HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | vcryan's commentslogin

Yes, I've had direct experience with this. At a gov agency in Boston we hired KPMG because some executive wanted to... and their work was such a joke. Not even week written. At the time I remember thinking we could have gotten a better result for 50 cents... instead of 500k. They submitted totally useless rubbish.

Seems like what they're actually selling is the right to tell your customers and investors that KPMG audited you

I love it. It's a bit slow. Hopefully other providers will pick it up.

Yeah, if you feel like building it - go ahead. News flash: the same affects that helped you build it will help you maintain and operate it.

We are shipping faster. Shipping speed depends on a variety of factors. That said, the ability to generate and validate designs, code, tests, data, performance and security evals, etc is increasing the speed of delivery for many organizations - I'm a consultant and I see it every day.

I also see companies that don't know what they want to build, suffer from toxic culture etc -- they are not faster because their core problems never had much to do with software development.

Sure, there are plenty of developers clinging to the "old way" or using AI in ways that add complexity and slow things down but I don't see this as the dominant group.


Claude vendor lock-in - Claude: not thanks! I prefer you as an easily interchangeable commodity that plays an intermittent role in my broader AI strategy.

I'm not convinced that agent memory is more good than bad.

If there is something an agent needs to know across sessions shouldn't the operator also know and include that information intentionally?

I often catch Claude (and wardon) noting information that is only pertinent to a single season as if it were a forever rule and then I need to tell it to forget.

Maybe the moment we need is to remove this capability?


This is also an example of how someone's personal settings don't belong in a source code repo at all.

I find it pretty annoying when someone commits their harness specific files into a repo - put that stuff under $HOME/.claude/


To be fair, things like AGENTS.md aren't supposed to contain secrets, and are helpful to publish for OSS developers who want agentically-written third-party contributions to follow certain rules.

it depends. Sharing AGENTS.md and skills is a common thing binding all harnesses to project conventions and processes. In my org for example this enforces security review, certain level and type of test coverage, documentation conventions etc.

It's arguable that there is a threshold of quality that matter and US and China are both there already. I guess we'll see. Many of us on here are software engineers and I think we've seen that while Opus 4.7 (I think) was some sort of outlier/miracle, today there are several options to choose from. Depending on the task, the harness, etc Astra/Fable are only better when the work demands their level of capability - which much of software engineering does not.


I built a "software factory" on top of pi agents so I can automate most product dev work


With the ability of models to generate design-system aligned interactive prototypes in HTML/Tailwind... there really isn't a purpose for Figma. I use to love it - now I don't touch it. It doesn't really help my process to have not-HTML to work with. Maybe for mobile apps?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: