I like herdr! But it's more opinionated about how you run your agents - I wanted to make something truly agnostic that works on any harness, any terminal, even if you're using claude-agent-sdk and no terminal at all. It has no opinions about how you launch and run your agents. Pulsar is meant to be a more general purpose message bus between agents, and in the next release will even allow agents on multiple machines to communicate to eachother (using tailscale, no cloud service or anything fishy like that). It's kind of like an agentic mesh where as long as everything is on the same machine, or the same tailscale - they can communicate freely.
Cool project, this is basically a small message broker for agents. I like that there are receipts and a nack back to the inbox. Is “delivered” the end of it, or will there be something like “done”? In message brokers, the consumer acks only after the work is done, so if it crashes halfway through, the broker sends the message again.
I like the thought process here, it gave me a few ideas I will bake into an upcoming release :)
Will have more of a proper lifecycle: queued -> delivered -> seen -> acked -> done - and add durable redelivery if it drops off anywhere.
This is especially useful because Pulsar 2.0 will do multi-machine over tailscale, and can definitely introduce more opportunities for flake with networking.
I'll go through some personal upsides to using eww.
The main utility I see in browsing the web through emacs is the potential to integrate it into your workflow. You can have your code/notes open in one buffer and have the website in another, which is useful for documentation, or an article you're following along, etc.
With gptel, it's easy to highlight part of a blogpost and ask an llm a question about it, or get it to rewrite or annotate the whole page.
An added bonus is that your keybindings for the rest of emacs are also valid here. (Though for that I've recently started using Glide, a firefox fork, and set all of its keymap to match my emacs bindings)
>You can have your code/notes open in one buffer and have the website in another, which is useful for documentation, or an article you're following along, etc.
I’m curious what the difference is between that and having pinned windows in Ubuntu
For example I’ll have sublime text, one terminal, a notepad, and a firefox window with multiple tabs, pinned to the four corners of my desktop
Everything You describe is possible without emacs so I’m genuinely trying to understand the appeal
> Everything You describe is possible without emacs so I’m genuinely trying to understand the appeal
The advantage is that it’s a single program with multiple windows with a shared list of buffers. So you can save transform your layout and save it, manipulate the content without any real boundary, unified bookmarks,…
Your WM can’t access sublime and firefox internals. And the last two can’t talk with each other.
If you don't want to, then you don't want to. Understand you may want things others don't, and vice versa.
Although I don't browse the web with Emacs, I see the utility.
Tell me: How would you select some text, and with a keystroke, send the selected text to yourself via email, with the URL included and the title of the page in the subject line?
> Tell me: How would you select some text, and with a keystroke, send the selected text to yourself via email, with the URL included and the title of the page in the subject line?
I think the takeaway for me is that emacs is for people who get enjoyment out of building their own custom computing environment
The example you describe is something I would rarely do so building a process around it would be inefficient for me but if that’s where people want to spend time then great
> The example you describe is something I would rarely do
There is some tacit knowledge in here that is nearly impossible to convey in words. Your "rarely do" is the thought that subconsciously ignores the principle of least effort; there's an affordability gap, e.g., I am more likely to use a thesaurus simply because I have it built into my text editor, versus someone who has to reach for it in the browser/separate app.
> building a process around it would be inefficient for me
That's what you're missing. Emacs makes it incredibly cheap. It's a Lisp REPL. When you understand what it means in practice, it opens up incredible opportunities for exploratory computing. You're not "building processes around", you're essentially living in one mega-process, a simulation, a digital universe where you are a god, commanding change at will. Right now, as I'm typing this very comment, I noticed a tiny gap in the way how I'm using LLMs, so I'm changing this stuff on the fly, with the agent running things in the adjacent buffer while I'm finishing this comment. The crazy thing is that it doesn't have to compile, restart, ask me to pause typing, etc. It's applying changes to my editor live. By the time I finish typing the comment, it will probably have already built this feature, tested it out, and it will be ready for me to use, instantly.
> There is some tacit knowledge in here that is nearly impossible to convey in words. Your "rarely do" is the thought that subconsciously ignores the principle of least effort; there's an affordability gap, e.g., I am more likely to use a thesaurus simply because I have it built into my text editor, versus someone who has to reach for it in the browser/separate app.
Indeed, this describes it better than anything else possibly could.
I've been carrying a Leatherman around for almost a decade. My friends make fun of me for it, and when I tell them what I do with it on a weekly basis, they always say they wouldn't need to do those things.
Yeah, I didn't either. Until it was trivial to do it because I happened to have it on me all the time.
It's like explaining to someone over 20 years ago why you "need" a camera or GPS in your phone. They wouldn't get it. Especially not if you tell them it costs $700+ "I already have a digital camera and who needs a GPS outside the car?"
> I think the takeaway for me is that emacs is for people who get enjoyment out of building their own custom computing environment
For long time users, that's the whole point of Emacs.
> The example you describe is something I would rarely do
I used to do it at work all the time (not with Emacs, but with AutoHotKey). Find a long article I'd really like to read, but don't want to waste time at work. With a keystroke, I'd quickly send the email to me with the URL etc.
> But why would I want them to as the default interaction?
Some find it useful. One can write code in vim or sublime, the only differences are the specific actions to get it done and the user experience. People will lean towards one another, not for the capability to write code, but for how it’s done.
So what I’m trying to showcase is not the capability, but the Emacs ways of getting it done. You can also implement something with a WM setup or tmux (with w3m). But it’s a different feel and effort, so people like ones and dislike the others.
I once wanted to find all the URLs posted within the HN thread. It's easy, but then you also have to filter the HN's own urls. In Emacs is a one liner that gives you a picker with the way to copy any url, preview it, open it in the browser or in Emacs. The list is plain text, you can stick the whole thing into your notes, share it, etc. I then bound the command to a key. Now I can do it with a keypress. Turns out it works also for Reddit as well. Without Emacs I'd probably will have to write a specialized script that would be wonky, error-prone and obsoleted in weeks.
> I’m curious what the difference is between that and having pinned windows in Ubuntu
The difference is the text consumption. Can you easily retrieve any text you're seeing on the screen into your editor?
Inserting any piece of text I see on the screen into my notes? A couple of keystrokes. I can grab text in any form, even if it's a frame in a YT video - I'd just select the area, snapshot it - Emacs OCRs the text out of it, which takes milliseconds. I fully control the playback of said video directly from my editor - rewind, pause, mute, speed up, extract transcript, etc. It is enormously liberating and empowering.
I have complete and utter control over text - I can send a query to an LLM in the middle of typing this very comment, without ever missing a beat. I can ask for anything - fact-check it, spell check it, reword it, explain it, give me different variations of the same sentence. I can replace part of it with diffing in-place. I can even start changing the behavior of Emacs itself, right there on the spot.
I can directly grab any part of the log of a process running in the terminal. Grep through it, semantically search through it with an LLM, whatever. Similarly, I can directly grab a piece of any text in Emacs and send it over to another app, e.g., as a command to run in the terminal.
> Everything You describe is possible without emacs
Everything is possible with Turing-complete languages, but Turing-completeness is a trap. It's all about affordability. What Emacs grants as a Lisp-REPL loop with a built-in text editor is lowering that affordability bar to the lowest imaginable minimum.
Have you ever thought: "What if I could change the 'Open File' dialog in Sublime so I can browse GitHub repos directly instead of folders and files?" This kind of thinking has probably never occurred to you - for an Emacs user, that is some prosaic, just-another-Wednesday kind of thought.¹
By the way fishing that url out of my browser history took a keystroke - of course Emacs can search through my browser history too - https://github.com/agzam/browser-hist.el
I think the takeaway for me is that emacs is for people who get enjoyment out of building their own custom computing environment
The example you describe is something I would rarely do so building a process around it would be inefficient for me but if that’s where people want to spend time then great
It's just a drop in a vast ocean of things. Your close-minded thinking just sees one thing and makes generalized assumptions.
> where people want to spend time
You're reading it completely backwards. This is the thing that I never understood about the majority of programmers. For whatever reason they just readily accept the status quo. Here's a typical example:
So often do I feel like rolling my eyes whenever I pair with my colleagues - I'd do something trivial, like fetching a list of PRs related to a specific ticket number at the cursor. They'd be like "whoa, that's cool", and then never do anything about it - they stick to their "learned helplessness" paradigm - copy the ticket number, switch to browser, navigate to Jira, pass through SSO, look around for the phone just to push the button, paste the ticket number, find the linked PRs, etc. The other teammate watching all that may say something like: "you could do it faster directly on GitHub"... And here I am - pressing a key, voila - the list. Why the heck don't they do anything about it, I just don't get it. Trained engineers, they spend years dealing with cranky software, why in the world are they unwilling to do anything about these seemingly small yet everyday annoyances? Why do so many programmers treat software as if it's magic? And I think I know the answer: because the software you use shapes your affordances. If there's no downloadable get-me-list-of-prs-for-a-jira-ticket VSCode extension and no simple way to build it, it would never occur to them to even get annoyed. In Emacs, I can write a picker in a scratch buffer by hand and it would take me minutes. Today with LLMs, I can just spend fifteen seconds, not even typing, speaking my thoughts and it goes to build it, run a sequence of e2e tests and hand it to me on the spot.
Sure, go ahead, talk about time. Make me chuckle. The irony is that the time you spend using a Lisp-based system never feels wasted; it only gets better, it has a compounding effect. It's the time you waste convincing skeptics that it is in fact enormously pragmatic and time-saving that feels like tilting at windmills. Why am I even still talking to you here, if it was clear from the beginning that you didn't in fact have good-will curiosity, only simply wanted to find evidence for your already settled and stiffened
mind.
You think people choose and stay with Emacs, because their parents baptize them into it? It's a hands-down the best known system to deal with text of any kind. It is not a text-editor, text-processor, IDE or coding tool. It's an effing text orchestrator. It is capable of handling multitude kinds of text-related tasks in anything in its computational vicinity - local and remote computers, apps, and services. And programming is all about text. That is the essence that every computer user has to conquer first and foremost; everything else is secondary.
> The difference is the text consumption. Can you easily retrieve any text you're seeing on the screen into your editor?
> Inserting any piece of text I see on the screen into my notes? A couple of keystrokes. I can grab text in any form, even if it's a frame in a YT video - I'd just select the area, snapshot it - Emacs OCRs the text out of it, which takes milliseconds.
Yes, Mac does this natively/automatically with screenshots. I'd be surprised if I've ever used/needed OCR more than a half-dozen times. Far more often it just gets minorly in the way when I want to copy-paste the image itself.
> I have complete and utter control over text - I can send a query to an LLM in the middle of typing this very comment, without ever missing a beat. I can ask for anything - fact-check it, spell check it, reword it, explain it, give me different variations of the same sentence.
Mac natively offers AI writing tools context menu options in every app for text selections. Right click -> search effectively does the same thing (every search engine has AI functionality featured prominently by default). I believe most browsers also offer straight-to-AI equivalents as well.
> Similarly, I can directly grab a piece of any text in Emacs and send it over to another app, e.g., as a command to run in the terminal.
I can do this natively and trivially on my Mac in every single app without having to learn a bizarre alternate universe of awkward, inconvenient hotkeys.
> What if I could change the 'Open File' dialog in Sublime so I can browse GitHub repos directly instead of folders and files?"
My IDE has featured this prominently as a native option for approximately forever.
> What Emacs grants as a Lisp-REPL loop with a built-in text editor is lowering that affordability bar to the lowest imaginable minimum.
It's literally not affordable to spend my time inefficiently re-inventing the wheel on every common UI/UX task in a usually fundamentally limited and broken way. I need an IDE where it's not a major source of controversy as to whether it's possible to configure basic auto-complete.
Having to install a random third-party extension to use a basic browser feature is a bug, not a feature.
...I'm not sure what I'm trying to accomplish by poking these holes. By all means, enjoy using emacs. It's just...strange to me that an emacs user would believe these are selling points when in fact having to configure them myself is a major downgrade from just using the native features in commonly used software.
I'm attempting to describe to you the joy of skiing, and you're responding with "I don't get the point of dragging my ass all the way to the top of the mountain just to slide down on a piece of wood..."
You will never see the appeal until you give it a heartfelt try yourself; there's too much tacit knowledge that is not easily describable in a few short paragraphs.
You're making it sound as if all the things you're talking about are unknown to me. I wasn't born into Emacs, and I didn't find it in my college years and just decided never to leave. I've been staring at computer screens for decades and have been using Emacs for only a fraction of that time. The only difference between you and me is that I have now seen both sides, I'm intimately familiar with your worldview, and I know the reasons why that side sucks. I'm not saying the Emacs-side is perfect and that there are zero tradeoffs to consider, no.
Lisp and Lisp-based systems have been an impossible sell for a long time, and mostly for emotional rather than practical reasons. "Emacs user" sounds like a lifestyle, and some people outright avoid it just so they don't have to join the tribe.
Those who genuinely try to evaluate the practical side out of curiosity pick some random features or one demo and typically remain unconvinced. I have never heard anyone say "I watched this video/read an article and I decided to try Emacs", because the value of Emacs does not live in any single feature. It lives in how the features compose, and composition is invisible in a demo.
Even using Emacs for a few weeks may not help; the value builds up over time. Each piece on its own looks, sounds and feels unimpressive. Nobody is ever persuaded by a sum they have to imagine. There's no frame that I can use for you to even listen to me; you don't have one. It's very much aligned with Graham's Blub paradox - from inside a less flexible tool, a more flexible one looks like the same thing with weird extras. You only see the difference by looking back from the more flexible side. Most people have never experienced an environment they could change while it runs, so they have nothing to compare it to. My enthusiasm reads to you as sunk-cost bias, even though it clearly isn't. I would happily switch away from Emacs whenever a clearly better alternative comes around. Alas, it just doesn't exist.
> in fact having to configure them myself
Yesterday, I would've said: "Oh sweet summer child, do you really believe you don't configure the 'commonly used software'? You're configuring your own brain and habits to match that software instead..."
But today, that's not even an argument. You can just install Emacs and ask a good model to build you a solution to a problem and then observe and evaluate the workflow differences, easily. Then it opens up a whole world of possibilities where the only limit is your imagination.
"Right-click -> search effectively" is one thing, but when you have a system where you can bind it to a key, to something more complex than a simple right-click, to a foot pedal, to a gesture, to a voice command, to a "Fus Ro Dah" Skyrim call - you just laugh at your own younger, naive self for being so dismissive without even knowing what the hell you were talking about back then.
You're mistakenly thinking I'm offering a replacement for all the tools you already know and use.
> to use a basic browser feature
You didn't even check what it does. It is in fact piggy-backing on the browser feature, it's not replacing it, it is rather enhancing it ten-fold. Emacs doesn't have to replace existing things in your toolbelt. It can act like a glue, like an orchestrator.
I'm very much a fan of building custom solutions to my workflows and have many shell scripts/aliases/userscripts for such purposes. Emacs is just a wildly inconvenient and inefficient way to do so for me as somebody who needs software features that actually work, like autocomplete, syntax highlighting, and semantic refactoring.
> Emacs is just a wildly inconvenient and inefficient way
Hahaha... So you think thousands of people using it are stuck in it because they hate themselves and I just love inconvenience and inefficiency? What odd masochists they are, these weirdos with zero skill of bashscripting. Total losers.
The autocomplete I have in Emacs is, btw., simply amazing; it's the best I've ever had, it's non-intrusive, and actually enormously helpful in practice. The completion previews sometimes feel like some blackmagicfuckery. I seriously doubt you even remotely have any idea of what you're talking about.
I too have amazing autocomplete and it didn't even require installing a random collection of third party packages that don't work together properly, or being forced to learn a batshit insane list of hotkeys for basic functionality.
What I finally figured out from this thread (I’m glad I started) is that the things you argue are…
“batshit insane list of hotkeys”
..Is exactly the part that the emacs user likes working on, they get exited and look forward to adding those configs because it’s like world building that they get to live inside and configure to be their full interaction layer with computers
You have to think about it more like, they like being cypher in their own personally built text based matrix
The reason it is offputting is that they never describe it like that. They do what you see; which is describe all the capabilities and reasons they like using it, as though it needs to be compared to other tools, rather than describing what it feels like as an eMacs user.
That is a great observation, thanks for sharing. I do see the appeal when you put it that way; it's reminiscent of a bike commuter sharing tips about what rain gain to wear which sounds ridiculous to a car commuter who isn't bought into the idea that biking is enjoyable and worthwhile for its own sake, including the challenges of creatively solving unique self-imposed problems.
> Huang had once found a soup vendor in Japan, he said, with a long line of customers. He joined the line, and after a long wait, enjoyed one of the best bowls of soup he’d ever had. When he asked for another serving, the soup-seller told him no—he had too many customers waiting and not enough soup for all of them.
> “He’s a better businessperson than all of you,” Huang told the cloud computing CEOs. The soup-man doesn’t sell out all his inventory to one or two customers, but instead keeps prices high and his customer base diverse, the CEO said.
How did you get it to produce outputs that aren't obviously AI? I tried multiple times to get it to stop putting subheadings under every header in monospace fonts, but even when I explicitly asked it not to and even when the design style never featured such elements it kept putting them in.
1. Have one agent build it and then another check(Usually the agent that checks is a bigger model or with more effort)
2. Make it deterministic, make sure you have a list of accepted fonts based on your brand guidelines. Have claude create a script that checks what fonts are used and if they follow the list, if not send it back to be redone, similar thing can be done to check things like header followed by a subheader(I usually have it create designs in html so it is a simple check of is there a h3 following say a h2)
I had the same kneejerk reaction to the title, but reading the article reveals that it's instead an investigation into how despite clicking the reject button, some advertising tags have already fired/will fire the next time the site is loaded, not honoring the user's choice. It's not yet another complaint about having to see banners.
I think what he said was that 10 months of inference paid for the hardware it runs on (which may have a lifetime of a few years). I don't think he mentioned training/development cost.
Consumer get the cheaper energy, while industry normally get the twice as expensive energy.
But for AI/Datacenters, there is a exception and they get the cheaper consumer level energy.
You need to take in account that the way China taxes is not the same as here in the West. And a lot more is put on the local governments regarding generating their own revenue (why there was so much building in China because those projects funded local government). A bit of a side topic lol. Its not so simple as they are making a loss on something because how its structured.
AI gets the cheaper tariffs then the rest of the industry, that is a fact. They simply have less energy profits on the AI energy. Now if you consider that subsidized or not, ... in both cases China is still making a profit.
What is overlooked is the massive amount of energy generation that China has and still keeps expanding. And that is a direct reflection upon why the prices for industry and consumers are so cheap. This buildout ironically had nothing to do with AI but was more about lower energy = cheaper industry production ... and a lot of buildout was also to build more independence from energy imports. They are not just throwing solar and wind turbines around like candy, the amount of reactors constructed and still under construction, ...
> China currently has 36 to 38 nuclear reactors under construction, maintaining the largest nuclear buildout in the world and accounting for roughly half of all global nuclear plant construction
So yea ... The AI in the west have a issue because it really does not matter if you cut China from Nvidia GPUs or advanced nodes, they compensate on the power level.
Edit: And a little extra, the irony is here in the West building nuclear is expensive as hell because we barely do one or two at the time. With a lot of lost expertise. China doing tons of them non-stop cuts down on the costs a lot.
I'm not sure how much you pay in USA. But I live in Beijing, where the residential electricity price is about 0.5 RMB per kWh, roughly 0.0749 USD.
China's electricity pricing involves cross-subsidies. Residential and agricultural users pay the lowest rates, which are generally below the cost of supply. Commercial and industrial users pay more and contribute the most of grid revenue.
Prices vary by region: commercial electricity can approach 1 RMB (0.15USD) in Beijing, but the national average is about 0.67 RMB (0.1USD), while industrial electricity averages around 0.63 RMB nationally.
In my state in the US, they started differentiating between a "supply" rate, as in who generated your electricity, versus a "delivery" rate, or who delivered the electricity. That way they can market the supply rates to you and charge you on delivery additionally.
That sounds a little complicated, do the two parts actually adjust dynamically?
In China, end users pay a single bundled retail electricity price that already includes the full cost of both generation and delivery. The State Grid company purchasing electricity from generators and settling with them centrally.
Electricity prices are also government-regulated, and any change must go through public notice and approval.
At similar prices and 1/4th or whatever the average salary, meaning the average person has to use a lot less energy, or spend a larger % of their budget on it
It's not particularly surprising. China wants people to use electricity. Germany wants people to use gas/oil. The rate of electrification in respective country reflects that preference.
I don't think that the steering effect (away from electricity) on private people is intended. It's intended to keep industry in the country. Makes sense, but still, it feels unfair as a private person.
Would that be due to the size of the models from DeepSeek or perhaps only for their distilled models? If it's for general purpose models that would crash the valuation of Anthropic and OpenAI, both who are struggling with profitabilitet to say the least.
Who said they need to distill anything? Deepseek is the most popular chinese model getting trillions of input tokens a day that have no ZDR availability. They specifically tell you that part of the deal is that they get your data to use however they want (atleast they're honest).
This idea that Deepseek needed to distil their way to success is nonsense. Its a great narrative for OpenAI and Anthropic to spread because Americans have been brainwashed for two decades into dealing with their own inadequacies by blaming things on scary asians stealing things.
In reality China is outworking and lapping most American companies. They produce 10 EEs to every 1 America produces. They are simply harder workers.
The West is cooked because we're too lazy to work hard and we'd rather make up stories about boogeyman who are stealing from us. The only thing we're good at now is killing people who economically challenge us.
DeepSeek's API used to (does still?) route your requests directly to Claude Fable[1]. Those were provably Claude Fable's responses being returned by the DeepSeek API. This was months after Anthropic accused them of distillation of Claude at scale[2].
Them provably distilling after being accused of distilling strongly indicates that... that's what they do. To spin a story of them not doing that (because why would they, with their superior talent and all) doesn't seem very reality conform.
The models are impressive enough as is (considering resource constraints and difference in CapEx) despite being heavily distilled from western frontier models. No need to pretend that they're not.
You really cited a tech politics person, and Anthropic... The poltical AI people are the exact type of cope distributors I complained about above.
I think the more reasonable explanation is this is totally made up. Notice how they use examples concerning "cyber and bio" notice how the examples are politically loaded subjects that are hyper relevant to proposed AI dangers and why we need to protect western AI companies with anti-competitive regulations?
Oh no!!! The scary asians are distilling our models, but they only want the scary things!!! They want to hurt you!! We better stop the scary asians!!!
> I think the more reasonable explanation is this is totally made up.
Based on what? None of the accused companies have ever denied Anthropic's accusations. And here you are confidently claiming it all to be made it. How much of a reputational hit to one's honesty do you think it carries to completely fabricate someone doing something, when they can just publicly disagree and disprove you? First thing DeepSeek, Moonshot, etc. would do if they hadn't would be to make a press statement calling out Anthropic for their lies.
DeepSeek routing to Fable was corroborated by many independent sources... since... everyone was able to just try it out and see it for themselves.
> Oh no!!! The scary asians are distilling our models, but they only want the scary things!!!
The straw man you're mocking doesn't exist. Non-Chinese labs are also distilling frontier models of their competitors. Elon testified in court that Grok was trained on ChatGPT outputs. And why would they not? It produces objectively better models.
Despite being "corroborated by independent sources," it was impossible - because deepseek has a higher TPS, can return logits and reveals thinking. Distillation happens asynchronously.
DeepSeek's Anthropic compatible endpoint doesn't return logits. The accusation is that requests to api.deepseek.com/anthropic coming from Claude Code or OpenCode just replayed Claude's responses sometimes. The clients would have just happily consumed the responses, as they were already meant to be Anthropic compatible. And yeah, TPS and the response-distribution were incredibly different between DeepSeek and Claude models, which is exactly why people noticed.
Multi-turn conversations have much more entropy than one-shot responses, making it more useful to do synchronous distillation.
So people were getting deepseek responses with long waits and no thinking traces? That would be easy to prove, we'd get more than just claims from interested entities.
When did I say everything is a grand conspiracy? This whole thing where centrists normies just call anyone who believes something outside their center comfort zone a conspiracy theorist is mega obnoxious.
You need better media literacy.
You cant just make up a reality where none of these companies have denied distillation.
The scary asians are going to get you, watch out! Your government is going to eventually tell you that we need kill a bunch of them too because they're so scary. Probably soonish. You're going to fall for it because you believe anything you're told.
You are postulating an organised psyop, where OpenAI and Anthropic are publicly lying about Chinese labs to paint an image of, in your words: "Oh no!!! The scary asians are distilling our models, but they only want the scary things!!!"
These lies are then further supported publicly my western media, random people on twitter, western governments, etc., all to paint China as an evil force that must be united against. Again, in your words "Your government is going to eventually tell you that we need kill a bunch of them too because they're so scary."
And you have dozens of independent parties pushing that same lie to that end and for that purpose? Sure, that's what the New York Times and CNBC must deeply want too. When CNBC writes that they've reached out for comments to the accused companies, but received no responses, they must be lying as well?
It shouldn't be hard for you to demonstrate DeepSeek denying it. Please, go ahead, link to a statement. China's foreign ministry has denied Chinese labs distilling, and, in the same statement accused US labs of distilling from Chinese models. Now that's a very trustworthy claim.
I call it a conspiracy theory because it's a conspiracy theory. Some conspiracies are true, but this one is not. Distilling is both trivially simple and produces objectively better models. Plenty of evidence points to that practice. But in your mind the labs in China are just morally too upstanding in engage in such lowly tactics to create better models, despite the evidence. And it's convenient that the evidence can be explained away by claiming it to be a psyop to paint Chinese as evil.
Deepseek Harness lets you opt out of your data being used for training. Perhaps they're lying, but if so I'd have expected someone to point it out and win internet points for exposing false promises. I leave mine opted in since I don't have PII to worry about.
reply