HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | verisimi's commentslogin

Surely the initial ai responses are a reasonably fair first pass, and would be acceptable to most users.

However, it is then on the person asking the query to refine the query and push for more specifics.

I don't see the problem. Ai doesn't need to get it all right, first time.


Maybe you aren't trying to solve unique problems? Ie at my job putting together a client side JavaScript async call to db backed endpoint is , for most common cases, solved. It's extremely reliable and can plug in the particulars. But for tasks where it's not rocket science but are unique and not just application of the tired template it's very hard to wrangle it and it's performance varies.It will often.. ignore the particulars and genericize to a more common similar type of problem. Can this be overcome? Sure but it's a tremendous effort almost akin to hand coding everything yourself in the first place.

> I don't see the problem. Ai doesn't need to get it all right, first time.

Yes it kind of does or it’s not what we were promised/sold. A tool has to work reliably. I don’t want a calculator that’s correct most of the time.


> Yes it kind of does or it’s not what we were promised/sold.

No one ever promised this, and in fact, quite the opposite.

> A tool has to work reliably

They work reliably for what they do. You make a request and it returns text. What you _do_ with that text is a question of engineering and process. That are plenty of unreliable steps in business and industrial processes that people _engineer around_. A huge amount of computer chips are just _thrown away_ because of reliability problems in the factories that make them, for example.

> I don’t want a calculator that’s correct most of the time.

An LLM is not a calculator and if you're trying to use it for that, that is a you problem.


> An LLM is not a calculator and if you're trying to use it for that, that is a you problem.

I’m talking about another tool. An actual calculator. I would never accept a calculator that is correct “most of the time.” I don’t want an LLM that only meets that bar as well.


It's correct, by some definition of "correct", essentially all the time. It always produces text that matches the probable token distributions that it was trained on. You seem to want it to be an oracle. Your job as an engineer that works with them is to figure out how to make what it _actually_ does useful.

That’s just a lot of words to say “if you don’t like the results that’s your problem” which is, quite frankly, ridiculous.

AI gets all these passes while also apparently being this amazing perfect 10x productivity multiplier. If you squint yeah you can see it maybe. But you can’t squint all the time and I won’t pretend I’m not squinting.


> I don’t want a calculator that’s correct most of the time.

What do calculators have to do with this?

The author asked for advice, not a result in Lean. The question has no objectively "correct" answer, only ones that seem better to the person in question.

An AI nor a calculator can read your mind, and both may require refinement of your questions to help solve your task.


So we can add a harness around it? We have decades of experience how to work with faulty sensors, etc… multi-voting, sampling, etc. This will become a part of the harness soon enough . I mean - we can want it to be perfect - sure - but we can deal with imperfect.

> In essence grey rocking itself is a form of defensive manipulation.

Maybe it is defensive but it can also be aggressive. For situations where time is on their side, it can really just be a means of handling the situation - there is no reason to think it is only a defence against aggressors. It is ultimately just a manipulation technique.

Perhaps it's a stretch, but I think the policy that Google has in place, where they are notoriously hard to get a response from, is an example of aggressive grey rocking. They have no interest in hearing your possibly justified complaint - if they make it impossible for you to speak, you have no ability to seek redress. Endless complaint procedures are the same thing. Being put on hold for hours also.


This is legal, no problem. Not monopoly abuse, nothing to see here. Government oversight is fine. The legal framework prevents wholesale financial abuse of the consumer. But in those rare cases where something goes wrong, the perpetrators are brought to justice. /S

... whereas the truth is ...?

That "capitalism" and "consumerism" are abstract concepts that represent pre-existing patterns of human activity that arise from a priori motivations, and are not things that exist as entities unto themselves exerting an influence on anyone's behavior or situational outcomes.

I've no issues with capital or people consuming stuff.

My issue would be with the corporations, which I see as the new estates. Except that they are far larger and far more powerful than what we had two centuries ago. Their perks include: regulatory capture, political access, access to finance. Ie powerful corporations run the infrastructure for capital movement and consumption - in their interests.


So it sounds like rather than objecting to a specific method of coordinating large-scale activity among multiple participants ("corporations"), you're actually objecting to political interventions that favor some parties at the expense of others? I can get on board with that.

It just seems really odd to look at "regulatory capture" and "political access" as problems originating from people engaging in commercial activity in the broader economy, rather than correctly seeing them as originating from insufficient or ineffective safeguards on the concentration and assertion of political power.

> Ie powerful corporations run the infrastructure for capital movement and consumption - in their interests.

Well, no, they don't. Both the capital and the consumption originates from the intentions and motivations of the public at large. The interests of "corporations" -- which are, again, just coordinated patterns of human activity -- are pursued by actually satisfying the motivations of the people around them. You can't get capital without offering a return to your investors; you can't get customers without offering a value proposition that's worth more to them than the price you're charging, etc.


>> Ie powerful corporations run the infrastructure for capital movement and consumption - in their interests.

> Well, no, they don't. Both the capital and the consumption originates from the intentions and motivations of the public at large. The interests of "corporations" -- which are, again, just coordinated patterns of human activity -- are pursued by actually satisfying the motivations of the people around them. You can't get capital without offering a return to your investors; you can't get customers without offering a value proposition that's worth more to them than the price you're charging, etc.

Well, yes, they do. If you use the law to legislate this or that, you are directing the infrastructure. A great example is that people in general don't want phones/cars/fridges that spy on them, they simply want the phone/car/fridge. However, the simple option is not on offer. The regulatory capture provides us with the government mandate that data be captured, so it seems that corporate hands are tied. The consumer cannot find the option they would like.

All this can happen while offering a return to investors. In fact, licensing businesses, creating moats that small companies cannot bridge, ensures that large corporations have an unassailable position. They can investigate the maximum extraction from the consumer, rather than price a product according to cost. Wait till we all start to experience personalised pricing, where each person is offered a different price according to who they are.

Finally, you distinguish between corporate and political interests. I don't. These are the same creature to me. We already live in a fascist environment, where the government + business operate together. Whether you vote red or blue will do nothing for issues where the outcome is predetermined - such as the complete loss of privacy.


> will soon

You realise that in the EU cars have a SIM in, and an emergency button? This is since 2018, see: 112 eCall regulation.


I do realise. That by itself is worrysome. But now car manufacturers tie legallly required functions like the enmergency buttons with bloated platforms of "convenience" functions that users can not disable completely.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think I've read somewhere that it can be a SIM-less phone that abuses emergency call flow in 3GPP. GSM specs have special accomodations for 911/112 type calls that don't require a SIM(that sometimes ironically lead to normal calls working fine and just emergency calls failing).

Yes, you don't (in most countries) need a SIM for 112/911, and even when you do have one, you are allowed to use other carriers for such calls, even when you ordinarily shouldn't be able to roam onto them.

The specs do have that, but I used to work at a major mobile telco which didn't implement that part of the spec. The argument was that people would use emergency calls to test phones without a SIM. That may well have changed, but you can't assume that the spec will always be implemented in the network.

Interesting, in the US this is a regulatory requirement and the decision is not up to the telco.

Why do you believe in it?


> it was just a variation in their judgement rather than a "we want to make money" type of scam.

Sure. I mean, dentists, unlike every other human, are not interested in making money, and would not abuse their position to give incorrect information that is in their benefit. /s


I had a dentist who preferred to see patients each 12 months for a relatively cheap routine check while avoiding doing anything if something was discovered during the check if that could wait. She fixed a minor cavity for me like after 4 years of checks. At some point she stopped accepting new patients because she had too many of them.


That's why I mentioned there was no difference seen with public health dentists. They are on a salary paid by the government and have a huge backlog, they have zero incentive to do more treatment than absolutely necessary.


Parent already covered dentists who are not making money by the widely differing diagoses, because they work for a set salary for non-for-profit government health coverage, and yet still do that.


In public healthcare medicines often make more money by treating more people, treating people longer actually makes them less money.


Plenty of dentists that are on a fixed salary and wouldn't profit from it.


Even if that is the case (which others here have argued against), maximizing the income is not the same as maximizing cavity fillings.


But, climate change!


Climate changeis a reason to produce more not less. Ac isnt energy free


"produce" what exactly?


Literally everything but specifically air conditioners and electricity to run the air conditioners. Better if production is skewed to productive equipment rather than consumer end goods but it isnt strictly necessary. More productive capacity will always do better against change than less.


Will ac fix all the other things that come along? Like, extreme weather, droughts, flooding?


Isn't stalking already illegal? Isn't this stalking? Or facilitating it, at least.


> I'm surprised that (particularly non-US) regulators are not investigating them yet.

Because corporate managed phones are required for all the id crap governance franchises intend to foist on people.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: