HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | SubiculumCode's commentslogin

Anthropic/Dario getting a lot of hate in this thread, but the argument he makes is rational if you believe for one second that AI is important to national security and that it can, or will soon be incredibly dangerous is misused. People pointing out that this position benefits his company might be overly reductionist in how they think the world works. I believe Dario and Anthropic about their belief that AI safety is paramount because they put serious dollars behind research to improve safety/alignment, not just lip service for others. Those resources could get spent elsewhere but do not. Certainly it doesn't at OpenAI to that degree.


Don't be so naive. He only wants a monopoly and a massive IPO.


It is not naive. Naivety is being overly reductionistic.


Dario is a fascist who wholeheartedly believes Yankee exceptionalism and its divine right to brutalize anyone in order to achieve its goals. Anthropic's models have helped bomb innocents over and over and over again, and will continue to do so.

If you think he gives half a shit about safety you've had a dozen lobotomies too many and should reconsider every decision you've ever made.


Can you explain how he is a fascist?


Helping a fascist regime blow up inncocents? Partnering with Palantir, the regime's own techbro spin on the SD?


So do you consider everyone who works at defense primes like Raytheon fascists? How about people who work at Boeing on dual use technology?

I’m in the camp that words have meanings you can’t just call everyone a fascist who you dislike.


Regarding words and their meanings, would you agree the current US regime is fascist in nature? What with the wars of aggression, the setting up concentration camps to put the undesirables to deport, using masked thugs with no badges to kidnap people in the street (and shoot people who protest), disregard for the Constitution and rule of law, curtailing of human and civil rights, ever increasing surveillance? Weird how people really close to the highest echelons of the regime keep getting in trouble for throwing Sieg Heils.

Would you not agree Palantir is at the forefront of this transition towards fascism?

What would you call someone who, as CEO, chooses to partner with said regime and Palantir? And not just in unrelated, innocuous shit, but in actively helping blow up innocents, including triple tapping a fucking school and killing hundreds of schoolgirls?

> So do you consider everyone who works at defense primes like Raytheon fascists?

They are collaborating with fascism, yes. Of course most of them worked in the industry before the current regime came in and made its fascist turn so they didn't set out to do so. Though the industrial military complex still was the main driver of US imperialism and so anyone who chooses to work in it is absolutely complicit in the mass murder of innocents the US has carried out. No idea about Boeing, can't comment on that.

Not that the agency of some working stiff is comparable in any way, shape, or form to that of the CEO of a private company valued at over a trillion motherfucking dollars.


> Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian, and ultranationalist political ideology. Its core features include a dictatorial leader, the complete suppression of opposition, and the belief that the nation or race is above the individual.

So no the current regime is not fascist in nature. There’s pieces that rhyme for sure but still words have meaning - the opposition isn’t meaningfully oppressed, we don’t have a dictator. Trump is awful but words still have meaning.

> Would you not agree Palantir is at the forefront of this transition towards fascism?

No more towards a surveillance state.

> Of course most of them worked in the industry before the current regime came in and made its fascist turn so they didn't set out to do so

So was Dario in his field?

So yes I don’t think there is a serious argument that Dario is a fascist.


> > Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian, and ultranationalist political ideology. Its core features include a dictatorial leader, the complete suppression of opposition, and the belief that the nation or race is above the individual.

All of those fit to a fucking T, except being a dictator which he hasn't yet managed. But he's been thoroughly undermining the constitution and limits on his power, has thanked Elon publicly for fixing the election, said he wants to run despite it being unconstitutional, and even that elections won't be needed anymore. He's fired was it Pam Bondi I think because she wouldn't persecute his political opponents as aggressively or vindictively as he wanted.

> No more towards a surveillance state.

My brother in Christ why the fuck would a democratic republic need a surveillance state. You're literally making my case.

> So was Dario in his field?

He was in AI sure. He CHOSE to partner with Palantir and lick the boots of the fascist US regime and its fucking department of war.

No skin off my ass though, it's your country. Enjoy the last dying gasps of your vaunted FrEEdUM. As we say in my country, nobody blinder than he who doesn't want to see.


I think we probably have a lot more in common than you think man, I am deeply troubled by things happening in the country and the world right now. That said, during difficult times it is more important than ever to think critically and not lose your head in a parallel reality.

Anyway, you really didn't make a point where it's fair to call Dario a fascist which was the point of this thread.


I believe forced exercise actually is counterproductive in terms of the facts that exercise usually has on depression, at least in animal models that have looked at the differences in forced versus voluntary exercise. There's a whole literature out there I believe.


The content was 'you need to get your head checked'. That isn't tone, that directly implying that if you hold that position, there is something wrong with you. It's rude and unnecessary.


How about, is there reasonable suspicion that a crime has occurred?


Not required at an airport, for whatever reason.


The constitution doesn't disappear at the airport. The man is a US citizen. He could have remained silent, and they would eventually have let him in.


Relevant reading for you: https://www.aclu.org/documents/constitution-100-mile-border-...

And no, they wouldn’t have denied him entry, but they would have seized his device.


I enjoy the funny implication it creates, that then perhaps if you're entering US in 2026 it means there's something wrong with you.


The reason is anti-immigration


But are not investigations typically under some reasonable suspicion that a crime had occurred?


Reasonable suspicion is required for a terry stop but that does not apply at a border crossing. Everyone can be stopped and questioned and searched at a border crossing.

An ”investigation” is just a fancy word that broadly describes the type of information collection that law enforcement does. Yes, it is typically about things they think are crimes. Because that’s their job. But there’s not some legal hurdle they have to pass here, the word describes their work.


Not a lawyer, but destruction of evidence would only be valid if there was first some reasonable suspicion of a crime? Is that right?


This is my core question as well. At what point do you have to maintain property so the government can use it to testify against yourself?

If I have a dash-cam, and I wipe the SD card, can the government imply that because I erased the card, it must prove that I was speeding? The dash-cam automatically over-writes old footage - perpetually destroying evidence.

Given nebulous cases such as "hacking" a site by looking at the HTML[0], am I destroying evidence of crimes whenever I format my PC? I hope the government requires specific charges and more proof of a crime other than missing evidence. Say I destroy my diary - can the government claim that is the key evidence where I confessed to being the gunman on the grassy knoll?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28992667


"At what point do you have to maintain property so the government can use it to testify against yourself?"

For the duration of the border search. This guy is at risk because he caused the data to be deleted during a border search, when CBP asserts they can legally look. He would have been fine if he deleted data on the plane or after leaving the airport.

(This is my understanding of the government's position; personally I don't think this prosecution is constitutional)


> If I have a dash-cam, and I wipe the SD card, can the government imply that because I erased the card, it must prove that I was speeding?

If the erasure was a non-automated result of them asking you, and you alone, what conclusion do you think is possible? Probable?


the government might not, but your insurance company definitely will


Also, can they proof that there was evidence on the phone?


Funny. In writing, the advice is to "kill your darlings". Don't let a particular paragraph that you love a lot stop the whole story because it doesnt fit.


I think that's still the same idea. In his example the darling would be the entire project, in your example it's the paragraph.

Advocating for killing a single paragraph for the sake of the book is like abandoning a single feature for the sake of the project, which is his central point.

The only difference is if you're referring to the darling as the whole or as one paragraph/feature


Does this mean California is more likely to get mega flooding?


Most of the most flood prone areas in CA have been significantly neutered over the decades thanks to massive water projects. There was a time when the LA river would destroy LA routinely. Now everything is channelized. At risk communities are probably the handful of remote ones that do not have great infrastructure, but I'm not even sure where those might be given how the state seems to be able to build thousands of debris flow cement storm drain setups in relevant areas.

Other states seem a lot worse off. Water table is closer to where people live, there's a lack of topology to actually run water out in a lot of cases, there's been little investment in managing water for stormwater for property damage abatement or power or irrigation like in CA where the topology really incentivized massive investment in all of that over the last century.


Yes, atmospheric rivers all winter.

Next year a super bloom then the following year massive wild fires.

rain -> fuel -> fire


Not necessarily... it isn't as straightforward as "stronger El Niño means more rain".

The steering of the jet stream seems to have some qualitative changes in these conditions but also more chaos. It could steer storms anywhere along the coast, so different parts of CA, OR, and WA get different impact. Just in my lifetime in CA, I've witnessed some very wet El Niño winters but also some drier than average.

The biggest precipitation threat on the west coast seems to be a repeat of some of the biggest flooding events known historically or geologically. But, these are relatively infrequent and most of the record predates any understanding or tracking of the El Niño oscillation. So the correlation cannot be stated so clearly. These are atmospheric river events which seem to stall, producing heavy rains over the same area for a much longer period.

Just in the recent centuries of CA history, there have been massive floods in northern and southern regions in different month-long rain events. There have been improvements to flood control infrastructure since then. But, the only reason those events aren't known as the most costly is because there wasn't as much economic development here back when the floods happened.

Our usual storms sweep through an area the heaviest rains over just part of a day. Our varied terrain means that each individual storm also has very uneven rainfall amounts due to orographic intensification. Prominences with the right aspect towards the wind will get far more accumulation. Our watersheds can absorb quite a bit of this, but even those brief rains can cause localized flooding.

If the rain continues for many days in a row, we will see widespread mudslides and flooding of larger rivers, basins, etc. Some of the historically extreme events had rain persisting for over a month!

Edit: along with these "mega storm" scenarios, we also have evidence of "mega droughts". It's worrisome to imagine what challenges may come from a more energetic and chaotic climate.


"El Niño, California Precipitation, and Landslides" <https://www.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/landslides/el-nino>

El Niño is the “warm phase” of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation and features warmer than average ocean surface temperatures off the coast of Ecuador and Peru in the equatorial eastern Pacific Ocean.... Historically, the presence of El Niño conditions tilts the odds in favor of wetter than normal precipitation across the southern third of the state. The relationship between El Niño and cool season precipitation is weaker in the central and northern parts of the state.

Flooding is possible, particularly if dams exceed capacity, perhaps exacerbated by earlier snowmelt and peak runoff. Landslides are a more widespread, and less manageable problem, particularly as loose-material slopes are waterlogged. The deluge -> high growth -> heavy fuel load -> large wildfire -> landslide cycle is one that's become fairly well-known in California.

Levee failures within the Sacramento Delta or Central Valley could result in very large-scale flooding, affecting agriculture or communities.

The San Francisco Bay Area may see "king tides" and general flooding throughout the bay and delta region, particularly during December and January, and all the more so if high tides coincide with heavy river run-off. Remember that the entire Central Valley of California, nearly 500 miles long north-to-south, drains out through the Bay. Prevailing winds may create a wind setup or seiche which can result in flooding along a some but not all shorelines, or alternating across a body of water.

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_setup>

<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seiche>


The aquifers are all extremely depleted and the reservoirs nearly empty. Extra rain will be very good. If private interests are allowed to graze and log public land, fire risk can be mitigated.


The reservoirs are designed and calibrated for specific times and rates of fill, largely driven by snowmelt runoff rather than precipitation deluges.

Aquifer fill rates are slow, and are generally predicated on large-scale flooding. Prior to modern flood control (dams, river channelisation, levee construction), in which much, and occasionally effectively all of California's Central Valley (as well as large riparian valley systems in Oregon and Washington) would flood.

See the Great Flood of 1862: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Flood_of_1862>.

Reservoirs provide parlous slim protection against landslides of elevated slopes. Those are affected by upslope water saturation (the stuff that's on its way to fill your aquifers in coming months or years), not floodplain innundation. It's exacerbated by fire-cleared hillsides, particularly those which burn ferociously hot, killing plant roots and baking soil. Those fires are not historically typical, but have been the conditions experienced with greatly increased frequency since the 1990s.

Cattle don't graze chaparral, oak woodlands, or ponderosa or Douglas fir forests. Those have been what's been burning.

Your suggestions / assessments are at a far remove from reality.


“Extra rain” have you seen what happens when you pour water over dry soil? I’ll tell ya, it doesn’t absorb particularly fast…


We haven't had any significant flooding in past El Niños. Of course, it will probably be different this round, but at least El Niños tend to align with Mediterranean weather instead of droughts and wildfires.

We also have one of the more advanced waterwork system in the US to support Central Valley agriculture, so a lot of the worst aspects can be somewhat managed.

It's bad that such dramatic climate change is happening, but we're definetly lucky to live in the West Coast because we won't face the brunt of some of the worst aspects of the El Niño comparatively and have the infrastructure to deal with it.

Sadly, the brunt of climate change will be felt by the poorer half of the world.


The costliest floods in state history were in the winter 1994-1995 which was a weak El Niño year.


True, but a lot of that was due to a lack of integrated water management (IWM) in California at the time, and led to significant reforms as well as infra expansion to prevent that from happening again.

The Lima Prieta Quake and the 1990s floods led to a lot of future proofing in Californian infra. The last major thing left is transmission weathering, which PGE and Sac are fighting over.

Also, most of our infra is state funded which gives us a lot of leeway.

Like I said before, it's bad that we're in this position and it's only going to get worse, but we're in one of the better places that can survive these kinds of shifts.


It's already happened but no one wants to admit it


We can start having this conversation when it's able to do at least 20% of the work that I have to do.


Oh yeah? Who even talks about the Turing Test anymore? Half a decade ago,that was the informal benchmark.


Not at all.

The Turing test was never about AGI, just about being able to discern a chatbot from a human in a casual conversation...

I would also say that funnily enough it's extremely easy to detect if you're talking to a human or an LLM after a few messages.


in 2023 i wouldve said gpt could pass the turing test. today i could figure out it was an llm in a few turns no problem. llms cannot pass the turing test now that we’re accustomed to them


The only reason you can figure it out is because of the system prompt which is designed to make model “useful”, safe and compliant.

Raw modern LLM with different pre-prompt will easily fool anyone.


We wouldn't be having any talk about AI Slop if it was impossible to tell AI apart from people.


Uhuh, but if it was so easy, we also wouldn't be funding billions of euros and dollars in anti-AI-disinformation systems, holding entire conferences about deepfakes and hybrid attacks on civilians, and have dozens of governments opening entirely new defense departments to study and counter the capabilities of AI to disseminate human-like disinformation at scale (which has been affecting elections across the world).

But yeah, your AI slop take about the local burger joint that used free chatgpt to generate a menu filled with typos and bad images is A+.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: