Check out solidcraft. I spent the weekend with multiple codex sessions watching it build 3d prints for me. What's nice is I can use the tool with it to make my own changes like fusion 360 and so it's like a built in helper. Pretty slick
I did it with Codex once. The model didn't even bother to chamfer the edges but if you have no experience building physical stuff it still could come as a miracle.
Just tell it to do that then. Im flabbergasted at how great claude is with 3d modelling and cad work now. If you have a proper skill set up its like magic. At least for smaller projects
On a bike ride a few months back, I saw a smaller bird fly right up to a chain link fence as if it were going to dive through one of the diamonds, stop itself in an instant before going through the fence because it realized it couldn't make it, turn, and fly upwards about a foot to fly over the fence through some barbed wire instead. This all happened in a fraction of a second.
I was driving to Costco in Burlington early this Sunday. Looked left at a mature Bald Eagle flying into a pretty thick stand of mature conifers. It was moving pretty fast. Just a second or two as I watched (seeing the eagle from behind) I saw the eagle tilt one wing to avoid a branch. Not the whole wing, the outer part I guess at the elbow (hope that makes sense). I thought to myself, "That's some pretty awesome awareness of multiple factors." Pretty big eagle, so likely 7 feet wing-tip to wing-tip.
Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude. Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground. (Obviously, airplanes go even faster, but similarly benefit from a lack of obstacles.)
I guess you may not have spent much time watching birds or other wild animals navigate their environments. Many birds routinely fly at maximum speed through trees, dodging branches, leaves, and twigs that would knock them off course and lighting suddenly on small limbs or branches that you can't even see until you are deep into the foliage. Maybe they can see them from outside the leaf envelope. It would explain how they are able to navigate such a cluttered environment in shadow at full speed. Birds may crash into window glass regularly but their innate understanding of navigation around and through natural obstacles is pretty remarkable.
Watching drone racing videos gives an idea of just how complicated the task turns out to be - flitting through narrow openings at speed and zipping around obstacles that suddenly appear. Birds were doing this millenia before anyone programmed a drone.
Oh yeah. I feed my crow family raw peanuts in the shell. They know me and watch me when I am outside working on anything. One of them taught itself to mimic me. Each time I would put out peanuts for them I would loudly say "peanut" a couple of times. When the group wants a peanut that crow will fly over to a nearby perch and clearly say "peanut". Crows are really intelligent.
I feel that swarms are easier than trees since you just have to rotate slightly for the most part, following the critter in front of you. If you bump, you correct. Trees on the other hand are much less forgiving.
If I had mentioned bird swarms then I would've needed to mention by extension that fish were also just as intelligent, and gnats, and mosquitoes, and wasps, wildebeests, and bison, and on and on through the animal kingdom.
We may even need to throw in humans if one mentioned group dynamics of pedestrian swarms inside transport terminals. I'm not sure that we can say at this point that all the members of a group like that are intelligent. It seems more likely that most are minimally sentient without any understanding of why they do what they do when they do it and probably none could offer a formulaic description of how they do it that would stand up to scrutiny. I think most would just SWAG it.
Humans actually change the environment to meet their sensory slowdowns at that sort of speed. E.g. spacing of road signs and even their size depends on the speed of the road, in anticipation of you needing more distance to make decisions at this speed, given your thinking speed didn't change.
A hummingbird on the other hand is moving with precision at its top speed in the environment as it is. It is adapted to this behavior at these speeds and maneuverability, while our lack of adaption needs that sort of sensory crutch.
> Why? There aren't very many obstacles at altitude.
Most birds don't spend their time flying at high altitudes. Most of the time they're remarkably close to the ground, and there are lots of obstacles when you're close to he ground. Some of those are trying to avoid being eaten, and others are looking for dinner.
> Humans routinely travel at 40mph+ too (bicycles, motorcycles, cars) and have to contend with much more diverse and surprising conditions on the ground.
That's just within the last 150 years, and has no relevance for our evolutionary history.
From an engineering point of view their control loop must be much faster. Things that fly need much tighter loops than we do that lumber about on the ground.
Watch a bird come in fast and then land on a narrow twig.
Bird neurons are roughly half the length of mammal neurons. This means you can pack in around 8x more neurons in a given volume.
I know that each one of us has different peculiarities about screen quality (some care more about colors, others about refresh rate etc).
My personal feud with OLEDs, is that even at very high resolution the fonts do not look as smooth and creamy as the equivalent IPS. It is like I can tell apart their subpixels.
For example I prefer text on my old iPhone 8 compared to my iPhone 17.
Which is why Apple stuck with 5K and 6K monitors/screens and 60hz phone screens, but in recent times, computer gamerboy crybabies have insisted upon 120hz. Apple basically was last man standing, they still sell the 5K@60hz XDR monitor.
Even if you know the timing of the collapse of a cataclysmic bubble what do you do?
All of the investable assets will collapse at the same time. Inflation will evaporate cash. Bonds will worth nothing (if the us gov bothers to repay them).
You need to know with ridiculous precision, though. And the triggering event for the collapse usually isn’t predictable. For instance, if we’re seeing the beginning of the end now, we’ll, no-one could have really predicted the current sequence of events, unless they knew about Huang’s misconduct _and_ when it would be leaked.
I do actually believe that LLMs and process around them will continue get better and become the accepted, but that there's going to be a 'fossil record' of a lot of problems having been seeded in these early years of AI that will take some time repair.
Why is everyone spooked by ai driven bioterrorism ? Like all of our water supplies are much easier to mess with compared to developing a virus or whatever that may or may not work
Evolution cannot optimize for maximum harm. Natural viruses only evolved to reproduce, with the harm just a side effect. Humans can combine features of multiple natural viruses. There's no obvious reason why we couldn't make something with both the infectivity of measles and the lethality of rabies, as well as resistance to all known antivirals. If something like that gets out it's probably civilization ending.
Maybe it's not "maximum harm" but there are selective pressures on zoonotic diseases to be harmful to organisms whose behavior is a threat to the ecosystem's stability. They fill a niche that guards against the emergence of monocultures.
Whether to be more afraid of nature's bioweapons, or human built ones, I don't know. But both exist.
But rabies is not lethal if not bitten (or scratched).
If an infected animal tries to kiss a person no danger whatsoever. If it tries to bite a person, bypass the skin, and the animal's saliva enters the bloodstream, it is only then that rabies lethality rate is relevant, but why should that be important? Do animals with sharp teeth pose to us any danger nowadays?
> Dog-mediated rabies kills tens of thousands [0] of people every year, many of whom are children. The disease is present in over 150 countries and territories across the globe
Measles is an airborne virus with extremely high infectivity, R0 estimated between 12 and 18, but it doesn't usually kill you.
Rabies infection is more difficult, but if you do get infected it's practically guaranteed to kill you without vaccination. It's likely possible to design viruses to resist vaccination too, e.g. splicing in human proteins to disguise them from the immune system, or using parts from a virus like HIV where we've failed to make a vaccine.
But the combination of both high infectivity and high lethality is an evolutionary dead end. Any virus that wipes out its host goes extinct too. A human-designed virus doesn't have this limitation. Look at what we've done with selective breeding in agriculture to see how much can be achieved when you optimize for things other than reproductive fitness. I'm certain that the range of physically possible viruses contains things far worse than anything naturally occurring.
Consider also that if somebody can automate virus design, they can scale it up and design hundreds of different ones. If they release them all at once humanity won't stand a chance.
If we had a pathogen-agnostic early warning system (what I'm working on: https://securebio.org/detection ) we would know. But we need a larger and more sensitive system than anything deployed today.
Assuming you have a medium city (half million people) and a suitably toxic substance (assuming something like dimethylmercury where you'd need at least 100mg per person => 50kg for the city), then you need to dump a lot of it into the water supply, because people use a lot more water than they actually ingest or even come into direct contact with (every person uses ~100l/day, but realistically ingest only like 2-5l).
So you'd need to dump literally a ton of an extremely toxic substance directly into the drinking water supply. I'm not concerned because that seems difficult enough (and likely to get the perpetrator caught beforehand while ordering mercury compounds by the barrel or sth).
For the purposes of terrorism and creating a crisis, you really don't need to kill literally everyone. A little contamination can go a long way toward causing a panic and lifetimes of distrust of tap water.
I'm not saying it's easy, I don't know that. Just that the bar isn't as high as the one you've chosen.
Terrorists generally want to actually kill people not just abstractly damage public trust in the water supply (or any other random public utility or good).
Sort of. Terrorists definitionally want to create terror to amplify the salience of the threat generally far beyond their actual capabilities.
Note that I did not say kill no one, just that it's not necessary to kill _everyone_ in order to create a crisis. It only takes a relatively small amount of injury and death to achieve the effect. The anthrax crisis in the early 2000s, for example, only had 22 confirmed infections but demonstrates the amplification of emotional salience very well.
They still do kill some people though and the threat of "random" death is where most of the terror comes from. They also generally just want to kill some because they really hate the group they're targeting too.
Yes, I'm just saying that neither killing people nor causing terror in the population is the primary strong motivator, because you should be able to find more effective means for either goal than what is typically attempted.
Especially because how hard it is to deal with the consequences. If a town's water supply is polluted you can shut it down and deliver water by truck until the situation is resolved. The consequences might be serious, but it would be a one-off event limited in time. Similarly, shutting down all freezers in a cyberattack would suck, but the consequences are limited in time
A new bioweapon let lose would be incredibly difficult to contain, and could potentially become something we have to contend with forever
A worrying trend to all of this is, if the attack vectors are becoming so strong, how do we stop it without a draconian centralisation of power? Though, to my mind, this is still deep in the realm of theoretical.
What makes you think we can stop it even with centralization of power?
The release of mirror life, or animal-borne pathogens with a long incubation period that infect humans, where the animals are in our cities — is pretty much game over.
I have been talking about this for over a decade now. No one seemed to care.
It’s bad enough that the current labs are speedrunning “gain of function” research online, with leaky containment
Giving everyone a simulated wuhan virus lab and hoping NO ONE will do anything bad with it is the stupidest idea ever. The chances of no one releasing anything with a long incubation period are effectively zero. And if anyone releases it, the chances of civilization surviving aren’t great.
All this so we can build slightly better local agents to send email, eh?
Aren't you skipping a few steps between a crazy person with no background in biological lab technique simulating viruses to actually releasing something?
Can AI even simulate a virus / protein folding / etc. with any degree of accuracy? or does it just orchestrate open source tools that were already available?
My grumpy take: because it's easier to displace fear towards something intangible than it is to actually go out and do something about the problems you have right now.
AI is already killing people, from denial of medical coverage to civilian casualties when an overwhelmed soldier just clicks "Ok". But worrying about AI viruses is easier than accepting that terrorist attacks are low-tech and, statistically speaking, the next one will probably be performed with a car, a gun, or a knife.
What's a better way that 1-3 people can kill literally hundreds of thousands (or millions, or billions) of people?
Convincing a lot of people to go kill other people is really hard. Doing it in secret is nearly impossible. But 1-3 people making a virus? Easier every day.
From what I hear "billions" is unlikely with current tech: with what we currently know, such a virus couldn't be designed to stay lethal and infectious on that scale, and that gets even harder if you want it to also resist mutations that might make it become less lethal, and also resisting mutations makes it easier for vaccines to protect against.
For millions, one failed Austrian painter did it by writing a book. From my understanding, it wasn't even considered a well-written book at the time, though my ability to read German is currently B1 (which is barely functional) and I wouldn't care to read that book anyway.
Hundreds of thousands, I can unfortunately think of a variety of ways; I hope they would not work outside of a film, but I will not suggest them on the off-chance they might work.
How many would you estimate Andrew Wakefield was responsible for?
World War 2/the Holocaust is absolutely not a story of some random guy deciding to write a book. The initial conditions and then the set of things that had to go right (wrong) are far, far, far beyond those required for the scenario we're talking about.
We do not need the entire global order configured into a specific point of political/economic/military tension, we do not need a media apparatus to fall into lock step, and we do not need a once-in-a-lifetime orator speaking to a recently disgraced industrial powerhouse nation.
The scenario we're talking about takes roughly: 1. Create pathogen, 2. Release it
Right now, Step 1 is very, very hard. Today it would take something closer to a Hitler to marshal the resources for such a project and not get stopped early on. But as the Step 1 becomes more accessible, the person required to achieve it, and the context in which a person could succeed, becomes much less special.
> Right now, Step 1 is very, very hard. Today it would take something closer to a Hitler to marshal the resources for such a project and not get stopped early on. But as the Step 1 becomes more accessible, the person required to achieve it, and the context in which a person could succeed, becomes much less special.
On the scale of "billions", right now it is impossible, not merely hard. As you say, it (likely) gets easier as the tech improves; myself, I am happy for things to get locked down ahead of time, but right now this wouldn't be possible for even a large and well-resourced racist government.
Tens of millions is possible, c.f. covid, albeit with essentially no control over who the victims will be, likewise c.f. covid.
Where are you getting this idea that a virus can't be engineered to be both highly contagious and lethal? Normally when I encounter this idea it's from people who are conflating a naturally evolved virus (in which this would be very hard/unlikely) with an engineered one. You've explicitly said you believe this to be impossible to engineer: why so?
> Where are you getting this idea that a virus can't be engineered to be both highly contagious and lethal?
From professional virologists discussing this specific risk.
The TL;DR (because I'm not a virologist myself, not just because this is a comment section) is that lethality works in opposition to all the things that make a pathogen more contagious, including long latency periods and choices of transmission vector and so on.
Even the worst case historical scenarios are things we now have a lot of tools for at the level of transmission vectors while we develop vaccines.
> impossible to engineer
Today. Impossible to engineer today. I would not wish to let anyone coming to the conversation late mistake this as an "impossible forever" kind of situation.
>For millions, one failed Austrian painter did it by writing a book. From my understanding,
You've all received memetic inoculations to that though. Unlikely, anyone will ever be able to write a book that does the same again. (Never mind that the book didn't do the damage, he did, the book was just a side effect. Never mind that it only worked in one peculiar economic environment which hasn't been repeated since. Never mind that zoomers are on the verge of never reading books again.)
Sorry if this seems obvious, but I grew up in the UK which liked to think it was "America's greatest ally", and I don't think this number is of the UK?
> You've all received memetic inoculations to that though. Unlikely, anyone will ever be able to write a book that does the same again.
I wish it were so, but even the memorial stones and constitutional bans on the party and its symbolism didn't completely stop the original memes, let alone things which rhyme with them: https://cybernews.com/security/afd-email-datat-leak-germany/
> (Never mind that the book didn't do the damage, he did, the book was just a side effect.
The book was kinda a big part of how he gained the power.
> Never mind that it only worked in one peculiar economic environment which hasn't been repeated since.
He's hardly been the only genocidal monster to rise to power, even in that century; just one of the more infamous ones.
> Never mind that zoomers are on the verge of never reading books again.)
So the next one only needs to tweet a lot? This isn't an improvement.
Are you actually asking this? Like why should people be worried that a disgruntled highly motivated person would venture into this area? Because it can happen. The outcomes of it could be really bad? It also doesn't have to be done by an individual, could be nation state or organization led. There are groups of people who believe humanity needs to end and all sorts of crazy stuff. Some of them have gone on mass murder suicide missions.
2 bad things can be threats at the same time. Even 10,000 things can be.
Contagiousness is less likely from a non-bio water supply risk. A bio attack could be even more pervasive and easier to carry out than an all water supplies at once one.
Didn't Russia march soldiers and tanks into Kherson...? At an unfathomably high cost of personnel?
(Russia's own stats agency says they've lost 450,000 soldiers in Ukraine – dead, not wounded – roughly equivalent to the number of American KIA across all of World War 2)
They did, but they lost Kherson after less than a year, back in November 2022, and the Ukrainian have since them controlled all of the western bank of the dnipro river.
But afterwards, the Russian have started a horrible drone bombing campaign from the other bank of the river, targeted on the civilians[1], with small quadcopeter dropping grenades on grannies walking their dogs or fpv drones blowing up civilians cars.
Because there are biological agents that can basically delete life on earth (okay maybe I'm exaggerating..), look at things like mirror life.
All it takes is one of these crypto/ai-grifter-30-under-30-chuckle fucks with more money than brains to put a lab together and create the actual torment nexus, and we are all fucked.
That seems a bit silly thinking they are not doing anything to protect the water supplies, and even more silly to not compare the impact of the things you are comparing. Poison a water supply and you hit how many, a city, a small part of a city? Now compare it to the impact of a virus like corona - we literally just went through that..
Instead of poisoning the water supply, you'd stuxnet the pumps. I imagine the network interfaces for status and control are about as well protected as grocery store freezers.
A bad pathogen could go world wide, but you could trash multiple cities with online attacks. No electricity, no water, no communications. Things would get bad.
Disrupting electric supply, water supply, and food supply chains are already tried and tested separately, with some limited monetary system disturbances, here and there. So doing those simultaneously - possibly leveraging on latent vulnerabilities kept covered for later abuse - sounds a natural step 'forward', close to trivial for those into that. Causing huge broad disturbances and possible unrest in societies. So that some governments started to ask people to build up reserves.
I can imagine that terrorist are sad now that they cannot use their preferred advanced bioengineering skills acquired through great efforts posing as scientist towards the so far unsuspecting services providing them with harmful DNA building blocks and now have to turn to much much more pedestrian methods instead of the heightened sophistication they crave.
Its hard to imagine a mustache twirling terrorist bent on putting PFAS and lead in the american water supply, putting mad cow in the beef supply and making everything cost more because he would have been outcompeted by the US government.
Have no idea what happens in the US but in Australia nearly all PFAS in the country comes from government properties, most often military bases or airports.
Plenty of blame should be reserved for the useful idiots high and low (and in the HN comments for that matter) who simped for the various policies that have poisoned ad impoverished us.
The evil billionares and megacorps as evil as they may be mostly don't give a shit about the minutia that people want to use to get one over on each other.
The regulatory state didn’t fail out of bureaucratic clumsiness; it was systematically bought and gutted so private balance sheets wouldn’t have to carry the cost of your cancer.
Blaming "the government" for toxic tap water and runaway prices is like blaming the getaway car instead of the bank robbers.
Surely the useful idiots who went to bat for every moronic expansion of the regulatory state regardless of cost (in opportunity and misery more than dollars TBH) because the "experts" said it made some random thing 1% better bear no responsibility for souring the public to the point it could be dismantled....
Private balance sheets wouldn’t have to carry the cost of your cancer is interesting. Do public balance sheets have to carry the cost of alcoholic's cirrhosis, smoker's lung cancer, and Type 2 diabetic's myriad of issues? Or does personal responsibility only apply to governments and corporations, not people?
But you’re still making the choice - are you that persuadable by an ad? What about the government anti-smoking ads? No effect there? Hilarious how nobody can take responsibility for their actions: always the government and business’s fault.
>Blaming "the government" for toxic tap water and runaway prices is like blaming the getaway car instead of the bank robbers.
Blaming the government for toxic tap water is like blaming an organised private/public coalition of bank robbers for a bank robbery.
>it was systematically bought and gutted so private balance sheets wouldn’t have to carry the cost of your cancer.
The US Government, day 1, was bought and sold to defend the right to own slaves, even from the predation of states that had made it illegal. It's not some recent malformation that it just started defending the interests of rich people over poor people lmao. The explicit purpose of the US government is to do the shit it does. The machine has been designed well, not poorly.
Sure, and the US was also home to the first abolitionist society, and fought its bloodiest war in history (by % of population killed) in a war to end slavery.
"...this sparkling analysis from Wood (History/Brown Univ.; ed., The Rising Glory of America, 1971) impressively argues that [the American Revolution] was anything but conservative. Wood's contention that the Revolution was ``the most radical and far-reaching event in American history'' may stretch the point (did it really have more of an impact than the Civil War?). But from now on it will be hard to argue that the rebellion was a genteel event that left fundamental institutions unscathed. Wood pictures colonial society as overwhelmingly deferential—to king, to family patriarch, and to aristocrats—with ``personal obligations and reciprocity that ran through the whole society.'' But patriots such as Adams, Jefferson, and Franklin, aspiring to become gentlemen, resented this entrenched order of patronage and kinship. Their classical republicanism stressed benevolence and government by an enlightened elite. To their dismay, however, they discovered that their rhetoric unleashed all the latent entrepreneurial and egalitarian energies of American life, which even the elaborate mechanism of the Constitution could not completely contain. Among the results, Wood says, were a new concept of the dignity of labor, improvements in the lot of women, the first significant antislavery movement, and the frank acceptance of private interest underlying the political party system. Above all, Wood suggests, the Revolution produced the messy, fractious politics of liberal democracy, dominated by ordinary people pursuing commercial interests."
Recent history also proves that adherence to the constitution was mostly an honor system.
Rhode Island negotiated its Royal charter with King Charles in 1663 it has gender neutral language and freedom of thoughts. The best parts of the US constitution. Unfortunately it was also the center of slave trade.
>and fought its bloodiest war in history (by % of population killed) in a war to end slavery.
In a war to formalise slavery through less obvious means. Black Codes, Jim Crow whathaveyou.
The entire concept of pairing slave states with non-slave states tells you how on board the north was with slavery as long as it wasn't done near them.
If England hadn't shut down the trans-atlantic slave trade let's face it, the USA would probably still be doing it today.
>The US voluntary shut down transatlantic imports long before the Civil War:
The US voluntary introduced a law that would have no real affect as the UK had shut the trade down for them.
Functionally, it was telling the domestic slave trade that they were now protected locally and abroad. And lead to a massive increase in Slave breeding.
And yet the Russian foreign policy is almost this: they know they can't compete on competence/science/tech so they try to tear everything down to their level.
I think this is a bad take. The Russian government wants to tear things down because they are a kleptocracy, and functional nations act as a check on corrupt governments. The more corrupt the US is the more theft russia can get away with and collude with pals inside the US gov on.
The framing of nations as inherently in competition with each other doesn’t track for me. Sometimes, in specific instances, nations will be in competition, but finland having a good or bad education system does not impact me even slightly.
> The framing of nations as inherently in competition with each other doesn’t track for me.
Where it tracks for you or not isn't relevant. It tracks for Putin and he's been extremely clear about that for hours and hours of extremely boring monologues :P
Nations in competition is a worldview of nationalists, dictators, and autocrats. I’m sure putin does talk about russia in competition with other nations all the time. He’s also a liar, who’ll stoke nationalism to bolster his power.
I don’t disagree they’re encouraging the collapse of other nations - i just disagree as to why
Sure, this is a common theme among the liberals who live far from war and poverty: never take any of those barbarians at their word when they say they believe something.
Personally I find it grating and it smells of racism.
We could have this same convo about trump, would that be racist too?
You keep missing my point. Idgaf if putin says nations are in competition, that doesn’t make it true. Idgaf if he believes what he says, that doesn’t change that it’s a monster’s way to view the world.
They have placed agent Krasnov though, so they influence US politics anyway. What is even more surprising is that Krasnov is now doubling down, despite the clear loss in the latest election.
Your status as a "defender" is measured by the fanciness of the threats you defend against, not their actual magnitude. That's why Space Force is so popular, and everyone working on vaccines is miserable.
Also, see the "lab leak" discourse. To me the question seemed irrelevant because the countermeasures would be exactly the same, but that's not how other people think; they're not interested in a mask mandate against a naturally occuring virus, but if they can tie the exact same genetically identical virus to a human enemy? The social status of the threat goes up!
Made-up AI-assisted super-measles? Doesn't exist yet. But it's a great super sexy threat to defend against. You just have to ignore the kids dying of boring old regular naturally occuring measles in the meantime.
The countermeasures to prevent future lab leaks are not the same as the countermeasures to prevent natural viruses. We should take lab safety more seriously and stop enhancing the lethality of viruses regardless of what happened with Covid, but we have failed to do so, probably in part because of denial of the lab leak.
> they're not interested in a mask mandate against a naturally occuring virus, but if they can tie the exact same genetically identical virus to a human enemy? The social status of the threat goes up!
Oh, that's what it is? I never had a model for such thinking.
reply