HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | thomas_witt's commentslogin

I really liked Tmux and Zellij for the time being, but Herdr does it all so much better out of the box when it comes to agentic coding. I haven't found something I can do with tmux/zellij but can't do with herdr.


Only problem with Herdr is the VC funding. Not sure what the rug pull will be, but it's coming sooner or later.


Maybe I didn’t give it enough of a shot, but I fond herdr was solving the wrong problem for me. I want to manage shipping work, gtd, not a bunch of agent sessions. The sessions are an implementation detail that I prefer jumping into only when something is wrong.


You can. I use it exactly that way with the individual terminal sessions accessible.

I'm mostly using it now because it integrates with ssh while still supporting image paste. I also use it via it's json API for a harness I'm working on which is agent agnostic.

I do expect I'll move off it if it becomes hostile and another tool takes it's place.


My only problem with herdr is its propensity to randomly crash and take out the whole session. At one point it was crashing once or twice a day, recently it’s more like every two weeks, but it still crashes. I have auto session resume on but that still means ongoing work is interrupted and I have to manually restart all the long running non-agent processes.

As a result I still run sessions and processes I really don’t want to lose inside tmux, nested inside herdr. Tmux never crashes.


As a counterpoint, I use herdr in WSL/windows and has never crashed for me.


If you’re mainly just using Claude Code, “$ claude agents” view is a good alternative coupled with tmux. I’m curious if herdr does other things though.


I totally agree. It's a shame that the ACL stuff in UNIX-based systems hasn't been changed in the last 20 years (xattr doesn't count).


Having had the (dis)pleasure of working with SELinux, it's clear that there are systems out there that can work to solve these problems. On Linux the problem is in the UI/UX layer (actually configuring SELinux rather than working around it is a massive pain) but Apple/Google/MS have the money to solve that.

I don't know if Apple has something like that. Surely they must do; Windows FACLs have been available since NT was part of the name, Linux has had them since Linux 2.5, and Apple invented a whole new filesystem relatively recently. They've also compartmentalised iOS apps since they were first released.

I'd be surprised if the currently available APIs aren't usable for applying effective restrictions just yet. Rather, I think Apple's choice is part of a process to move desktop applications towards the iOS model instead.


> On Linux the problem is in the UI/UX layer (actually configuring SELinux rather than working around it is a massive pain) but Apple/Google/MS have the money to solve that.

That assumes it can be solved and even then it requires research, so you cannot know how much effort it takes to find a solution.

Also, and IMO highly likely, any solution will be unusable for mere mortals. i thin that’s why you are saying “(dis)pleasure” and “configuring SELinux […] is a real pain”


SELinux was originally designed by the NSA to serve their needs, which are probably a bit more intense than "normal" users, and that was over 25 years ago. I'm not convinced a fresh effort couldn't do better, though I'm more skeptical that anyone is willing to invest the resources.


The Russians did, with Astra Linux. They didn't do better


Has it substantially changed since the 1970s introduction of user / group / others octal permissions?


Yes. The name that you should look up is Trusix.


Trusted Unix Working Group (Trusix) Rationale for Selecting Access Control List Features for the Unix System

https://irp.fas.org/nsa/rainbow/tg020-a.htm

What is the signficance now of this 1989 report?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: