HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | yojo's commentslogin

I work at a company that sells security software, and one of our customers is a major grocery chain. They definitely have a security team, I’ve talked to them.

State government leadership did change in unexpected ways, and they do get to pass laws. See: Texas


Yes. I actually hadn't read the article before commenting because initially the link was to the Reddit thread. The data center buildout slowing, with Texas (among others) blocking otherwise expected to be built data centers is probably a significant justification for re-evaluating the business.


The "planned" capacity in Texas represented over 40% of the total power generation of the entire USA, how did the market think that was going to get built even without moratoriums?


Maybe they planned literally THOUSANDS of "walkaways" or "wheelhouses" with horses or cattle going round and round in circles powering generators, every 4 hours new, fresh horses go online and the previous go to pasture to eat more grass.

Grass / weeds to data center power conversion achieved !


$2–3 trillion dollars would honestly be about the right price to do that.


Curious to see your working out for that statement, if you have it handy.


Thinking is a disadvantage when you're playing Hot Potato


> how did the market think

Wait, what? When does the market think at all?


If your business is this faulty that you have to rely on subverting democratic norms maybe you don't deserve to run a business in said society.


> If your business is this faulty that you have to rely on subverting democratic norms

I'm not seeing the relationship between building datacenters and subverting democratic norms. Could you explain?


the people building datacenters don't want to go through the normal process. they want special exceptions to do whatever they like and put the externalities on other people.


My take is that they get subsidized energy prices and the average person is going to pick up the tab. That doesn’t seem very fair.


It's worked out quite well for social media, so why not AI?


Did social media REQUIRE to subvert democratic norms or is it just that social media was so good/powerful that it ended up inadvertently hurting democratic norms and that social fabric?

I didn't think your Facebooks and Twitters required shady data center deals and circumvention to actually establish a viable business model.


>I didn't think your Facebooks and Twitters required shady data center

there were years of debate on whether or not a lot of the things early social media groups did constituted violations of, and not limited to : FTC Act Sect 5, the electronics communications privacy act, the CFAA, the video privacy protection act, and us state privacy laws from coast to coast.

they just did what they wanted, lawyered up, got big enough to lobby, and became legal ..

point is, these groups aren't stranger to 'shady deals'.


Fair point.


Neither. Governments and other politically aligned entities realized social media was useful and it was intentionally used to hurt democratic norms and the social fabric. It was neither an accident nor an intentional part of their business model (with Facebook being a possible exception.)

It's heresy to say here but related content algorithms aren't inherently evil.


On (2): I’ve noticed Claude being very concerned with token spend when working on agentic systems. Both in designing them, and in running them for validation.

I assume this may have something to do with training it to not light huge bonfires of money on fire spawning subagents (as it was apt to do), but that’s just my armchair robopsychoanalysis


> training it to not light huge bonfires of money on fire spawning subagents

Which is funny, since Claude will happily spawn tons of subagents and sometimes even attempt to kick off a dynamic workflow (the $$$ mode you need to explicitly approve) for simple code review tasks if I don’t explicitly say something like “with a single subagent”.


I’m still crying about taking a Dropbox offer over Cloudflare’s pre-IPO in 2016.


Yeah hindsight is incredibly frustrating.

Also owned a bunch of asml shares a decade or so ago. But it didn’t really move so got bored and sold. Good picks bad patience.


AI is just another technology, and all technologies should be employed in service to humans.

I think it’s reasonable for people to say “I like the way things were, I don’t like this new future you’re proposing, and I want to limit the technology that’s doing the thing I don’t like.”

There is nothing inevitable about AI. As a society we may decide it is fundamentally unhealthy or anti-human. We have banned or curtailed access and research for other technologies before.


The potential fruits of this tree are far too rich to realistically imagine shoving this genie back in the bottle.


> We have banned or curtailed access and research for other technologies before.

Such as? I can't think of anything comparable. Nuclear energy maybe, but that has obvious justifications for regulation. Not just "I don't like it".


I guess they meant human cloning, excessive DNA "customization" etc.


You'd be surprised how much of nuclear energy regulation is in fact based on "it just feels scary".


It will actually take a little while to tell if they were, in fact, crying wolf.

There is a lag between when carbon is released and when the effects of it peak. If we did stop all carbon emissions today, the effects of prior emissions would play out over the next 30ish years.

We’re injecting unprecedented amounts of thermal energy into planet-scale systems, and it is hard to predict second and third order effects.

I have kids/I really hope they were crying wolf.


Working in b2b SaaS, there’s a real gravity toward checkbox-driven development. Any time we lose a deal because a competitor had feature A, the immediate response is “we need to build feature A.”

And from a sales perspective, that’s probably not wrong.

I think a new (or newly critical) engineering challenge is how to build in a way that keeps a codebase that’s churning out features from crumbling under the weight.


> from a sales perspective, that’s probably not wrong.

Possibly not wrong. One scenario that happens over and over again is that we lose a deal because we didn't have feature A. So we build feature A, and we still don't win deals with it. One way this happens is when the competitor has a focus on one part of the market, and we have a focus on another.

Example: We go after SMB, the competitor owns "The Enterprise." Just building A will never break us into the Enterprise part of the market. We have to build an entire strategy around seizing part of the Enterprise market from our competitor. That strategy may or may not include A, but it is definitely more involved than "Build A and customers will come."

if we aren't going to build an entire strategy around "The Enterprise," not only can building A fail to win the business, it may cost us some of our existing SMB business. Every feature our core market doesn't want or need is additional complexity and feature surface area for our customers to absorb. They stop thinking of our product as "tailored for their needs" as it begins to bloat with features they don't need.

And worst of all, the investment in feature A means some other feature—B—that our existing customers have asked for gets punted down-calendar because we're suddenly tearing up our road map and building A because the VP Sales threw a temper tantrum about being unable to close deals without A. This is another way that chasing feature A means sacrificing value for our existing customers who are asking for feature B.


Is this equivalent though? The Laya article ends with “ Treat Laya as a fast foundation model to specialize, not as an omniscient zero-shot oracle.”

I have a dozen different things at work that are currently using LLMs as classifiers for different questions. I don’t have the time, data, or resources to fine tune a model for each of them.

I haven’t had a chance to plug in Jev yet (waiting on approvals), but if it has the general intelligence claimed in the press release, then Laya is in no way comparable for my use case, and whatever TypeSafe has done is a substantial innovation over the Laya paper.


Jev seems pretty cool! I just got access and have only gotten to do minimal experiments, but I love this general area of research and it fills a very real need.

I agree with you. I think the OPs pushback is emblematic of a larger reaction I've seen that is, at the very least, misinformed.

There are a lot of approaches that use a self-attention backbone for classifier-style outputs. You have structured generation libraries like SGLang and Outlines, but those basically give you guided generation on an autoregressive model. You also have a bunch of models that are non-autoregressive that try something similar. Older NLP stuff applies here, and there's newer stuff using diffusion transformers for this purpose.

But I don't think the Jev author has ever said that he's the sole human, alone in a vast sea of misguided researchers, who is interested in schema-guided classification? I think he said he found a novel way to train a model for this task that has much higher general intelligence at much lower cost than other approaches. Which is an exciting result with lots of applications if it bears out.

I think some people are just reflexively skeptical of anything that gets a lot of hype. Maybe that's fair. Things that are wildly successful and high impact also tend to get a lot of hype though, so it seems like a poor filter.


hey, you might wanna try this? - https://github.com/deepanwadhwa/OpenDecision

it's very similar to jev's api and runs locally - if you like it, you can try jev for your actual usecases.


In a world of agents, doing a BERT run takes about 2 hours from having an empty folder. Just a thought you could consider. Once you've done the first you can do the rest of them before the end of the work day.


BERT run on what? You would need training data, no? The things would use Jev for have no training data. Not that kind of problem.


Presumably, if you are positioned to plug in Jev (or an LLM classifier), then you are also positioned to collect training data.


The domain is code analysis, all languages and frameworks. It’s b2b SaaS, so total volume is not incredibly high. And many customers have contract clauses that we don’t train on their data.

I’m not convinced we could train easily here, or that it’s worth the investment compared to (previously) spending fractional cents on Luna, or now paying even less on Jev. Especially given that these numbers are not meaningful to our margins.


In TS/JS you’re usually inlining the reducer fn, and there’s something hard to read/especially ugly about the comma after the bracket or arrow fn into the initalValue.

That said, when I’m reducing a list, I still use reduce.


You’re not wrong, but I think the alternative future is sama loses control, goes and raises a quick $100M, and hires all the profit-motivated staff to make something that looks like today’s OpenAI.

Dario already showed there was an appetite for this.


Right. Much like the alternative future is that someone considering stealing a public museum could instead build a building, hire away the staff, and fill it with art he acquired, instead of just stealing a museum that was created via charitable donations.


Late reply, but I think once you took away the profit motivated people and the money man, the “museum” would have been exactly that - a collection of antiquated artifacts. But I guess we’ll never know.

I’m not saying it was right or moral, just probably inevitable.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: