HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | throwawaycsdc3's commentslogin

In many ways, I think so.

The big difference is in hardware it's much easier to measure cost/bug and days_of_schedule_slip/bug. Because we have those metrics, and people trust them, we can much more easily justify decisions that software teams never make. Like spending big on verification.

Why do you think we try to push everything into software. You guys are free, right? :)


Good ASIC design is not like FPGA design. For FPGA design I think your analysis is spot on. But FPGA design is configuring someone else's ASIC. ASIC design is circuit design, even if you're describing the circuit with RTL, it's still circuit design. To differentiate that ASIC you need to transform the net lists into circuits that are actually interesting. If you just use the defaults you're unlikely to sell a single chip as your performance will almost certainly underwhelm. In think in most ASICs I've worked on I have more TCL code driving the tools to make them do what I want them to do than I have RTL. RTL is shockingly efficient at describing data flow.

I agree with this, and I think most of the posters here aren’t following.

LLMs are very good at RTL (all I can consider is that the parallel posters arguing otherwise haven’t tried a modern one against significant RTL?). It’s easy to verify, the optimization constraints are relatively straightforward, and there’s adequate simulation to build a good gym for it.

LLMs are not good at layout and floor planning and because there is near zero public data available, I’m not sure how well they’ll iterate. For PCB design they’re improving because while it’s a similarly thorny problem, the physical constraints (trace properties on a given substrate) are highly public and can be simulated and turned into an RL gym. For ASIC, any public PDK is 10-20 years old so making an RL gym becomes outrageously difficult on top of the fundamental problem (highly multivariate/layered spatial optimization) being hard to solve.


> LLMs are not good at layout and floor planning and because there is near zero public data available, I’m not sure how well they’ll iterate.

Surely you can train an RL model to do this


Well, you're not alone in that thought. We've had a steady stream of papers claiming RL models that can macro place and floorplan since at least 2023. [1] And I won't even mention that Google paper...

There have been some minor victories, but it's still mostly done the traditional way in every group I'm aware of.

[1] https://developer.nvidia.com/blog/autodmp-optimizes-macro-pl...


How do you think the architects that optimize the performance per watt of designs are working? they simulate at the circuit level. It's all stuff that llms can be fantastic at. There is a well defined goal, and metrics for being better that are very accurate. The only question is will anyone invest enough money building the datasets to be good at this. Given the hype around RSI, the answer is .. yes.

anyone who thinks llms can't get good at this is engaging in wishful thinking


On an infinite time horizon, sure. Maybe. But unless you use these tools I don't think you realize just how manual the whole process is. For example, I've never had a chip be 100% DRC free. I always have to go in and hand edit the database in the end to fix those last few nitty gritty nets. Look at the TritonRoute paper [1], the open source router. They're claiming victory because they got a contrived benchmark down to "unprecedented, extremely low level" of <20 DRCs errors, but not DRC free. And that's a benchmark, not a real design. So much of the EDA flow is about finding what is merely a valid solution, never mind optimized...

But can LLMs improve chip design? Absolutely. They're improving chip design right now. That gobs of TCL I referenced. Claude is amazing at it. And I'm working on structures that are way more complicated than I could previously do. And I don't really care if it's not following good software engineering whatever because I'm going to run that code once and my product is a chip. Not TCL code.

But am I going to prompt an LLM and it's going to give me a competitive chip back? Not any time soon. I'm sure.

[1] https://vlsicad.ucsd.edu/Publications/Journals/j133.pdf


A lot can happen in the time frame widely regarded as soon. Let's revisit in a year.

One thing I will agree with is LLMs won't directly raise the ceiling in chip design but they will almost certainly raise the floor. And since much of the cost in making a chip in 2026 is the NRE, that could make barely mediocre chips very cost competitive, and at the end of the day, cost wins. That could definitely be our innovator's dilemma right there and is something to watch out for.

If you want to make what is basically a "Hello World" chip, then yes. But if you want to make a chip that is not essentially identical to your competitors, then no.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: