HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | zahrc's commentslogin

El. Psy. Congroo.

You just reminded me of two things:

1. Their practices outside of china even, are aggressive and openly corrupt: https://netzpolitik.org/2021/wolf-culture-how-huawei-control... Which I think I first saw here on HN actually, IIRC

2. My parents, both were born behind the iron curtain in Germany in the 50s and 60s, so they spent only a little over half of their lifetimes, in technically the “western world”… they had some crazy stories how they and family friends were essentially pressured to do some morally questionable stuff, nothing like this of course. But it really isn’t that far fetched, and technically not that long ago…


Guns don’t kill people (with intent)

That is why firearm engineering has hardwar level safety (firing pin blocks, drop safeties, heavy trigger pulls) and why manufacturers still face strict liability when a gun fires on its own… regardless of intent.


Comparing AI to simple tools like a hammer or saw just isn’t right.

AI tools are complex systems that definitely can have agency, even though that is mostly human controlled. Bad controls = bad outcomes.

Yes, I totally agree that humans have the most control over them, but that doesn’t mean it’s completely off the hook.

If we really have to draw simplified real life comparisons, maybe a car or a gun would be more suitable “systems” that we can metaphorically compare AI to.


Any strong empire, nation or person in power has.

With great power yadda yadda


I have never understood addiction either. My whole life I’ve been told that I am addicted to “computers” or video games, because I spent so much time on it. But frankly there wasn’t much better to do and it’s just a hobby, passion that now pays my bills…

Only until I started smoking cigarettes and later stopped I realised what addiction really means, and how hard it is to kick it.


Literally the first paragraph:

> Forgejo is self-hostable free software for software development, built on top of Git. Codeberg is powered by Forgejo, which is in turn a hard-fork of Gitea. Compared to Codeberg, Forgejo is not one service, but free software to help you build your own. Everyone can install their own Forgejo instance to host their own projects. There are also public Forgejo instances as well as Codeberg you can use, but make sure you find a site that is actively maintained and updated, and that you trust the provider.


[flagged]

If that is too long, you have an attention span problem. That is your issue to deal with, not ours.

Or from another angle, how would you say it more concisely? Preferably without using AI to summarise.


If anything it seems like you are the one with an attention span problem when you can't remember that he posted the correct consise definition earlier in this thread. Being a dick when justified is counter-productive, but being a dick while also being the one who is confused is a way worse look.


> he posted the correct consise definition earlier in this thread

As a question, not a statement of knowledge, when if they'd read that “too long” paragraph they could have stated the point confidently.

And while that description, if stated as such, is more concise, it leaves out notable details (its relationshipt to Gitea, which many may recognise, and that it isn't the full feature set of the service) so is probably too concise.


i phrased as a question as a courtesy.


thank you , you're one of the folks who make it worth visiting here.


Many email providers and third party security tools default settings automatically bounce or block SPF failures, no matter what DKIM says... so no, not using SPF completely is a bad idea.

Using it minimally is correct, thou. Route outbound mail through as few controlled relays as possible so your SPF record only needs to list infrastructure you actually *own*, rather than growing it every time a new tool needs to send mail.

I have seen way too many clients almost hit the char limit in a TXT record


SPF failures overriding DKIM successes is a direct violation of RFC 7489 section 4.2 [1]. I have never observed such behavior in the wild, though my experience may be more limited than yours. There are two possible explanations anyway, one is that the DMARC record was missing or misconfigured, the other is that the DKIM check did not actually succeed even though you had reason to believe it should have (e.g., misaligned sender domain, invalid/stale/rotated key, etc.).

I would certainly agree that DKIM is harder to get right. However, the TXT record data size limit is surmountable. You can either use EC algorithms, which have much shorter keys, or stick with e.g. RSA and its very long keys, but span them across multiple 255-byte record data chunks. That having been said, I still think DNS providers should do more to make configuring DKIM easier.

Ultimately, if you have SPF and DKIM set up such that both cover all senders, then you are just using SPF. It is the simpler and more forgiving mechanism, so its broad-scoped successes will always swallow DKIM in practice. The only reason I can think of to do this anyway is if you suspect your email provider will change IPs on you and they don't provide their own SPF record, but if that were the case, they are basically telling you not to use SPF in the first place.

EDIT: RFC 7489 was superseded by RFCs 9989-9901 rather recently. Nevertheless, the definition of success, now given in RFC 9989 section 5.3.5 [2], remains the same.

[1] = https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc7489#section-4.2

[2] = https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9989#section-5.3.5


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: