HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | techgnosis's commentslogin

I felt the same way, and made a CashApp account, but I don't think it matters. It didnt say anything about the fraud account having her email address. It just had her name and they inputted her social. I don't think there's anything you can do but pray.


This story is making me angrier than any story in the news right now


Sam this really hits a nerve just thinking about all my friends and elderly family that are not tech savvy.


I don't think technical knowledge really comes into play here, which is exactly why it's causing such anxiety. If you're a U.S. citizen, enough of your identity is available for sale that this could happen to you, and there's nothing you can do about it.

You can't keep your PII safe because government and financial institutions have it, have already lost it repeatedly, and keep exposing it. You can't prevent these types of accounts from being opened because credit blocks and monitoring don't come into play with them. You can't monitor it yourself because the accounts don't show up on credit reports and there's no way for you to find out they exist.

The victim in this case was randomly selected. It could have been any person in the country, because literally every single one of us has had the minimum info needed to create a Cash App (et. al) account leaked at least once. Some people commenting here have probably had accounts opened in their names and never knew about it, only because the police weren't as malicious as the guys handling this case, or didn't feel like bothering to investigate at all.


I can't blame any motorist, for any reason, for hitting someone crossing the interstate. If you walk across I-80 then your life is forfeit.


Yeah, this has echos of that Uber incident in Phoenix where the lady was jaywalking across a divided highway.


"And yet...you are part of society. Interesting..."


Sorry, my point was that I don't think the average person understands they're constantly making use of data centers.


Perhaps not but there's a vast difference between the infrastructure that had been used prior to the current boom in hyperscalers. If I had to choose between DoorDash and breathing the exhaust generated by 30+ gas generators I know what I'd pick.


> exhaust generated by 30+ gas generators

The utility monopolies are partly/mostly to blame for this. Their rates have become so disconnected from reality that it's cheaper to install your own power generation. They've all been posting record profits, up 50% where I am, in the last 5 years, as rates continue to increase.

I'm sure the utility companies are ecstatic how the blame as been put squarely on data centers.


Maybe utility power is more expensive because it has to pay for pollution mitigation?


Maybe they shouldn't be profiting so heavily if that's the case?

But yes, they say it's green energy requirements/expansion. But, they're also very good at making excuses, including when they're old equipment erases whole towns due to fires they started, from leaving it all unmaintained to help with those record profits.


Yup. The headline is also about opposing more datacenters. The AI datacenter boom is now approaching 6% of US GDP and it's not surprising so many are feeling unnerved about the massive footprint of this tech on not only the economy but their physical spaces.


Maybe if they had, they would have opposed them earlier. On the whole, I'd say the surveillance industry has benefited much more from widespread ignorance than it has suffered.


Doest mean we need so many of them.


I disagree. There is a huge difference between web host data centers and hyperscale compute data centers. It's disingenuous to use the same term to refer to both of these things. People are mad about the hyperscalers who want to pollute low income neighborhoods with noise and smog. Traditionally, data centers have used grid power, used far less power, and created far less noise than a "compute center".


Ironically enough I could have Codex make this for me in like 5 minutes. If there's a published API, a CLI is always within your grasp.


You're talking like you're old. You are --25-- my friend, young. No reason to resign yourself to the idea that your friends are all too old.


Not the OP but I would guess its a combination of things

1. The style and motif. I've never met someone who got interested in Linux and didn't immediately appreciate the look and feel of the terminal. People see hackers and fast scrolling text on TV and in movies and it's just fun. Lord knows I was and still am obsessed with CLI and TUI stylings. It brings me joy.

2. It's a lot easier to get started writing a TUI or a CLI. Picking a GUI framework is not easy and many times they are not fun to use. You can only use so many languages to write a GTK app or a QT app. You can use almost any language you want for a CLI tool.

3. CLI and TUI tools are way more universal. I don't have to care if you run GNOME or KDE or if you have GTK-3 or GTK-4 installed or whatever. CLIs and TUIs just work. I can also distribute a single static linked executable instead of a .deb or a Flatpak or something more difficult.


Also, you can control it remotely using something lightweight like SSH. VNC is not a great experience most of the time.

Though I usually prefer a webui.


I almost lost my Google account because of Safari. I bought some official Google USB keys https://store.google.com/us/product/titan_security_key?hl=en...

I setup two of them for my Google account but I made them both in Safari. Only one of them worked. What if both of them failed? I would have been fucked.

I re-made them on Chrome and they both worked.


Seems like its just a bunch of young engineers making bad architecture decisions. Not sure I would blame the culture of vibe coding everything. It might just be bad taste.


If you blindly trust frontier LLM architecture 'decisions,' they often do look a lot like what a young/junior engineer would do.


Yeah I feel this. My strongest passion in computing is simply learning how the machine and OS work. The code I would write would usually be experiments, not projects or tools.

I'm less pessimistic than the author though. There is always room for people who know what they are talking about. Take a deep breath.


I wish that I could agree with you that "There is always room for people who know what they are talking about." I think that you are right in the long term. Eventually we will return to a world that values people who know what they are talking about.

In the short term, I have seen a lot of managers and other higher-ups talk about how we do not need to worry about low-level details anymore. In their minds, we are now all designers and architects, so we do not think about the small implementation details that ultimately do matter for performance and reliability.

People who know what they are talking about worry about all of the details from the big picture down to the small scales. We can still operate using abstractions like designers and architects, but we must know enough to choose the right abstractions that account for the concrete details properly. I've discussed this point earlier this year [1] using the tree swing diagram [2].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46422597

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_swing_cartoon


> I'm less pessimistic than the author though. There is always room for people who know what they are talking about. Take a deep breath.

But what will their day to day look like? Meetings?

Previously, I'd have to work days undisturbed to get important stuff out of the door. There was effort involved to reach an elegant solution that fit business need.

Now I'm a meat bag pressing enter on a "recommended" option Claude already figured out was the best approach.


> Now I'm a meat bag pressing enter on a "recommended" option Claude already figured out was the best approach.

And how long can that last? We’re expensive meat bags…


> Now I'm a meat bag pressing enter on a "recommended" option Claude already figured out was the best approach.

If you are constantly thinking claudes approach is the best then perhaps you were not that good of an engineer to start with.


Fair, but the real question is what this person's manager thinks, as that tends to carry the day. And at the moment, there is an enormous gulf between what the managerial class believes LLMs can do and what people in the trenches know LLMs actually can and cannot do--not as a matter of current frontier capabilities, I might add, but more ontologically.


lmao


I couldn't possibly predict but I just doubt things will be as bad as everyone thinks, they never are.


Denial Anger [Bargaining] Depression Acceptance


Kinda feels more like [Denial]? What bargain am I making?


One suggestion for the feeling that has been great for me. Finding a hobby where you can focus on sweating the details. Detach it from economic imperative (the core definition of a hobby, you dont make money from it). Ham radio, maker and micro electronics, woodworking, calligraphy, music. Of course there are more technically advanced solutions to the problem, that's not the point. The point is the effort and discovery.


That would be cool, given an ample income stream of free money to support this indulgence...


I was never the best programmer and never was to keen on building things or providing some value to users. I'm more interested in how systems work, especially computers and the OS, and so far, LLMs haven't taken that away from me. If programming and solving problems had been important to me, I'd probably have a problem right now. While I feel for OP, what interests him most—namely, understanding things and developing an intuition for them—is not a productive activity in the sense that it’s not about building or producing things. But the job of a software developer has always been exactly that and LLMs take an ongoing trend to the extreme. I think people like OP have no choice but to separate their personal interests from their job, as hard that may be.


Interesting. You don't feel like you were building an edge with your understanding of said systems or OS?

I'm very interested in systems as well, but being less sure about the future (on whether this is something I really need to think about, or whether I'll get opportunities to work much at this level), I started reading about such topics a fair bit less.


You act as if there's only two types of people, the ones who are competent and the ones who are not. But there are plenty of people who are competent at a certain task, which will no longer be needed soon. It would require extreme hubris to think that you are one of the few who is competent at some task that LLMs can categorically not perform.


> There is always room for people who know what they are talking about. Take a deep breath.

In the long run, I'm certain you're correct. In fact, "vibe coding remediation" has been a big business boon for us.

But the capital owners and managerial class can remain irrational far longer than experts can remain solvent...


Room where? You're obviously not going to hire someone for their knowledge alone in late 2026... ChatGPT probably knows more than you know in every domain. What questions could I ask you that ChatGPT wouldn't be able to answer?


ChatGPT is a fantastic encyclopedia for knowledge retrieval and even is occasionally accurate!

It doesn't yet know when I brushed my teeth last, what specific foods in what quantities give me heartburn/indigestion, what that funky smell from my running shoes might be.

It can write pretty good code on a recursive loop when its provided a clear target. It can write better code when it has someone who understand architecture guiding it. It can review code reasonably well as well.

ChatGPT tied to robotics might even be able to do more interesting things!

It does pretty poor on highly specific knowledge where a RAG better supports -- something like Agent Search at GCP or AI Search at Cloudflare. But it can synthesize.

In effect, we've built an amazing library registry and need to up our librarian skills and the skills of people or systems that can use the information the librarian and their system can find.


The point of the knowledge is that it helps you ask the right questions, not so much the ability to answer them.

Knowledge has been available just by asking Google for decades now. The LLM makes it easier but it's a difference of degree not of kind

Until the models are 100% reliable knowledge will be required in order to quickly spot issues and work efficiently with the model to address them.


The room comes from recognizing that, in many many domains, you don't even know the questions to ask.


Beautifully said.

I do wonder though about the optimizations within it, what could be the most optimal way to achieve such room (ie. knowing which questions to ask)

Yes, learning and tinkering is still really the greatest way to achieve that

but I think what I am talking about can be better simplified with the analogy of a gym: previously what used to be necessary (manual work/labour) but when most people got into information work, even then there was/is a need for it (physical work), then we saw the evolution of machines specifically designed to optimize for it and we got machines specifically designed for this training, which helped push people's body to their absolute limits.

I do wonder if an hyper-optimized environment of learning and for asking questions (or more so knowing the know how on which questions to ask), this whole process might be optimized for it and what that process might would look like is a source of curiosity to me.

A relevant video which talks about similar topics: Bodybuilding for the mind: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0DtxUJ6rAc


Entirely agree with you, but I also lend some credence to the worry that capital owners and the managerial class might not want to pay a six-figure salary for "knowing the questions to ask".


I'd be lying if I said I hadn't spent any hours worrying about it. But on the other hand people pay for exactly that when it comes to law, accounting, actuaries, and whatever other white collar professions. I am nervous but optimistic for the time being.


They pay for tangible "deliverables" from those professions, too, not pure thought and judgment. One could probably argue that, as with programming, one has to have written a lot of code in order to think in code at a higher level, so to speak, although I can't say to what extent that's true in each of those domains.

However, the first part applies to programmers, too. A lot of the value of code _was_ simply in the fact that it was written, so you don't have to write it yourself. I'm not suggesting there isn't more to the value proposition, but the value destruction is there.


You won’t hire someone to answer questions for you; you might hire someone to make decisions for you. And domain expertise is still very useful in both making good decisions and convincing other people to trust your decisions


ChatGPT doesn't actually know a thing, and will happily give you false information right alongside true information. Using an LLM to provide knowledge is a foolish choice.


Know what to ask is about as important as the answer. You can't do that very well without domain knowledge.

I'm not sure how it plays out in 5 or 10 years, but that's how it is now.


Maybe people will be hired for the question they can actually ask and not for the raw knowledge they have


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: