HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | SubiculumCode's commentslogin

Hmm. When playing online, I feel like Pathfinder/DnD5e put a lot on the game master in terms of lots of prep, battle maps, tokens, etc. B/X etc can be played much more theater of mind, and so would seem to require less work. In person, probably less of a distinction.

Personally, I have tired of the modern 5e/Pathfinder type games where the play often revolves around combat that takes way too long, where playes don't interact much, spend their time waiting to roll the dice and gazing at their character sheets trying to find an answer rather than by interacting with the world.


In human memory, we often use a sense of familiarity to guide our memory decision, in the absence of explicit recollection of details. There is a whole memory literature about "recollection and familiarity" that dissociates the two cognitive processes, recollection which involves retrieval of specific details of an experience, and familiarity, which is a sense of memory strength, but absent of any qualitative detail. Familiarity is a faster process, and can often spur subsequent retrieval attempts that can lead to actual recollection..e.g. you see someone that seems familiar, but can't place where...and after a few moments, you remember who they were and where you had met them.

When measuring these processes, one approach has been to ask participants to provide confidence ratings. Recollection tends to lead to threshold-like, very high confident responses. Familiarity is more graded and continuous. Many then use a dual-process ROC model to identify the recollection and familiarity components, on average, of a person's memory of a memory test (see work by Andy Yonelinas).

This kind of work goes beyond memory, but applied to the general problem of how people judge their confidence in answers.

Its likely been applied to LLMs. A familiarity signal would probably be pretty easy to generate... The recollection kind of component might take some of those introspection type of approaches. For example, these papers, which I have not read, [1] https://arxiv.org/html/2603.17839v1 [2]https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.09250 might be getting at these ideas.

This might be relevant


I think one of the impetuses to not using the Old School Essentials rules was the Hasbro DnD debacle where they started making moves to undo the Open Gaming License (OGL) in 2023. The resulting Dolmenwood system cleanly removed the last vestiges of anything that might be subject to the OGL...e.g. certain spell names, monster names, etc.


I agree, and it's certainly a good idea; OGL fears are still valid to this day. I think a much cleaner route, however, would be to abandon the chassis entirely. It protects one's long-term IP through unique game mechanics or by using an open system as a base.

A lot of how a game encourages play is based upon the small details that designers choose to include. In 1974, looking at OD&D for the first time, players probably wouldn't think to tap the floor for traps, but a 10' pole is curiously listed on the equipment table. Same with listening at doors, or things like that.

So instead of coming up with something entirely bespoke, companies seem to use D&D as a base not because it serves the game, but because it has lower "buy-in" for customers. Which I think is a shame.


I'm just working up the courage (and the people) to run it. I might have the face of a grognard, but I've only run a handful of sessions as a gamemaster / dungeonmaster. Between relative inexperience and the demands of my career in autism research career, I have not yet taken the plunge.

On the plus side for prep, the Dolmenwood books and pdfs are wonderfully organized...bringing the same expertise that Gavin Norman brought to Old School Essentials that had won him (and his team) wide acclaim.


Bare bones is a plus for me honestly. I'm fairly tired of crunchy mechanics that takes days and slow player interaction.


That's why I like the PBTA approach. All the rules you need are right there on the character sheet and a couple of pages of quick references sheets.

Even with it's stripped down system, we spent plenty of time rulebook diving in Dolmenwood, where I've never needed to reach for the rulebook running Dungeon World. It manages to be very concise, but also massively more capable as a system.


I often think that PBTA and OSR/NSR type games have a lot more in common than is generally recognized.


I am sure those systems deserve a modern renovation, but as a general matter, I think the particulars of game systems matter less, overall, when it is not a mechanics heavy system like Pathfinder and DnD 5e...or Rolemaster. It mostly comes down to rulings over rules...which is why rules lite systems, e.g. Mausritter, Knave, Into the Odd, have play in the OSR/NSR scene.

I do not know where on the crunch spectrum the systems you mentioned fall,


For a video with a fairly comprehensive overview, worth checking out:

https://youtu.be/hL_YAarvB5U?is=SQGjmmBP0ignvSy4


I was a backer and the books are lovely, and the setting is awesome.

Also this is my favorite t-shirt: https://necroticgnome.com/products/dolmenwood-goatlord-t-shi...

Also check out 3d6 Down the Line, an actual play worth listening to. https://youtu.be/xNWg_IcbHl8?is=54oqh6TbY5g6DP-B


Who can read that text color and background combo? I had to turn on reader mode in Firefox.


Firefox on desktop renders as black text on white background. The link colors are yellow, which is not great, but still okay for me to read.

I use the "Dark Background and Light Text" add-on. Sometimes the add-on makes a bad website worse (like IMDB), but it can be switched off with a click.


renders fine here on firefox android, black text on slightly yellow tinted light background


very strange. for me, on Firefox Android, it was light gray text on white background....


Gymnastics? The argument was straightforward and rational.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: