HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | trvz's commentslogin

Especially when their product only exists due to the biggest intellectual property theft ever. They already have shown their nature.

Yeah, but that gets into the arguent as to whether IP is philosophically good and useful in the digital age where the marginal cost of replication is virtually zero.

That's not exactly the question, because copyright is still being enforced against most people while being mostly waived for just a few companies.

It seems that at the least this helps everyone questions a lot of things about the system as it stands because any system ultimately falls into power law trap and equitability only sounds good in theory

The cheapness of replication is the reason IP was invented in the first place.

But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication, because a broader scope would amount to intellectual and cultural ossification.

IP does not account for cheap generation.


> But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication

Patents are old too. In both cases it's meant to be a practical system to incentivize publication of inventions and original works (people often forget that a fundamental requirement to getting a patent is that you must publicly document exactly how your invention works) but you could definitely argue that that bargain has broken down and nobody wants to publish original content anymore.

> IP does not account for cheap generation.

Ya I guess that's probably what GP meant.


I think IP only makes sense if the cost of replication is low.

More to the point I really dislike it when corporate freedoms are placed above personal freedoms.


Defending IP in these circles would for years get you downvoted to oblivion. Pirate sites and projects have long been heroes around here.

This goes way back before HN, way back to the roots of hacker culture. There’s always been a skepticism of IP.

Until AI. Then it flips 180 and IP is good now.

I do kind of agree with the criticism. AI models are huge scale piracy. That’s why I personally don’t believe models trained this way should be copyrightable and I have doubts about whether access to them should be sold for a profit without sharing them. Which means I do have doubts about the ethical legitimacy of the whole for profit frontier lab industry. We basically just saw something a million times larger than Napster IPO.

My point is really just about the 180 on IP, and how it reveals that the pro piracy position was never a principled one. It was just “I like free stuff so piracy good.”


But it's about the scale and the power imbalance. Few pirates enjoying something for their own entertainment doesn't really make a big dent in the total numbers; authors could still become successful, sites could still generate some revenue. Now, a massive corporation vacuuming all knowledge and media for their own benefit that they will charge you to access, per token? Google taking away site traffic with their clanker, leaving your site dry?

And yes, the big issue is that individuals would sometimes get prosecuted and get hit with fines beyond what they can earn in a lifetime, while no one is even trying to close down these companies.

I would just consider putting that argument behind IP and copyright on surface level misses the point - whichever it is, the powerful companies use it for their advantage. Make individual piracy illegal to extract as much as they can, while also allowing themselves to suck up everything from the smallest of authors, to again, extract as much as they can.


I think what annoys a lot of people about it isnt that they necessarily believe IP is a good thing, its that its unevenly applied legally. If you commit IP theft, its theft, if Anthropic do, its "a grey area"

There's actually a ton of precedent that points to inference being considered fair use most of the time, unless you can get the LLM to start regurgitating substantial copyrighted work verbatim.

People usually like to point to Aaron Schwartz as the foil here. I'm not trying to say that what happened to him was right, but it was very consistent with copyright law. He was literally copying original works and distributing them.


And if anyone dares to distill Anthropics stolen knowledge, it's theft again!

Has anthropic actually filed suit against anyone for distillation? They take steps to prevent it, in the same way other sites take steps to prevent scraping, but there’s a difference between wanting to stop something and claiming it’s theft

They may not want to litigate that for fear it would go against them.

It would require them to defend that the model is “theirs,” and exposes them to a lot of counterarguments about that.


> put a floor on the pricing

ceiling


It doesn't even make sense when you look at a periodic table, at least without a chemistry degree.

The elements are: hydrogen < carbon < neon < argon

But the models are: hydrogen < argon/neon < carbon


Same. User of 15 years. Solid native apps turned into buggy Electron mess. I'd be fine with Electron if it weren't buggy. Wi-Fi server went away. 25% price increase this year and they do stupid sports sponsorships now.

I wonder how much of this is to be blamed on ai psychosis C-suites have. Everybody I know has been complaining that the push from the c suite down is to ship ship ship with AI. Proper engineering is seen as a waste of time, along with testing and future thinking. Companies just ship more and more untested slop

They took $200M outside investment in 2019.

https://1password.com/blog/accel-partnership

Enshittification began shortly thereafter.


Right, but what part of VC funding means ditching native apps for electron? Enshitification usually means exploitation, this is just change for change's sake

Prior to that the Windows version was a somewhat half-baked thing made by a contractor and didn't keep parity with the Mac version. It was better than nothing if you had to use Windows sometimes, but you wouldn't have bought it just for that version.

But with the VC funding came a change from B2C sales to Mac users who wanted good software to targeting B2B enterprise customers who wanted a feature checklist across their fleet, Windows included.


Ditching native apps means ditching native developers?

And dump money into Omarchy

You're giving them a lot of leniency with that phrasing. Personally I get the impression many never do think in the first place, just imitate it by regurgitating what they've heard from others.

I try and give a lot of leniency because generally these people aren't stupid or meaning to be unpleasant, they are just scared. Which means sympathy, kindness and understanding is the likely cure. You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into.

Hugging Face, and Nvidia hasn’t bought that yet.

Damn you are right, I'm reading through https://www.reuters.com/world/us-doj-is-inquiring-about-nvid... as I was quite convinced this was all behind us now.

I’m on the Pro (~20$) plan, and it’s available for me, having replaced 3.8 Flash.

This is not AI's fault. In fact, they had to probably fight the LLM to get it this simple.

I'm a subscriber to Humble Bundle Choice (their monthly offering), and it has been a pain to receive a code via email at every login.


This disaster never would have seen the light of day if it weren't for AI.

I don't know, I'm more inclined to blame the usage rather than the tool here.

Do we blame the bulldozer if it bulldozes the wrong thing? We're just not used to bulldozing yet.


I'm not blaming the bulldozer. I blame the people who gave everyone bulldozers knowing that they have faulty steering and that nobody is used to bulldozing. And the people who shut down every attempt to prevent that with the argument "bulldozers are the future, you can't stop them!".

And yes, I also blame the people getting on that bulldozer, bulldozing like there's no tomorrow. But mainly I blame the first two groups.


Bulldozers aren't restricted vehicles, anyone can buy them. What you seem to be upset at is that they became very cheap and easy to obtain, and everyone is using them to landscape their small front yards and the damage caused is often outweighing the time saved by using something simpler that takes more time and effort. The bulldozers work fine, but if you use a large one to clear everything you might just find you've also taken out the walkway to your door inadvertently, when a small one that took a bit more time and effort would have allowed for you to target what needed attention.

That metaphor has been stretched about as far as I can take it, but it's the tools and people getting access to tools they've not been trained on to do tasks they have no prior experience with. As someone who just laid laminate flooring myself for the first time, I'm keenly aware of both having the right tool for the job and the knowledge of how to use it and knowledge of how to do the task in general affects the end product. The mistakes I made are my own, not the cause of the incorrect tools I used at times.


I'm not going to blame the tool. I'm sure as fuck going to blame the peddlers of the tools that are always ready to support this kind of nonsense; worse, they tell everyone around that this is perfectly fine.

> I'm more inclined to blame the usage rather than the tool here.

Which is what your parent comment is doing. They didn’t say AI was to blame, they said this wouldn’t have happened without it. It may be your fault if you blow up your hands with a firecracker, but it’s also true that it wouldn’t have happened if firecrackers weren’t a thing.

> Do we blame the bulldozer if it bulldozes the wrong thing?

That’s such a tired analogy. By this point it’s honestly hard to believe it is made in good faith.

There isn’t a massive industry with tendrils in every facet of society trying to sell you on autonomous bulldozers that do the bulldozing for you without interaction, is there? Caterpillar is working on autonomous bulldozers, but even those aren’t targeted and advertised at every household as something you have to use.


Once you can't go for a walk without experiencing a bulldozer bulldozing the wrong thing somewhere on your path, it becomes a distinction without difference.

The bulldozer goes in the direction the person is sitting enough of the time we can call it "all the time" without having to argue "what if it breaks down, or a lever breaks and sticks on".

Do we blame the bulldozer if it bulldozes the wrong thing?

The people who make the bulldozer don't market it as "intelligent."


Disagree on which end of the telescope were looking down.

AI has caused a generational set back on how stakeholders view the value of expertise knowledge, but the gun is still people, AI is just one of the bullets along with things like obsessive cost cutting.

My large orgs entire marketing strategy is now run by an MBA using Claude to generate 'idea and best practice docs'.

The process that lead us to not having a CMO or any other marketing leadership with domain knowledge? Consulting partnerships using MBAs.

The reason we're not changing any strategies even though we're burning money pper CPA? MBAs concerned seeking alignment and having the right narrative to change course.

Thr planned new course? More Claude.


That is true, but this can be said about so many things. Hit and runs would also not exist if it weren't for cars.

The technology itself is not to blame, but maybe the marketing around it should be. AI coding tools are marketed as magic tools that can somehow spit out perfect solutions even if the input spec is garbage. Of course that is impossible, and no amount of technology can solve that problem unless every AI coding agent is equipped with guardrails that makes it stop if it gets the impression that its user is an idiot.


A fool with a tool is still a fool.

AI is a massive multiplier. It’ll 100x anyone. It’s just many people start with negative coefficients…

What if it was intentional?

Thought experiment. A startup is at the end of their runway. Need to show income or go down. Businessmodel is to sell "one off" sales, and vast majority of their accounts buy once or twice (a year or ever).

What if they "accidentally" make it easier for hackers to take over those accounts. Accidentally, as part of a large overhaul or rewrite of their systems. Then, at least for a while, their accounts suddenly "buy" much more products per month or year.

Cynical, I know. But not unthinkable.


It’s the person’s fault who says you don’t need to review/read/understand the code. “2fa? that’s just gobbledygook”.

I doubt you have to fight anything to get there.


Nah. Pre-AI you'd never make it deep enough into a project to actually ship with this level of incompetence.

This just simply isn’t true. How short is your memory? Bad software, AND bad software of this nature, existed in plentiful quantities before “AI”.

No. This isn't "bad software". This is Code Bootcamp 2nd semester lab levels of incompetent. Most of the security lessons this product ignores were known (and solved) 20 years ago. The last time I saw a website in the wild that fell down this badly on basic user account security it was written in Perl.

The law doesn’t apply to the woman and her company, on account of being limited to the USA.

The law also doesn’t apply to an American billionaire, on account of being a billionaire.

So really, nothing wrong happened here.


Mildly amusingly, an LLM running on Nvidia hardware will gladly help you avoid paying the Economist.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: