HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | tw600040's commentslogin

I would bet we are missing some critical piece of information. The pieces that have been revealed so far don't add up.

His personal thing is for him to deal with. What we need more clarity on is -

1. Did the circular financing involve some accounting shenanigans 2. Were export laws knowingly broken

Everything else is a distraction..


The GPU pricing allegations are just chaff and flare to attempt to rally the court of public opinion against him. Though outrageous, it's no more outrageous than a dozen deals that are made daily, and is dwarfed by things the public aren't concerned with, like incestuous investment between all the major AI players that's created an economic house of cards. Consumer GPU prices affect us personally, however, and thus that story was dropped in the days after Huang was ousted to attempt to make the coup stick.

Given the moral failings (including numerous, far more egregious affairs) of basically every public and political figure (many of those failings involving actual loss of human life, at scale) there's no reason why Huang MUST be removed because of affairs.


It would most likely be the export control laws being broken, no?

Why did he resign then?

1. Circular financing isn't as big of a deal as the media make it out to be. It's a tiny percentage of Nvidia's total revenue and it's strategic.

2. Department of Justice and Department of Commerce released a statement on Alice Huang and Nvidia. It did not say Nvidia broke any laws or did not comply. In fact, Nvidia stopped sales to Megaspeed in 2025, as soon as the US started investigating.

https://www.commerce.gov/news/press-releases/2026/11/joint-s...


I don't understand how is circular financing different from an equipment manufacturer selling a machine to a factory on credit

Isn't that super common?

I remember that was like a textbook example in econ when learning about balance sheets


Of course it's the same. It's just on a larger scale. Business has been done on credit since the beginning of time.

Selling on credit is fine as long as the underlying demand is real. And, in this case, it appears to be real.


You are 100% right the pieces don't add up. In addition to what you said, did the US government put their foot on the scales? Did the board have any ulterior motives?

I would think the US government didnt put their foot on the scales given the disposition of the President and Commerce department, but if they did it would help explain the boards decision.


You do understand the reasons right? iCloud, iMessages etc are an interplay of software in your device, software in cloud and some networking. They have to work together. A jailbroken phone can have a tinkered iMessage app. Supporting tinkered / unsupported versions is more overhead / possible security risk. Why would you expect them to take on that?


I agree with your point, though I can easily modify ~/Library/Messages/Attachments or ~/Library/Containers/com.apple.MobileSMS/Data on macOS, which is a platform similarly secure to an iPhone when you take sandboxing, sip, etc. into account. So Apple already supports macOS, which can be tinkered, no? I guess the argument is that by locking down iOS, a platform which was never open, they just never needed to handle that class of security risks which are introduced when customers have more freedom.

I did actually discover a bug in iOS (related to photos which have failed to sync to icloud for the past four years) by investigating why there were over 23k empty folders in ~/Library/Containers/com.apple.photos.ImageConversionService/Data/tmp/, fwiw.


You're right, but I could see Apple acting on iOS alone, just because of scale.

There are some orders of magnitude more iOS/iPadOS devices than macOS devices.

There's a bunch of ways we could debate ourselves about things Apple would or wouldn't do, but at the end of the day, Apple is going to do whatever is in it's best interest.


My computer is jailbroken, I have sip disabled yet icloud and imessage work. So what makes my computer different from my phone?


Who bears the security risk? The user.

The only security risk for apple is a job security risk if the ecosystem lock-in is eroded.


The risk to Apple is everyone else’s trust being eroded by having their ecosystem compromised. Why risk it?


It does not make sense for someone to lose faith in apple because someone else was able to run a modified imessage app.

For apple to entertain this idea is to create more problems for themselves in the long run.

If you understand this from my perspective, which is that these actions are motivated by a desire for more control. It begins to make more sense. If you can benefit from increased control, then these unreasonable expectations of security against your customers (held by other customers) are a desirable problem to have as opposed to an increasing burden.

Imagine the same being said of a car manufacturer. "We need to install security measures in place to prevent you from modifiying your car because other people may see that modified versions of our cars exist and that tarnishes our brand somehow".

As long there is no reason to allow companies to exert this control over consumers, it just allows the manufacturer to enforce a total monopoly on the post-market.


People are giving Meta access to their emails, messages and calendars and other apps? Are they out of their mind or what am I missing?


People are both lazy and curious. Meta is an attention grabbing juggernaut. Put the two together and plenty of people will experiment with giving Meta / Muse access to more of their digital lives.

It's scary to think how the hyperscalers will continue to get more and more access into everyones tools and lives under the guise of "AI assistant".


They also give them to Google in Gmail


Gmail is 1 part of the puzzle. A big part but still one part. But when you give something access to your email, calendar, iMessage, browser, passkeys of other apps, location it can autocomplete the missing parts and can pretty much complete the jigsaw.


I would never run Grok Bot or Muse with any sort of authentication.

I did try booking a flight with Muse and it worked surprisingly well. But I never used it after.


definitely not by someone asking it about circuit schematics


is it not?


Obviously it is. Just like when you give a monkey a camera and it takes a selfie, the photo is obviously yours. But the legal system doesn't care about obviousness.


Because chatGPT can get away with listening to you all the time, but if Siri does that without it being explicitly prompted it will be a class action


Well Apple is building a slew of AI voice devices, Open AI is too and purportedly so is Space X creating an AI focused phone.

We'll see if consumers embrace it, but ive been using chatGPT's voice conversation tech since Sept 2023 especially while driving to get things done. For me it feels like the next natural UX Internet usage paradigm.


Someone who won't have that $433 has no business even thinking about a 1200$ phone in the first place


you overestimate the financial health of most Americans.

most people live on credit cards as bridge finance between paychecks. when I mean most people - I mean 50% of the population.


The median US household has a net worth of $200,000. Even a 50th percentile US household is very wealthy by global standards.

Credit card statistics are heavily manipulated because it's easy to make them sound terrible. I don't know which factoid specifically you're referring to, but the studies about "X percent of Americans couldn't handle an emergency expense without putting it on a credit card" often use tricks like including anyone who would pay by credit card if they could. I remember reading some of these studies and realizing that I would have been included in the statistic because I prefer to use a credit card where I can, even though I pay it off before interest accrues.


Net worth or net income? Being 40yo with only 200k of worth between two when you’re halfway through your working life and have had 10y of appreciation of assets isn’t very much to go forward with.


> The median US household has a net worth of $200,000.

Which is primarily the market value of the home they live in. They can’t pay a bill with it.

The median American household has $8000 of liquid cash in all of their cash accounts combined.


> The median American household has $8000 of liquid cash in all of their cash accounts combined.

That’s a lot of liquid cash. It reinforces the idea that the median American household has an unparalleled amount of money to burn on whatever.


That includes savings. The median checking account is $2800. People can burn from that $8000 but it’ll be at the expense of being able to handle an unexpected emergency expense, or a goal they’re saving up for.

And this is the median, which means that half of US households have less than this. Which is quite a lot of people who still use phones.


I’d assume that net worth is mostly housing and/or retirement accounts, and thus not really available to pay off credit cards.


>Even a 50th percentile US household is very wealthy by global standards.

Not by purchasing power. We're also in a weird position compared to our "peers" in that most of them have relatively easy access to much less wealthy neighbors via over-land transit or a cheap plane ride, whereas we have to travel quite a distance or pay for extremely expensive plane tickets. Which means that we're stuck here with what a USD buys in the US, instead of being able to hop over to someplace else where a dollar goes further. We also work more than our peers, so our per-hour earnings take a hit compared to theirs.

I could go on. The trick is trying to gaslight Americans into second-guessing the economic pain they've increasingly felt over the past few decades. The 50th percentile American household lives worse than the 50th percentile household of quite a few less-wealthy countries.


averages strike again.

Median wealth in the U.S just around $100k - see Wikipedia & other databases.

how many people own houses ? & for those people that own houses - average equity in those houses is less than 45%.

ain't no factoid - but lived reality of most people. maybe on the coasts where techies and finance bros live - but the rest of america is facing a bleak financial reality.


> averages strike again.

My comment said "median" explicitly

The number was for household wealth. I think you're looking at individual wealth, which would naturally be lower because it's spread across more people.

Source: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scf/dataviz/scf/table...

The average (mean) is closer to $1 million per family, but that's not a useful number.


actually per UBS [0]: Median Wealth in the US is $68K. Almost neck in neck with median income.

[0]: https://www.ubs.com/global/en/media/display-page-ndp/en-2026...


>when I mean most people - I mean 50% of the population.

That's not really applicable because:

1. the study is for an "unexpected" expense. This you can see from 2 years away

2. The wording in the study was something along the lines of "would have to dip into savings", not that they literally don't have any money for it. The fed's survey of consumer finances shows the median household has between 7-13k (depending whether you're counting median income or median wealth) in their checking accounts

https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scf/dataviz/scf/chart...


Not sure what you are trying to argue.

Should people be more financially responsible? Yes

Are they today? No

In a rational world payday loans, predatory auto loans, BNPL, perpetually rolling credit card debt etc would not need to exist. Yet these sectors are rapidly growing and companies in it are thriving.


>Not sure what you are trying to argue.

I'm saying the specific claim of "most people live on credit cards as bridge finance between paychecks. when I mean most people - I mean 50% of the population" is false.


I think what he means is that if you can't swallow $433 on one payment, it is more likely you can't support and accumulate monthly subscriptions either and you should look at sub $200 smartphones.

It is not like having a $1200 flagship smartphone is a requirement to earn a living like, say, having a mean of transportation is to many people not living close to their workplace. There is nothing one do in a flagship that you can't do - albeit maybe with less quality or slower - than a lower end one. All allows to make and receive calls, use messaging, have a browser, apps.

To be honest, I am clumsy and break stuff easily so I have never spent more than $200 on a smartphone, my current one is a pixel 6a running grapheneos that I bought for 180€ 2.5 years ago. It makes very good photos actually and is fast enough for everything I do. I understand people can want something nicer but it is not a need.


There are phones that cost a lot less though. 50% of Americans being unable to afford iPhones doesn't mean they should just lease them. People need to stop associating so much personal sense of worth with their handheld computer.

- written on my S10


For many that is their only computer in that context having a smartphone definitely isn’t a bad thing. What’s bad is not saving up to buy it. Do not buy it on credit if you don’t have to, however, it must be said that if you get an iPhone, it does have better resale value (all Apple computers, and iPads) have a longer lifespan software wise, probably more than most other smartphones, which comes back to the question why are you renting or leasing? Just buy it on time with minimum interest upfront if you absolutely must buy it? Owner of an 11 Pro iPhone from 2019. With one or two years of Apple software support left?


Crazy you had such a pertinent message written on your S10.


> People need to stop associating so much personal sense of worth with their handheld computer.

This might be the funniest thing I’ve ever read on this nerd website.


A lot of people buy phones as conventional status symbols rather than for nerd points. My massive generalisation is hn values doing something interesting with the hardware.


Exactly. I'm talking about the green bubble vs blue bubble social nonsense that causes people to spend >$1k on a device that they use for talk, text, and basic media functions. It's essentially jewelry, nothing to do with nerddom.


And those people never get to a point where they save anything, renting, leasing, pay as you go, credit cards, reverse mortgages are a losing game the house always wins.


Have you met…America?


wait till you see what people do with car payments


Selling my car that I fully owned in favor of a nice bicycle and an e-scooter was one of my best financial decisions in the last few years.

I don't have to deal with insurance, parking (if parking is free by you, it shouldn't be), maintenance (I work on them myself, I just pay for cheap parts), and fuel is effectively free. That's all on top of the car payment for people who haven't paid off their car.


Genuinely wish I had done so when I lost my job at the beginning of the pandemic. I've dumped so much money into a vehicle that's falling apart, which I've driven probably less than 25k miles since. If you can't justify car ownership with your income, they're a money pit.


My car is fully owned and justified by my commute taking 3x longer by bus. Time saved is as important a measure as miles driven.


So was mine, but time saved driving didn't justify the amount of maintenance I would have had to do on my car/sanity with 5 min in car + 2 hours on a coach vs 50 minutes fighting interstate traffic + paying for parking.


We should ask some game theorists why the busses are so slow :-)


You do understand that unless you live in a relatively warm metropolis this is literally not an option right?


There are real infrastructural reasons it's harder to do in North America compared to Europe, but that's not it.

Biking is relatively popular and definitely feasible within ten km or so from most city or town cores here in Scandinavia, not just the metropolises.


You need to travel more. Plenty of people in Canadian cities rely on public transport just fine.


The Netherlands would like to have a talk with you.


Tell me you’ve never slipped on ice riding a bike in Europe in the winter without telling me you’ve never slipped on ice riding a bike in Europe in the winter.


Europe has a concept novel to most Americans which is known as public transport.


I’ve lived in Europe for 18 years.

People bike all winter in Germany and the Netherlands.


You do understand that coats exist, right? I live in New England. I bought a heated jacket for less than the price of two months of parking.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: