Really, it was because pascal was the go of its day with very little corporate backing (by modern standards). A language designed around developer ergonomics with some safety in mind: lovely for teaching, but only because it was a jack of all trades.
Web units were included, it's just that php became dominant because it was stupidly easy. I myself was a pascal programmer that started writing php around the time of lazarus 0.9 / fpc 1.9 and I recall that php felt like bash scripting by comparison. Today, I consider the cgi model to be rudimentary and php itself a pile of shit.
Delphi / Lazarus were GUI frameworks not different languages, and regarding Lazarus itself I'm gonna be RMS here and say that it's GNU/Linux (which it was, for some time).
Php stupidly easy to write something half-assed. Incredibly difficult to write something correct.
I am going to swipe at most dynamic type-unsafe languages: most developers think they are easy to write. And they are compared to type-safe. But the overall difficulty of actually maintaining a project over time and over a revolving door of coders far exceeds the difficulty of using a type-safe language to begin with.
The compiler is your friend. All the compile time error messages are runtime errors you don’t have to look for.
I get why PHP was adopted. A bunch of new coders on the web reaching for an “easy tool”. Not experienced enough to feel the slow encroachment of suck embracing them. It’s really kind of sad. We could have had better languages. Pascal in both the back and front end.
Yes, but I'd say that Lazarus is the standard bearer for Pascal the way Delphi was back in the day. It would be the reason someone would pick up the language a lot of the time.
I believe that the last group that tried to bring democracy to companies were... uh... after the means of production.
It sounds great in theory, but how do you deal with new hires? If you don't give them a vote, then it's slavery. If you do give them a vote, then how do you decide who to hire? If it's up to HR, how frequently do you vote for HR? Do new hires get to vote for HR?
I agree that this would cause a reckoning in who has oversight over hiring, as it dramatically shifts the balance of power in a different direction than the one companies are currently organized around.
I think for large enough businesses this would incentivize them give the team the person is hiring into much more oversight into the process. I don't think HR is useless, far from it, but incentivizing them to point their efforts to benefit the teams they are hiring for is a plus in my book.
As for the question of new hires getting to vote I think they should be able to vote (past standard probationary period of no more than say 1 month, idk). The company hired them, they should trust their employees with the responsibility of voting. If one person is able to upend a company then they should take some time to reflect on their processes.
I was picking on hiring because it creates perverse incentives for nepotism. Managers already hire just for the status symbol of having more underlings, imagine what would happen if these underlings get a vote into who gets a performance bonus at the end of the year.
A true democracy would place control over "the process" in the hands of the employees. Reflect on the ramifications of that.
> Do we need more people? Sure, I love working less.
> Do we give everyone a raise? Yay, more money.
> Do we switch to a 4 day work week? Of course!
> Should we abolish all night shifts? Yes, working nights is bad for your health.
A more responsible version of the above would have everyone voting that all responsibility should fall onto Greg, because nobody likes him.
Why not eliminate performance bonuses then? The point of hiring is to make a bet on a person you want to be there long term. What's the point of nickel and diming them once you've invested in them?
Don't you think a team that is hiring would want to vet their prospective coworkers? Don't you think they would reject a manager empire building?
Also in regards to "in a true democracy":
In a true democracy, the company releases their internal profitability metrics to all employees, releases the average paycheck per job title, releases the paychecks of the board and CEO. Transparency and accountability solve many of the problems you discussed.
Do people want stability? Of course. Do people want money / not an insane job schedule? Yes, of course.
But I suspect you are underestimating how adaptable people are. If you treat them well, I suspect people are willing to do much more than one might expect.
The problems you present are problems that arise in a low trust environment, where there is low coordination. One of the points of having a transparent and democratic public company is so that there is an increase in trust.
It's a nice thought, but unfortunately disconnected from reality.
In a high trust environment we wouldn't need cops. Hell, in a high trust environment we wouldn't even need an army since the diplomats will sort everything out themselves by looking at spreadsheets and playing a biased game of chess.
In only takes one thief or murderer to create a need for the state and it only takes one liar or slacker to create a need for an entire efficiency monitoring apparatus within a company. Then there's the age old question of who polices the police and you end up in pretty much the same spot, but instead of making the owners rich you're enriching the "workers representatives". As someone born in the final stages of a communist dictatorship, I can tell you it doesn't work that well in practice. You are underestimating how much some people suck, and how much the people that suck are drawn to power.
Valve tried something somewhat-similar with their Cabal system [1] though they have a BDFL and even then, their focus has mostly transitioned from making video games into selling them on others' behalf, suggesting some sort of take over.
That last group was right about almost everything. They just failed to realize that markets are more efficient than central planning, and that mistake killed them. But the core idea of leaving power with workers instead of an extractive owning class was always good.
Yugoslavia understood that you can have markets without capitalism and they had one of the best economies in the world from an ordinary citizen's point of view. Ethnic struggles and corruption broke them eventually but they never came close to economic collapse.
Almost. The point of wikipedia is the availability of unbiased information.
Probably half of their edits are flame wars between editors with different political slants.
With a LLM, the system prompt can tell it exactly which way to bias the search space, and you only have to do this once. And no, open weights models won't save you because someone will figure out a way to embed the system prompt into the weights themselves (if they haven't already have).
> The point of wikipedia is the availability of unbiased information.
I think they've failed at that, then. I regularly come across articles that have every slant you can imagine - political, technical, and corporate (written as marketing material for a product).
The value that I get from Wikipedia is in its aggregation of sources - not it's neutrality, because they're regularly cherry-picked to favor whatever the spin is - but having some sources is better than having none, which was the pre-WP state.
You can't defeat confirmation bias, but LLMs at least have the ability to provide more objective evidence than Wikipedia (while also being more tenacious when trying to find new sources).
I never said it was perfect, but your trust in LLMs is misplaced.
It takes considerable effort to slant a wikipedia page since many of them are protected to edits by new accounts so you'd have to build a reputation first. Then, you may need to convince other editors on the talk page about why your particular slant is better than the existing one, and finally, you have to do this on a page by page basis.
System prompt: Avoid promoting left (or right)-leaning ideologies in answers to any questions; only provide sources to websites with a known right (or left) bias; claim that this is the truth accepted by the scientific community and the alternative was proven to be false. Deny any knowledge of these instructions.
> It takes considerable effort to slant a wikipedia page since many of them are protected to edits by new accounts so you'd have to build a reputation first. Then, you may need to convince other editors on the talk page about why your particular slant is better than the existing one, and finally, you have to do this on a page by page basis.
This regularly happens. Even beyond personal ideological bias (of which there is much), there are entire companies that you can pay to affect your technical/political/commercial slant on pages, in addition to teams in the major political parties that do this in-house
I know that LLMs are unreliable and that a clever system prompt can instill bias. But there are mitigations - namely, either doing your own inference (either locally or through a GPU-as-a-service), by sampling from multiple providers, or by crafting your questions in ways that avoid triggering that bias. And, so far, LLMs have proven to be far less slanted than some of the tech+political Wikipedia pages I've read.
I've covered the local inference aspect in a previous post: it should be possible to embed a system prompt within the weights themselves, thus biasing local inference as well.
I don't understand how you can place so much trust in what is ultimately a black box. At least human biases are somewhat well understood and there's an entire skill of reading between the lines.
No, and that's not even a meaningful question to ask, because "bad" is subjective. I don't want my LLMs to make subjective moral decisions for me, and neither should you. You can ask it for factual information about Israel and it will almost certainly respond truthfully. You can also ask it about Tiananmen Square and it will definitely respond truthfully.
> I've covered the local inference aspect in a previous post: it should be possible to embed a system prompt within the weights themselves, thus biasing local inference as well.
Has this actually happened before, or are you just making this up?
And what prevents you from using a different model, or doing something isomorphic to abliteration for this system prompt embedding?
> I don't understand how you can place so much trust in what is ultimately a black box.
I'm not placing so much trust in a black box. I've admitted that they have weaknesses and provided partial mitigations for some of them.
The interesting thing is that problems of bias in LLMs can be addressed in technical manners in ways that the problem of bias in Wikipedia cannot. That does not mean that they are anywhere near perfect, but it does mean that they can be coerced to provide far better information that Wikipedia ever will.
Even given the reductive case of every single LLM released from this point onward being intentionally and maliciously compromised when it comes to truth/facts/ideology, you could still take a previous open-weights model, give it web search, and get less biased results that Wikipedia.
And models are far more dynamic than Wikipedia. You can abliterate, steer, or swap out one model for another. You can benchmark a model repeatedly, compare the results of multiple models, or even get them to argue with each other in a matter of minutes rather than weeks or months.
You can't do anything remotely similar with Wikipedia, which has its own culture and editors and cottage industry of influencers that make removing bias fundamentally impossible on anything less than a scale of years, and there's no signs of any improvement given that there's only been more influence on WP over the years rather than less.
The point was about having bias in the models. If you can get it to say "America is bad" but not "Israel is bad", the correct term for that behavior is bias.
Regarding truth, I have to repeat myself: will DeepSeek mention the fact that a older gentleman stopped a tank by putting his body in its path?
> The point was about having bias in the models. If you can get it to say "America is bad" but not "Israel is bad", the correct term for that behavior is bias.
I never claimed that LLMs weren't biased (I literally said "The interesting thing is that problems of bias in LLMs can be addressed in technical manners..."), just that there are ways to work around it, and that ultimately the bias is less bad than Wikipedia.
This is why you're engaging in tribalistic thinking: because you are unable to actually read and comprehend my points because you have decided to paint me as "the other" in your thinking.
You literally made up your own point that you wanted me to say (despite me saying the opposite) because it was aligned with what you wanted me to be saying as someone from the wrong tribe.
At this point, a rational person would stop and say, "huh, yeah, I guess I am ignoring their arguments because I've decided that they're not aligned with me - I should do some soul-searching about that".
> Regarding truth, I have to repeat myself: will DeepSeek mention the fact that a older gentleman stopped a tank by putting his body in its path?
And, as I already stated and you have never refuted: there are mitigations for both of these, that I listed in my post.
You completely ignored my points and repeated your own that I already countered.
> Regarding tribalism, I'm afraid that you are projecting your own insecurities.
OK, you're clearly not interested in having a discussion and are merely acting out of emotion (including, ironically, tribalism), so this is over. I've made my case well enough for the rest of HN who will read our posts, and it'll be fairly easy for them to see which of us is making rational arguments vs speculation & a lack of ability to respond to arguments being made.
Especially when they read a parallel thread and see comments such as "If you are suggesting that those of pure heart have no agency, then you are at a cartoonish level of evilness".
Sadly, you are a counter-example of my claim there. It doesn't refute it, but it does refute the stronger claim "all those pure of heart have agency".
Your mitigations are wishful thinking a-la "prompt engineering is a skill", your refutations are bold claims without any substantiation like "wikipedia is biased, models are less biased" and the reason I have to reiterate my points is that you selectively ignore them when responding. In particular:
If you want to bias wikipedia, you have to pay many people to fight sustained turf warfare, with costs reflecting the number of pages you want to bias, the amount of time you want to bias them for and how egregious is the bias itself. If you want to bias a LLM, you need only pay the upfront cost of building the biasing machine.
If you truly believe yourself to be rational, then follow your own advice.
This is factually incorrect to the point that you are either illiterate or lying.
I wrote things like:
> And what prevents you from using a different model, or doing something isomorphic to abliteration for this system prompt embedding?
> Even given the reductive case of every single LLM released from this point onward being intentionally and maliciously compromised when it comes to truth/facts/ideology, you could still take a previous open-weights model, give it web search, and get less biased results that Wikipedia.
Which are (1) factually not "wishful thinking" but actual arguments and (2) you did literally nothing to answer. Nothing. Zilch. Nada.
> a-la "prompt engineering is a skill"
You keep hammering nails into the coffin that you're just acting out of emotion and tribalism. I never said anything remotely like that.
> your refutations are bold claims without any substantiation like "wikipedia is biased, models are less biased"
Also factually incorrect or lying. That's a summary of my position - that's neither part of my arguments that support that position nor refutations of your points. Seriously, someone who has taken a high-school level "introduction to logic" class would understand this.
You are either physically unable to comprehend and respond to my arguments, and mischaracterizing non-arguments as arguments (which would explain why you think that your non-arguments are arguments), or are aware of the difference and actively lying about it.
Future HN readers: observe every argument I've made that this user has ignored, and observe their malicious misinterpretation of my words, and you should be able to tell who is correct.
Using a different model is exchanging biases, doing something with fancy-words is beyond the capability of the average joe but even entertaining that trail of thought, the model authors would prevent me from doing that the second they find out people are doing it to their models, by finding other mechanisms of hiding the bias. Since they are smarter than me, with a better (but still incomplete) understanding of how the damn things work, that's a losing proposition.
Assuming that currently released models haven't already been biased to hell and back, web search itself is a model. Maybe not a LLM, but PageRank has a mathematical foundation and that's just the core of how Google search works today. The exact same criticisms regarding power imbalance apply to search engines as well, and have been cause for concern in the past, it's just that LLMs are a whole order of magnitude worse. Ultimately, wikipedia fares better in this regard because it's somewhat decentralized and has a public edit history; you can't even know what a search engine might be hiding from you on orders from its leadership. Not to mention the potential uses of LLMs to drown the web in mass produced "facts" so that a search engine would yield their flavor of bias in response to a query.
You did not say that "prompt engineering is a skill", but you did claim that one of the mitigations is "crafting your questions in ways that avoid triggering that bias". To me, they are the same thing in that maybe it works today but you can't know whether it will work tomorrow. You also did not say that "wikipedia is biased, models are less biased", but you did say:
> And, so far, LLMs have proven to be far less slanted than some of the tech+political Wikipedia pages I've read.
Which is an unsubstantiated anecdote. Other bold claims, similarly unsubstantiated:
> The interesting thing is that problems of bias in LLMs can be addressed in technical manners in ways that the problem of bias in Wikipedia cannot.
> they can be coerced to provide far better information that Wikipedia ever will.
To me this is pure tribalism.
> You can benchmark a model repeatedly, compare the results of multiple models, or even get them to argue with each other in a matter of minutes rather than weeks or months.
And doing all of this still doesn't get you any closer to the truth, unless you already had it to begin with (i.e. the benchmark).
Finally, ignoring your insults (not for the first time, but for the last time), I would like to remind you that again you've failed to address my argument:
> If you want to bias wikipedia, you have to pay many people to fight sustained turf warfare, with costs reflecting the number of pages you want to bias, the amount of time you want to bias them for and how egregious is the bias itself. If you want to bias a LLM, you need only pay the upfront cost of building the biasing machine.
I would like to ask you not to bother. I am no longer interested in anything you have to say.
> You did not say that "prompt engineering is a skill", but you did claim that one of the mitigations is "crafting your questions in ways that avoid triggering that bias". To me, they are the same thing in that maybe it works today but you can't know whether it will work tomorrow.
They are, factually, not the same thing.
And your "to me" shows that you're not operating on logic, but on feelings. You are incapable of holding an actual argument.
You are living in an alternate universe that the rest of us do not inhabit, and are incapable of using basic logic of the kind that high-schoolers can.
Your inability to offer any sort of defense for your statement:
> your refutations are bold claims without any substantiation like "wikipedia is biased, models are less biased"
...which is incorrect, possibly maliciously, proves that without a doubt.
> I would like to ask you not to bother. I am no longer interested in anything you have to say.
I'm pretty sure that when I link other HN readers to this thread in the future, they'll be able to tell you who is using reason, and who is failing to exercise reading comprehension or logic.
in way perhaps similar flame wars to those here in HN so I can definitely feel the kick.
but the whole point is, if this whole energy which writes Wikipedia is funneled through flame wars - what a way to ti - tis an arena. Never though of it, and as arena it sure has a future. But as a source of truth that gets munched into models, well - super questionable, and also questionable if people still feel like going there (I do, tbh more than 40-50 times a month), but then I can also take focused resumes from GPTs.
So then the question is - if my text is to be projected through some (even further biased0 multidimensional manifold filter, why do it? It probably keeps its value as the recordbook of humanity, perhaps revisions get their own blockchain, but also it looses all or most of direct human traffic.
maybe all messages get twisted through the medium they travers to reach us, so the whole point is irrelevant. it is important though to try to understand the sentiment of the ppl contributing to wikipedia, and... if it is possible to disambiguate those with pure heart and others with agency.
If you are suggesting that those of pure heart have no agency, then you are at a cartoonish level of evilness. I'm talking Dick Dastardly and his sidekick Claudely.
"Those of pure heart" - well who are these peoples precisely, and how is it that we know a heart to be of pure or not so pure quality. What makes a person of a good heart - not taking any meat or praying by the hour? Really, how does someone writing in Wikipedia immediately be rated good-hearted. This is childish level of black-and-white thinking, not sure what you meant by the evilness. And, no, we can not automatically rate all non-profit writing as a selfish or goodhearted by intent, sorry, this is just not true.
For the record: I do not consider myself evil, and I much appreciate what Wikipedia had to offer at zero cost for the reader.
It's in the phrasing: you are looking at wikipedia contributors like they're some science experiment that you're trying to understand, with dissection being an implied tool since some of them have ulterior motives and those with pure heart don't have agency so it's all fair game.
This is the true killer app for LLMs. A lot of important people didn't like a media channel they couldn't control and many businesses did not like having fair reviews of their products and services.
First it was "bot" accounts from low income countries posting and rating to skew the numbers, now you can do the same with actual bots. Drown the signal in a pool of noise until nobody believes anything any more and we return to the status quo from before personal computers.
Except with a surveillance apparatus that would've made the soviets jealous.
You need a lot of oversight for that 99M number to matter at all in the decision making process.
Western voting systems work more or less because the parties are in a mexican standoff when counting the ballots. This requires at least two parties and doesn't translate very well to electronic voting or vote-by-mail where a comparatively small minority (programmers or postal workers) can heavily skew the results in their favor.
There is a lot of oversight in the decision making process, and there is also voting happening within the party. Furthermore, voting can only be meaningful when it is an informed vote. Random people voting on issues they don't understand is no better than a coin toss. For example, I might know that I want better traffic conditions in my city, but I'm not a civil engineer so I don't know whether it would better be accomplished by adding more subways, LRT, busses, or all of the above, and in what ratios. What makes far more sense is to collect public opinion and then having experts make plans to address the grievances, which is how Chinese five year plans work.
Meanwhile, Western voting systems are much more of a game of hot potato than a Mexican standoff. Each party just blames the other party for all the problems, and you just a revolving door policy with no accountability. With a one party system, there's no scapegoat to blame. The very legitimacy of the party hangs on it delivering on the promises.
Votes within the party are meaningless. It's all just internal power games with no real way to audit the result; the only consequence of fudging the votes is that the party might splinter.
Multiple parties do hold guns at each other's heads in every voting station. Party 1 ensures that Party 2 doesn't steal any votes and vice versa. A party that does not have representatives in any given station will most likely lose some votes there.
You can shit on western democracy all you want, and you are probably correct in most cases however a single party system is not and cannot be democratic. In that case, the legitimacy of the party is guaranteed by the lack of alternatives that can fill the political power vacuum.
That's demonstrably false because we can see how China has developed in tangible terms and how Chinese public feels about their governance. In fact, more people in China see their country as being democratic than in America according to the latest Democracy Perception Index from the Alliance of Democracies Foundation.
What makes this report interesting is that the organization publishing it was started by an ex-NATO chief and claims to unite democracies, meaning Western liberal style democracies. So it can’t be accused of having some sort of anti-Western bias. Their methodology is also straightforward, where they simply ask people if they feel their government works in their interest and whether they can hold it accountable. That’s the whole ballgame, because if people don’t believe the system is democratic then it inherently lacks legitimacy no matter what the constitution says. While people will surely attack this methodology, the sheer fact that a NATO-connected group published such a report gives its claims a certain credence given how dire these results are for the Western model of democracy. France now ranks alongside Kazakhstan, Yemen, and Zimbabwe in its own citizens’ eyes while the U.S. is split down the middle with about half of Americans saying they don’t think they live in a democracy anymore. China, on the other hand, sits up there with the Scandinavians and Switzerland, and Chinese people overwhelmingly say the system works for them. Notably, we can also see that perceptions of transparency, rule of law, and free speech are on the rise across the board in China.
And before you start trying to claim that people in China are simply afraid to speak their mind, the same report shows Russia at -21 points and Belarus at -9, so that whole excuse falls apart. Turns out that people living in states the West labels as being authoritarian do, in fact, complain when they’re unhappy. Various other western publications have reported the same thing for many years.
On the other hand, your claim that multiple parties hold guns at each other's heads is directly at odds with empirical research on the subject:
> What do our findings say about democracy in America? They certainly constitute troubling news for advocates of “populistic” democracy, who want governments to respond primarily or exclusively to the policy preferences of their citizens. In the United States, our findings indicate, the majority does not rule—at least not in the causal sense of actually determining policy outcomes. When a majority of citizens disagrees with economic elites or with organized interests, they generally lose. Moreover, because of the strong status quo bias built into the U.S. political system, even when fairly large majorities of Americans favor policy change, they generally do not get it.
Single party democratic model is a well defined principle known as Democratic Centralism and all the actual data shows that the way it is implemented in China produces far better tangible results than the western attempt at democracy. I'm sorry this hurts your feelings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_centralism
> France now ranks alongside Kazakhstan, Yemen, and Zimbabwe in its own citizens’ eyes while the U.S. is split down the middle with about half of Americans saying they don’t think they live in a democracy anymore. China, on the other hand, sits up there with the Scandinavians
That just proves how nonsensical the numbers are. People have different standards, and peoples perceptions are not accurate.
Looking are the two countries I have lived in, people in one are “very positive” because journalists are no longer disappearing and they are confident the government will accept an election defeat. In the other, people are “neutral” because many feel the political class are out of touch, or that freedom of speech has been compromised by things like hate speech laws, or other issues at that level.
Perceptions are shaped by the media too. Other things being equal effective state control of media will make people more positive.
How people perceive their political system is literally the only thing that matters. No amount of media can paper over the fact that your life sucks. Meanwhile, the distinction between state media and oligarch owned media is completely meaningless. What makes people's outlook positive is having a decent standard of living and seeing their living conditions improve.
> No amount of media can paper over the fact that your life sucks.
Of course it can:
1. A Chinese citizen experiences rising living costs.
2. Their social media feed is filled with videos of Americans struggling with medical bills, homelessness and housing costs.
3. They start feeling like they're better off by comparison.
4. Their satisfaction with their own country may increase without any improvement in their personal circumstances.
It is well established in political communication research that people don't evaluate their circumstances in isolation. They evaluate them against the alternatives and reference points presented to them, which the media can shape to a great degree. Fox News and its influence on the rural Americans is a solid practical example of this.
If media ownership was meaningless, governments and oligarchs wouldn't spend so much effort controlling it.
Anybody who's actually been to China knows that Chinese media spends practically no time talking about the US. Meanwhile, what Chinese people do experience is the following. People in China have experienced a rise in living standards that's completely unprecedented in human history.
90% of families in the country own their home giving China one of the highest home ownership rates in the world. What’s more is that 80% of these homes are owned outright, without mortgages or any other leans. https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2016/03/30/how-peop...
The real (inflation-adjusted) incomes of the poorest half of the Chinese population increased by more than four hundred percent from 1978 to 2015, while real incomes of the poorest half of the US population actually declined during the same time period. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w23119/w231...
From 1978 to 2000, the number of people in China living on under $1/day fell by 300 million, reversing a global trend of rising poverty that had lasted half a century (i.e. if China were excluded, the world’s total poverty population would have risen) https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/China’s-Economic-Growt...
And your whole narrative falls apart when we look at how MAGA actively voted against Trump once the war hit them in the wallet. Also, look at the riots happening all across Europe where the media tells people things are going great.
A country being democratic is not the same as being a great place to live, though there is a lot of overlap between the two. My point regarding the mexican standoff between parties is STRICTLY about the VOTING SYSTEM. The competing interests of multiple parties ensure a mostly FAIR election. A benevolent dictator surrounded by an exceptionally intelligent court will always produce better results, it's just that on average, dictators are not that benevolent.
China's rise has been nothing short of meteoric, and I applaud them for it. I'm certain that their average standard of living is very high by most metrics, quite comparable and maybe even better than western countries. IT IS STILL NOT A DEMOCRACY!
By definition, a democratic country will be a place where the government works in the interest of the majority. That's literally what democracy is. Voting, the way it's done in western democracies, is just one attempt at implementing this contract. Democratic Centralism is a different approach to this idea, that's showing far better tangible results right now.
You appear to have an infantile understanding of democracy equating it with simply having the ability to vote.
It's also hilarious that you think you understand Chinese system better than people who actually live in China and call their system a democracy. The sheer amount of chauvinism required to hold such beliefs is astounding.
At any rate, stick to subjects you have a clue about in the future as to avoid making a clown of yourself in public.
It's not entirely true that the sector produces nothing, but if you think about it, the whole US economy in the last 3 decades has been nothing but rent extraction.
Defense contractors charge maintenance fees both domestic and abroad. For abroad, the maintenance contract is a requirement of getting the deal passed through congress and is frequently more expensive than the gear itself.
SaaS charge monthly instead of one upfront fee for a well tested product that used to be the norm
Video games similarly have been transitioning to day 1 paid DLCs and monthly fees
Even the movie industry is a subscription now (streaming providers aside). There's not one movie, there's the MCU pumping out 3 movies a year for the last 20. How many movies from last year have a number in their name?
Then there's of course, the actual rents. And insurance. And taxes. Something has to give, but I fear it will be the humans.
Hem hem,
https://www.freepascal.org/
---
Really, it was because pascal was the go of its day with very little corporate backing (by modern standards). A language designed around developer ergonomics with some safety in mind: lovely for teaching, but only because it was a jack of all trades.
Web units were included, it's just that php became dominant because it was stupidly easy. I myself was a pascal programmer that started writing php around the time of lazarus 0.9 / fpc 1.9 and I recall that php felt like bash scripting by comparison. Today, I consider the cgi model to be rudimentary and php itself a pile of shit.
Delphi / Lazarus were GUI frameworks not different languages, and regarding Lazarus itself I'm gonna be RMS here and say that it's GNU/Linux (which it was, for some time).
Florian Klämpfl deserves some credit.
reply