I definitely have increased the price of consulting for "annoying" customers doing stuff I don't want to do. Many moons ago, I was doing some contract training for a small airline here in town. I liked teaching but I didn't really want to do the training they wanted me to do - it was a pain in the ass, it took a week, and didn't really pay enough to justify the opportunity cost.
So I kept raising my price, and eventually, they stopped asking me to do the training. It was great because I didn't have to do the thing I didn't want to do anymore, and I made more money. You are allowed to charge different people different amounts of money - some people are just a pain in the butt and charging more pays for the lack of sanity.
But that's just charging different amounts for different services. Not at all the same as the typical end user price discrimination which is all about charging whatever you can get away with with that particular cusomer.
I agree with the principle but where I think price discrimination goes too far is, for example, Uber charging people more by age or statistically imputed income. Or PlayStation charging more for a game by the time of day.
Notice the difference. One is charging people more because they're actually costing you something by imposing an inconvenience, the other is charging people more because you've X-rayed their wallet and set the price to be the amount that cleans them out.
Notice also the thing the customers should be doing in response to the second one: Sharing the prices they're shown for everything with the other customers so they can arbitrage by having the person offered the lowest price be the one to order it.
> Notice also the thing the customers should be doing in response to the second one: Sharing the prices they're shown for everything with the other customers so they can arbitrage by having the person offered the lowest price be the one to order it.
Ah, but this is worst in industries where resale is not possible. For example, flights, digital games, and rideshare. Of course one has the option to just not fly, buy games, or use Uber, but this limits a lot of convenience and function in a modern society. This is why I think targeted regulation is not such a bad thing - provided, as you explain, that the reason for the price discrimination is not because the customer actually costs the business more.
> Ah, but this is worst in industries where resale is not possible. For example, flights, digital games, and rideshare.
Resale is only not possible in those industries because the companies are getting away with forcing it to be. That's the actual problem. You shouldn't need the airline's permission to resell your non-refundable plane ticket. You shouldn't have to use Uber's app to summon an Uber, so that Bob can use a different app to automatically summon one for Alice when Uber is trying to show Alice a higher price, and then Alice and Bob each get half the difference between the prices they're being shown.
So is the idea that laws should allow price gouging only for certain reasons that they must be able to justify?
That would get gamed immediately and we'd be in the same spot. Allow price differences for problem customers that require more attention and airlines will say that why they change prices basedcon certain factors.
> That would get gamed immediately and we'd be in the same spot.
That's what happens anyway. Instead of showing you a different price for the same product, they show the person they want to charge more a subtly different product that costs more etc. There are way too many ways to do things like that for a general prohibition on "price discrimination" to actually work.
What you need instead is a way to apply competitive pressure against companies who try to do that. When they show you a higher price, something outside of their control should be automatically checking for you to see if anyone else has a lower price for something equivalent, so that doing that causes them to lose business.
I'd be supportive of a consumer-side tool that lets buyers see what prices others have been shown for the same product.
That falls squarely within the realm of where I think these problems should be solved, the consumer. We need people informed so they can patronize who they agree with and avoid companies they disagree with. What we don't need is regulation trying to enforce this, regulators always get bought, regulations get nerfed ahead of time or gamed after the fact, etc.
The main issue here is that you need the consumer-side tool to not be blocked by the companies. You especially need them not to be able to have the entity providing it sued or prosecuted, which might require changes to some laws.
Yeah I'd be very curious what laws might exist that would make such a tool illegal. It'd be hard to create, but I'm not sure how a company would claim its illegal for a tool to share the price shown for a given product and user.
The idea is that if you have a handful of customers and you offer bespoke service to each you can have custom pricing. If you offer standardized service to many customers, you can't.
Airlines are already a good example of how that would be hard to regulate though. Their cost basis is pretty fluid, especially when we start wars that throw a wrench in the oil industry. Seats aren't uniform in value, some are more valued by customers than others and some come with perks like legroom or free drinks.
Trying to write regulation that is understandable, enforceable, and not leaky without focusing on any one industry is just really hard to do.
Its much easier for customers to simply stop paying if they lose faith in a company or find that all companies offering said service or seem to collude or use the same dirty tricks. We don't have to fly, for example, effectively all of human history survived without it.
> Trying to write regulation that is understandable, enforceable, and not leaky without focusing on any one industry is just really hard to do.
That's why when writing regulation you shouldn't think about any industry at all. Just focus on the customers. Regulate with customers in mind only.
> Its much easier for customers to simply stop paying if they lose faith in a company or find that all companies offering said service or seem to collude or use the same dirty tricks.
Customers can't do that. They can be manipulated into almost anything. That's why Santa is red, we've got halitosis and single use electronics exists. Regulations should protect customers and customers only.
It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner. What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.
> It's not practical to have customers coordinating purchases in that manner.
Why not? It's software. Instead of searching Amazon for a product, you use a third party service that searches Amazon (and every other seller) for you, using the account of some other user(s) who are being shown lower prices. Then the order gets placed as them but shipped to you and the difference in price gets shared between the two users and the third party service.
The thing stopping it is if the companies are allowed to block it from happening, and that's the thing they shouldn't be allowed to do.
In general a company shouldn't be allowed to control the interface through which the customer orders their product or service. Providing one is fine; prohibiting the customer from using a different one is not.
> What should happen is the customers report to a regulatory agency "this seller is engaging in illegal price discrimination" and that agency brings the hammer down.
The problem there is that "price discrimination" is extremely hard to define, much less identify.
Suppose you go to the site and it shows you a price of $7 but your cousin visits five minutes later or earlier and it shows them a price of $5. Is that price discrimination, or is it because you have a different address and there is some legitimate reason it costs more when you're in the other location? Or is it because the price just changed for everyone, but they're willing to honor the lower price for a period of time for a user who was already shown it? Or because one of you is looking at model number 123A and the other at 123B, which are visually identical but have some trivial difference that cause them to have a different price?
You don't have to deal with that entire quagmire if you just have your cousin place the order at the lower price, and companies shouldn't be able to stop you from automating that or having someone automate it for you.
I still think the solution to most of those difficulties is to tilt the rules based on size. If joeschmoe.com wants to sell paper clips at different prices to different visitors, fine. If Amazon wants to do it, not fine. Just set broad guidelines and say "if any large company comes anywhere near these limits, they will be destroyed".
But you don't have a way to figure out what your competitors are charging and have automated systems find the maximum you can extract without losing the customer
I definitely have increased the price of consulting for "annoying" customers doing stuff I don't want to do. Many moons ago, I was doing some contract training for a small airline here in town. I liked teaching but I didn't really want to do the training they wanted me to do - it was a pain in the ass, it took a week, and didn't really pay enough to justify the opportunity cost.
So I kept raising my price, and eventually, they stopped asking me to do the training. It was great because I didn't have to do the thing I didn't want to do anymore, and I made more money. You are allowed to charge different people different amounts of money - some people are just a pain in the butt and charging more pays for the lack of sanity.