HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | thih9's commentslogin

> New cameras are being researched and added every week

How? With no description of the process I’m going to assume it’s all ai generated. Especially since they say they use ai for images.

Edit: are the images re-styled content from third party sites? E.g. compare:

- https://www.cameraindex.co.uk/camera-details/adox-gnome-35/r...

- http://historiccamera.com/cgi-bin/librarium2/pm.cgi?action=a...


Why not both? Major platforms were indeed walled gardens before ai - and they started tightening restrictions after ai.

If you own an iPhone, go to Health app and scroll through your mobility stats. You'll find step length, double support time, walking asymmetry, etc.

Apple released a document in 2022 where they documented these features[1], along with details on how they work. I guess next versions will have more accuracy.

[1]: https://www.apple.com/healthcare/docs/site/Measuring_Walking... (PDF)


Similarly Garmin run watches [1] can tell ground contact time of each foot, your vertical oscillation and how much you slow down when you step down and speed up when you push off for each foot.

[1] https://www.garmin.com/en-US/garmin-technology/running-scien...

[EDIT]: I think a chest HR monitor is also needed for some of those measurements


I think a chest HR monitor is also needed for some of those measurements

Used to be true, then Apple demonstrated that those metrics can be obtained using just a watch, so Garmin upped their game and got rid of the HR strap requirement.


And these metrics aren't even from the Watch; they're derived from the iPhone, which I assume is going to have a greater possibility of locations where it's stored on the body.

> stored on the body

or in, just for completeness' sake.


swallows-phones-George screwed the machine learning algorithm and shouldn't have been counted

I keep being pleasantly surprised that there's no crypto on that nvidia diagram.

While nvidia does have crypto focused offering, they could have easily went all-in, especially during the hype. I'm sure they profit anyway and that makes playing safe easier. But still, they could have increased their short term profits by a lot - and many corporations would have done that.


Crypto never proved to be believable enough to be the vehicle for funneling nation-state levels of wealth into private tech companies; the public would've rejected it. AI was slightly more believable, and so it completely cannibalized the crypto industry from the silicon to the engineers to the captured media.

To whatever extent you think AI is legitimate, or a bubble, you have to recognize we are behind schedule on the grandiose claims Sam Altman made at the beginning. In both cases it points to some degree of desperation, since 2008, to convince Americans there is still a path to wealth creation. Otherwise it's just pharma and weapons executives vs everyone else, which is an extremely politically unstable setup.


I am pretty sure crypto is somewhere in the realm of DVD players as far as the average person is concerned, the only people holding that topic up is saylor and his crypto exchange buddies that have accumulated a lot of "Wealth" and are spinning up transactions to hold up a baseline price

How long before we have a meeting with multiple Claudes wearing different hats?

Will external contacts join calls with their own Claudes?

Are Claudes going to switch to a non speech audio protocol when humans leave the channel?

Are they going to communicate with ultrasound when humans are present?


All of the above is hilarious, terrifying and exactly what I am also assuming will start happening very very quickly.

It'll be like bringing a translator. Your AIs have your own project context loaded. Except, they are really probably more knowledgeable than the humans who haven't read any of the relevant documents for the meeting yet.

At some point some human needs to understand and decide at least something all these meetings are about.

But we are quickly moving away from that point.


> At some point some human needs to understand and decide at least something all these meetings are about.

Do they? I'd wager something like 90% of all corporate meetings are an utter do-nothing waste of time. Negative value-add and that's being charitable.

The best solution would be just deleting them all. The interim solution is having robots do it until some beancounter realizes how much spend on AI tokens useless meetings are taking and deletes them all.

I see AI as more or less the only way for society to escape this insane situation we find ourselves in. Probably much more likely it will fail, but at least there is a chance to get out from under the useless administrative class rule!


Then we’ll be able to sit comfortably, With Folded Hands.

Except Claude will bs in the same way as a human about having read everything and when called out will just partially it "You're right. I did overstate how much I context I had read. Page 14 was beyond the context of what I had read. Would you like me to read all of the project now?" [pinky promise this time. Spoiler: it'll lie again]

The documents were only written for the clankers any way

Oh boy Anthropics are reading this site. You're giving them ideas which will make us all suffer...

And in these meetings, do I have to press RETURN or can I just say it?

This looks great.

How long until we get that with a native support for changing firmware?

As in: preload ten firmware versions and switch between them, with persisted state?


not enough space on device

but hook your FM1 to your phone and flash from there (the firmware hub)... very portable.

i like m-pyre a lot right now - https://historyofsky.github.io/m-pyre/


I think it might be, Tesla, Cursor, Twitter/X have also been notably user hostile.

No, they haven’t? Relative to their competitors, all three have been excellent.

Twitter is not “excellent”, it’s a sewer. Cursor isn’t even really a thing anymore. Claude Code and Codex killed it. Tesla just discontinued their garbage can on wheels and promised (and charged for) fake “full self driving” for years.

Subjective, Bluesky is also a sewer, reddit /r/all is also a sewer.

Objectively all of those things are sewers. Twitter is the worst though.

All Reddit bullshit.

Cursor: $4 billion in annualized revenue. https://presenc.ai/research/cursor-usage-and-revenue-statist...

X: 550 million daily users. https://twtdata.com/twitter-statistics/

Tesla: "Fake" or not, 1.74 million active FSD subscriptions with record growth: https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/4862/tesla-fsd-hits-record...


I don’t know what “Reddit bullshit” is, I’ve never even used Reddit. $4B revenue (and dropping) is nothing today.

X is a sewer, quite a bit smaller than the other social networks too!

Yes, “full self driving” is fake. Compare any of the numbers you’re quoting with the fraudulent valuations behind Musk’s scam companies and you’ll see why the SEC should throw him in prison, were we living in a functioning society.


He may be a victim, but note that he had to choose to participate.

Also note that his wife and children are victims of his unfaithful actions. He is the only one responsible for that - he just said so himself.


He may be a victim, but note that he had to choose to participate.

To play devil's advocate here.. If she's a spy trained in psychological manipulation and seduction we'd be right to call him a victim instead of a participant since he'd be a target of those techniques applied to him. Maybe?


I would personally agree that it is possible he is a victim of advanced psy-op technology. I don't personally believe we have nearly as much 'choice' or 'free will' as NA culture of the past 40+ years has led most people to believe.

At a deeper level we do get to choose our overall environment and what kinds of things we are exposed to frequently, the recurring patterns of life can be consciously managed and shaped. But in the moment, we are more like an LLM doing a forward pass on next token. If a specific weight relating to refusal has been abliterated, it's not realistic to expect the next token to somehow still come out to refusal.

We can control our training better than we can control our inference. We have ego-ideals and specific mental makeup that can be exploited if identified.


The "advanced psy-op technology" of feigning physical attraction to a sexagenarian billionaire.

I kind of see where you're coming from, but people are still responsible for their actions. McDonald's employs psychologists and spends millions if not billions of dollars per year to abliterate my weights in regards to their restaurant, and yet I still refuse. And it would be my choice if I gave in. As pointed out elsewhere in the comments, Huang had to make many decisions to end up in his current situation, and each one is a failure for someone leading a company of that size and influence.

Also, other reporting has well established that extramarital activity is the relative norm for ultrawealthy men in business. Are we to believe that every time one of these guys enters a sexual relationship with a younger woman, it was an attack leveled by some psy-witch harpy on a hapless CEO? It seems more likely to me that Huang was participating in normal behavior for men in his position, and in this case it may have actually had consequences.


That can help explain what led to him deciding to cheat, but no it doesn't make him a victim. People have to be responsible for their actions rather than being labeled a victim of their own choices.

That's generally true if the victim is a laymen, but somewhere between being a college pool-boy, to the president of a nation, to running a company that is more powerful than many nations... there arises an obligation to defend against such foreseeable attacks.

He's married... he made an oath, signed a social contract to another person, his wife, that he made the conscious choice to break.

Its clear his wealth generated a level of narcissism here that rose to a level that permitted him to invalidate the feelings of his wife, who, again, he made a vow to.

It does not matter if some hot chinese spy tried to get into his pants. He still let it happen. He his actions spoke for him: "I know i have a wife, but this chinese spy is so hot. I dont care about my wife anymore, but im going to keep this a secret from her because I know its wrong". For a loooooong time.

I'm personally so tired of excusing infidelity. He is a big boy. He can make big boy decisions.

Unless they're a poly couple, who knows.


Can you please point me to the documentation on marriage?

There are other ways to compromise a target that do not involve infidelity. These “techniques” just facilitate the process for an at least somewhat willing and/or interested target.

So, no, he’s not a victim, his existing personal potential for infidelity was exploited. It worked because he would have done the same thing if the right non-spy were to arrive on the scene. The spy takes advantage of that.


What if she wasn't a trained spy but someone naturally gifted in psychological manipulation and seduction? No longer victim but participant? Even though the effect he faced was the same?

> If she's a spy trained in psychological manipulation and seduction we'd be right to call him a victim

What's the difference between this and sales?


Why not both? Victim and a participant. This is what the grandparent comment is saying. The further part is relevant too.

And if he was a gambler and she offered him money to pay his debts, would you say he is a victim? Come on man.

We just don’t know the story enough to judge. What if he was given benzos and was immediately blackmailed for example? This is a nation-state organized affair after all, not just a poorly judged night at the bar.

Jensen's offspring are both adults, at some point the relationship changes from one of total responsibility and dependence to one among equals.

We should really stop with this "just think of the children" knee-jerk


I have friends who as an adult one of the parents had an affair and and it was pretty tough for them, and the parent child relationship has never been the same again.

I don't know why you seem to be so against considering Jensen's children. Some people really value the commitments of marriage and see adultery as something very serious and damaging.


And project their world views onto others.

I don't consider his children because they are nepo-babies that were hired into Nvidia, make tens of millions of $$$, and stand to inherit billions. They will be fine.

There are so many other children in the world that deserve consideration before his (grown adult, very rich) children.

Jensen should be apologizing to Americans for compromising NatSec.


The world does not have a finite supply of “deserves sympathy” juice which must be carefully metered. One can reasonably feel sympathy for people (and animals too!) who are experiencing different forms of suffering, even if some are much more severe than others.

If you’re trying to distribute aid resources or something, it would be worthwhile to get an understanding of who is suffering the most. But if someone is just having the normal human experience of feeling sorry when they hear another person is hurt, there is no benefit to intentionally cultivating schadenfreude to shut that down. That’s not an instinct we should encourage in each other.


> Jensen should be apologizing to Americans for compromising NatSec

Why? National Security is not in his job description.


There's a tacit expectation that you don't use the privilege of doing business with/within a country to put the people you're doing business with at risk.

He does advanced chip technology it's 100% in his job description and is why he spends a full paragraph talking about natsec in that apology letter

I disagree. Even as an adult I would be distraught if one of my parents decided to cheat on the other. Your children being adults doesn't mean you no longer have a responsibility towards them.

Then its time to grow up, people change, interests change, lifelong love and happy life together is and always was a fairytale. Once you are 20 and somewhat independent its time to relax your responsibility claims on your parents. They already spent a great deal of their so very limited life time on you, at least be grateful for that.

Of course people change, but there's a way to go about it that doesn't involve going behind your partners back and making national news coverage in the process. The fact you don't see that difference is bizarre.

The national new part is only because he is a CEO of the gigantic and strategic company, I was addressing the idea that parents are responsible to adult children in general.

>Then its time to grow up, people change, interests change, lifelong love and happy life together is and always was a fairytale.

If this is your attitude then you should just never get married in the first place. At the very least you owe it to a partner that expects a real commitment.


Perhaps growing up is coming to the understanding that we have a responsibility to each other regardless of our ages.

This is not people changing. This is discovering someone that you had an intimate connection with and who helped shape your worldview actually has some major flaws in character. Presumably and at some level, you probably followed their advice and made choices that lead you to where you are in connection with their wishes and it should be at the very least a great cause for self-reflection given they are not the person you thought they were.

I can tell you from experience that it hits different when you're legally an adult.

For one, there's no custody case. There's often also no child support (some jurisdictions extend it to college students) to speak of.

There's really mostly the sorrow of the parent who was cheated on.


> Jensen's offspring are both adults

So, they are not allowed to be upset if daddy decided to cheat on their mommy after long marriage with some chinese honeypot? I hope you are not planning on start your own family any time soon


I believe parent post's point was that the children are allowed to be upset, but it's a bit rich for the internet to be clutching its pearls on behalf of them if they're adults.

"Think of the children" is a rhetorical appeal to pathos.

There's plenty to talk about here that doesn't require assuming how an adult is going to feel about another adult's behavior.


Forget the children. Please think about the shareholders!

I notice quite a few people worry more about the financial implications (nVidia's stock price) than the ethical ones.


I think many of his defenders are very worried about the financial implications and are defending him to try and steer the conversation in a way that will minimize those implications.

> We should really stop with this "just think of the children" knee-jerk

From the horse's mouth:

>> My actions hurt her and our children.

Parents (or "equals") can hurt and and disappoint others at any age - including adults.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nighthawks_(Hopper)

Wikipedia has a higher quality version of the painting, click the image in the article to see it.


Yeah, it's great on my desktop. Love the article (well, both of them).

Always had a great nostalgia for this image. Is it just me, or do other night owls find it soothing, quiet, and productive for deep thoughts? (Even if it's just thoughts about games.)


Centralization is nonironically my biggest problem with AI. It feels like a step back towards mainframe era.

Will we go back to PCs? As in: are we going to get cheap local hackable frontier AIs at some point? I hope so.


> Will we go back to PCs? As in: are we going to get cheap local hackable frontier AIs at some point?

Forget about AI, the entire PC market is getting killed over this.

As an avid gamer I'm unsure if in 5 years I can even buy a gaming PC anymore. Not even because of cost, but it's unclear if anyone will still make the components anymore.

NVIDIA isn't interested, nor is AMD.


Today I opened newegg for the hell of it and figured I'd look at the cost of a 2 TB NVMe ... Fuck man. This is seriously depressing.

BUT! I feel that lost hope could/will turn into a new forms of "min-maxing" or whatever where we will see people focusing on small, efficient software to make the most of what we have to weather the drought. We got spoiled with cheap hardware. Time to make the most of all that cheap hardware we have.

Though of course, replacing this hardware as it breaks down will be expensive. Perhaps we could go back to 1/2/4 GB RAM sticks and 256/512 GB Disks. Then run minimal Linux installs, minimal GUIs, minimal services, minimal software.

To amend this: Reading the 8088 domination article and the little $8 RISC-V Linux board I think we have plenty of opportunity. Maybe we learn to shed our inefficient BIG computers for small, low power, purposeful, yet general computers. I play with Plan 9 a lot and its portability, small footprint, low resource, and distributed design has showed me we can do a lot with a little as long as we stay disciplined to keep things simple and to the point.


I have an external USB-C 4 TB portable SSD called the Samsung T7 Shield 4TB Black.

I bought it at the middle/end of 2024, and I paid 3790 NOK (~357 USD at the time).

The lowest price online in my country for the same product new online today is 10233 NOK (~1085 USD)!

270% of what it was before, it’s absolutely bonkers.

I was even considering putting it up for sale a few weeks ago. But of course what I would be able to get for it would be no where near $1000 when selling second hand. Instead I might if I am lucky get slightly more than I originally paid which would be nice and all except that if I then regret selling it it’s still expensive to replace, or I have to also buy it second hand from someone else that may have worn theirs out considerably more compared to what I have done to the one I currently have. Mine is very well taken care of since the start, and although it’s nearing capacity now I haven’t written and deleted data over and over on it. So there has been very little wear on the flash.


Isn't there SMART data that lets you more accurately value it?

"... we will see people focusing on small, efficient software to make the most of what we have..."

Been doing that for myself for the past 15 years

Advances in hardware are only impressive and useful for me when I avoid the so-called "tech" company "engineer" BS

The reason I stop using old computers is never due to software. It's always outdated proprietary cables, failing power adapters, screens, hinges, and so on

Sometimes "minimalism" is simply for _speed, resource usage control and/or reliability_ (that's what I get from small software, anyway) in contrast with prevailing marketed garbage that is bloated and sluggish by commparison

Other times, claims of "minimalism" might be trying to capitalise on some silly trend

Personally I like what the computers I own can do for me and learning to make them do more. I have a brain, I don't do much "guessing" and I don't really need "inference" on a daily basis, certainly not for such a high cost

I have all the "convenience" I can handle


I think there is a second order effect of this: it won't be worth making games for PC. At least, large budget games.

It also won't be worth it to make games for next gen consoles if the prices end up being what people are saying. So in the end they'll just keep doing what they're doing right now, and not increase the hardware requirements of their games.

The extensive use of AI for producing better code (if so instructed) may even decrease the hardware requirements.

...AI may do is such a tired trope by now.

not true. it wont be worth it anymore to implement Path Tracing or Ray tracing which is absolutely not needed for a prime gaming experience. its deterimental even because ull only get into games with a certain type of person who can afford a big machine.

Many games that come out still, and are quite successful, do not require such technologies.


AI slop-cloning is killing small indie games too.

Is it really? Slop clones of games have been a thing for ages, I’d expext the market to be reasonably resistant by now.

Here's how it's been going:

1. Indy developer releases a game or trailer of a game. 2. Within an extremely short time (days to weeks at most) there are clones on the market. 3. These games often outperform the original.

It's absolutely not something that's gone on for ages.

It might be a novel gameplay idea / twist on a genre, and mere days after launch instead of being able to stand on its own and gather attention it's drowning in a pool of lookalikes. It's no longer distinct.

The speed of being able to slop together something like this is less than 1% of what it used to be.


Clones are not going to be the problem. The slopalanch will be the problem. Take a look at https://www.reddit.com/r/playmygame/. There's a new game every few minutes and pretty much zero of them are getting any attention. And this is only the beginning.

So it's easier than ever to make a game, but it's more difficult than ever to get anyone to try what you've made. I'd say that's just as bad, and in some ways worse, than having your game cloned.

For someone looking to play a new game it will be difficult to sort through all the bad games to find the good ones. And for anyone pouring their soul into a game they will more likely than not have an audience of one.

Our eventual destination is probably going to be a) pick up a device, b) ask your bot to make up a game on the spot, c) play. It sounds so lonely and depressing.


HN went crazy over 2048, which was a slop clone of Threes, something like 15 years ago.

So yes maybe it happens more often now, but it’s still not new.


> So yes maybe it happens more often now

Yes, that's literally the point of the people you're responding to. Has HN lost reading comprehension, or are you arguing in bad faith?

It used to happen occasionally. Now it happens instantly. That delta is the problem.


I'm still hoping some future LLM is good and small enough for people to run local AI for everyday life.

It's interesting trying to be an AI "moderate," which as the owner of a 16gb card I definitely am. Still working on the balance, but it really does feel like I'm going to land on something like "use external AI services to build a few tools, but use my local rig to actually handle everything personal once those tools are built."

Already here. 3.8-27b is good enough.

5 years ago it would have been science fiction


Do you find it intelligent enough? What hardware are you using?

For me, qwen 3.8 27b on my m5 max is so slow and dumb that I can't think of a single use for it. Haiku, Luna, or data center scale open models are ten times faster and ten times smarter (and inference so cheap that it's essentially free). It was a nifty toy to brag to friends about but why would I waste my time goofing with something so slow and dumb?

Try DeepSeek 4.1 Flash 1017, feels much better: https://github.com/drawthingsai/local-code-community

For roughly the same reason you might slow down and read a book on how to do something as opposed to speedrunning 20 youtube videos?

Are you insinuating that your agents are more effective at 20 tok/s than 200 tok/s?

I don't even understand your analogy. I'm not watching the youtube video or reading the book. The model is. And a big computer can watch 20 youtube videos faster than a small computer can watch 1, and do a far better job understanding all of them (bigger model at data center scale is both smarter and faster than smaller model at local scale).


On my Mac Mini M4 Pro with 48G I find Qwen 3.8 27B perfectly usable, useful and fast enough.

Are you trying to one shot create the Linux kernel?


There a lots and lots of great games that will run on computers that would be considered low power today. And I’m not even talking about older games.

I was floored to discover that my i3-1215U with integrated graphics can easily run PS2 games at 60ish FPS. These are triple A games, just a little older.

If I started today and played 10 games I can emulate every single day for the rest of my life restricting myself to purely emulation, I wouldn't run out of new games for...five and a half years. (assuming my rough calculation of ~20k available games).

Drop it to a game a day and I will likely never run out of games given my life expectancy.

Consider that I will find some games I like to play for more than a day and there are easily well more than enough games in emulation alone to entertain me for the rest of my life on existing entry level hardware.

Will I ever play MODERN SHOOTER {CURRENT YEAR} on this device? Certainly not, but I can't see a reason to bemoan lack of access to such a small portion of the available industry.

Like, suppose you're a reader. You might be right that you might enjoy your favorites in their original languages, but you'd be silly to be worried about your future ability to enjoy books just because you'll likely never get to experience reading 三体 as a chinese citizen fluent in the language.


It's also killing the console market. Sharp drops in all console sales after "adjusting" to ram prices.

Not just the Console and PC's market, the Phone market to. On my country before, IDR 2.000.000, you can have a 8GB phone with G100 Ultimate. How about Now? On that price, you'll just got the 4/128 with Unisoc T7250.

I agree it’s brutal right now.

I have to think, it can’t take much time before the Chinese DUV fabs come online and non-frontier chip prices crater. Sure, you might not be able to get 5090 equivalents, but the 30xx series was DUV and so that should be replicable in a few years.

Whatever quality bar / process node China gets to you know they will scale it out super hard.

(Some quick investigation suggests that the Yuliangsheng DUV machines currently under construction are 28nm, which would map to 2014’s GTX 900. Perhaps I’m being overly bullish but I assume they will recapitulate/clone the tech faster than the rate it was originally discovered.)


Its interesting because I was at Costco the other day and they weren't even selling PCs unless they were gaming ones. It seems most consumer electronics have switched over to laptops.

Also, this reminds me so much of the download more RAM ads back in the day.


Most of it has switched to mobile phones and tablets. It doesn't help that almost everywhere digital classroom means tablet instead of laptop. Sure, the control is convenient for the teacher, but it also means we are raising our children in walled gardens. So much so, that whole generations don't even leave that garden in their spare time.

I'm still waiting for the day a mac air style shell exists where I plug my phone in and just get a real desktop experience. The chips in phones these days are plenty powerful. I always thought it would be where we were going, but alas, no major manufacturer seems to want to make it feel like a seamless, premium experience. Samsung got sorta close, but the peripherals involved never felt great or didn't make sense from a cost perspective.

I wonder what it would look like if Apple offered a slimmed down shell from the Neo for ~$300 that required a connected iPhone. Maybe as iOS and MacOS converge we'll get there.


Sure they will. The same components go into every office PC. As for GPUs, we could always play older games.

Office tower PCs aren't a market anymore. It's only laptops or single-board mini PCs connecting to a remote environment.

intel makes gpus :). Maybe games will be finally made again in a way that a PC can run them without needing a 3k GPU in there to get toward half the refreshrate of your monitor.

gaming does not equate to only things like the last of us or cyberpunk which need extreme machines. a lot of visual fidelity can be reached still without having such a monster. Just need to not use certain features which are currently pretty much exclusive to Nvidia...


Cyberpunk runs even on steamdeck, it doesn't need an extreme machine.

Have you seen the current prices on Steam Deck? Almost $800 for the base model.

And I assume they will only continue to go up. When it came out, purchasing one seemed like an easy decision. But I paid half as much for one with the same CPU/RAM (and upgraded my SSD for cheap).


At least you'll be able to get a Pi 5 for $700.

Pi6 might get very close to buisiness usage but i guess microsoft will use just more cpu/gpu for windows to stop that from happening.

What's the rumours on the Pi6?

its gonna be at around early 2028

Year or price? /s

If nobody can afford a gaming PC, devs will need to make games that run on older hardware. This isn't a bad thing.

On the bright side, you’ll be able to play Skyrim-halo-Pokémon-Minecraft as much as you want.

If the AI bubble bursts and prices normalize because demand for AI hardware is reduced, then these companies might pay more attention to other markets like gaming again. But who knows the future anyway.

What is more sensible: Listening to the best music on an average sound system or listening to average music on the best sound system?

There should be a big enough back catalog of great games for you to enjoy without having to buy a new gaming rig.


Sound systems are a bad analogy. A decent amp and a pair of speakers can be had for next to nothing and the tech hasn’t changed that much since 1970. If the parts haven’t broken due to age a vintage set can sound very very good and be picked up second hand for less than 100€ or $

Isn't it the same for gaming? You never need a new computer to play old games. They can't even take benefit of the improved technology.

I'm just sticking with Tetris.

Regarding graphics capabilities, haven't we reached "good enough" like a decade ago? Does anyone actually want to see ultra realistic gore when attacking an enemy? I'd also submit that photorealistic art style is not the most popular one either nowadays except for a handful of special sims like race car driving.

If not for adults, my opinion is that teenagers/younger generations are gonna be interested within buying ultra-realistic games. Aside from Minecraft, Roblox, GTA 5 as indie games, most players in this age do in my opinion play AAA games or the most solid graphics game that the world has to offer (as much as their laptops allow them to)

It's worse than centralization. These AI models have gobbled up all the world knowledge. If for some reason the Internet dies we will have no option but to be dependent on these proprietary, for profit, AI models for any information we need.

You might say that this is impossible but look at current trends. A lot of information today is getting shared in the walled gardens of Internet. You have to login to social media to view posts. The Twitter, Reddit threads that were accessible freely now require you to log in. Similar thing is happening across other networks. People are no longer asking questions on Stackoverflow. All those queries are gonig to AI. If someone chooses to not use AI, their options will be limited in future.


Not only if the internet dies. If the country or countries managing the AI decide they don't like your country and ban you from using their (major) AI providers, in a world where most knowledge and work tanks will require access, you're screwed.

Not even talking dictatorship scenarios here. The USA might simply decide it doesn't like your country. Or maybe heavily cripple the models you can use, or censor them, for whatever reason.

I guess this is an argument for local AI. Probably not feasible for the less technically savvy.


I have high hopes for AMD Halo / NVidia Spark or sth. similar - relatively open computers (unlike Apple) with unified memory. Now if those prices just came down a bit... :-/

We currently have politicians in the U.S. talking about “stopping” AI.

So it’s plausible they’ll block me from accessing Mistral since they host DeepSeek models.


They're already censored

Yes, I know. I meant additional censorship that blocks whatever you're trying to do with them. In other words, that you are not in control.

Some things will always be true:

- Large centralized compute is more powerful than portable compute

- Wired is better than wireless

- The public wants new things

- The tech industry grows to use/“use” the available processing power

As long as you’re not continuously comparing to AI in large centralized compute, what you’re really looking for is “when does portable compute become powerful enough to run AI models that are capable of meaningful work” and I’d say we’re already there and it’s getting better.


- Full time professionals do a better job of maintaining a reliable and secure service than end users

Also:

- local latency is lower than network latency

- latency is important for action games


This began with cloud. When software began running as a front-end in a browser, people began complaining about centralization.

But then it became normal.

The monopolization of knowledge and expertise is the next step. I don't mean as if it were intended, but it is the logical progress given the technological evolution. The cause is inventive structures: the tech is neutral (in my opinion), but the way in which it is used and deployed is subject to and disciplined by capital.


It was the same with cloud and software as a service. We underuse the power of our local machines and pay high cost for modest resources that are bandwidth constrained for most users.

One consequence has been lower power requirement for local machines. This is partly why a 2015 MacBook is still perfectly serviceable for basic use in this day and age.

The AI boom first reversed the trend, to now try to get back to that cycle.


People long ago stopped buying computers and started using Saas on their mobile devices instead. Ask HP.

HP was making shit laptops that barely worked a decade before SaaS was a known acronym.

Sure but businesses bought them and people bought them. Their quality is beside the point.

People keep saying that but I have never met anyone who doesn't own a PC or laptop.

Do you work in tech by chance? I work in an entirely non-technical field (to the point we barely use email), and I have several coworkers whose only “computer” is their phone or a tablet.

I guess the answer is Yes now but I used to work as a philosopher at university until recently. I literally never met a person, both inside and outside of professional settings, who owns a smart phone but doesn't own a computer. (There were, of course, plenty of people in the 1990s who owned neither a mobile phone nor a computer.) Most of the people I know use laptops, though, it has definitely shifted from PCs to laptops.

I guess it's because I used to work in a writing-based profession and mostly know academics.


I know youngsters who dont even have an email address. Though, this may change if they have to enter the workforce.

Lot of people using their office-notebooks at home, even if its not allowed. Most people out of tech do not have big hardware at home anymore.


A smartphone is the main / only 'computer' for a lot more people than you think.

This is complete conjecture on my part, but I bet if you're late 20s - early 40s, you probably have some form of pc/laptop laying around. But people 50+ (gen x / gen boomer), a phone is likely all you use or own. My mother, aunt, et. al operate totally through their phones. The same is true for my pre-teen, teenage cousins or cousins children (ipad generation).


There has been a relatively strong local model community since the days of llama-3. IMO, the number of non-technical people interested in qlora, adapters, parameter fine tuning etc is remarkable.

that was when RAM and GPUs were cheap. Now that is dying, too.

Only people who have no concerns about privacy would give up on it entirely.

But yes, it has been a test of just how few tokens you can get by on.


Don't think of it as a step back, it's just a point in a familiar cycle:

New application of computing requires a lot of compute -> compute centralizes -> compute improves, smaller, faster, cheaper -> compute decentralizes -> new application of compute is found -> (return to beginning of cycle)


Can you think of examples of this cycle? I know this is roughly what happened with mainframes, but I struggle to think of other times it went like that.

Maybe arcade games?


CGI rendering. To do Pixar quality animations you used to need racks and racks of servers and it still took months. Now anyone can do it, and we saw tons of slick animations on YouTube from indie studios as a result (before the AI slop cloning started I mean)

The first one was code breaking. The most recent was "cloud". If you look you will probably find others.

cloud? I feel like that's an example of things going the other way. It used to be every company would have either on on-prem or a colocated server at the nearest network hub - a fairly de-centralized system, and then everything went centralized with cloud platforms.

To be clear, I am not skeptical that it will work this way - I think it's pretty likely llm usage will be come a split of de-centralized and centralized. But I am not very convinced this is a natural law of technology.


Yes, we will. Eventually, specialized AI hardware (ASICs) will emerge that will be good for AI, but not much anything else. PCs are general purpose computers that are good at many things, but excel at few. There are quite a few startups working on it already.

There's also major not-startups working on it, such as Broadcomm: https://www.broadcom.com/info/ai/3point5d

I don’t see frontier AI ever happening in local machines. For the same reason that supercomputers don’t fit in your pocket/desktop.

But, the “good enough for most lay people” intelligence bar will for sure miniaturize, especially as inference ASICs get more specialized.


Supercomputer do fit in your desktop though. Most supercomputing challenges of the 80s or 90s fit comfortably on a modern home pc.

That’s not a supercomputer today.

But yes, we both agree that what was the frontier many years ago will fit on your desktop.


You know what that era has in common with fossil fuel? It takes a very specialized infrastructure and supply chain that you can limit with lobbying efforts and gatekeeping so that all the money only flows to you and your cronies.

> It feels like a step back towards mainframe era.

:insert Will Smith presenting meme:

The Cloud


The only way this may happen is when the internet were to be somehow destroyed.

Which would not be all too bad. It would also mean the end of stupid SaaS subscription services, and mass surveillance, adtech. And shitty propaganda.

And your local AI could emulate the good parts of the internet.


Propaganda would still propagate through more closed networks. There's propaganda on TV. And at the bus stop.

> And your local AI could emulate the good parts of the internet.

Like talking to people?


People did not live in social isolation before the internet existed.

In fact, it was closer to the opposite.


Why are you here, instead of having your AI emulate HN locally?

Trump and AI-power security research are both doing a good job of promoting installable software!

I never left the PC era, but the RAM prices kind of hurt me. I don't know when I would want to buy a new PC - it seems to be 3x the cost for barely any real benefits over the status quo.

Which is not a bad thing per se: most of use could use our devices a little longer than we usually do.

most games which require that big PC are poorly optimised and often times they arent even fun. these companies focus on visual fidelity and give all their engineers insane machines to build the games on. that has beenn destroying PC gaming way before AI/LLMs came into the picture.

I am using AI now to make a game engine that will run and make 'nice enough' graphics on simpler machines. things like laptops with iGPU and 4gb of ram.

U can still get quite ok graphics, and make very complex and rich gameplay systems using such a machine. It just needs to be the target machine while developing so the right tradeoffs are made.


Yes we will and we all know it. All those are raw materials.

Yupppp. My current conspiracy theory, with all of the increasing hardware costs and how easy decompilation projects are, is that there is going to be a major push to eradicate consumer hardware and keep all software in the cloud.

Everybody will have a mini PC for the sole purpose of streaming content, with no storage to keep anything on it.


Why would component vendors allow shortages to continue indefinitely for the benefit of hyperscalers and AI companies, especially given what may be years of pent-up demand in other markets?

And why would the game industry, considered as a whole, want to incur higher costs to exclusively deliver its product in a way that provides less value to the majority of its customers, many who won’t be willing to pay the higher prices required to maintain similar profits?

Recompilation at most threatens platform exclusivity as a business model. Otherwise, it’s just piracy with extra steps.

At most, I expect to see already existing trends towards more live service components and microtransactions continue, with digital delivery only and a required online component in many cases, but with most if not all of the actual game code and assets hosted and running locally.

As for non-gaming applications, content creation and a software development are two examples where "cloud native" workflows remain cost-ineffective in many market segments in spite of hardware price increases, and will remain so as long as cloud providers continue to nickel-and-dime customers for IOPS and compute.


I don't know how much of a conspiracy that is. If the current trend of hardware costs keep rising to the point of pricing people out of having any real compute locally, and chip makers actively de-prioritizing consumer-grade memory, GPUs, etc, companies will (more) heavily push thin clients and streaming for everything.

I really don’t see it happening at all, not with current trends, you can barely run Win11 on 8GB ram anymore

This kind of makes my point. Consumers won't be able to run things locally, so you end up with Win11 in the cloud and your device is just a glorified browser because that's all you can afford.

I would have laughed at the thought a few years ago, but now I am slowly starting to adopt some of the viewpoints of American second amendment hardliners.

It's just unfortunate that producing a half decent computing platform is significantly more difficult than a rifle (and that in the case of said hardliners, the capital is backing them, here it's working against us).


back to the mainframe era came with the insane proliferation of cloud everything, not with ai

There's a lot of hacking going on right now with small (qwen 3.x and gemma 4 based) and medium (deepseek flash and others) models alike.

Have an agentic enough setup and they'll do anything that the biggest closed models can. They'll also do more, making them the true frontier.

A sensible point of entry is a 2899$ Mac mini.

If you're not partaking that's only on you.


> A sensible point of entry is a 2899$ Mac mini.

> If you're not partaking that's only on you.

There's honestly nothing sensible about that for a lot of developer budgets across the globe. Don't assume most folks have $3k to burn.


Yes, but that's a lot of money if you don't already have the hardware, plus you'll still be paying for electricity costs. (No comment on relative capabilities.)

$3k being a point of entry for a pale imitation of the models being compared to is not very inspiring.

Surely this is a joke or sarcastic comment?

They absolutely can't do what, or more of what the biggest models can do. There's nothing frontier about small local Qwen or Gemma models.

2899$ gets you a machine that is just good enough to run some small models, slowly, with terrible context, requires a ton of tinkering and fine tuning, managing and constantly downloading a bunch of huge file blobs, etc.

Partaking those $2899 in most of the large cloud models would bring you much more productivity, much less boilerplate and time spent in setup, etc.

So.. just weird accusing people here of "not partaking" in AI when you're just essentially toying around if you're actually comparing local Qwen and Gemma's with frontier models.


Yes but then you'd have to give closed-ecosystem-ass Apple money, which is worse than giving it to Nvidia who at least support linux properly. And you still get prompt processing speeds of a leisurely sloth.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: