HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | tonic_note's commentslogin

Cool read. Would fit nicely into a broader cultural analysis Instrumental Rationality, which I would argue is the upstream cause of this phenomenon as the dominant framework of the world since the industrial revolution.


the OTP code input focus ring doesn't actually align with the input, there are these tiny gaps around the corners.


It always amuses me when people throw a fit when they can't understand technical philosophy written by experts, for experts. You never see someone posting an excerpt from a physics journal and being like "ugh so inaccessible!!!"

Like, I'd get maybe if she wrote this in a NYT opinion piece– but this was written an obscure book you'd have to go out of your way to find.

BTW, this is not that hard to comprehend if you're familiar with continental philosophy, go figure!


Sokal and Bricmont have debunked your amusement eons ago.


The irony is that the experts don't understand it half the time either.


> We're going to have to figure out how to protect ourselves. The start is to avoid it individually as much as we can, but it's going to take even more.

Collective problems require coordinated action. Individual boycotts won't cut it.


People are stuck in a weird loop of complacency and learned helplessness, based on the idea, their "democracy" would see to it all problems get solved satisfactorily without them engaging at all.

That's never been true really, only the scale of problems wasn't that huge. Now, where the problems get the upper hand, people are confused how those stay and compound.

The idea of "boycott" is utterly defunct. Pretending, AI would never reach nor surpass humans anyway is patently absurd in contradicting the billions poured into it to achieve exactly that and the first already replaced by AI being those professions long thought to be the intellectual pinnacle of humanity.


> Pretending, AI would never reach nor surpass humans anyway is patently absurd in contradicting the billions poured into it to achieve exactly that

By that logic anything can be solved when you throw money at it.


Love living in a manifestly dysfunctional country with no regulatory state. Just running the country on autopilot until something catastrophic happens.


It's a symptom of the long standing ghettoization of design and front end engineering. FE has always been cast as frivolous and unserious by conceited developers.

That's how you get slop that feels uncanny. There's no one in the room with the taste to call it out and no one in the room who cares enough to put in the time to fix it.


Yeah it's problem of sensibility. Like people do not realize that developing a sensibility and good taste here is an actual still that takes time, and is highly undervalued in tech circles with the exception of a handle of truly design driven companies.


Exactly. The benefit to the Bootstrap boom was it elevated a lot of cookie cutter designs like a raft on a series of sensible defaults that were are close to sensible/good taste as some very talented designers could make industrial cookie cutter standards. Bootstrap enshrined smart, intelligent defaults like good color contrast and a baseline of accessibility for developers just copy and pasting and modifying what Bootstrap gave them. For a brief moment the "I just need to get this done" web had a good accessible baseline.

LLMs aren't starting from sensible defaults and don't have to meet WCAG scores unless you tell them to (and even then might hallucinate checks they didn't actually make).


Yeah I think one of the vestiges of the "liberal consensus" era of politics (pre 2016) was that "persuasion" was seen as the only valid way to advance your advocacy. But the shattering of that consensus has allowed the left of center to realize that, in fact, winning is what matters. Your biggest ideological opponents by definition cannot be persuaded- politics is now a tightly coupled to the ego and therefore someone attempting to change your beliefs is deeply threatening.

The right learned this a long time ago. Persuasion does not matter. Our system is winner take all. Winning is all that matters. Online debate is a waste of time. Find your base and activate them instead.


I think a big issue we keep running into is this idea that language is ambiguous but code is somehow not. Code is merely an extension of language, a DSL if you will. Implicit assumptions become baked into the logic of the code and those assumptions can be wrong.

Look at the guy whose AI changed the entire rules of the game to avoid breaking the law. Was that really the desired outcome? And the more you try to lock it down the more language you add and therefore more ambiguity and assumptions.

You cannot solve the problems of language with more language.


Yeah all of these attempts to try and control AI outputs by using language fail to grasp that language is itself the problem. It is a closed system with no ground truth. Words only point to other words in an endless self-referential chain. There is no "closure" in language, ambiguity cannot be erased.

Imo LLM researchers would benefit a lot by reading what continental philosophers have said on the topic of language. Barthes, Sarte, Deluze, Derrida, et. Al have a lot to say that explains why we're running into the same problems over and over.


Natural language is ambiguous. Specifying exactly what you want in a way that is truly verifiable is the act of coding.


Start printing the t-shirts!


You mean t-shirts of this comic, from 2016?

[0] https://www.commitstrip.com/en/2016/08/25/a-very-comprehensi...


I think LLM researchers understand how LLMs work and what the limits of using natural language as an interface are. The problem is everyone else thinks they're basically magic, expecting them to be infinitely intuitive but also strictly deterministic, like the computer from Star Trek.


The computer from Star Trek sounds like it could entirely plausibly have been made with LLM components and a century of harness tweaking piled on.


Plausibly based on what? The computer from Star Trek wasn't real. It was Majel Barrett talking into a microphone. You can no more extrapolate any real world computer architecture from that than you can determine amphibian evolution from Kermit the Frog.


It's a thing you can talk to that does stuff for you. What other "architecture" do you need to know?


Fair enough. Your logic is unassailable. There is literally no difference between fiction and reality and no need to understand anything beyond "LLM talk therefore Star Trek real."


Literally not what the comment you were replying to was saying even remotely, but ok.


Right. Feel free to extrapolate a reading like "I think LLM tech and a century of tinkering could achieve computer performance similar to what it appears the entirely fictional, voiced by Majel Barrett, Star Trek computers has".


>Feel free to extrapolate a reading like "I think LLM tech and a century of tinkering could achieve computer performance similar to what it appears the entirely fictional, voiced by Majel Barrett, Star Trek computers has".

But that doesn't mean anything. "Similar to" is vague enough that it could include video game NPC dialogue.


Bend would make Dijkstra happy even when proof checking can’t verify if the laws are what was actually meant.

I actually think Asimov is more instructive here, while Gödel and Tarski tell us the tool can’t prove itself…

Nonetheless, it is a worthwhile endeavor and I hope more rigorous practices like this catch on.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: