HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | thaeli's commentslogin

The launch industry defines payload as customer mass delivered to a target orbit. This does not include the mass of the launcher.

Kick stages are uncommon; most satellites raise their own orbits slowly, with onboard thrusters. When they are used, they are usually disposed of in a high parking orbit.


Exactly. So customer mass to orbit does not include whatever stage did the orbital insertion burn, released the payloads, and then immediately returned. So these numbers are not the full story to the questions surrounding the amount of metal being burnt/vaporized into the upper atmosphere.

The Shuttle did have limited engine out capability. The only in-flight engine-out (as opposed to a pad abort after SSME ignition and before SRB ignition, which happened five times) was STS-51-F with a successful abort to orbit. The various other engine-out contingency modes were never used, but they did exist.

Initially only single engine out was broadly survivable; after the Challenger disaster new abort procedures were developed that made two engines out survivable during all of flight and even all three engines out at some points.

The big caveat here is that most of these modes were never tested, and the risk of failure during the more demanding aborts was substantial. RTLS abort was famously not tested on STS-1 because it was considered riskier than going all the way to orbit on the Shuttle's first crewed flight.


I wouldn't call it incompetence. It's more a sign of government misalignment.

I see misalignment as a form of incompetence.

Incorrect. Governments can - and should - have goals beyond simple engineering problems. Traditionally government funds corporate and academic R&D which is then productised and commercialised by the private sector.

This is literally how the computing industry was built.

Ignoring those goals for short-term corporate profit is politically incompetent, and has terrible consequences - as most of us are about to find out.


What you describe isn't an issue of misalignment. Re-read the discussion thread. It's perfectly consistent for the government to prioritise long term prosperity. The issue is when government chooses not to prioritise aggregate social benefit because it is beholden to, for example, local and special interests. Maybe a particular local race needs to be won to secure a House or Senate majority, and in strategising and negotiating that win, they drop important policies which would have maximised long term prosperity. This is baked into how democracy works. It is messy, inconsistent, and frequently misaligned with long term prosperity. This is why government could not do what SpaceX has done.

Cost savings are one of the drivers for reuse, but not the only one. Maximum practical flight rate is another. F9's peak flight rate over the past couple years would not have been attainable without first stage reuse, simply because of the manufacturing bottlenecks on stages. And fairing reuse was openly driven by a limited capacity to manufacture fairings fast enough - it's not even clear that SpaceX is overall saving money there, but they are saving time, and their business model is based around putting as much mass in orbit as they can as fast as they can.

One interesting aspect to the need for flight rate is Starlink replacements ...

The planned constellation size is ~40,000 satellites (they currently have ~11,000), and the designed lifetime of the satellites is 5 years. Replacing 40K satellites every 5 years means 8000 per year, which would be 160 launches per year at 50 satellites per launch - i.e. a sustained 3 Starship launches per week just to replace satellites.

So, they'll need to be able to refurbish 3 starships (& boosters) per week, just to maintain the size of the Starlink constellation !!


No, they just have more Starships in the refurbish flow to accommodate the launch schedule. If you need to launch 3 a week, 6 will allow you to refurbish over two weeks and 24 will allow you to refurbish each for a month. There’s a reason they also designed a factory to make more Boosters and Starships.

Yeah, my glasses are a substantial part of my personal style and I'd be sad to have to go back to something generic looking. It's been a minus with other smart glasses as well.

Also I need to wear safety glasses with side shields frequently and would really rather be able to integrate there. Particularly relevant here since that's also in noisy environments where regular speech recognition struggles.


I really like the distinction between "prediction" and "generation" here. Thank you for putting that into words so clearly.


The generation is done by... prediction. It is making a guess based on weights (statistical likelihood) plus a pinch of wobbliness.

It's worth reflecting on the original domain jargon for selecting the next token: completion.


I know how LLMs work. I understand the output projection and logits and sampling just fine. I don't think we should call what is happening prediction because it is a misleading term with a lot of baggage associated with claims that LLMs are just statistically modeling language and "guessing" tokens without any internal representation of meaning. Since your reply is very short I can't tell whether you mean it in that sense or not.

And yes, I understand "prediction" is a standard term in the field. I just think it is a bad one and we should stop using it.


#1 seems like a feature, not a bug. The real problem is that health insurers in their current form exist at all.


Germany has non-profit sickness funds (Bismarck model). So you don’t have to ban health insurance companies when rolling out universal healthcare. Their freewheeling excesses have to be reined in. Access is a right. Standardize coverage and prices on both the insurer and hospital/doctor ends. Once everyone is in the same risk pool, there will no longer be a perverse incentive to deny claims for profit. A single standard plan will also have the negotiation power to drive down prices.


We are saying the same thing: I was stating what the desirable state would be.


Not for me. I tried out the high refresh rate thing, switched back to 60.. can't tell any difference at all. Same for high DPI vs "regular" DPI screens.

Screen flicker on CRTs with low refresh rates was terrible for me, but with modern flat panels.. nope, can't really tell the difference.


Huh. Maybe that’s why I find Claudish fairly easy to read.


For most of my life, I never quite “got it” about the night sky. It was pretty, but not THAT different away from cities.

I only recently learned that visual snow syndrome is a thing, and that most people don’t have it. For me, there is a faint background of multicolor static (analog TV on a dead channel, for those who remember that) on everything, all the time. Light washes it out, so it’s only in the deep dark that I’m absolutely surrounded by it. (It’s basically visual tinnitus, which in turn lead me to discover that I’ve also had auditory tinnitus my whole life, it’s just a soft static not a “ringing” so I never realized it was the same phenomenon.)


Huh, I just assumed everyone saw visual snow/noise in the dark, guess not. I was thinking of it like underexposed film grain.

I don't think I notice it that much with the night sky unless the stars are faint though.


I still think everyone sees a noisy image in the dark if they pay attention. Simply because the retina is underexposed. "Visual snow" usually refers to a more extreme condition where you see it even in good lighting.


I can't say that I do. Covered eyes or pitch black room, I don't see anything like "static", either stationary or moving.


Maybe you just don't notice it? It's most noticable in a dark, but not completely dark, room when the eyes got accustomed to the darkness.

To clarify, a similar case: most people are able to see Haidinger's Brush [1], even if they have never noticed it. Why? Because it's not very noticable, so they don't pay attention to it.

1: https://www.polarization.com/haidinger/haidinger.html


So you're living in the opening of Neuromancer: "The sky above the port was the color of television, tuned to a dead channel."


That sentence has changed meaning twice, depending on what generation you are, it's either "snow", solid blue, or a screensaver.


Never considered this, but what a clear example of how drifting language can cause us to lose information, even if it’s written down somewhere.


Kids these days don't even know what a channel is ;-)

(Well, except for YouTube channels)


It's one of those things which seem to exist on a spectrum too; I have it severely enough that some days I outright can't read and my vision distorts quite badly, and it's accompanied by a permanent migraine-like headache. On the other hand, many people I've spoken too experience little impairment at all.

It's a badly named syndrome in my view, since most people younger than me have no idea what TV snow is, and some of the symptoms aren't visual.


I have this as well, and it showed up suddenly about 9 years ago. Trying to observe the sky ever since is distressing because I remember how my visual field used to be.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: