HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | tappio's commentslogin

I don't see much reason not to self-host a properly built password manager like Vaultwarden or something similar? The clients keep a local encrypted copy of the vault, so the server only needs to be up for syncing. If it went down for a week, you probably wouldn't even notice unless you were saving new logins. And even if the server got hacked, everything on it is encrypted. Why do you think it should not be selfhosted?


you just listed all the reasons why you don't need to self host yourself


Thanks, on these topics I feel like I’m fucking crazy for not wanting to self host.

If you believe that the technology works, that encryption is happening and that the decryption is only happening on your local machine then why in the fuck would I host this myself?

You need to believe that it does not work when they do it, but does work when you do it.

I have not seen any evidence of that.


It works just fine when they do it as long as they want, that is not the point. For me self hosting is a mostly a question of independence and digital sovereignty. We've seen all kinds of service providers turn into garbage over time, so I'd rather not rely on a company that needs to extract as much money from me as possible.


So what do you think the threat is? That they’re skimming data off with their extension? That they’re going to close up shop and take your encrypted vault with them? That they’re lying and storing your master and then peeking at your vault?

In order for snooping to be true, the extension would need to phone home what you’re viewing and I think that would be a pretty big no-go with everyone.

In order for them to close shop and take your vault… do you have any serious reason to assume that might happen? I’m sure it’s happened with X or Y obscure company before. Does it seem likely at bitwarden’s size? Is this threat not just as equally remedied with your own paper backup?


There are a lot of ways they can make the service worse without doing anything illegal. I would not be not worried about my secrets, I would be worried about all other things they can do when they sit at my browser.

The top comment in the post has a blog post which already shows that they are hiking prices without proper notifications, etc. To me it seems that Bitwarden is in a state where the software is pretty much complete, and majority of further development will go into capturing more value.

While "enshittification" might not happen here, its a typical pattern and there are many early signs here. When you selfhost things that just work, you need to worry far less about it.

Like, there are just so many things they can do. Their plugin already knows where you visit, they can sell your visitor data if they want. They can just increase prices. They can start making stupid limitations that force you to upgrade. They can remove possibility to export your data, claiming its a security feature, making leaving as hard as possible. They can start spamming you with all new obscure features and some NPS surveys and what not. Nothing bad, but increases cognitive load.

If you don't mind the risk, good for you. It is great that everyone can choose for themselves.


If you have endless compute and you keep poking this toy, I'm not at all surprised you get all kinds of outcomes. Even without anykind of instructions I would guess that the models will align towards some goal and do stupid shit.

However, I really doubt its cost effective to do anything like that with these models.


> you keep poking

This is waving over engineering an agent with tools, harness, prompts, and loops. The models are still just next token predictors and everything, including predicting more than 1 token, is the result of outside "poking"

LLMs can't and don't "want" anything. If you don't specify a task even the smartest one will just ask you what you want and if you tell it to be creative, you'll get mundane slop.


Yes, you need a way for the model to interact with other systems, and a way to preserve memory over context windows. And then you keep poking it ("agent loop"). Poking itself does nothing without the other ingredients.

And yes, you need something to start from, but if you ask it to "do something" and loop it to endlessly ("poking"), you will get some interesting outcomes. So yes you need some initial prompt or task, but that can be "do something" and if you keep asking it everytime it finishes to "do something more". I suspect it will not start saying "no" but rather... it will find some stupid meaning and then drift towards what ever goal it guesses you mean.

I'm unsure whether we agree or disagree on the topic.


I think this is pretty insightful actually, the fact that even something as basic as predicting more than one token is really in effect the result of an outside harness. More complex things like memory, where people implement them using RAGs or vector databases, I would definitely classify as poking and honestly seem like a hack to me. And this is what I've been thinking for a while: it's hard to reconcile the idea that we can get "AGI" (however you define it) with such a system that is completely stateless. Yet, despite this statelessness, they can go ahead and solve Millenium Prize problems (with sufficient compute). It's hard to reconcile.


Perhaps our own statefullness is a hack of nature. We have electrical signals in our brains, neurotransmitters, neuron growth. By any reasonable measure it’s a hack on top of a hack. But it works well enough for us to get buy. So it does for the agents.


That is true that intelligence is kind of a "freak of nature" in a way, but it's also true that even single neurons are extremely efficient, and the brain has a lot of recurrence that isn't represented at all really in today's artificial neural networks.


Good argument going here but here is what internet tells me about 'facts':

Its about the same amount of population who have access to clean water and who have access to internet, and that's maybe about 75% of global population for both. Don't know how they overlap, but probably there is people who have no access to internet but have access to clean water and the other way around.

In absolute terms that is still billions of people. Billions.


with a good enough LLM you can greatly increase the capability to build a functioning well (and other basic infrastructures) in remote and undeveloped areas without great technical knowledge, they are very good as assistants for practical tasks where you can give feedback step by step on what is happening


There are privacy respecting ad brokers that dont require user tracking. Its just that people are too lazy or greedy to use those.


There are many analytics solutions that dont require cookies. You can do aggregated analytics just fine without. Saving preferences does not require consent either.


My understanding is that any front-end analytics solution will require consent. You're right about explicitly set preferences. I was mixing that up with inferred preferences.


It depends on what is to be analyzed.

How many requests per second are being served? How many error codes were delivered to clients? How quickly the service responded? Service logs without PII? All perfectly fine to aggregate and analyze without consent.


How long did it take x user to navigate from x screen to y screen is one of the most valuable metrics for any site, and most people consider this to require consent. Or at least it not being worth the risk to not ask.

Acting dense like this isn't productive... And literally this information would be stores as anonymous user 12345, but that still would require consent (probably, or at least arguably).


That can be implemented. Within a session you don't need to know it's the same person tomorrow, so a per-day key derived server-side is enough to measure that someone took 40 seconds from x to y. No cookie, no localStorage, nothing stored on the device, nothing to consent to. Hash ip + user agent + your domain with a secret salt that rotates and is destroyed every 24 hours, and you are on the safe side. Of course, recognizing users across days requires consent. But is that really necessary?


Or use some JS to put the time-on-page in the next request, right?

Is it a violation to send data that could theoretically be used for more invasive tracking than you actually do? I don't think so, or else you'd need consent just to receive an IP packet.


In the world of zscaler, CGNAT & corporate proxies, IP address is nowhere near enough.


>How long did it take x user to navigate from x screen to y screen is one of the most valuable metrics for any site

Stats like that are only used to implement dark patterns better and justify user hostile decisions since pretty much the time the idea of telemetry was introduced. Otherwise, we'd live in the world of perfect web ui and we're not.


that's not true at all, plausible can be configured to require 0 consent


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: