I don't give code quality a consideration at my job, as that is the expectation. I'm on-paper delivering more projects and "more productive".
I also don't think this is the right way. We are giving away practices and lesson learned over decades, in just over 6 months without fully understanding long term implications both technical and non-technical. And that is based on very optimistic bet that models will be able to handle all those potential issues that we might be concerned about in present. All the arguments/counter-arguments are mostly speculative, and I think only time will tell. My speculation is that this all BS will at some point self-correct at some point, it wont be like pre-LLM but it wont be crazy vibe-code don't look at code (or pretend we review code) either.
That's a big problem I think. We should use those tools to improve applying our practices. Along the way we might figure out that we can and should do things differently. But just throwing everything away, hoping for the best, does sound like a recipe for disaster.
Probably. Bluray still exists, still a popular medium for selling games on PS/Xbox and to certain extent movies to people who like to watch on their high-end equipment.
I wish people stopped equating LLM to interns or junior engineers. They are tools, and as good they may be at some specific things people do, they also really suck at many more which we wouldn’t find acceptable in humans.
Indeed they are tools. But if people/companies treat them as tools that can take a problem a human used to solve, and make them solve it from start to end, then the comparison begins to be necessary.
It's merely a way to frame things, in terms of experience and trust. And it highlights how an LLM can code very well, but not truly understand the ramifications of that code.
An "eager, bright 20ish year old interns" will grow as you guide them, while LLM will not, they'll only grow when their owner (definitely not us) update them. So, trying to humanizing some tool with human emotion is wrong way to framing it. Treat tool as tool.
That’s a norm at my place as well. But it’s not free. We have definitely given up on quality (both code and general stability) and fully understanding what’s going on. People are generally working more as well, because of all the layoffs pressure.
Industry is betting that we don’t need to. I still consider it a bet because Claude Code this scale has become norm just for a year.
>> what people are sending to Claude that is so secret
Its the same point used against privacy. What's so secret you are doing that you need privacy. I think in the end, its about privacy and not trusting these model companies with your data. Facebook manipulated people behaviors with all the data they had, no reason AI companies wont someday decide to do that same, and they have far more intimate knowledge.
When it comes to coding, I also don't like the idea of them taking my money and potentially at same time potentially using as dataset generator.
I've mixed opinions on that. For example, there are products like Google Shopping or Google Travel etc. They show up bunch of stores where you can buy a flight ticket or a particular product from.
However, in the end most people just end up buying it from top 2-3 marketplaces anyway, not because its cheaper, but also because they can trust it, it arrives in 2 days, and you can easily return it if you don't want. So if I'm going to most likely buy something from Amazon anyway, why not just use Amazon web page. They've had one click buy button for ages.
> However, in the end most people just end up buying it from top 2-3 marketplaces anyway, not because its cheaper, but also because they can trust it, it arrives in 2 days, and you can easily return it if you don't want.
I've got enough complaints about the amazon customer and user experience that I'm not going to list them here, but returns are so easy.
I click the button, and then I don't need to print off a shipping label or even package the item back up, I just drop it off at the convenience store by my house, they scan a QR code on my phone, and take the bare item from me.
Yes Amazon’s power is very difficult to overcome. The hope with my marketplace is that stores will offer cheaper prices since we are interfacing with them directly and they are not paying Amazon a cut.
Also, Amazon Prime is affordable now, but it will get more and more expensive. They have a large distribution network but most of their drivers are contractors. Amazon also is not as powerful in non-Western countries. They still rely on many different websites depending on need.
>> but I kind of wonder why we write articles like this
I think its a way to speak out and get it out there, than stay unspoken. Author as well others who share same opinion get some validation that they are not only ones.
I'm actively uninspired to write high quality code when using Anthropic/OpenAI models given the high chance I'm a customer as well as used as dataset generation tool for them.
But currently cloud does beat costs of hardware ownership, particularly with ridiculously high RAM/GPU/SSD costs....again due to these same companies.
Or, they can figure out something else out? I recall couple years ago when China didn't have enough GPUs (still don't?), DeepSeek team figured out how to train with less computing. IIRC they made Mixture of Experts mainstream and made really optimized kernels and clever use of PTX instruction set.
I also don't think this is the right way. We are giving away practices and lesson learned over decades, in just over 6 months without fully understanding long term implications both technical and non-technical. And that is based on very optimistic bet that models will be able to handle all those potential issues that we might be concerned about in present. All the arguments/counter-arguments are mostly speculative, and I think only time will tell. My speculation is that this all BS will at some point self-correct at some point, it wont be like pre-LLM but it wont be crazy vibe-code don't look at code (or pretend we review code) either.
reply