In practice the answer ends up being both. There are some devices that only exist in one protocol (sometimes for technical reasons) and as a sibling noted, the antennas are cheap and home assistant exists.
ZWave stuff tends to be rock solid (there is expensive certification involved) but that means the devices are more expensive and the selection can be limited because the volumes aren't always there to make sense to get certified.
The only real problem I've found with the "all of the above" situation is that device bindings only work within one protocol. If you want to bind a lightbulb to a wall switch such that they don't require a trip through the hub they need to both be zigbee, zwave, or matter. This is unfortunate because there are a lot of really nice ZWave wall switches but not a lot of ZWave lightbulbs.
Look at Zooz, they have a variety of plugs and multi-port strips with control of individual outlets (both at the outlet and via zwave). They have options rated for being outdoors (holiday lights, etc), heavy duty ones for large motors, in wall switches and relays that go in the electrical box if you want something more permanent or invisible, etc. Solid support in home assistant. Push, 100% local, no shenanigans, no apps, direct to home assistant even for the updates.
I also have some eve energy plugs that do matter/thread (also push/local). There are apps here but i generally haven't needed them once i got things set up in home assistant.
reply