HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | tocs3's commentslogin

The ones holding the bar up are getting tired.

I wonder how many species are around that locals know of that the broad science community just has not seen and described (the article does not say how it was found).

Wishful thinking and self interest may play a part.

You could try coring the tree. (I cannot think of a good joke for this though.

The models themselves aren't what's valuable.

This is a real question, because I just don't know. Don't the models needs lots and lots of training that need the gobs of giant data centers? So you either need the infrastructure or the money to buy computing to make the models? I see that all the money is being invested in AI and data centers but I do not quite understand why.


> I see that all the money is being invested in AI and data centers but I do not quite understand why.

I am no economist or business person but AFAICT the massive amount of money being burned is because everyone in the space believes there will be a Google-like (for search) single winner who takes all when the dust settles on the AI race.

Because of this belief they are willing to burn any amount of money they can get their hands on to get to this mythical finish line as fast as they possibly can, seeing it as existential. Moving fast (particularly when your main cost is hardware capex) means moving expensively.

The real question is why anyone (let alone everyone) believes this single-winner theory in 2026 when all available evidence over the past few years shows that there is neither a moat nor a lock-in opportunity at all in this market.

For your product to be fit for purpose, it has to be able to automate your customer's ability to switch to a competing product with little to no friction. And all of the competing products are roughly the same in capabilities over a long enough timeline. Good luck building any kind of real moat with that burden.

But I guess after a certain point after you've taken on hundreds of billions of dollars of investment you're pot committed and just have to keep going through the motions even if you later see the futility, perhaps that's where the AI labs are now...? Either that or just common variety denial.


I feel like there is a case to be made that they will be the dominant players, but if we're talking about them charging a heavy premium and trying to target enterprise customers, then I don't know how well that'll go

they're already making a business model where enterprises buy tokens and put them in a pool for their users to use, and I feel like that's exactly where some companies will then compare that token pricing to open source models and find it hard to justify the prices, especially as it's quite obvious that many models https://news.ycombinator.com/formatdocare now "good enough"


That turns into a world where NVidia + AMD get 90% of the profit. Supermicro and friends get the other 10%. (Excluding cloud markups.)

depends on if they're cost efficient. if there comes some kind of "good enough" inference chips and so on (which i believe will happen), then those will simply provide the most tokens per dollar and make open models even cheaper

Yeah; the open model markup goes to zero. The manufacturers of the "good enough" inference chips are probably going to be some subset of NVidia, AMD, Apple, smartphone SoC manufacturers, and (long shot) Intel.

I shortened my list to NVidia and AMD because putting Apple in muddies my point: I'd argue they'll be able to sell laptops + phones in that world, but only if you can run frontier open models on their devices, and do so efficiently. This is definitely not the case for their in-house AI offerings, like Siri, but it is already true if you install llama.cpp or whatever. I suspect that AI will not be a big revenue source for them (unless they completely turn around their software engineering org), but instead will be a "good enough to keep people from dumping their iCloud subscription" offering instead. Siri is basically that: It's completely useless, but people aren't switching to android because of it.


they get 90% of the profit, but the pie would shrink without the massive VC investments from anthropic and openai

> The real question is why anyone (let alone everyone) believes this single-winner theory in 2026

In the First World War, when they introduced the tank, everybody assumed its role would be to punch a big enough hole in the front lines that the horse cavalry could ride through and attack the enemy's supply lines, because That's How Wars End™. You fight the war you know, even when it's not the one you're actually fighting.


For your product to be fit for purpose, it has to be able to automate your customer's ability to switch to a competing product with little to no friction.

This is a really great identification of why, from an investing perspective, AI is nothing like past technologies.


The models are costly to make, but they're hard to monetize because there's not enough difference between them. It's a general commodity, so profit margins are thin because what companies can charge ends up being pushed down to the cost of inference.

There's a finite amount of training data available, and multiple companies have downloaded all of it. Arguably, trying to get a monopoly on training data is equivalent to getting monopoly access to the open internet + books.

That ain't going to happen, and if it somehow did in the US, things like Anna's Archive + libgen will save the rest of the planet from our self-imposed dark ages.

As for those data centers: The cost of inference and training on the same hardware is dropping much faster than Moore's Law. That multiplies with hardware advances, since Moore's Law isn't quite done yet.

So, those datacenters are depreciating at 50% every 18 months (Moore's law) at the same time as performance/$ and performance/watt of the software is dropping at some crazy rate like 10x per year. So, token per unit of data center is increasing by something like > 20x every 18 months, and that'll probably happen at least one more time. If it does, the datacenters will be provisioned to produce 400x more tokens than they could have when they were sized.

Put another way, if the singularity is coming, the first things it will destroy are those data center build outs. That doesn't matter though: the data centers are being built on circular loans, so the money needed to complete them probably never existed.

Dark times ahead; hopefully Trump will be blamed, since all this corruption happened on his watch while he had control of the senate, house and (partially) the courts. The stock-goes-down graph will show it happening after the midterms, of course.


> The stock-goes-down graph will show it happening after the midterms, of course.

This, to me, is the most interesting question in all of this. I increasingly feel like we live in a 'post-truth' world with regards to money and the stock market in particular. Like even during the COVID lockdowns the market blinked and then was at record highs within 6 months. It was just lol and completely out of touch with the reality on the ground.

The fed, and government alike, seem to have gradually shifted their mandates from trying to provide to a stable playground to trying to create a playground where important kids are never allowed to fall down. And when your existence is tied to trillions of dollars of the economy, you become the important kid.

Come to think of it this is also probably being exasperated by the rise of money management firms controlling tens of trillions of dollars. When the market valuation is technically just based on sentiment and you control that much money in a self-interested way, you're going to get weird outcomes.


Chancellor On The Brink

I am sort of an armchair observer so I am open to others thoughts and observations here. I am wondering what sort of economic impact the AI Boom will have. There is lots of money moving around, the construction will have a positive effect on GDP, and I do not really doubt that AI will have a long term effect on production in the general economy (likely positive). But are the amounts being spent now and the giant tax breaks really worth it?

In some states (Texas) data centers are getting significant tax breaks. I (in Texas) on the other hand have seen my property tax rise about 700% in the last 10 years.

Texas is giving data centers more than $1 billion in tax breaks each year : https://www.texastribune.org/2026/04/08/texas-data-centers-s...


I wonder how this will affect the Musk - Abbot emails (https://www.tpr.org/government-politics/2026-10-28/abbotts-a...).

It would be unfortunate for Musk if he has to avoid the state.


10 hectares:

   - ~25 acres

   - ~1076391 sqft

   - ~19 US football fields

It is not as if data center development is suddenly ended. Democrats have paired up with tech in the past. Tech might want to make friends with those that hold the purse stings. Regulatory capture is still in the cards. Projects on the way are still on the way.

It might be that tech would like some regulations / laws that slow data center development (maybe a good thing) if they think it has just turned into an arms race that has gotten out of hand. Investors might think this also (S&P 500 up ~1.5% as I write this).


Negative sentiment on data centers is bipartisan. It’s incredibly strong right now.

Regulatory capture won’t save the tech industry if they can’t improve public sentiment.

They’ve been talking down to the average person, doom-bragging about the existential crisis of AI to juice investors, and people like Sam Altman have been generally been acting like Bond villains.

I think their shortsightedness has backed them into a corner of a potentially highly regulated environment where building a data center is harder than building a chemical plant.


You mean like the Democrats were so hard on the financial industry during / after the Occupy Wall Street movement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupy_Wall_Street

The Democrats are just politicians and Americans will have to keep there focus if they want things done.


What you’ve brought up is a non-sequitur.

The polling is clear, both sides of the aisle are negative on data centers:

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2026/09/22/americans...

https://www.annenbergpublicpolicycenter.org/opposition-to-lo...

> Majorities of Democrats (69%), Republicans (54%) and independents (53%) oppose new local data centers. Opposition is highest among young adults under 30 (70%) and declines to 57% among those 65 and older, the inverse of what one might expect for a new technology


I do not think it is to much of a non-sequitur but I do hope you are right.

> Democrats have paired up with tech in the past

Yeah, and both their politicans and constituencies were directly betrayed by them. They made their bed and now they must sleep in it. Many of the dems who won made data centers and AI a part of their platfrom.


> Tech might want to make friends…

They might find that tricky after they sold out to right wing causes last election.


And while before you could say well money overrules everything, they outspendint Democrats like crazy and still got wiped out. So if you want to keep your job as a politician suddenly more fundraise no longer means more advantage

But the money was going to the Republicans, who did what they were told. The money may not actually win the election but it can (not always, but it looks like often) buy politicians.

Regulations just mean Democrats get to pick the winners, which will most likely match donations.

Which is what Republicans were already doing, while agreeing to NDAs that kept their constituents in the dark.

With the mandate from voters, hopefully we see less secret development and more open communication about the deals being cut.


I am a little hopeful here in Texas. We have needed change for a while. Still, we are talking about politicians and while there maybe be a mandate from voters it is a long and narrow road to solutions that are good for everybody (especially the constituents).

The nice thing about politicians is they can be held accountable by constituents, per the Constitution.

Data center developers, who should be equally distrusted (but seem to get a pass), are not beholden to you.

It will take developers and politicians working together to find a solution, rather than let developers do whatever they can to maximize profits without regulation or public process.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: