HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | teknologist's commentslogin

So long as their VPNs to Singapore stay working.

Google beats them on performance, and OpenAI beats them on price. I find CursorBench to be a pretty accurate representation for the most common use case (coding, and software architecture).

Grok Bot seems relatively popular, and it does launch and use Cursor and Cursor Agents.

Theo seems to dislike anything that isn't Anthropic Claude. Suspicious, to say the least. On CursorBench, a good measure of real-world coding tasks, Gemini 4 Carbon comes out top: https://cursor.com/evals

Every time I see a Theo tweet he's judging something on the most absurd metrics. Today for example, he was saying Astra 6.2 is bad because when he gave it a single line prompt telling it to create a new level for a game it used a name for the level that he'd seen before. Judging a model on how often it reuses a name is one of the most ridiculous benchmarks I've ever seen.

As far as I can tell, all his judgements are based on similarly absurd metrics, I don't know why people treat his preferences as valuable.


They have excluded all OpenAI models, though? Of course I doubt they'd have the highest scores but likely would be most price efficient.

No, they have not. But they don't seem to have the latest ones. I think that's because OpenAI announced that they will stop providing their models to Cursor.

https://openai.com/index/our-decision-on-cursor-following-it...


I do not like Theo, but he is transparent about his OpenAI bias. He criticizes Anthropic frequently - mostly for their hostile closed-garden policies.

I’m not sure Claude favoritism is fair; he loved OpenAI for a while. He just has really arbitrary and frankly bad takes imo

Depends on which is paying at the time I would think. YouTube influencers tend to have price lists.

Also, Google uses their own TPU architecture rather than GPU/Nvidia.

Beware of the paid influencers who don't disclose their affiliations in this space. Theo is another one who now talks smack about anything that isn't Claude. They bend reality to fit a narrative.

Even if they're not paid by the AI labs, they're bluechecks on X, they get paid by the view, so they stir up bullshit controversial takes just to get shared widely.

Why would he resign on this note? He could have powered through it for a couple more years, and asserted leadership.

Because the CEO serves at the pleasure of the Board. The board decided it was time for him to go.

Then it was a negotiation about how.

Sometimes people can see the writing on the wall and choose to not burn down their life’s work on the way out.


> Because the CEO serves at the pleasure of the Board. The board decided it was time for him to go.

That’s also why more recent tech companies got rid of that pesky independent board by having total voting control.


Not sure people have grasped how serious this all is; the second affair alone would fell most CEOs because it was with an employee.

But my guess is, he'd rather resign on this note than what will come out in a few weeks.


> the second affair alone would fell most CEOs because it was with an employee

I mean realistically, no it would not. They do not resign for that in general. It is tall order for them to resign or leave when there is credible or proven accusation of actual abuse or harassment, there is not even that in play.


No, they really do, even at big firms.

McDonald's, Intel, CNN, NBC, CBS, Astronomer, Best Buy, Nestlé, Kohl's, Comtech, BP, CBOE, Barclay's.

Not hard to find examples from the last ten years.


I checked CNN thing (picked randomly) and:

> At CNN, Mr Zucker faced criticism from those who believed the network gave too much coverage to the former president, especially during the Republican presidential primary. Mr Trump has also criticised what he saw as unfair coverage.

I will happily argue that affair was just an excuse for other reasons. His coverage was not pro-Trump enough.


> I will happily argue that affair was just an excuse for other reasons. His coverage was not pro-Trump enough.

Well you could, but considering:

1) Zucker's "too much coverage" that was internally complained about was him trying to be pro-Trump, not anti- (regardless of what the then-still-disgraced former President whined about)

2) his resignation came in 2022 while CNN was still largely free of the right-wing pressure campaign it has been under in the last 18 months pre-merger

3) … in the middle of an internal sex scandal investigation involving someone else, in the #MeToo era, when the company was trying to make it very clear that it would not tolerate such things

I think it would be quite a stretch to make your case.

Jeff Zucker was not even fired for the relationship, but for failing to tell the board about it as company rules said he must.

Again: top CEOs do indeed resign over this stuff. Because it is serious: it opens them up to blackmail and opens the company up to lawsuits.


I said "not pro-Trump enough". I did not said "anti Trump". Yes, it is long standing conservative tradition to call yourself victim when having pro-you bias.

2.) It was not free of that pressure, it was just not that super high yet.

My case is that sex alone wont make it. It is easy to make my case, you are kind making it for me by adding more reasons why it was not just afair on itself.


I'm supporting your argument by offering a straightforward, easily proved counter-argument to it? You're wrong, it's that easy.

> I said "not pro-Trump enough". I did not said "anti Trump".

He was not ousted from CNN for not being pro-Trump enough. If anyone at CNN ousted him for politics-related reasons, it would have been because he was too pro-Trump. Because he was, for example, helping Trump before the election debates, offering to have a weekly show with him etc. This pissed off a lot of his colleagues.

None of that is why he was fired (not least because it would have happened a lot sooner than 2022).

He was fired because he broke corporate rules in a way that embarrassed them when they were trying to boot out Chris Cuomo for being a genuine abusive boss.

That is the reason, end of story.


> If anyone at CNN ousted him for politics-related reasons, it would have been because he was too pro-Trump.

Oh, please. That was already time when everything Trump related was whitewashed and sanitized, biased pro-Trump. While conservatives constantly complained and managed to put mediocre conservative pundits in.

And even in YOUR story it is someone elses abuse that needed to happen for him to be pushed out - combined with political pressure. The affair alone is not something they care about. And even that abuse needed to happen during #meetoo, they dont care about that either outside large public pressure.


I know we're all very sensitive these days. But he was running a multi trillion dollar company.

I'm quite interested to know what you mean here, between the lines. OK, he was running a multi-trillion dollar company, are you saying currently it's a over-reaction because of that, and the reaction would have been justified if it was smaller/bigger company? I'm really not sure what the underlying point you're trying to make here.

The guy changed the world, heaven forbid he sleeps with a few extra women. They were age appropriate for him. The guy's getting more punishment than the Epstein class did.

It is not about the sex! It is about the corruption/lying to the board/misuse of company resources/risk of abuse of power/impact on other people's career progression.

He clearly is a high agency person, and has to be to have founded Nvidia. The board might have messed up here.

He has had undeclared relationships with two of his subordinates (one a direct report).

I think you don't understand that this creates _enormous_ legal liability for Nvidia. It's straightforwardly bad news and people get fired for it.


What constitutes “enormous legal liability” for a company of nVidia’s size?

The sky is the limit. The problem with high-level CEOs having affairs with subordinates is that they create extra scope for insider trading, for blackmail (and thus for espionage, corporate and otherwise), as well as the ordinary stuff like people defrauding the company in various ways, staff being compelled to keep the secret, staff finding that their own promotion is impossible because the person boffing the boss gets their job, the subordinate themselves effectively finding they can't break off the relationship, all sorts of stuff. Lawsuits all over the place and usually some other secrets come out.

Whether or not you're arguing that Nvidia should just say, well, the worst his shagging around is going to cost us is X billion, price it in and let it slide, as so many seem to be, I can't give you a number.

But ethics, the law, it actually does matter.


At the end of the day, all that really matters is impact on the bottom line.

And the board of that company decided that the risks he presented to the company outweighed the benefits.

He's facing one of the largest divorces in history, you don't think that would be a little distracting?

And if you don't know why leaders can't have relationships with their employees, that ignorance is on you. You're trying to insult other people but it just makes you look bad.


Can't legally, or are you just talking about social pressure/policing? Because everyone involved are adults, and knew what they were doing.

Besides that, it comes down to how well he's able to separate personal life and work, and whether he continues to add value for shareholders (which Nvidia has clearly been an absolute outlier at doing, during his tenure).

But it looks like they won't give him a chance anyway.


I guess I mean corporate rules with actual teeth.

A lot of marriages survive even after stuff like this. Especially in Asian cultures. The fact that his wife is White is the only thing that hurts him on his chances here.

She'd be stupid as hell to divorce him.


Or she'd be more than adequately rich, worth around $75bn, able to do whatever the hell she wants with the rest of her life, able to have impacts independent of him, and free of a sleazy worm who humiliatingly cheated on her twice.

“Twice” is public information. The things that happened twice have high probability to occur more often.

Indeed! There’s a whole “another shoe to drop” vibe around this.

Edit: and there it is. Two employees, not just one.


A multi-trillion dollar company... so the standards are lower?

I think the implication, rather, is that the bar for dismissal should be higher.

Those are effectively the same thing.

That does seem to be the way of the world lately. Sure this person is awful but look at the shareholder value they have created!

There is evidence of a second affair that is also problematic coming out, the BBC had some reports.

Presumably he was not given a choice by the board.

Time will tell if this is the best for the company... I hope he was a very hands-off CEO and mostly did marketing gigs.

My understanding is that he was a very consolidated-power CEO. No real second in command / replacement-in-training.

But that doesn't preclude there being a lot of competent talent on the second rung. (I think 60 people reported directly to him.)


He's famously incredibly hand-ons. I think he has something like 60 executive direct reports.

> I hope he was a very hands-off CEO and mostly did marketing gigs.

Hard to imagine that could have been the case given that he was Nvidia's CEO from the very beginning.


My understanding is that he has been very hands on, but it's also not that unusual for people who have built successful businesses to "check out" once the role chances from building an early-stage company to growing a large one. Whether or not that works obviously greatly depend on whether the people around them can take up the slack.

Resignation means that he can start liquidating his shares without input from shareholders or directors.. Divorce will also be likely. Affairs with the staff would matter if he had promoted people; who knows what else is in that stack. He had planted his own kids with no experience in tech as executives there too . He is a zillionaire though and he has enough cash for many generations.

Don't worry about him.


I'm concerned about how this affects the industry, not his personal life

Hopefully the industry is resilient enough to not depend greatly on one person. Otherwise it isn't really much of an industry.

He didn’t resign he “resigned”

Because it would be damaging to the company which he founded and has a massive stake in, both financial and personal.

I guess even if Jensen Huang leaves scorched earth, he will have sufficient money for the rest of his life. On the other hand, any other person who invested into Nvidia stocks will have a much more serious problem. :-)

So, it would not be a dumb idea for Jensen Huang to leave scorched earth and "let the world burn" (and in particular cause utter panic in the AI sector). :-)


Could have just powered through it. I'm surprised he decided to resign.

I'm not sure he decided to resign. "X has decided to step down" is often PR speak for "X was forced to step down".

Both of these scandals individually are usually pretty rough to weather, together they were essentially guaranteed to have him forced out by the board. He's choosing to resign the same way a cop under investigation resigns to avoid more public consequences and to hope to sneak away to a new job.

Can't help but wonder if he is also getting out while the getting is good.

He's getting out while he can without being forced out. A second in the company affair came out already.

He is at retirement age and a zillionaire. So he is going to start cashing as he is no longer required to report the sale of the stock. He is going to liquidate.

Also, there are signs that the bubble is weakening. Probably a good time to leave that specific game.

Pushing the sale of the chips into circular ecosystem was a sign that it was topping too.

I know. But the legacy story looks pretty bad at this point. He's been running it for decades.

Gates did it too and they still think he is a guru which he never was by the way; all of them are into this stuff when the hit their 50s feeling left out of the game while accumulating zillions.

Whether he can do that might be determined by any divorce proceedings, I guess.

He's not going to be left with zero from the divorce proceedings.

The criminal ones might, though.


How integral is Nvidia to the success of LLMs? Seems like a few companies could step in and put that TSMC capacity to good use...

I'm sorry, who exactly? NVIDIA essentially has no real competition because of how wildly successful they are.

Google, Microsoft, Amazon, AMD, Apple, Huawei...

These aren't all entirely drop-in replacements, there are some trade-offs involved, but there are many companies with alternatives that could take Nvidia's market if they stall.


> Google, Microsoft, Amazon, AMD, Apple, Huawei...

Which of those sell chips at the Nvidia caliber sell to AI model builders in the US (not use internally)?


Apple just needs to bring back the Xserve :p

Google

Not internally, which is what Googles TPUs are for

Google started selling TPUs externally a few months ago: https://www.networkworld.com/article/4200864/google-has-star...

Haiku 5.5 xhigh/max is surprisingly capable; it just uses too much context.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: