HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | throw_m239339's commentslogin

The parent is getting downvoted but he is absolutely right. Do not ever do what you just did. It makes you an easy target for a frivolous lawsuit in the US or in other countries because of the potential liabilities in your message, they are real. Even if you didn't do anything wrong, you are painting a target on your back, for no reason. I would ask HN to delete that thread directly.

You cannot foresee the financial/civil consequences of that RCE and some people might be looking for scapegoats in the future.


Anyone can sue anyone else for any reason. We should encourage honesty and transparency, not discourage it.


This isn't a matter of transparency, was the OP legally bound not to disclose the RCE? That whole "embargo" was pure courtesy between the people involved. The OP committed no fault at first place and the exploit was already in the wild anyway. Whoever really wanted to exploit it before the patch could without using the OP as a source.

> Anyone can sue anyone else for any reason.

And it's easier to have cause to sue when someone publish an "admission of guilt", which makes a lawsuit harder to dismiss thus costlier.


To win, the cause needs to be a broken law or contract. Neither are here.


While possibly true in theory, in practice it's not. Courts and judges do not take kindly to frivolous or unsubstantiated claims, and any halfway good attorney would advise you to not waste your money and your time on a claim you are unlikely to win or be able to collect on.

People and companies do get sued with the full intention of a settlement and it never going to trial. But that only happens when the defendant has deep pockets or good insurance.


There's at least some evidence in the other direction.

https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2017/10/in-patient-in...

> New research shows that discussing hospital errors with patients leads to better patient safety without spurring a barrage of malpractice claims.


It has nothing to do with anything I said.


Sure it does. Saying sorry sometimes reduces liability risk, which is quite counterintuitive at first.


> Sure it does. Saying sorry sometimes reduces liability risk, which is quite counterintuitive at first.

No it doesn't have anything to do with what I said. The OP has no contractual or legal obligations toward any community, unlike a doctor and their patients in case of medical error.

edit:

> A doctor has no contractual obligation to apologize, either.

> But it can help prevent things from going to lawsuits, versus the "fuck you I admit nothing" approach that sometimes just pisses people off.

OP isn't a doctor as far as you know, and isn't apologizing to a specific person. OP can't be bound to an embargo he didn't know about and wasn't involved in any decisions.

You're completely off topic and you just want the last word.

Your ramblings have nothing to do with anything I have said.


A doctor has no contractual obligation to apologize, either.

But it can help prevent things from going to lawsuits, versus the "fuck you I admit nothing" approach that sometimes just pisses people off.


"Weekend at Burnsie's"? anyone?


"See, it's sentient! It misinterpreted my prompt!".


I bet my wife thinks that of me sometimes :).


RIP, what a fantastic person she was.


Right, don't ban them that's bad for free speech, just impose huge fines on Facebook to bankrupt them.


Whoever wrote that article doesn't understand that these agents operate from AI companies servers and aren't rogue, they are doing exactly what they were programmed for. If they cause any sort of damage then at the minimum it's civil or criminal negligence. A subpoena for internal communications during legal proceedings might demonstrate that researchers knew about the risks, but went forward with that anyway, which would be more than negligence...


Someone made VST versions of both the Machinedrum and the Monomachine, after doing the Virus series, the JP8000, the Supernova...

so people can have all these at home without the hardware, if they manage to find the original OS online AND have a computer powerful enough to run all these... they are emulations of the original devices...

But in theory, someone could make hardware bootleg versions of all these devices...


Links??!!


Enjoy:

https://theusualsuspects.io/

Truly one of the most interesting developments in software synthesis in the past few years.


> There needs to be a free, non-ad, non-login environment people can use to access this information posted by public entities.

RSS.


*slaves do. Amazon big shots must be laughing at these people who have no choice but to accept these work conditions to make ends meet, so hard. They must talk about these people like they are garbage, peasants, when Amazon yuppies are among themselves...

That's what shocked me the most when I was doing odd jobs, the contempt, the disdain.


It's fraud, and wire fraud in US, and it's a federal crime. But yeah, it sounds like a fake story.


What makes it sound fake?


The public confession of a crime part.


What about OpenAI’s breach of huggingface?


The fact that they apparently attempted to sandbox those tests would seem to be a clear difference between the two cases.


Fair point


They admitted it once they were forced (HF found out about it).


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: