HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | yed's commentslogin

Did they? I don't recall any significant voices saying it couldn't be done. Mostly doubts about the commercial and financial viability, but that comes with every venture not just Elon's.

They sure did. They said it wasn't possible/economically feasible to launch that many times. Reusability still wasn't a thing, and people here said that wasn't possible as well. They said even 600 sats would be too many. That everyone that had tried satellite constellations before had gone bankrupt, which was true. The deck was stacked against SpaceX. Everyone thought Elon was lying as usual. That he was trying to pump up the valuation for false promises.

Hindsight is now 20/20 that Starlink is a huge success. I guess all you guys forgot, and now think that the success of Starlink was obvious all along. Bitcoin and TypeScript are also things I remember HN being dismissive of at first that have both been very successful since.


You're forgetting the millions of years of evolution that "pre-trained" child brains for this task.


I agree that language is innate.


Yes but it can be both innate and built on statistical models, contrary to Chomksy.


The idea that there is some level of statistical inference involved in language acquisition is not contrary to generative thought, look at Charles Yang's work or Lidz or a fair number of other people. Chomsky just thinks this is uninteresting so he is dismissive of it as a central explanation for language acquisition.


The central question remains whether there are categorical rules built into the brain for grammar (plus "some" statistical inference possibly), or whether the entirety of our grammatical processing is statistical. It is entirely possible that evolution encoded statistical priors into our brains with grammar overall being a fully statistical process. Therefore, the fact that children learn more quickly isn't really hard evidence one way or another.


We could innately have built-in statistical models, then everyone can be happy. Given how well statistics seems to work for language acquisition the brain is probably approximating a statistical formula at some level.


But the statistics only work well at vastly unrealistic scales of data, and the learning pattern doesn't match children's behaviour at all.


Well, Chomsky wouldn’t be happy, that’s the point of OP; he explicitly argues against this.


A statistical model is approximating the brain at some level.


JEV only sees transcribed text, so long term I don’t see this use case beating audio models built for this task, or especially voice to voice models.


Are you sure you finished the third book? Book 2 ended as you describe.


In the note it was written as “$5 - 10 bil”


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: