HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | werdnapk's commentslogin

Do you really believe a guy doing some wiring caused an air traffic shutdown last week?

Yes, at least in a "straw that broke the camel's back" sense.

Chernobyl was caused by a guy flipping a switch, Challenger blew up because of a faulty O-ring, etc.


That is all true, but those shouldn't be the stated reason that's reported to the public in a press-conference headed up by a US departmental head; that's how misconceptions poison the information-space for everyone.

I also wonder if Trump's administrations' spokespeople even realize they have a massive credibility problem, and that if they want people like me to believe anything then I have to hear it from a mid-level functionary, not a political appointee.


Proper root cause analysis takes its time so the last obvious fail in the chain of events is what gets published quickly.

You are in a minority, and no-one cares anymore.

You say whatever makes your stocks go up and now down, and if you don't, you are stupid because it's normalized now, there are no repercussions, and if you don't someone else will.


If the mid-level functionary tacks on, "This is why we demand that Congress allocate $50 billion in new funding for modernization!" do you still believe them?

> If the mid-level functionary tacks on, "This is why we demand that Congress allocate $50 billion in new funding for modernization!" do you still believe them?

Of course not, but that's the point of wanting to hear something from someone lower in the org chart: people lower-down on the totem-pole have fewer things within their remit that they can credibly talk about publicly; so if they ever speak of things above-their-pay-grade (like a technical team manager giving an official statement concerning departmental-level funding) then it's a signal they aren't speaking honestly.


"Chernobyl was caused by a guy flipping a switch"

No, just no...Chernobyl was caused by the staff doing an experiment that to put it mildly was wildly risky. They disabled safety systems with wrenches (meaning they couldn't easily be reenabled). Challenger blew up because staff at NASA ignored warnings from the people who made the O-rings. Saying these were "straws" is completely irresponsible. Attitudes like this are what cause outrages. Also, unless you are being dishonest, this is the worst string of outrages in the history of tech. There is a cause. It can be found. And unless you think in these terms, you have no business working with a production system in any way.


You’re not in disagreement with op. That’s the point motionlessveloc is making, it’s a series of mistakes (straws that make up the hay on the camel’s back) that points to a broader systemic problem.

I think you missed their point a bit. I believe they are saying that the cause was the faulty wiring in the same way that Chernobyl was caused by a switch flip.

In other words, the wiring problem might be the wrong thing to focus on - but it probably happened, and the systems likely wouldn't have crashed that day without it.


Do you have any reason to believe it didn't?

It's the sort of thing that is common in all systems I've been inside- which is to say, something little, to do with configuration, hardware fiddling, etc.

While AI rollouts have had issues, it is far from safe to assume just because there is an issue, it is automatically AI-related or vibe code specifically. Things always are breaking. Lines go down, servers have power failures, etc.

With this level of frequency and breadth? The _only_ common factor is AI implementation.

The trend is your friend until it bites your rear end. To give a topical answer, the Outlook issues were blamed on a software bug from months ago. While AI is being embraced en masse and causing all manner of issues, we have AI issues as _well_ as traditional "it broke" moments. The main point is we should not jump to a conclusion without stated evidence. Just because AI is to blame sometimes, does not mean it always is.

I think it is the co-occurrence of many incidents across different industries that points to potentially common causality.

LAX outage is blamed on a single computer

https://www.latimes.com/travel/la-trw-laxdelays15aug15-story...

By Tami Abdollah Aug. 15, 2007 12 AM PT

U.S. Customs officials said Tuesday that they had traced the source of last weekend’s system outage that left 17,000 international passengers stranded in airplanes to a malfunctioning network interface card on a single desktop computer in the Tom Bradley International Terminal at LAX.

The card, which allows computers to connect to a local area network, experienced a partial failure that started about 12:50 p.m. Saturday, slowing down the system, said Jennifer Connors, a chief in the office of field operations for the Customs and Border Protection agency.

As data overloaded the system, a domino effect occurred with other computer network cards, eventually causing a total system failure a little after 2 p.m., Connors said.


I automatically trusted the accuracy/honesty of this explanation from 2007. Zero trust today. We have much to fear from fear itself.

Running Window 98 SE.

I can really believe that they plugged in a misconfigured router and that a new router on a faster link was able to flood downstream legacy hardware with junk requests to the point where it started to fail.

Are RIP and BGP still a thing?

BGP4 is only still a thing on The Internet.

BGP is very much a thing, and increasingly used inside larger networks instead of just on the edge. RIP should very much be dead, but probably isn't. Afaik OSPF is the interior routing protocol of choice for situations where iBGP isn't used.

Do I believe a change in networking caused a networking issue? Yes?

Hilarious how I got down voted for this comment as multiple other networks and systems start going down all over the place. So many wiring jobs going on I guess.

I don't know, do computers use wires ???

  >Do you really believe
Thanks! Conspiratorial thinking hadn't annihilated my last brain cell yet.

I bet he feels bad about it. He should have known that flipping over to the fiber link would take out the whole FAA. /s

[flagged]

This right here is what needs to stop. AI has its problems but everyone blaming everything on AI is starting to wear thin. By all reports the new SMART AI system wasn't even in any way connected to the network that went down[1]. I guess we can put our tinfoil hat on and say every problem we have from now on is AI's fault and nobody will report it, but I'm not sure that helps anything. Probably better to wait and try to see what actually happened [2] before our knees jerk and credibility gets lost for when actual AI problems occur.

[1] https://apnews.com/article/faa-smart-ai-outage-08af345749c81...

[2] https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/nationwide-ground-stop-question...


Hang on - that first link says: "there’s no indication the communications issues that caused the ground stop are linked to the new computer system,"

As near as I can tell, they are saying that the communication issues are not related to the new computer system (not causative) - not that the new system is physically disconnected from the communications network.

(The article is a bit confusing, using "connected" and "linked to", which could either be describing physical or causative relationships).


FAA's site says:

Q: Was this caused by SMART system? A: No. The two systems are not related. SMART is a data aggregator, and it does not feed information into the air traffic control system.

If you dig a bit further the aggregator gets its data from SWIM, which receives (but does not send) data from the system that went down. I believe it's a 1 way VPN connection that they use to aggregate data because SWIM is consumer facing as well.[1]

So unless something went terribly wrong the AI couldn't have had anything to do with it. But that won't stop it being the top narrative for all time because nobody will look into it this far and we no longer believe any official stories about anything.

[1] https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/technology/swim/sfdps


Thanks - I appreciate the clarification. :)

Can you blame people for not trusting government officials when for the last decade Trump and co have been doing everything in their power to make sure people don’t trust government officials?

Not at all. But the AI would've had to be doing something completely different than its function. It doesn't send or receive data to the system that was overloaded, it's built to receive data from a completely different system. I also think this would be analyzed by enough people that one of network engineers or someone who just generally hates the idea of AI in their workload would've come out and said something by now.

Don't counter lack of credibility by spreading information you can't verify. It just muddies the water even more. There's people out there right now who think it's the AI apocalypse because a banking system is a bit slower.


It needs data to function and since it is LLM more likely they they implemented MCP that starting DDoSing the rest of the system when LLM was being asked for every single flight.

> It doesn't send or receive data to the system that was overloaded, it's built to receive data from a completely different system.

You're adding your own assumptions. This is what they said:

> Q: Was this caused by SMART system?

> A: No. The two systems are not related. SMART is a data aggregator, and it does not feed information into the air traffic control system.

It doesn't feed data, they didn't say it is completely isolated, which fits what I wrote.

They absolutely have incentive to avoid investigation that the company that donated to Duffy's son in law received nearly a billion no bid contract and failed to deliver a working product.


I looked into your claim about the son-in-law, and it seems you’re kind of right but mostly wrong. It looks like there were about a dozen bids for the contract and he does not own the company. But he is definitely involved in the company that received the contract.

Now don’t get me wrong, Duffy could totally be running cover for him and that is certainly the kind of corruption I expect from this administration. But the details are not quite as severe and direct as you are making them out to be it seems.


I didn’t spread anything. I just think people are inclined to think it’s whatever this current administration says it isn’t. I don’t blame them. There is no shared reality anymore, everyone is basically a little conspiracy theorist

It will get better at some point. When Trump is away I promise you to blindly trust the government again.

Except on Friday Mullin accidentally said that (when there was a question about attack) it happened after the system was patched and you can on Duffy's face that he was not supposed to say that.

Then next day they had conference where they came up with the maintenance guy.

Are you truly believe that a guy replacing a switch somewhere in Arkansas can just shut down the whole air travel in the entire country? The biggest disruption since 9/11 25 years ago? And just happened a day after SMART was deployed.

We are on tech forum, I would assume I'm talking to tech people who I hope understand how networking equipment operates.


Is this how the "AI will lead to the end of the world" type stuff I've been hearing about starts?

And how much was AI trained on their data? That's the sad part. Nobody asking new questions, so not much more for AI to train from.


Kind of makes me wonder how knowledge transfer is going to work in the future.

How many times have you found a random forum post solving your problem? How many countless people has that post likely helped?

Now every single person facing the same problem will regenerate from scratch the entire thought process and result. What a waste.

There needs to be some way to close the feedback loop from the work that LLMs do.


Another way the questions were answered wasn't by searching through existing content , but talking to someone who knew how to solve the problem or how to get to an answer by trying some things.


It's training on every single codebase in the world instead now

You prompt it to fix the mistakes it made and that goes into the new training data


More importantly, the newer generation of models don't even need Stackoverflow. With tool calling they can pull up as much documentation and source code as you could possibly want, and in the past year they've become alarmingly good at piecing those things together to solve problems.

It's less efficient than being able to point to a canonical answer on a widely respected forum, yes. And it sucks immensely to have to rely on these horrible AI companies to replace the real human interactions that getting work done used to require, yes. But realistically, we are not looking at some kind of model collapse anytime soon due to lack of SO threads.

Losing Reddit and blogs and other forums is going to be a bigger problem. In two years from now, if I ask GPT-8 or whatever to build me a Web server, what web framework is it going to use? How will it and/or I know which one is a good choice? if the web becomes a ghost town and nobody is talking about anything anymore, there's no form thread it can uncover and say "that's the one everyone uses". Losing the library of technical Q&A is nothing close to the catastrophe of losing actual conversations between humans.


In two years from now, if I ask GPT-8 or whatever to build me a Web server, what web framework is it going to use?

My guess is, you won't care.

How will it and/or I know which one is a good choice?

My guess is, it will make a good choice.


> a good choice

For who?


For whatever requirements are specified by gwerbin.


FWIW, StackOverflow posts are licensed under Creative Commons BY-SA v4.0, same as Wikipedia.


With or without training they would have gotten eaten.


There is a difference between dying tomorrow and dying in 5 years.


Why?


The golden age of SO was when all the important questions that have accumulated over decades were getting asked and answered. SO stabilized once that backlog got finished, and then started dying once people moved to github issues for project-specific questions. Chatgpt just replaced the last remaining type of questions ("plz do my work for me"), which arguably shouldn't have been getting asked in the first place.


The peak number of questions was in 2013, and they had roughly zero growth between 2013 & 2016. They were in decline long before LLMs were on the scene.


There's a board game with this theme: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_Grid

I've played it and enjoyed it.


Wait until you see how non-Apple hardware innovates... that Apple then copies.


This is wrong for two main reasons.

First, everyone copies. In computing space, let me give you a funny example. Apple iOS home screen is a copy and evolution of PalmOS user interface, down to four buttons, pages, graffiti area and so on.

Palm's phone (Android running one) copies Apple Watch's user interface as home screen like a revenge, with a iPhone X-esque camera bump. Funny, ironic, real.

Second, Apple is a slow moving company. They don't rush things. They are the last company to move OLEDs on their phone, because they want to implement without any apparent flaws and with a long life. i.e.: My parent's Samsung A9 2018 phones have screen burn-in, but my iPhone X doesn't. They are at a similar age.

Like them or not, their engineering is solid and novel. At least give them that. My 18 year old Mac still boots despite being dropped (I fell on top of it) and bent badly, and gone through three batteries.

My 12 year old MacBook Pro still runs like day one despite being hammered for years for high performance computing, and its disk still shows ~10% wear.

Like every company, Apple makes mistake (these keyboards were bad, yes), but they are sometimes misunderstood (you can only charge that upside down, but charging it for 2 minutes gives you 8 hours of use, so get a coffee and flex at least).


As a mechanical engineer working in software, I think both fields have completely different philosophies of product development. In hardware, you give a lot of thought to potential failure modes and contingencies before building something, which takes time. In software, I’ve rarely seen a product whose first version is completely free of bugs. Shipping with some bugs and fixing them through iterations is standard industry practice, whereas it’s less acceptable in hardware.

I think Apple is more of a hardware company than a software company these days. They invested enough time, resources, and patience in ARM for it to now compete with the once-mighty Intel x86 architecture. That kind of progress requires patience, so I don’t think we can simply call Apple a slow company or say it isn’t innovating.


> As a mechanical engineer working in software, I think both fields have completely different philosophies of product development.

A sloppy mechanical engineer can be sued for malpractice and lose their license to practice. If they do something unethical they can't blame it all on management and could end up being held personally responsible with fines and even jail time.

Sometimes I think it we might be better off if the same held for software engineers.


That is, if they're licensed. Most hardware engineers, at least in the US, are not licensed PEs; you only need a PE license if you're signing off on engineering work under government contract or public safety is a concern or its some otherwise regulated industry where the regulations require it.


It wasn't always the case with software, before the internet era and updates. Software were done with a lot more cares because burning discs and distribution were costly. Exactly the same reason why Hardware put a lot of thoughts into it for failure because recalling product is expensive.


Apple is always a hardware company first, they always have been. The software is supposed to be a reflection of their hardware perfection and passion (we can discuss this later).

I didn’t use slow in a negative way. On the contrary, my context behind that “slow” was “patient, detail obsessed and immaculate”. Also I didn’t mean that they are not innovating. Again, they innovate and bake well, then release things, which is how I like my hardware.

Thanks for your reply though. Seems like I missed the point I was trying to make by a mile.


Android as a whole is basically the store-brand version of iPhone. There were a lot of controversial decisions made on the first couple of iPhones that ended up being industry standard. (And yes I know Android is technically only the OS, but idc)


There are plenty of excellent engineering products that Apple have engineered themselves. Starting with the iPhone itself which was an enormous cut above the competition.

Yes Apple has "copied" or brought out its own version of particular products before, usually in a much better state.


> Starting with the iPhone itself which was an enormous cut above the competition

I wouldn't say that at all. Correct me if I misremember, but the original iPhone didn't even have an ecosystem of apps outside a few Apple-sanctioned ones. I was thoroughly unimpressed when it came out, at the missed (in retrospect, deferred) opportunity.

My older Palm device felt superior in nearly every way I cared about.


Considering practically every smartphone to this day is derivative of the 2007 glass slab hardware design (and software UX), I'd say they were on to something even if it didn't launch with the App Store immediately.


> Considering practically every smartphone to this day is derivative of the 2007 glass slab hardware design (and software UX), I'd say they were on to something

Lowest cost of production is what that formfactor provides.

Palm's devices, by contrast, felt like a polished river stone in the pocket. I know which I prefer.


> Lowest cost of production is what that formfactor provides.

Maybe, but to compete with the iPhone everything else that goes into the production of a smartphone would have been way more expensive. More compute requirements, better screens, way more software engineering headcount.


Palm's Pre[1] supported multi-tasking, having multiple emails open at the same time to read and compose, unified instant messaging, copy/paste and myriad other features iPhone didn't have at the time.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palm_Pre


I went from a Palm Treo to the iPhone in 2007, these devices were not in the same league. Years apart in all aspects. I had an external box for tomtom gps on the treo and a janky mp3 player and some crappy apps on a resistive touch screen that looked like it had a permanent hazy film over it as all resistive ones do.

The apps part was rectified pretty quickly but even the kind of halfway decent web apps available after iPhone launch beat treo apps.


I'm not an apple fanboy but they were the first to really understand and solve touch screen phones - they went with capacitive tech when everyone was doing resistive and they went all-in on the UX and studied how touch should feel and how the UI should reflect it.

They were by no means the first smartphone nor were they the first touch phone but the "iphone moment" was coined because they figured out how to make frontier tech mainstream.

They also weren't the first to make an MP3 player but it sure felt that way with the ipod. I don't know how people have rewritten this history in their minds


This is true, but I felt the same with the HTC Dream, although I guess Apple was first, they were more than a year apart. I don't miss typing 'reboot\n' in any app, or at any time, and the phone rebooting, because the first release had a left-open root session.

So the Android polish wasn't quite there on release either.


Your older Palm device was almost certainly much worse at browsing the web both in fidelity and interactivity. Loading a full desktop website on a device that small and being able to pinch to zoom in to sections was pretty novel at the time.


Yeah arguably the biggest innovation the iPhone had was the capacitive touch screen - they weren't the first (that was the LG Prada) and the various interactions like pinch zooming and inertial scrolling were done before, but they did have a 2004 patent on capacitive multi-touch screens.


Yeah as I recall it, the iPhone was the first device where touch felt really natural and fun. They nailed that feeling that you’re actually interacting directly with what is under your finger. Previous touch devices I tried felt kind of disconnected because they hadn’t sweated the details in the same way.


thats a very different narrative though.

but this discussion always has the tendency to go completely off teh rails because there are so many people unable to talk rationally about apple products.

innovation basically never happens in a vacuum, and especially apple products have historically "come second" into a product category -- and just nail the implementation so well that they just felt great to use. (and yes, smartphones were well established by the time the iphone was released. thats what i'd call the product category there. dialing in to ever narrower definitions to make it into a "new" category is exactly the reason why this can never be settled - because you can call _every_ product a new product category like that)

So now we got endless discussions about "who was first" even though its completely meaningless to ask this question -- because that "previous product" also took inspiration from other products, and if you squinted enough, could also be called "just an iteration" vs a "innovation".


It’s not really a different narrative, though: They started with the idea that the phone should be nearly all screen (which was very controversial at the time) and designed the software around that. No one had a UI or UX that was as fully committed to this idea as the iPhone, although they certainly got inspiration from others.

You’re right that Apple isn’t usually a first mover within a product segment. But that have a tendency to nail what they consider to be a better execution of that product.


I'm so glad someone else remembers and values their contributions here.

That full package of capacitive touch, a UI and UX optimised for touch, inertial scrolling with pinch and zoom came together to form something much greater than the sum of the individual parts: an experience that could convince you to part with physical buttons

Also I think it took me almost a decade to find a touch keyboard (fleksy) I liked as much as the iOS keyboard. I think people also take for granted how far ahead their quiet innovations in the touch keyboard were without fanfare.

The ones in 2007 were unusable, the original android ones were terrible and I didn't much like swiftkey. Google Keyboard came much later but lacked some of the smoothing and tappiness of the Apple one


Nokia was dominating the smartphone market when iPhone was released. There was no ecosystem there. All these "pocket PC" devices were very cool for their time, but they were really really far from mass market adoption.


There was the “sweet solution” :) When reading the stories about how the first iPhone came to be, had they tried to also have an sdk with the first release, it would not have shipped on time. And although Jobs was famously stubborn, this is something he changed his mind quite quickly on. In no small part due to the ecosystem that popped up despite him thanks to jailbreaking.


And on the other side of that argument are people lamenting that it didn’t stay web app centric with PWAs and whatnot


an ecosystem of apps

To be fair here, you're replying to a thread where people were discussing mechanical engineering, and hardware. Not software.

Held to that metric, the software layer isn't part of the original discussion.

Not saying that discussing other things is wrong, but the comment you replied to seems to be "The hardware was an enormous cut above".


1. Some tech exists that isn't ready to use in phones yet

2. X Android phonemaker uses said tech in half-baked manner

3. Apple releases phone with polished version of tech

4. "Apple copied X phonemaker"


That is a problem with their software mostly.


Like what?


foldable screens


Yes, Apple reliably lets other manufacturers discover the hard problems, and then Apple solves them. And then residents of HN and Reddit think this is a great zinger every time.


Apple buys them. Paying Sammy $330 bucks for every one of those handsets they sell: https://www.gadgetreview.com/apple-is-reportedly-paying-sams...


That puts me in mind of Google paying Apple billions per year to have Google as the default search engine and (maybe more importantly) discourage Apple from building their own search engine.

Knowing what we know today, probably a good choice as search engines themselves are quickly getting less usage due to AIs. (I for one would never have predicted there would be something that could replace search engines, but then I also thought Facebook was here to stay forever for everyone. Happy to be wrong)


Apple pays Samsung for making the things Apple designed.


Like folding screens in question?


Possibly. It's complicated. It's not uncommon for Company A to produce a design based on Company B's proprietary R&D. Just because Samsung is making those displays for Apple doesn't mean that Apple didn't do major parts of the R&D. Nor does it mean that Samsung can make the same displays for Samsung, or for their other customers.


Just because something is possible doesn't mean we can deny ground truth. Apple did not invent folded screens by any stretch of the imagination, and is the latest one to the party, even for Apples standard of "freshness" it is late.


That's good, we saw how the early ones were. Nobody said Apple invented the concept of folding screens.


They could have. It's sad to see a trillion-dollar smartphone company with such shallow ambitions.


Their ambitions are to sell products that work. I’m a customer because I want the newest stuff that has the kinks worked out.

Idk if you’ve ever worked on… anything… but the last 10% of the apparent work is the hardest. It’s incredibly ambitious to take an idea from 90% to 100%.


An oyster with 2-3 drops of Tabasco is just the perfect amount of heat.


And how long until you realize there were mistakes?


It depends how frequently you interact with those bots. I interact on a daily basis, and it took me a few days to realize strength/weaknesses of those bots. I also keep an eye on the grok bot team workshops and learn from their practices. They share a lot. There is a bot called “ dr eggbot” on marketplace, which you can use to create other bots. That bot was created by one of the leading grok bot team member.


In firefox it is Swedish on the left and English on the right.


So you just go digging under neighbours properties? What about underground infrastructure?


I don’t think it extends beyond property limits.


Canada actually has quite a lot of domestic production across the country. BC and Ontario are the main producers and have many wineries.


Yes, but many of those wineries import their grapes from California (or other places). My wife and I participate in this boycott and were drinking a sparkling white from Mission Hill Winery which is one of the biggest BC wineries. We noticed the label said something like "Produced in Canada" and then listed grapes imported from California.

Wines that are produced from 100% BC grapes are labelled "BC VQA" and only 19% of the wines in BC are BC VQA.


This was a temporary measure for a couple vintages/years after a frost decimated nearly all the vines in the BC Okanagan. The regulators stepped in to allow relaxed importation rules to help wineries survive. A winery like Mission Hill typically grows and sources all of its grapes within BC.


I think this is temporary and related to crop failures when a lot of BC berries froze. AFAIK they grow their own grapes otherwise. Who knows for how much longer and if the climate will allow growing grapes sustainably at all in those places.


I have a bottle of Niagara icewine downstairs I'm very much looking forward to!


The wine from Canada is not good, unless you like dessert wine/icewine. Maybe there are some exceptions for riesling but it's too cold to grow nice vines there.


You can't be making such blanket statements. There are a lot of great wines. Some of the best syrah I've ever had is from BC, and there are plenty of other great wines.


My response to this would be drink more Syrah from Northern Rhone, because there is no producer in Canada that is producing Syrah anywhere near the quality (find me someone trying to claim they are; they cant the soil and climate are too different) . You can say it's subjective, but we both know it's not. I made one exception, Riesling, because their are some good expressions in cold weather.

If you dont believe me go find a bottle of this Chave (https://www.klwines.com/products/details/2010088) and drink them side-by-side.


I had wine from the niagara peninsula - it was either cabernet or a cab/merlot red blend. I enjoyed it as much as I enjoy most dry reds (which is a lot). It wasn't exactly the rival of France's appellations (high bar) but still very good.


I think we agree then - Canada makes "a lot" of of wine; it's possible to enjoy drinking it, but take the same grape in Europe and it will be better!!


Even Ontarians don't speak kindly about wine from Ontario lol


That's because the LCBO has a monopoly on wine sales in Ontario and it's very difficult for Ontario wineries to get their good wines into the LCBO. It's a combination of shelf fees, minimum volume requirements, and an idiosyncratic evaluation system where their participation costs are not covered.

Spend some time at wineries on the Niagara escarpment and you'll find some great wines, especially whites that benefit from the limestone heavy soils. Even the large producers that have a poor public reputation for quality (Trius, Iniskillin, etc.) have much better wines available on site that never make it to the LCBO. For the most part (some exceptions), the people who run these wineries are wine enthusiasts who genuinely care about quality. Prices for that quality are higher than other wine regions with more favorable climates, higher production, and lower labour costs though, that is true.


Depends. Ontario ice wine is great.


because it sucks lol


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: