HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | telebub's commentslogin

Are you replying to something else? I don't see the connection to a problem affecting a small number of websites or the suggestion of reporting them all to a browser maker to indirectly inform them.

No. This is a very old debate I'm bringing up. The criteria for being listed as an "infected site" is not clear enough.

Your example is how the site got infected. The types of infection is listed 2 or so paragraphs above that

What makes you so sure that kind of malware isn't being distributed by otherwise trusted 3rd-party scripts?

That's the standard definition of a supply chain attack. If the website maintainer was acting maliciously or incompetently, it wouldn't be a supply chain attack anymore.


If I’m about to enter my credit card information on a site that’s compromised, I don’t care if it’s because of infected first party code or infected third party code. I want my browser to say “bro this site is fishy, maybe don’t”.

I find this whole removal idea a bit lazy. In theory some logic possibly declares some aspects of the BOM/DOM must be JS for introspection reasons, etc, but the reverse can't really be true.. There's nothing that can declare things like XSLT must be more native than a little trick with a otherwise standard JS VM, so the unique security edges of delegating things to a second class backwards support level could be quite small.


This is not an intermediate; they presumably block the 8 bad intermediates already (there's the vulnerability website to confirm that) while blocking other intermediates that are not known to have any problem is more disruptive to (ex-)customers of eMudhra the shorter the grace period.


Here the user was the deployer and presumably owner of the deployment. An overall setup is only correct if they and the software define a setup that happens to be correct. The software is incorrect if it doesn't support the incorrect setup they require.


> The software is incorrect if it doesn't support the incorrect setup they require.

Is that what you intended to type?

Software is not required to support the requirements of every potential user. Only the ones they mean to support. That’s why Porsche and BMW ignore people complaining about how expensive they are. You aren’t their customer and they don’t want you.


A family of eight who buys a (classic) Porsche bought an incorrect car unless it is for an expensive gag like putting sugar in the gas tank then an EV would be incorrect, no?


As written you have stated that Porsche is wrong for ignoring this family's complaints. Because they didn't support an unsupported configuration.


You are confusing the wants of a manufacturer with a system that is being used by a person. The person owns the system that is either correct or incorrect for their needs and the manufacturer takes money and screws off. Or, you have the "soup Nazi" as proposed with the manufacturer makes sure you use the system as they imagined and not with a database setup beyond their control.


I'm not in perishable food so what do I know.. But organization wide food safety measurements are probably more important than the average process BS.. Performing a full heat cycling of a freezer while no one is present to confirm the correct device OTOH sounds idiotic.


We need only ask that these weak sciences also progress one funeral at a time to fix everything by canceling 18% of the economy.


Dual or quad core is not that unusual even in very cheap SoCs, but this particular CVE needs a kernel line from this decade. Thousands of other CVEs indeed..


I think your expectations are too high. The vast majority of criminals don't bother checking targets where there's not good evidence its easy or something has worked before.


That doesn't even make sense in this context lol


I cant really refute what you don't explain.

Just going from what Binance PR must believe about a laptop it seems unlikely to me that they've been tested in much depth by anyone with mafia tactics.


Great application of cross continental research by Blomberg. A typical Nigerian family of 3 (already atypical) is probably not spending one parents entire salary on electricity.


Isn't this just giving in if your only reasonable backup location is a US cloud that regularly has to negotiate with the US federal government. The only difference I see is that they have to resort to parallel construction.


> Isn't this just giving in if your only reasonable backup location is a US cloud

my backups are not in a US Cloud.

Contacts and calendar on self hosted carddav

Pictures and files on self hosted drive.

Deltachat on mail servers (non us hosted provider) and XMPP conversation backups.

I don't backup whatsapp automatically, only do manual exports once in a while of important conversations that get copied to my self hosted server. Whatsapp pictures and vids are automatically synched with syncthing.

I host encrypted backups for another tech savy relative on a server of mine and in exchange he also host space for me on his own local backup server. We are 2000km appart so it allows us to keep a safe backup in remote location in case of fire or natural disaster without relying on the cloud.

Only thing I have missing is an automatic backup test of random files to compare checksums. I have done test backups manually but last was a bit more than a year ago so it is time to run a new one and add this automation as well.


That's quite an approach, thanks for sharing. I still don't think it mitigates restoring within the US since they claim to have search rights within 100 miles of any international airport. Personally, I try not to fall into the trap of believing I need retention of data that doesn't fall into a few categories, most of which I would assume I will already be sharing with authorities through taxes, etc.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: