Effectively it is because getting accredited as an official App Store is made so ridiculously demanding by Apple that almost no one can afford it and then you still have to somehow get consumers to switch to your App Store.
Why do you have to set up your own App Store when others have already done that? There are alternative stores; publish there without any Apple oversight.
What's important is that you can publish without Apple's review. I doubt that unless you publish something extremely criminal Apple would care to revoke the certificate.
Apple can’t lead a horse to water. Most people still to this day don’t buy most of the apps that are on the App Stores and mostly it is a trust issue and in most cases quality issue even at this late date.
Epic had a chance with their own store in Android. It turns out no one trusted them and no one bought from them, but that didn’t stop them from crying. Google is unfair and what’s interesting is that they still have the same problem on iOS. No one trusts them and the government ultimately can’t help with that.
And no surprise, Epic is having the same problem within the iOS world. No one trusts them.
I do not consider any messaging service requiring a mobile phone number as the account handle to be private or secure. One cannot build security on the foundations of inherently insecure technologies.
you can never be confident that it won't be taken from you when the number is inevitably reused.
there was once a way to prevent that from happening but now you won't even get a notification that it's happening so you won't have a chance to move your number.
I wrote in another reply that your government may know you paid for the service which may be dangerous. Signal not tracking me is the least of the worries here; your oppressive regime trying to keep tabs on you is the real issue.
> One cannot build security on the foundations of inherently insecure technologies.
Of course you can?
Maybe I am missin your point, but that is fundamental basic that you put the encryption and decryption in the ends, and you can transfer over any inherently insecure technologies.
To pay, using a KYC-based system you mean, since Signal does not accept crypto?
In the countries like Russia they simply blocked incoming registrations SMS from Signal and the others to wade off people from the service. I wouldn't risk using a direct payment in a country famous for jailing people for payments to "extremists" organisations either.
Just do email, or stop calling yourself "private" and "secure"
Russia, China and Iran is an edge case Signal don't care about. Messengers need network effect and there are too many hoops to jump through to make Signal work inside the network where the state is actively opposing that. Just wrong tool for the job and different set of assumptions.
Most likely such an attempt will fail even earlier than Google/KYC become relevant: their account creation vCaptcha de-facto doesn't accept challenges made from VPN connections (based on app reporting the network status, not endpoint IP).
Note that none of this new. Men with guns and gag orders show up to companies in the US and take over parts of their offices to set up shop, splice into their network, install their hardware, and take whatever they want. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
According to the slides from PRISM program NSA used a combination of automated legal data requests from Apple (number of which Apple publishes every year) and hacking for direct access to phones. Nothing in the slides shows that there is or was a backdoor for the NSA. In fact, the slides indicate NSA efforts of getting the information they have no direct access to.
> and able to access anything and everything they want.
Apple added E2EE so they couldn't give over that stuff. Yeah, there could be tons of metadata collection, but you'd have to provide evidence if there was a backdoor in the client side encryption.
There's gonna be tons of spying considering the vast majority of people don't use advanced data protection. I don't think people are debating whether non-E2EE stuff is being spied on. It definitely is.
But to claim that E2EE stuff is being spied on, you gotta provide evidence.
It's wild that you seem to be able to accept that apple has been handing over private customer data for years under secret government orders, but can't imagine that apple would ever be forced to backdoor, collect keys, or weaken the encryption on the blackbox closed source consumer devices they also build and maintain full remote control over. Do you seriously think the NSA just said "Aww you crafty guys at apple got us by encrypting stuff! Oh well, I guess we better just pack up and go home!"
Hey, maybe we'll get really lucky and yet another highly paid professional with a promising career and a family will risk his life and throw away everything including his home, freedom, and the ability to see his loved ones just to tell you all the details again. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for the updated NSA power point presentation though.
When DOJ tried to force Apple to do just that, Apple went to the court and DOJ had to drop the demand. There are no laws in the US (as of yet) that force companies to create backdoors.
Therefore, I'm asking for the evidence, not your belief or conviction, that such backdoor exists.
There's a world of difference between what the DOJ can do through the court system and what the NSA (which is DoD/DoW) can do outside of it. There are no laws in the US that force companies to allow the government to march in and take over office space in their corporate headquarters to illegally wiretap their network and also the entire American public, but black rooms like Room 641A still exist and actions by the NSA that are blatantly unconstitutional are what prompted the disclosures Snowden gave us.
If it makes you feel better to have the belief or conviction that the NSA is now powerless to collect data because of Apple's "one weird trick" of using of encryption you are free to believe that. For my part, I've seen more than enough evidence to give me doubt.
Some years ago I had to add a squircle to a UI system that lacked one. I compared Figma's approach to Apple's and found out they do not match well. So, then I just drew a default rounded rectangle path in Apple's playground and read the Bézier curves from that path. I got my control points I could use to perfectly represent Apple's approach!
One interesting detail I noticed: in Apple's squircles the rounded corners are slightly pushing outwards from the flatness of a side. But the absolute value is very low, so the effect isn't visible unless you specifically look for it.
When a similar thing was introduced to Swift it too raised a lot of heated discussions. Somehow, people became extremely passionate about this little extension.
Fast forward to today. After years of using it I find it very good for readability. It became the default in codebases. Nobody complains anymore and absolutely no one is confused.
Heck I use copilot at work and use M365 copilot chat for a lot of short things and small scripts and tools over credits in Github Copilot. At home I throw things things into copilot chat free, google AI, and more to avoid cost.
Then all the real AI work I'm using my local setup on dedicated hardware for large local models. I have usede my Copilot pr sub a few times this month to check work but it's either:
1. I ask about bugs and security fixes, glaring holes, and other checks before calling the work complete and posting a release to my persona github. 2% credit usage over 20 minutes and useful small changes.
2. I ask about information in a repo I'm using, like GUFO or Halogen-flash-next, and some key info. 35% of my monthly premium credits gone before the one chat completes.
How can 20 minutes on a whole custom project looking for bugs and issues use almost nothing, then a question about a repo eats 30%+? I don't even have budget to learn how I failed as 2 more tests and I'm burned on premium requests for the month (in minutes).
So I abuse the free options for everything I can. Draft scripts/sql/etc, stage prompts or handoff/etc files, ask questions or research something and pass on to vs code/copilot chat/etc like I run at work (with much more credits through the enterprise plan).
The author talks about revenue growth on the basis of Anthropic's S-1 filing, but ignores the third quarter results which were posted later.
The growth slowed and operating profit has swung to a loss. The company can still make money, just not at a pace that has a chance to pay off the investments.
Also, the author conflates AI's technical potential with the market potential, naively assuming the demand will also grow as technology matures.
Big money (Wall Street) will be looking at GAAP equivalent accounts for their real valuations. They'll happily go along with public figures looking healthier than reality, providing they can exit investments or lock themselves in to be paid back first, when offloading to the public or in the case of bankruptcy.
GAAP rules exist for a reason. One of the main reasons being the investors should have a clear and consistent view of the business before they decide to invest. The "non-GAAP adjusted" might as well read "But if we exclude the numbers we don't like our future looks so much brighter".
Most of the "laws" of economy in this form say often as a footnote "all else being equal", which remains to be seen. Otherwise you can justify any attempts at price decrease in any industry the same way.
> it’s quite rational that demand increases as price decreases
This is not necessarily wrong, but neither is it right; it is underspecified. Even if we were ignoring other factors and taking into account only the assumptions of a classical economic model, the shape of the demand curve still depends on the size of the market and the price elasticity of demand.
I absolutely disagree number of users is saturated. Fortune 500 companies, for all of their 'AI accelerating' shareholder speeches, are doing very little to actually integrate or spend on AI for the average employee. I've talked to a lot of people who work white collar jobs that could absolutely be accelerated by AI, and they just... aren't using it at all. Some of the companies make Copilot available. Some people just copy paste their tasks into the free version of chatGPT and spend a lot of time correcting the dumb model. A lot of orgs are concerned about data leakage and just have a blanket AI ban.
I recently joined a software dev team in which nobody is using any AI at all. They weren't conceptually against it, they just didn't feel the need to change their process.
That doesn't make them more money. Those people who aren't maximizing their AI subscriptions already have an AI subscription. If anything this would hurt AI companies if people were actually using the compute they have access to with their subscription, instead of how it is right now where most of these underused subscribers are floating the people who are really using it.
> I don’t think this is naive at all; it’s quite rational that demand increases as price decreases, which does seem inevitable.
But that's not what OC is saying, isn't it? Frontier models becoming better and cheaper at the same time are not a given.
Near-frontier models that have 99% of the capabilities of frontier models, at a tenth of the cost of frontier models, might ironically be what pops the bubble.
CPUs (and a million other things) got better and cheaper with time, I see no reason that AI would be any different.
The distinction between frontier/non-frontier models doesn’t matter much here, for the overall market. With CPUs, for example, Pentiums got better and cheaper while Cyrix/AMD did the same.
The real question is not if the technology is going to get better and cheaper, but rather if it's going to meet the market expectations to justify trillions of USD in valuation.
1. What you want changes as the market does, in the way people use agentic coding now rather than just cheaper versions of Cursor autocomplete
2. Frontier labs are cheaper than open-source models too
Is there seriously a non-frontier model out there that can do what Opus 5.5 does? I can say: go look at a ticket in Jira and figure out how to fix it, write end to end tests for it, make sure it aligns with previous architectural decisions we've recorded in documents, and then test it, summarize all the testing you did, and open up a PR for review?
Anthropic, for one, doesn't seem to be replacing their human engineers and data scientists with Opus 5.5 yet even when they would be better positioned to do so than any other company. https://www.anthropic.com/careers/jobs
A 10x will always be beat by 10x+ai. But ai+10x is better than just ai. The world has an over supply of ai (or soon will) but a finite number of 10x coders.
Demand will also grow as technology matures, if that maturing means more efficient and cheaper models. We're already at a stage where only a very small niche cares for better more complex models.
People keep repeating this but is it true? In natural sciences, for example, there are endless applications. Anthropic models have only recently reached the level what I would call useful. Still, they are far from perfect and there's a lot of room for growth. Is science a very small niche? I don't think so.
> But the AI industry doesn't consist of just Anthropic.
That is not the claim. Author uses Anthropic's filing as an example indicating growth of the whole industry. While questionable on its own, it is also not given in full, which I pointed out.
The competition is also a problem tho. Both of them are betting the house pretty much on winner takes all. If competition reduces growth, that's a sign that they both can't fulfill all their promises which ipso facto means one or both is overvalued.
I know this is a bit of an ad hominem attack, but it is hard to take the authors arguments seriously as they also argue that the imperial system is superior to the metric system because people in Italy apparently state their height as 183cm (in real life everyone would use 1.83m) and that calculating things using the imperial system is easier as well...
This is just general comment to all the excitable kids over here.
Anthropic is one company in a gigantic ecosystem.
You want to understand the eco system. Got to flyover the jungle, not just stare at one elephant herd.
Read annual reports of NVIDIA, atleast one from Microsoft/Amazon/Google and atleast one representing activities of Enterprise projects (Accenture/IBM/TCS). Then look at govts budgets/programmes for AI US/EU/UAE/S.Korea.
Isn't that worse because you then get into neocloud companies like Coreweave and Nebius who have taken insane debt to build out data centers and if the demand sinks for those they'll go under
It gets worse. CoreWeave has more than $50 billion in debt. rising costs will make financing economically unfeasible. And a demand shock will push the company into bankruptcy. This will affect NVIDIA and others involved in this entire AI supply chain.
CoreWeave defaulting vs say Alphabet or Meta or MS or Amazon is very different thing. According to Pachai right now they are severely compute constrained they have 2x the demand they can serve. So while CoreWeave bondholders might take a haircut one of the hyperscalars will likely gladly buy their assets.
reply