Anthropic models were much worse for this than OpenAI but they did improve the default significantly with the latest release. It’s easy to get around by just instructing the models on what not to do or using a preferred guide like you mentioned. It doesn’t magically produce good writing but that’s always been the case. You still need to play editor and give feedback.
I have a creative writing tool. OpenAI is just as bad, if not worse. 5.6 was a sharp drop in quality. GPT-6 was an improvement over 5.6, but still not as good as GPT-5 (5.0)
Claude peaked with 4.5. Beautiful model, probably one of the best. It dropped sharply with 4.6, and sort of recovered with 5.5. 4.5 was magical good writing, even on Haiku.
GPT-6 still has potential but you need to spend a few hours wrestling it into shape.
It's incredibly lazy, so it's terrible for dialogue; you'll get one line responses. It doesn't try to go anywhere interesting, doesn't explore unless instructed to.
GPT-4.5 was one of their most expensive models and probably the best for dialogue, probably no coincidence. I don't know how it works under the hood but it feels like the cost is because it searches a larger space.
This is the cost of capitalism. Things get done only when it’s top-down. We as a society are so scared to test different economic systems that may address this head-on.
You've gotta get past the first few rungs of Maslow's needs before you get to anything that's done without capital. Water, food, shelter, security, etc - in spite of the best efforts of humanity and millennia of progress, none of those have been consistently provided for a society without transferring money.
Not the same. You could, and many will argue we already have, strong enough models that you wouldn’t need an upgrade. Web development is already there. The competition to train better models is about capturing more market share now.
Okay, I will play along. Anthropic stops training new models tomorrow. They start turning a profit. Yay! Except wait, they still have 450 billion in commits that cannot be cancelled and another 300 billion that apparently they can cancel under certain scenarios. But maybe that all magically goes away somehow; I don't know, Coreweave is feeling generous because they are doing so well, probably not, but this is the fantasy so I digress. So they have this really great product that people want and they can just sit back and make money. Except no one else is going to stop training. And not only that some random Chinese company you have never heard of is distilling their model and is going to come out with a clone version that is 99 percent as good in one year. And on top of that, every 6 months one of the big 5 competitors comes out with a new model that is better. Anthropic can't keep charging the same price so they lower their price and lower their price until they are back to break even. Now they have an inferior product and are not competitive anymore. There is no moat.
If under the scenario you outline where they don't need to upgrade then AI is commoditized and margins are razor thin. And that is fine. Great even! But it doesn't justify Anthropic's trillion+ dollar valuation.
Where is the moat? There is no cost of switching. Anyone or any company can bounce between AI with minimal cost of switching. So unless they find a way to keep users beyond, “our model is the best” user acquisition isn’t going to matter a whole lot.
The important point is that all competitors are in the same position, they’re all on equal footing and face the same costs for training frontier models. The major players do have advantages from their infrastructure buildout and the deals they’ve negotiated with enterprise businesses which partly shuts out small competitors. It’s also yet to be determined whether smaller competitors can actually surpass the big labs in capability or whether the degree to which they depend on synthetic data generated using frontier models puts a hard limit on how far they can improve. The market is unique, it requires huge infrastructure but can also grow through investment in research and also easy to duplicate the latest advancements. It’s also not constrained by location so it can’t be easily understood as something like railroad infrastructure or power utilities. The biggest factor is growing demand, there’s more than they can all supply together and it seems likely to keep growing as more tasks can be automated.
Do you return your shopping cart or leave it in the parking lot? or if you don’t drive to supermarkets then do you return clothing you tried on in a changing room neatly on the hanger or do you just leave it piled in the changing room? do you tidy up the hotel room a bit before you leave or just grab your stuff and go without doing anything else? I’m curious if there’s some correlation here.
reply