HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | xinuc's commentslogin

And also millions of poor and suffering people from the colonized countries. Millions of them died of famine. I'm not sure how much we can learn from those elites.


All right, but apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine^H^H^H^H cricket, public order, irrigation, roads, the fresh-water system, and public health, what have the Romans^H^H^H^H^H British ever done for us?

Brought peace!


Yes, before the British arrived none of these colonies experienced famine and were in effect a cross between the Garden of Eden and an Ewok village.

Perhaps not blaming everyone else for their misfortune also helped the British succeed?


It did mention the colonial empire up near the beginning.

> There is a longstanding view that the prosperity of Britain’s elites came at the cost of the hundreds of millions whom they subordinated and oppressed, and no doubt that is at least partly true. But on their own terms, the British ruling class enjoyed a victorious century.

> Maybe the Victorian elite succeeded in spite of being feckless and incompetent: the Industrial Revolution created great wealth, which they enjoyed passively and parasitically. We cannot run controlled experiments on Victorian Britain, so this thesis is hard to test. But I want to explore the possibility that a relentless focus on soft skills, team building, and intra-elite networking actually worked rather well.

The essay is intentionally exploring an alternative to the obvious one. I think the essay does brush off the cruelty of the empire too quickly, but cruelty isn’t inherently profitable, so there’s still some explaining to do.


World War I killed so many victorian elites off and destroyed their culture because it proved honor culture inferior to industrialized killing


WW1 was nearly a generation after Victoria's death.


It was the 'extinction' of the victorian era's structure of society. Come on you can understand this.


That is an oversimplification. It was the effective end of the Edwardian era, which contained some of its own tendencies.


*inferior to industrialized versions of ancient cultures. The Victorians essentially gave up all sense of their medieval culture (Longbowmen and archer traditions, Yeoman farmers) for immense wealth and new luxuries (Tea, tea houses, Opium, and lots of parties).

This led to their decline within 200 years, compared to China or the Roman Empire. The Chinese had to deal with the incompetent Qing, but luckily they survived as a culture, and learned a lot from Deng Xiaoping.


> cruelty isn’t inherently profitable

agreed. But it takes tremendous amounts of stupidity to not be profitable while cruelly exploiting millions of people and their resources.


Exploiting people and resources is a terrible way to be extremely profitable; it's very inefficient.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse

This is why economics is called "the dismal science"; slaveowners got mad that economists told them having slaves was inefficient and decided the economists were bores.


other than the fact that success is mostly just luck (and lack of morality), not hard work.


I wouldn't say there was a relative lack of morality compared to other elites. Quite the opposite actually.


I don't know man.

The great famine of Ireland, The great famine of India, and even The late Victorian Holocaust is a thing.

It is also well documented where other empire wanted to help the starving people, but denied because it would make them looked bad.

I really can not see that they are not lack of morality.


Countries that were not under an empire also had famines and other disasters (China had a civil war with 50 million killed, IIRC) as well as endemic practices like slavery.


Sure. But we're discussing Victorians here.


If you had a Rawlsian veil over your eyes, and someone said you could be born in any empire throughout history, but without knowing your place in that empire, which one would you pick?

Are there empires you would rather have lived in?


This always comes up.

Those famines were not created by the Victorians. They were all originating in natural disasters that the locals were unable to handle for themselves. The claim that the Victorians did something immoral is an ideological one, as it's effectively a claim that even though they did try to help they could have tried even more - and not rising to that level of assistance (determined arbitrarily by moderns who were not there) was somehow evil.

This view is usually also implying without stating that it is uncharitable or morally wrong for governments to not suspend free markets and impose a communist planned economy the moment there's a natural disaster. That's a highly controversial view (and a wrong one if you want something that works), but it gets slipped into criticisms of the Victorians all the time.

This is the same logic that says shutting down USAID killed people. It's an attempt to convert the possibility of charity into a hard moral obligation - but if accepted, that would make it no longer charity.

Specifically:

• The Victorians did provide aid to Ireland during the potato famine.

• In India they did also provide aid, organized relief camps, suspended tax collection, and spent large sums of taxes and Victorian Brits made large numbers of charitable donations. It didn't look so different to the various aid campaigns for Africa in the 20th century.

• There is no such thing as the "late Victorian Holocaust". That's a concept from a book written by a Marxist in 2000 that argues that capitalism is the same thing as genocide, and frankly seems incredibly offensive to survivors of the actual holocaust.


It´s true that some Victorians organised aid for Ireland during the famine, it is also true that other Vicorians, English origin who were landowners in Ireland courtesy of the Cromwell invasion in the 1650's, exported large amounts of food from Ireland during the famine, to pay some of the bills mentioned in the article. Many land owners in Ireland were heavily in debt, with mortgages on their property. Potatoes were peasant food, and the failure of the crop, combined with lack of control over the food suppliers, led to the death and forced immigrations of millions. The population of Ireland is still lower in the 21st century than it was in the 19th.

So we can take a look at it with 21st century eyes, and consider that actual control is a nebulous thing, and that the absentee landowners were protecting their interests, while some at least of the local ones, including anglo-irish intervened to try and help the people on their estates. but then we also have to dig into the fiasco that is the 1847 Poor Law extension relief act, which sets up systems for relief that effectively dispossess people of their land, and makes the entire thing much worse.

Did the people creating the act understand systemic behaviour well enough to predict the consequences? Do we even understand these things well enough now? The interaction between debt and market pricing, and its inevitable consequences are playing out in real time now with AI.


Man this is dumb.

Ireland produced more food than it needed, even if we don't count potatoes. It was exported, mainly to England, as other markets could pay more. Plenty of other things the victorian's did to make the situation worse. Mainly thanks to free market idealists.

Pre colonial India had famines and many ways to handle them, the British did away with them. The system they set up and replaced made it a lot worse and whatever small trickle of help they provided clearly wasn't enough.

I don't know why you're trying to whitewash colonialism. That it's immoral is pretty simple, they let millions of people die for profit.


> Those famines were not created by the Victorians.

The one in Ireland certainly was. The famine was an outcome of the exploitative economic system that they imposed on the native Irish population. The problem wasn't that there wasn't enough of food available in Ireland (or that it didn't have the capacity to produce enough food). Rather the people living there couldn't afford to buy it and due to free trade/laissez-faire policies imposed by Britain that food was exported to England.

> • The Victorians did provide aid to Ireland during the potato famine.

Yes they gave back a tiny fraction of resources they extracted from Ireland back. Fact is that if Ireland had its own government and wasn't an exploited colony the outcome would have been very different.


Are you really gatekeeping the word 'Holocaust'? The late Victorian Holocaust fits many definitions of the word that are documented in sources like Merriam-Webster. I find your gatekeeping of the word holocaust offensive to survivors of all other non-WW2 holocausts.

Also, why can't capitalism be capable of genocide?


Elites are generally immoral, even today. I mean only in relative terms, they were no worse than others. On the positive side, they did quite a few pro-social things as well (abolition of slavery, for example).


which one you called terrorist?

surely the one creating such destructions and deaths no?


Somehow a powerful state army destroying homes and killing civilians is not "terrorist". It's only "terrorist" if the weak try to respond in kind, using means available to them. It's almost like "terrorist" is a propaganda term used by the strong against the weak who try to resist.

As the saying goes "war is terrorism with a bigger budget".


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: