This is a very, very common story for many tech corporations. They find a place then fail to adapt. Adaptec (ha ha) is another example that could not adapt.
This inability to adapt is inherent in the corporate business model. Look at Apple. They have a chicken that lays golden eggs. Then the chicken dies. Oops. So
they invest in speculative funding of massive proportions. Just ask AI and it will tell you.
Maybe there needs to be some other form of business that can do better?
Didnt Adaptec invest heavily in Fibre Channel? From what I remember from Computer History Museum CEO interview they went all in on FC and didnt see a point investing in InfinityBand as they saw it as also ran.
The issues around privacy are inherent in an internet that is paid for by targeted advertising. If there is privacy there is no way to pay the small amounts for email for example.
If we want privacy, we need an alternative business model.
The Internet was in many ways a better place before data capitalism came along so the likes of Google and Facebook could monetise.
We had email and it worked just fine. You got an account via your ISP or paid a small amount for a separate service and perhaps a custom domain that you controlled yourself. Centralising this with the likes of Google is not progress.
We had more content than anyone could ever consume in a lifetime on the Web even back then. It was mostly created by people interested in sharing for personal satisfaction and perhaps the enjoyment of a good discussion that followed or by organisations that benefitted from sharing that information freely. It wasn't done with a direct profit motive based on metrics like page views. We didn't have endless AI spam designed to host endless auctioned ad spots diluting the good stuff.
So here's my proposed privacy-friendly alternative business model: You don't get to harvest personal data for reasons unrelated to whatever products or services you're providing to willing consumers and if you do then we throw you in jail. I'm pretty sure the Internet would find a way to continue providing the functionality that is actually useful. I'm pretty sure the signal/noise ratio online would be much better too.
Civil damages can become merely a "cost of doing business".
Jail time for the responsible executives makes it personal for the decision makers. Obviously there still needs to be due process. It would be sensible to have stages where there are clear warnings given by the relevant regulators with indications of the specific remediation actions required and then a reasonable amount of time to actually implement that remediation before anyone is getting carted off in handcuffs for non-compliance.
I am not generally in favour of piercing the corporate veil but in cases of flagrant and deliberate disregard for the law I think there is a point where it becomes justified and perhaps even necessary.
I see the point. My misgiving is that jail time means the government can just refrain from enforcing it because the leaders have found favor with one another.
A data breach of 10 million records, times $10k per offense, might not deter Google, but it would raise the eyebrows of smaller violators. An industry of class action lawyers might emerge to specialize in those claims.
I don't think that this is a hard problem, if you look at it the right way: after the fact. It is the end state that is important.
Here are the end states:
Choice 1: You pulled the alarm when you believed there was reasonable cause. An ordinary person would believe the same.
------
Outcome 1: It was only a bag, so you look foolish and maybe have people annoyed that you stopped the train for nothing.
Outcome 2: The person could have damaged their arm seriously. You did a good deed and look good and maybe people are annoyed that you stopped the train.
Choice 2: You do not pull the alarm when you believed there was reasonable cause, as above.
----
Outcome 3: Only a bag so the person is annoyed that you did not and maybe other people.
Outcome 4: The person suffered severe injury. People are annoyed that you did not stop the train. You are clearly morally wrong and have lost part of your humanity.
Given that you reasonably thought the person's hand was in the door, the only ethical and moral action is to stop the train. It makes no difference what actually happened after the fact.
While the other possible outcomes may be unpleasant, the one where you stood by and let a person be hurt is the worst.
This is not an idle speculation. Once I was driving on an inter-state and a person who was seemingly drunk came zooming up, weaving in and out of traffic crossing lane lines. I could have called, highway patrol and did not.
My exit came up and after I took it I heard on the news that there had been an accident on the highway, in my direction a few minutes later. I don't know it was the drunk, but it could have been. No math, no analysis will save you from losing some of your humanity when you could have saved someone from harm and choose not to do so.
[formatted for better clarity. Hopefully]
Here I think you are trying to make this from a hard problem into an easy one, but a lot more hinges on your use of "reasonable" and "ordinary".
That then becomes the crux of this; someone who hears "hey, hold the door" and pulls the brake is entirely different world from this scenario, even if they held the belief that someone was in danger.
In the real world moral decisions are incredibly complex because they always have an element of uncertainty about the state of the world and the effect your actions will have on it.
So in the end, judging real life moral decisions always comes down to applying some standard of reasonableness; that's the hard problem and it is irreducible.
Problem is, we live in a society filled with sociopaths who do not care about injuring someone else to save 1-2 hours of their own time. Look at all the comments on this site defending Huang's affairs. Seems our society has lost any sense of morality.
But this is really socialism. It was not a bailout of banks, it was socialism for wealthy. Did the people lose their houses? Yes! What about the people who made obscene profits from lending money to people when they should not? Did they lose their money? No. We - the taxpayers, the ex home owners - gave them money.
What about socialism for the egg industry? When the centralized chicken stocks got a disease, we people who were paying usurious prices for food, also provided payments to ensure the wealthy owners did not suffer.
Socialism for the wealthy === good, socialism for the poor === evil. Hmmm. Oh no that can't be so lets call socialism for the rich "a bailout".
Since we force people on food stamps to work now, maybe with this "bailout" we should force those people to work minimum wage jobs?
Nah, the wealthy would have been fine either way. Bailouts are done to placate the common voter and keep their lights on. The great depression didn't see the rich and powerful starving in most cases.
The bailouts were loans, which returned slightly more than was borrowed.
Besides, business were net tax payers. It's perfectly reasonable we lend them back some of their own money so they can continue to pay taxes next year.
The big problem with the internet - which is very dysfunctional - is not censorship but propaganda. Everyone on the internet is selling something because that is the only way to pay for being on the internet.
If the people who pay for the internet are not the users then who will the internet serve? Not the users. and since corporations are known soully (as in that is their soul) what would you expect? If people who want to profit by targeting people with lies pay for the internet, is that censorship? Well sort of - but maybe worse.
We need a community internet task force. Lets start one. Request for comments.
RFC.. but we would have to agree what the ground rules are. I somehow suspect that those will be will be somewhat different ( kinda like some would argue against/for codes of conduct ) person to person. Still, if we could upend at least some of the underlying commercial interest or even the need to rely on advertising, it could be something.
One persons propaganda is another persons truth. Who are you or your task force to decide? The big problem with the internet is it gives dumb people access to each other.
Was this a serious comment? It made me realise that prior to the Internet, information flow was controlled by journalists or through peer reviewed papers and academic forums. People without advanced education would, generally, be limited to people in their local area.
I feel like it is generally a flippant but serious comment. A lot of social problems right now are caused by the fact that rather than having to travel to some large city for a meetup with people that have your particular neuroses, against the friction of well-adjusted people in the real world, now there is a fan club one click away that will ratify whatever fake illness/condition/problem that you have with no serious pushback. A LOT of personal, social, and political problems right now basically boil down to this.
This makes so much sense, this is why I like Hacker News, you get smart people from different political views all having interesting and healthy discussions.
That just points out that another real problem with the internet is that everyone's voice carries the same weight in ways it didn't used to. Every city has a few folks who believe aliens walk among us or otherwise wear tinfoil hats, but their message was limited to AM radio and cable access, and it was clear their content was not of the same journalistic level as the three major networks used to be - used to, because they've also changed. For example, there is conclusive, repeatable and verifiable evidence that the world is not flat, and it shouldn't be so easy to make convincing content that seems like it is.
"We"? I think you can look to the history of the 20th century for your soul mates. The kind of thinking you express in your comment always ends with wholesale murder and mass torturing of innocent people to death.
In the past we had communities. They provided us with a context of meaning for our lives. We have lost that. So the context people have for their lives is either money, or just themselves.
Many people have not even experienced community these days. Imagine where you feel part of something bigger than yourself. A gestalt, where the whole is greater than the sum.
We People grew being in that situation - we would hunt, farm, fix things, make things - better not just for ourselves but for our community. It became our nature, just as it has became the nature of sheep dogs to herd.
Imagine a sheep dog who lives a life with no sheep. They have all that built into their nature and never get to be that. That is you and so many other people. So there is your challenge.
It is interesting that you say that, because it may explain my relative ease with this particular transition. Community ( as understood these days -- not exactly a neighborhood, but not just your household either ) was not really my guiding light before so its potential loss is not as pronounced to me. In other words, loss of that context does not visibly affect me.
In my opinion TypeScript is not a feature. Why? 90% of the benefit of TypeScript can be obtained by using `foo({duck, clock})` pattern. And at 90% of the cost and time. TypeScript, like Java, is beneficial in situations where an error is catastrophic. That is not my situation nor the situation of what 90% of programmers?
So to the bro who wrote the otherwise interesting article I say "Just strip the types bro". You can do it!! You like it? You do it!
[Rant of course, but if you had wasted as much of your life writing types in Java you would probably rant as well. Recipe thinking sigh.]
Time to F*$k the internet. The whole concept of anonymous IP addresses was broken but worked for a long time. Now it is just stupid. Just like domain names. (Are more names used by squatters than real?). And email as identity? Time to engineer solutions and create a new protocol layer.
This is not a hard problem. It just requires that someone build a certification wall. The IETF should have done this long ago, right?
Email has been turned into a by-the-corporation, for-the-corporation service. Corporations need DMARC so they can control email and the ability to spam. The spam I cannot block is spam from Google.
If you decide to think about this, you will quickly realize that email is f*ked and needs to be forked. Perhaps we need a Community Email Initiative that blocks corporations and only allows Community members.
Trust is the one thing you can't buy on the Corporate Internet.
I am sure many people will be offended and down vote this comment because they cannot conceptualize an internet without Corporations.
You can do this right now, and you don't even need to fork anything. E-mail is an internet scale protocol that's not owned or ownable, except by convention. Since you specifically want to cut out Google, and their attempts to capture E-mail are what makes rolling your own E-mail hard anyway, just go for it.
Depending on how hard you want to make it, you can slap all the parts together yourself or use something like Zimbra, Mailcow, iRedMail, mail-in-a-box.
The advantage over a fork, whatever specifically that means, is any service that needs E-mail as an identity verification, still works.
What I am proposing is that community email servers can talk to each other. I have email servers setup - all the hoops - for my community. I want others to set up community servers and be able to interoperate. My server can send and receive from other communities. No corporations, no tracking. If your sever spams it gets dropped from the federation.
Yes it is more complex, and there will be problems and issues. But hey, if we can have crypto currency why can't we get emails?
let's say this federation has three communities, a, b, and c. you run a, I run b, and my spammy friend runs c. C is my friend, and I'm going to keep allowing him to send me email, but you drop him, because he spammed you.
that's literally how email works today, unless the federation can supersede my authority as an operator to choose who may send/receive with me, at which point it'd stop being a federation anyway.
You are thinking of approved domains only, and perhaps people can vote them out. But, what you are describing is an RBL (in this case a real time whitelist instead). I like the ability for existing members to be able to vote out other members, but you run into the issue of spammers creating a million domains and then being able to vote out all legitimate members.
Yes, email is just completely broken. It's not private, sender identification is mediocre at best (and nonexistent without things like DMARC and SPF), and all the kludges thrown up make self-hosting harder. Spam has zero cost basically also. Nobody trusts email anymore for anything confidential, it's become a clumsy notification service "come check our portal for your real email".
It's time for a new protocol with end to end encryption and sender verification built-in. That shouldn't be as hard as it sounds, because at the time when email was invented the internet was very different. Connections were intermittent, for example I would retrieve my email once a day with UUCP (and some other people would use batched-SMTP). Which means you could not rely on the sending and receiving server being able to communicate directly. In this day and age this is possible and that direct communication opens up a lot of better crypto like key generation algorithms which require both parties to be online at the same time.
The problem is, is you don't allow corpos you will break 95% of mainstream people's usecases. So I think this is a non-starter, unfortunately, though it is a lofty goal.
You can already do this without changing anything. Just set your corporate mailserver to not accept mail from common community email providers. There's a reason nobody does this, and it's because it's a bad idea.
There is so much crossover between personal email and corporate email.
My previous employer did this, and no one seemed to miss it. If you had a use case to add an exception (the most common was to send yourself a mail from your personal Gmail, to print something on the corporate printers) that was supported and straightforward too.
One solution would be whitelist only. You must specifically whitelist a domain or email address, and everything else is blocked. If someone wants to send you an email, you must get their email address.
However, if you are using it to sign up for a service online, the domain often does not match the sender. You might sign up at the example.com website, but you get an email from noreply@auth-example.com as the email address.
No, email is the only digital communication left where I can talk to normie relatives AND businesses without having an account on normie tech service. DMARC does not impede that at all and it not a valid cause to throw away this lucky artifact of computing history.
You can't solve a social or political problem with a technical solution. Whatever you invent, Microsoft and Google will still collude to block you and not each other.
This inability to adapt is inherent in the corporate business model. Look at Apple. They have a chicken that lays golden eggs. Then the chicken dies. Oops. So they invest in speculative funding of massive proportions. Just ask AI and it will tell you.
Maybe there needs to be some other form of business that can do better?
reply