Im genuinely 50/50 on what the boring Occam's razor explanation is. Because obviously it should be "software be buggy sometimes" like duh. However, hypothetically:
- let there country A and country C
- A and C are caught in technological arms race involving technology that enables cyberattcks
- A has a much more powerful version of the technology than C so C probably does not want a direct escalatory cyberwar
- A large event occurs in which Cs apparent access to an important enabling technology for this arms race is revealed and the consequences likely involve A cutting them off
- The leaders of A and C are also scheduled to meet at a summit within days of the large event.
So we are in a period between the large event and a summit. A period where C may feel compelled to make a point/insinuate consequences before a pivotal meeting. But also if they do anything that's obviously a cyber attack and traceable it could escalate and they might not win.
If suddenly there are a series of high profile embarrassing disruptive cyber occurrences with no clear shared cause during that interval impacting As government and key industry players in their tech banking and defense sectors, well, look. Occam's razor is still probably "software be buggy." But also like they're on their way to a summit literally this week which sounds like a really obvious time to amp up the pressure a bit no?
The thing about the world not caring about your personal workflows - that's not true. Not if you used to be someone else's customer because of that workflow. Sometimes those little internal dashboards would have been a vendor contract instead.
I would argue you are never going to see an "explosion of delightful software" of the type you're imagining regardless of the level of AI capability. "Toys and dashboards" will just encompass more and more. A rising tide floods all shores.
Lets say you vibe code some software that's relatively straightforward to vibe code at a given level of AI capability. Are you going to turn it into some sort of commercial product? Of course not, there's no competitive advantage. It's trivial for competitors to enter but more importantly it's also trivial for your customers to just do it themselves.
What about release and maintain it as an open source project? Sure might as well. But nobody is really going to notice since it's easy to do and even if people do, of they have a feature request - it's kind of weird that they want you to spend your tokens on their special case no? Just fork it!
At some point if aaI gets better and better than those toy projects grow to include like, your operating system.
There's room for delightful ai written software. T3 code (agent dev environment) and grokbot (cursor's personal assistant) are both pretty nice. There the heavily vibe coded software is worth using because it's made by people who have more tokens than you and know how to use them well and seem to have decent product sense. I think it's not surprising that the software they chose to work on is software to help agents write code better. I think probably we'll see like, a really good android alternative or the like pop off too. But, these are going to be very rare. And they are arguably boundary pushing and not things you can vibe code "easily."
Also not to say programming will not be social anymore. Hopefully whatever your social circle is doing together you work on things with them - everyone on a forum or a chat group is a contributor etc.
But the source code itself does not matter for whatever software is at a level that widely adopted AI can produce with ease. I believe this should bevalid without having to project AI capability in the future since it's just quasi-tautologically stating that code that's easy to produce will be produced easily.
People will share ideas, you'll see a cool thing your friend is doing with their setup and adapt it to yours, ideas will spread more easily than ever. But the source code wont be valuable anymore.
This democratic party is not exactly the same as any other democratic party that's been in power. There's been a pretty clear shift in party beliefs again. Democrats used to be pro tech neolibs, defending Elon on the debate stage while Mitt Romney attacked him, etc. The democratic party now is the one that got betrayed by the oligarchs and has an axe to grind and mandate to grind that axe
#3 is not a given. That money is poison. If Mississippi can go blue then new york can go red. We're just entering a less polarized era of politics. Things have been trending in that direction every election this decade.
One of the things that Americans broadly agree on right now is data centers can go to hell and data centers are just a proxy for tech. Democrats won in primaries and the general by being outspent. Not while being outspent. By being outspent. Just accepting particular categories of donor money sunk primary campaigns and the general in e.g. Texas turned into a referendum on the donors.
Politicians' driving motivation is getting re elected. If that money is toxic they're not touching it. If democrats turned around in Ohio and Texas and accepted data center money after rage against them was specifically the one thing that got them into office, you think they have a snowballs chance in hell of keeping those seats? The GOP just ran that experiment. They betrayed the like specific things said they'd do, and got rewarded with a comical amount of donor money, and fricking Blansas Blexas Blississippi because it turned out voters were like no but we were serious about that tho
If the democrats don't deliver anything after this I think you'll see a wild swing backwards to whoever on the right promises to solve problems but won't solve the problems, and after that I think all bets are off in terms of what happens.
People will have had no rational reason whatsoever to believe that they have any say in the running of the country or whats being done to their lives families and communities. Democracies that don't respond to voters die and absolutely nobody running a company in silicon valley or SF understands the level of utter rage simmering among people.
#3 was probably more true in 2024 than it is today. Not realizing populism is becoming a bigger factor in both parties is a pretty big miscalculation though. Also media and tech were both common axe grinds in the first Trump term. So maybe they thought they would get ahead of the retribution which they probably did but at the cost of losing the other side. They also miscalculated that Trump will just do stuff even if you thought you paid him off, eg tariffs.
Definitely, and I think it was more true in 2022 than 24, and 20 than 22. Personally for 18 and 16 I feel like I have no idea what has happening. I think sometime around then polarization peaked and started to decline. Like the populist surge with Bernie and Trump (end citizens United/drain the swamp/etc) was 2016 but I don't trust my my own memories of what I felt at that time because what even was the pre pandemic era? Im sure people smarter than me can explain what was happening then and how it relates to now but to an idiot m like my it just feels like stuff was happening, then we all paused, put the world in a blender, shook it up, then hit play.
But since then every election has just felt (I keep qualifying "felt" because these are just the vibes in my bubble) like "can we have less chaos and good economy and [some vision of a government that is less powerful and controlling, anti covid or anti trump corruption or something] and also [a somewhat frustratingly contradictory vision go also, a government that is not inept and gridlocked and gets stuff done] and less war"
"No for real tho"
"No for real tho let me try the guys on the right again"
"No for real tho what about this socialist mayor"
"No for real tho - uhh - this is not working - let's try some mashups. Jesus and single payer healthcare - or - no that's not really a mashup I guess that was sort of his original deal anyway. So uhh, Union Bros, but, they're pro immigration now and hate tarrifs. And what if we had like a younger Bernie type that's on about all the same things but he's Muslim and he calls himself a capitalist. We'll do an old senator in ohio and a young governor in Alaska, and, actually fuck it just reroll everything one of these gotta work" <- we are here
Who TF knows what we're gonna get for 2028s "No like for real tho" but somehow I feel like a dominant driving force is going to involve how stuff is expensive and people don't like war.
That sucks - I've definitely been there. I think the lesson of "opus 5.5 is functionally the greatest model ever made and probably actually better than fable for a go research alternatives task and frankly I could have gotten away with sonnet subagents and why would I even use Fable for a task like that" is just one we all have to learn our versions of at the cost of a reset lol.
For me it was "oh max mode is literally a scam and always worse and never worth it" followed by "ultra code is not worth it" followed by "fable 5 rules but literally anything simple enough that I can do before I run out of usage limits on the 5x plan, the other AIs can do." Luckily though it turned out fable was also good at orchestrating non fable subagents so that was cool.
But yeah that's not a harness problem unfortunately. I guess they do encourage you to hit the money furnace button (ultra code pretty colors!) but yeah that's rough. Silver lining - you had a reset!
No. I think the fact that the government wouldn't do a better job is a skill issue and the government has to get good. But also this government where it does farm out to contractors and monopolizte for every little thing could never build the software itself. Even saying "the government makes it itself" is saying we fundamentally have a government tha is different than right now.
It's been pretty cool to see NASA lock in under the new administrator, starr making things in house and not wait on contractors etc.
This is a narrow and shortsighted take. Government would absolutely do a better job if only for the SOPs around redundancy that business is famously flexible on (read: happy to ignore).
That rules! Looks like you can do it with like 3 filters so it's more triangle shaped which makes sense. That's so stupidly simple too. Also aesthetically pretty cool - would look great in a workshop where it's like function first/don't hide the mechanism. And I feel like there's gotta be clever ways to incorporate something as simple as "box fan but the box is made of air filter" into like a coffee table or stand or something else clever? Probably you'd want to hide the filters inside if they look grimy before you actually need to replace them so you don't feel obligated to waste money by replacing too soon but sounds like a fun time to figure out how to integrate that in a hidden way into whatever's your vibe without looking jank
So we are in a period between the large event and a summit. A period where C may feel compelled to make a point/insinuate consequences before a pivotal meeting. But also if they do anything that's obviously a cyber attack and traceable it could escalate and they might not win.
If suddenly there are a series of high profile embarrassing disruptive cyber occurrences with no clear shared cause during that interval impacting As government and key industry players in their tech banking and defense sectors, well, look. Occam's razor is still probably "software be buggy." But also like they're on their way to a summit literally this week which sounds like a really obvious time to amp up the pressure a bit no?
reply