But that's just charging different amounts for different services. Not at all the same as the typical end user price discrimination which is all about charging whatever you can get away with with that particular cusomer.

I agree with the principle but where I think price discrimination goes too far is, for example, Uber charging people more by age or statistically imputed income. Or PlayStation charging more for a game by the time of day.

Notice the difference. One is charging people more because they're actually costing you something by imposing an inconvenience, the other is charging people more because you've X-rayed their wallet and set the price to be the amount that cleans them out.

Notice also the thing the customers should be doing in response to the second one: Sharing the prices they're shown for everything with the other customers so they can arbitrage by having the person offered the lowest price be the one to order it.


> Notice also the thing the customers should be doing in response to the second one: Sharing the prices they're shown for everything with the other customers so they can arbitrage by having the person offered the lowest price be the one to order it.

Ah, but this is worst in industries where resale is not possible. For example, flights, digital games, and rideshare. Of course one has the option to just not fly, buy games, or use Uber, but this limits a lot of convenience and function in a modern society. This is why I think targeted regulation is not such a bad thing - provided, as you explain, that the reason for the price discrimination is not because the customer actually costs the business more.


> Ah, but this is worst in industries where resale is not possible. For example, flights, digital games, and rideshare.

Resale is only not possible in those industries because the companies are getting away with forcing it to be. That's the actual problem. You shouldn't need the airline's permission to resell your non-refundable plane ticket. You shouldn't have to use Uber's app to summon an Uber, so that Bob can use a different app to automatically summon one for Alice when Uber is trying to show Alice a higher price, and then Alice and Bob each get half the difference between the prices they're being shown.


I agree. I would also like to see regulation on this.

So is the idea that laws should allow price gouging only for certain reasons that they must be able to justify?

That would get gamed immediately and we'd be in the same spot. Allow price differences for problem customers that require more attention and airlines will say that why they change prices basedcon certain factors.


> That would get gamed immediately and we'd be in the same spot.

That's what happens anyway. Instead of showing you a different price for the same product, they show the person they want to charge more a subtly different product that costs more etc. There are way too many ways to do things like that for a general prohibition on "price discrimination" to actually work.

What you need instead is a way to apply competitive pressure against companies who try to do that. When they show you a higher price, something outside of their control should be automatically checking for you to see if anyone else has a lower price for something equivalent, so that doing that causes them to lose business.


I'd be supportive of a consumer-side tool that lets buyers see what prices others have been shown for the same product.

That falls squarely within the realm of where I think these problems should be solved, the consumer. We need people informed so they can patronize who they agree with and avoid companies they disagree with. What we don't need is regulation trying to enforce this, regulators always get bought, regulations get nerfed ahead of time or gamed after the fact, etc.


The main issue here is that you need the consumer-side tool to not be blocked by the companies. You especially need them not to be able to have the entity providing it sued or prosecuted, which might require changes to some laws.

Yeah I'd be very curious what laws might exist that would make such a tool illegal. It'd be hard to create, but I'm not sure how a company would claim its illegal for a tool to share the price shown for a given product and user.

The idea is that if you have a handful of customers and you offer bespoke service to each you can have custom pricing. If you offer standardized service to many customers, you can't.

Airlines are already a good example of how that would be hard to regulate though. Their cost basis is pretty fluid, especially when we start wars that throw a wrench in the oil industry. Seats aren't uniform in value, some are more valued by customers than others and some come with perks like legroom or free drinks.

Trying to write regulation that is understandable, enforceable, and not leaky without focusing on any one industry is just really hard to do.

Its much easier for customers to simply stop paying if they lose faith in a company or find that all companies offering said service or seem to collude or use the same dirty tricks. We don't have to fly, for example, effectively all of human history survived without it.


> Trying to write regulation that is understandable, enforceable, and not leaky without focusing on any one industry is just really hard to do.

That's why when writing regulation you shouldn't think about any industry at all. Just focus on the customers. Regulate with customers in mind only.

> Its much easier for customers to simply stop paying if they lose faith in a company or find that all companies offering said service or seem to collude or use the same dirty tricks.

Customers can't do that. They can be manipulated into almost anything. That's why Santa is red, we've got halitosis and single use electronics exists. Regulations should protect customers and customers only.


It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner. What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.

> It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner.

Why not? It's software. Instead of searching Amazon for a product, you use a third party service that searches Amazon (and every other seller) for you, using the account of some other user(s) who are being shown lower prices. Then the order gets placed as them but shipped to you and the difference in price gets shared between the two users and the third party service.

The thing stopping it is if the companies are allowed to block it from happening, and that's the thing they shouldn't be allowed to do.

In general a company shouldn't be allowed to control the interface through which the customer orders their product or service. Providing one is fine; prohibiting the customer from using a different one is not.

> What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.

The problem there is that "price discrimination" is extremely hard to define, much less identify.

Suppose you go to the site and it shows you a price of $7 but your cousin visits five minutes later or earlier and it shows them a price of $5. Is that price discrimination, or is it because you have a different address and there is some legitimate reason it costs more when you're in the other location? Or is it because the price just changed for everyone, but they're willing to honor the lower price for a period of time for a user who was already shown it? Or because one of you is looking at model number 123A and the other at 123B, which are visually identical but have some trivial difference that cause them to have a different price?

You don't have to deal with that entire quagmire if you just have your cousin place the order at the lower price, and companies shouldn't be able to stop you from automating that or having someone automate it for you.


I still think the solution to most of those difficulties is to tilt the rules based on size. If joeschmoe.com wants to sell paper clips at different prices to different visitors, fine. If Amazon wants to do it, not fine. Just set broad guidelines and say "if any large company comes anywhere near these limits, they will be destroyed".

But you don't have a way to figure out what your competitors are charging and have automated systems find the maximum you can extract without losing the customer

> You can't put an item in the store on the shelf and charge every customer what you like. You have to put up a price and adhere to that price regardless of who wants to buy. Anything else is illegal. Or at least should be.

It should be but unfortunately I don't think it is. The main reason store prices are the same for everyone is because it wasn't practical to individualize them without making it clear to purchasers that they are getting screwed. Still, store membership programs / value cards are one way this is being done in a limited way. And some stores are already switching to digital price labels which can be updated instantly so this is going to get a whole lot worse.


In Poland its a law for physical stores. If you put out a product for sale you must label it with a price. And the product and the price constitute a sell offer. Buyer can accept your offer and then you have to give him the product for exactly that amount of money. Anything else is illegal. If you made a mistake in the price, that's the cost of your mistake.

Russia too. Yes, some store chains try to dodge this by saying "but computer said price was updated!"(label photo usually helps) and this law somehow doesn't apply online (large online marketplaces use trick where they provide variable discount).

Legally for ecommerce in Poland, when you put out a product description with a price it's not understood as a sale offer but as an invitation to issuing buy offers which the seller may or may not accept. It was done like that probably because in case of ecommerce likelyhood of an error in price is higer and it can impact thousands of purchases before it's detected. I'm not sure how that relates to requirement of same price for everyone. Also discounts are allowed and they could probably be personalized. I haven't heard about comapnies using that for anything else except some contrived loyalty programs, but I think in theory it could be if almost nobody pays the undiscounted price. Haven't seen a company that operates like that. Yet.

Market segmentation is widely practiced. I believe your objection is not to the overall practice but rather certain aspects of it.

My local grocery store has a senior discount on Tuesday mornings.

Many places have student discounts.

Some places offer a discount if you buy in bulk.

I used to be a book store club member, which would give me a discount on prices. A local history club has monthly public talks, with discounted prices for members. And of course most grocery stores have that sort of scheme.

My father worked for a company which offered family discounts to its employees.

You'll find little support for making all of those illegal.

Of course some of these schemes are illegal in some areas, such as a bar offering discounted drinks for women, but those fall under civil rights law, not customer protection.

I tried to come up with a solid way to prohibit the market segmentation practices you don't like, but it's such a slippery concept that I failed.

Like, consider how some regions require bars to close by, say, midnight, but members-only clubs are allowed to be open after hours. These clubs respond by making membership trivial -- show up at the door, apply for membership, and you are in.

"Do you want to apply for the student club? Membership is free, with student id, and then you can pay the student club fee rather than the public fee." Repeat with "retired club, with proof of age" and "frequent buyer club', etc.


The main difference between your examples and what prompted this discussion is transparency. The student/senior discounts aren't actively hidden from other customers.

And bulk discounts aren't market segmentation, but a way for the store to pass on reduced costs due to lower overheads to the customer. Again, they are also usually clearly disclosed because incentives are aligned.


I mentioned grocery store cards. I'm pretty sure you know that while they show club prices on the shelf, many actively hide additional discounts by offering personalized discounts, right?

I don't every remember seeing places which are transparent about the discounts they offer staff and family off staff. At the very least, I've never seen signs listing those discounts.

Okay, it's not market segmentation. My comment was in response to what scott79 wrote: 'You have to put up a price and adhere to that price regardless of who wants to buy.'

That means that if I didn't list a bulk price and someone comes in and asks what the discount is for a bulk order, then, what, I need to refuse them?

Or can I can scribble the price on the tag right then, for the sale, and erase it immediately afterward?

I'm simply not able to figure out what the guidelines should be. I'm also not sure that "transparent" is that useful of a term, given how easy it is to put clauses in terms&services which people affirm without reading.

Or from HHGTTG: “But the plans were on display…” ... “It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying ‘Beware of the Leopard.”


Its a failure of customers, we don't have to pay them our money and fly on their planes.

If we really care about prices changing per passenger, quality of services, terms and conditions, etc them just don't fly with the airlines that have those practices you disagree with. If that's every airline, well you don't have to fly at all.


I agree in principle but airfare pricing must be more complicated and harder to get right than normal retail. Seems crtainly worth trying to get this right tho

So then, haggling should be illegal and banned or is this idea of "one price for everyone" only to be applied to airline tickets?

Negotiating a price is as old as humans. "That merchant over there is charging 10% less. Can you beat that?", "I want to buy 10 of these, can you give me a bulk discount?"

I have friends that haggle at local stores. One goes does the "Store X is cheaper thing". Another does "My parents live in Oregon where they're is no sales tax, can you lower your price to cover the difference? Otherwise I'll just have them bring it down from Oregon", etc....


How do you haggle with algorithm that is being fed on aggregated data of who you are, how much do you make and what you did yesterday?

It is nowhere close to example you gave.


Exactly. Haggling makes sense when the two parties hav similar levels of information and agency. For entirely one sided transactions where one party has all the power such arbitrage only benefits the powerful party and it is very reasonable for us to come together and decide to make that illegal.

That's not true.

There are many conditions under which price variation allows the seller to maximize the overall amount of services/products that it sells to the largest number of people, all of whom feel like they're getting a good deal.

Should a loaf of bread cost the same thing in Malaysia as it does in the US? No. And if you required it to be such, then people in Malaysia simply wouldn't have bread, and people in the US would likely have higher prices because cutting off less-wealthy markets would reduce the economies of scale that drive overall prices.


Thread is about cost of the same loaf of bread for different people.

Should it be different depending who they are, or more precisely who seller thinks they are?


I don't have a position to take on whether they should be different. I have a position to take against the false claim that any such variation is necessarily advantageous only to the "more powerful" party.

> I would be unambiguously outraged only if they were gouging everyone and making fat stacks.

No, the thing they're doing is still awful.

The basic problem is that they do actually have competitors and are offering a product which is basically fungible, so their margins are inherently going to suck, even if they do every slimy thing, because then their competitors will just do the same thing and they're back to having thin margins only now they've made everything more deceptive/inconvenient/confusing.

The ideal thing in a market like that is to have an efficient way for customers to cut through the BS and find the best price for a ticket that isn't screwing them in covert ways, because then the deceptive tactics don't work, which takes away the incentive to do them. They'll still have thin margins, only with less deception.

But an individual airline can't unilaterally allow that if their competitors have a way to block it or they'd be at a competitive disadvantage, so they're going to try to stop that from happening. It's in no one's interest -- not even theirs -- to let them. They just need you to not let their competitors get away with it either.


I'd argue there's only three "major" carriers: American, United, and Delta.

The rest, such as Frontier, JetBlue, Southwest, Allegiant - are all discount and/or regional airlines.

For example, allegiant flies to most cities secondary airports that are 1-2 hours drive from the city.

EDIT: It's really 4 equally large ones by passenger miles:

* 1 Delta Air Lines 17.8%

* 2 American Airlines 17.5%

* 3 Southwest Airlines 17.3%

* 4 United Airlines 16.0%

The rest are sub 10%


Southwest and Alaska are absolutely major carriers. Not the absolute largest perhaps but major. Alaska is certainly not discount, and despite the name is not particularly regional.

To your edit, Alaska is something like 9.9%. Technically below 10%, but barely.


No, they aren’t. Alaska is slightly more of a major carrier than Southwest, but just barely. It’s the same as Jet Blue, except it has the American partnership for code sharing that helps it have an appearance of better coverage across the US. Yes, it carries more passengers, but that doesn’t put it in the same league as the three majors.

Like Jet Blue, Alaska has a handful of wide bodies (that it got from its Hawaiian acquisition) and does a few international routes on its own metal, but it is an airline you fly domestically and that primarily serves the west coast most effectively.

It’s not a bad airline (it’s also not anything special), but it’s not the equivalent of American, United, or Delta. And that isn’t to say the individual flying experience might not be the same as those carriers, but it’s not the same class of operation as a business. Again, it does a handful of international flights. To me, major means you have an array of wide-body jets and a large international operation. Not a few seasonal routes on its 29 wide-bodies. For comparison, American has a fleet of 137 wide body jets. Delta has 179. United has over 240.

These are not the same.

Southwest is even less of a major carrier. It’s got a lot of marketshare from its previous era focused on selling the idea that it was cheaper than the majors, but it operates one type of jet, has zero wide bodies and its international destinations don’t count.

And while Alaska might have to use American to pad out its network of flights at major hubs and markets, at least it can. Southwest’s design to eschew major hubs means that tou can’t get a lot of direct flights to major cities. If it happens to fly where you travel to, fine, but otherwise you have to look at at least one hop and go to a smaller airport than what you might expect.


It all depends how you measure. The statistics will say whatever you ask.

> Southwest is even less of a major carrier. It’s got a lot of marketshare from its previous era focused on selling the idea that it was cheaper than the majors, but it operates one type of jet, has zero wide bodies and its international destinations don’t count.

Southwest's market cap is more than double American.


> Like Jet Blue, Alaska has a handful of wide bodies

Jetblue doesn’t have widebody aircraft, but they still offer transatlantic connections.


The Alaskan problem is they more often have unique routes. Which is great and serves cool stuff, but you can’t always count on it bringing competition to your main flight. Allegiant is similar.

If you're in the western half of the country, Alaska is essentially always a route for wherever you want to go, whether staying west or going east.

If you're already on the east coast and aren't going to the west coast, then Alaska doesn't have a route. So I suppose they are "regional", where the region is about 70% of the country rather than all of it.


You don't have to go to the east coast to have trouble finding them. In St Louis they have a whole 4 flights, and 3 go to the west coast. So yes, absolutely regional. And that's the western side of the midwest. In comparison, Southwest has 55 direct destinations from the same airport. This isn't cherry picking: You have as sparse a route map from Dallas, yet another non trivial city. From there, Southwest has 70+ direct flights.

So yes, still a regional airline if your home base isn't exactly on the west coast.


Which is actually worse than the regulated airlines were before Jimmy Carter deregulated them. When prices were uniformly set by the government, there were 11 "trunk" airlines in 1978, 9 regional airlines, and three unregulated intrastate airlines- one was Southwest (flying just in Texas, the other two, Air California and PSA, were just in California). Those 23 airlines are now down basically to the Big 4 plus 3 little ones (Alaska, Jet Blue, Frontier). Airline tickets were more expensive- well, the prices were about the same number of dollars but thanks to inflation that's a lot less buying power.

> Which is actually worse

why?

given "Airline tickets were more expensive"


I meant just in terms of number of airlines, we are worse off. Oh, and service quality. And comfort in flight. (Ignoring things that changed in the rest of society: in 1978 all flights had smoking sections!)

I specifically mentioned the price as the one metric that has improved. And it's a pretty important metric! But not the only one.


You can still get service, comfort, and quality on modern airlines - you just have to pay the 2026 equivalent of a 1977 coach ticket. And I'll bet today's first class is better than yesteryear's coach.

> I meant just in terms of number of airlines, we are worse off.

Ok, but why do you care how many airlines exist? Competition?

Guess what? There was a larger number of airline CEOs, and... less competition! Airline profit margins were fat back in the day (isn't excessive "producer surplus" supposedly a sign of a non-competitive market?).

Not only did the government set the maximum and minimum price an airline could charge, but all routes had to be approved by the government. Airlines who served a particular route were even allowed to protest when another airline petitioned to offer service on that route, and "too many competitors" was considered a valid reason to deny an application.

The reason we have so many fewer airlines today is that some airlines outcompeted others after airlines were finally allowed to compete for customers. One of the things that nobody likes to talk about w.r.t. competition is "what happens to the competitor who got out-competed?"

The answer is: He exits the market (goes bankrupt or gets merged into another competitor). This happens one-by-one until the number of competitors has been reduced enough to achieve a stable market equilibrium. That equilibrium is achieved when the number of competitors is sufficiently small to give the remaining competitors "pricing power" to maintain reasonable profit margins (and thus not go bankrupt).

> Oh, and service quality. And comfort in flight.

Right, when the government makes it illegal to compete on price, you have to compete on other things.

You can still get that old-school level of service and comfort today. It's called first class, and it's great!

They do all sorts of wonderful things, like offer a glass of bubbly before takeoff, halfway decent food, loads of legroom, wide seats for our fat American butts, a couple free checked bags, and flight attendants who act like they give a damn. Most of that wasn't included in a domestic economy ticket back in the old days.

The best part is that modern domestic first class still only costs about the same as an old-school economy ticket. But it turns out that what almost all customers really want is the cheapest ticket possible. Their revealed preference is that they prefer lower quality, no checked bag, and cheaper prices. Airlines who offered this option survived and those who didn't perished.


Economy Plus or whatever most carriers call it these days (aka domestic first class) is definitely not "first class" in any real comfort sense.

I road it once, and the only real difference is an included hard drink, getting off first (which doesn't matter if you have a checked bag), and more leg room before your knees hit the wall in front of you. Debatable about feet room though, since feet can't slide under the wall...


> Which is actually worse than the regulated airlines were before Jimmy Carter deregulated them

Worse than when the government set, not just the maximum, but also the minimum price an airline could charge for a ticket? You're saying that time, when price competition was literally illegal, was better than today?

Is there any chance that you're not actually old enough to remember that time?

What, pray tell, is the advantage of competition when the competitors are forced by the government to charge the same price for the same route? And not just forced to charge the same price, oh no! But forced to charge a price higher than railroads (which cost more to operate than airlines), so as not to outcompete railroads, which are both slower and more expensive to operate.


Free markets compete, it's what they do.

It's like getting mad at your cat for killing a bird - it's just what cats do.

The answer to this behavior isn't being mad at or boycotting particular airlines, it is regulation.


The interesting thing is that even though they got deregulated, the airline business is not a true free market.

So much of the business is mediated through limited realestate inside airports (which are a quasi-public organization).

That's some of the reason why there are monopolistic dynamics at play. Only so many planes can land at an airport and the times of day are restricted. This is true in every major urban city in the USA- NY, LA, SF, Chicago, etc.


"The market" is not doing anything. My point is that there are rational agents making decisions here, and it's not even some intractable situation where you have 1,000 players and someone will necessarily be a scumbag. This is a small industry with a very high bar to entry. They don't get to pin it on market forces.

And I have actually heard "if you hate it, you should have asked the regulators to stop me from doing it" from a techie, and man... no. You have agency. You own this. If you need a regulator to stop you, you're not a good person, sorry. The market didn't make you do this. You just felt that it absolved you.


Sure, but are you looking to assign moral culpability or fix the problem? Because the market and regulatory environment is what ensures that the people you are judging to be bad will be the ones that are succeeding. It doesn't matter how bad you (or anyone else) think it is, if even a small fraction of people are willing to do it and they are rewarded for doing so, then they will be the people who are in a position to do it.

> The answer to this behavior isn't being mad at or boycotting particular airlines, it is regulation.

Or, you know…accept that a cat is a cat, and stop trying to regulate scratching simply because you don’t like it.

(I get that you probably understand this, but the “regulation is the solution” is kind of a leap. People whining about efficient market pricing have always struck me as just fundamentally misunderstanding what capitalism is.)


Monopolistic competition is not efficient markets.

OK. Cool. That has nothing to do with what I said, or the topic.

I can barely afford to live because I'm competing with others for the same scarce supply of houses, good schools, and groceries.

Where is the sympathy for me? Why do only large corporations get to use the "competition" excuse?


You have my deepest sympathies, but to be clear, I would genuinely prefer to live in a world where airline pricing was more transparent and fair, I just can't attribute the fact that I don't live in that world to greed on the part of airlines

This comment doesn't even make sense. Nobody is stopping you from pricing your services however you want

Humans need a minimum of about 1,200 calories a day. If a human prices their services too low, they won't be able to afford to eat and will die. If a human prices their services too high, they won't be able to afford to eat and will die.

You cannot price your services however you want.


In the United States, you are not seriously at risk of being unable to consume 1200 calories a day, between SNAP, community food banks, and other state and local resources, unless you have a serious mental disorder or cognitive disability that would prevent you from being able to price your work in the first place.

I know you think you said something interesting, but you really didn't. You can absolutely price your services however you want, and if you die pricing your services too high or low: well that was a silly thing to want.

That has nothing to do with what we are talking about though, and was not the point in the first place. An airline obviously cannot price their services too high or low and expect to survive. You didn't show how the user's comment made sense in the context that it was originally made, nor did you give a proper retort to my comment.

You just picked the wrong thing to focus on and contributed nothing to the conversation.


“Good” schools are made up of their members. Good houses are largely a function of location, and community. Good groceries… I don’t know. Never knew this was an issue in the year 2026 outside of, like, North Korea.

But anyhow, you see the problem.


> Never knew this was an issue in the year 2026 outside of, like, North Korea.

Look up food deserts. I'm sure there are myriad issues you think exist only in North Korea.


Food deserts are simply a consequence of grocery retailers avoiding locations that are unprofitable because of high shrinkage.

Blue Apron, instacart, hello fresh, etc. The logistical options boggle the mind, as long as one has enough money.

> The logistical options boggle the mind, as long as one has enough money.

Yes, obviously. But you said these conditions don't exist outside of North Korea, while people live in poverty the world over.


Likely cheaper than owning a car in a food desert though.

If one had enough money they wouldn't be living in a food desert.

They would, and do, but never notice it. The 30 minute drive to the trader joes is just part of life

I honestly don’t see the point of this comment, it’s not even that coherent. Are you saying poor communities should just go conjure up some “location” benefits, or conjure up some money to get more nutritious food? Please expand.

> it’s not even that coherent.

They are saying the biggest problem with the poor communities you're talking about is the people living in them. That seems true statistically no? Or at least, there's more data that supports that than the idea that there's magic soil in the rich communities.

Are we going to pretend like communities aren't shaped by their people now and everybody is just NPCs that has no influence over what their communities look like?

We can at least rule out that poor people can't make good communities because there are plenty of counterexamples that show otherwise.


Maybe if you took one step farther out, you would see that the reasons some people and communities are poor are due to external factors. But go on, keep blaming all your problems on the individual poor people that obviously have something wrong with them.

> But go on, keep blaming all your problems on the individual poor people that obviously have something wrong with them.

Well, I didn't say I had any problems so I'm not sure what you're even referencing here. Weird strawman

> you would see that the reasons some people and communities are poor are due to external factors.

Oh spare me. This is like reaching algebra and thinking you've reached the frontier of mathematics in 2026. As if nature vs nurture wasn't drilled into every prepubescent brain in even the worst school systems in the west. It seems that you're the one that's unable to escape elementary pop psychology.


I see from your history you have some incredibly bad takes and analogies that simply don’t work. Most of what you say I doubt even you understand. For your own sake, go get out of whatever bubble you’re in for 5 minutes.

> I doubt even you understand

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.

When disagreeing, reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

…

Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.


Low IQ signal is focusing on the analogy instead of the point being made. You're still in grad school, spare me about bubbles. I very much doubt you have the kind of self awareness that warrants this kind of comment

One of the most interesting things I recently discovered about airlines in the States is basically none of them make money selling airline tickets. It's break even at best. They are all credit card companies who happen to also fly people around.

Around break even is exactly where comoditized services should be.

European budget airliners make money with selling overpriced sandwiches and coffee. People want cheap so the profit has to come from somewhere.

> It's possible the airlines that set their prices "honestly" simply do not exist because they can't compete.

Or perhaps it’s simply not a functioning competitive market in the first place, for a variety of reasons including obvious ones like large barriers to entry.


It doesn't have to be attributed to any negative moral stance. I think the people implementing these pricing schemes don't think they're in the wrong.

- It's that having an AI agent try to find me a lower price is a completely rational outcome of the situation.

But also note that a dynamic of consolidation in all industries seems to make financial transactions more and more adversarial- self-checkout (Walmart specifically), Amazon pricing, etc.


Delta is one of the healthier companies with an operating margin of 9.4 percent (this year's September earnings)

What about over the last 10 years or so?

That they will charge you more for the exact same service just because they think you can/will is evidence of greed and malice in and of itself.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: