It is incorrect. They are not plants. I am curious why you think it is correct to call protists plants? It is not just taxonomy, but ecology, life history, tissue structures, and so much more. Some plants do photosynthesis. Some algae do photosynthesis. Not all things that do photosynthesis are plants. Not all things that do not do photosynthesis are not plants.
Presumably because "plant" was a word used to describe all sessile, photosynthesizing organisms visible with the naked eye long before we developed sophisticated enough tools to scientifically separate sea-weed from other plants.
Also, I'm not an expert, and I know Wikipedia isn't the most authoritative source, but https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant#Alternative_concepts seems to suggest that green algae are, at least at times, scientifically considered the parent group of land plants. So there's that, too.
Well, I am an expert. And ya, the “parent group”, sure, but we all have common ancestors though. So by that line of reasoning, I guess you are a plant?
Anyway ya plants evolved from protists. What other groups of organisms do we lump together based on an 19th century understanding of the world? I am amazed by people’s ability to warp the world to their priors rather be bothered to update them.
> What other groups of organisms do we lump together based on an 19th century understanding of the world?
Ooo, I know this one! Fish! Also, trees.
People love to annoy people with the fun fact that palms aren't true trees, but are actually grasses (hell, grass probably is one too), as if tree doesn't just mean "Fairly rigid plant that will usually grow taller than humans." It's useful to have words to describe categories of organisms based on how they appear to us and their relationship to us (say, "gut flora"), even if they don't describe coherent clades.
Sometimes it's important to know that a screwdriver was developed separately from a hammer and really has a very different purpose and theory behind it, and sometimes it's important to know that they both go in the toolbox because they're both things you hold and use on other things to attach things together.
My hot take is that just because a term develops a more specific, scientific definition doesn't mean that the existing colloquial definition is wrong, it's just a different use of the word. It's ok for you to disagree with that, but it's strange that you're so very dismissive of the idea.
Your friends’ botany joke is lame. Tree was never taxonomical, only a growth form or “habit” in older parlance. Plenty of individual species grow as trees or shrubs and many genera have representatives from forb through tree. There is no true tree.
The thing is if all you know is that the screwdriver and hammer go in the toolbox, you lack a functional knowledge of those tools and therefore the skill to use them. I for one am confident that you are capable of understanding that while plants and algae are both living organisms, they are functionally, ecologically, evolutionarily, and taxonomically different. The layperson so married to their colloquialisms need not worry about too much detail, yet may benefit from the knowledge that algae are not for bashing nails and plants are not for driving screws. Alas you may wish to know which of the sea you may eat raw or which might seasonally give you a nut flour. Or you may more easily grasp the functional and ecological role of microalgae, armed with the background understanding of their distinction from trees and grasses, should you encounter those creatures. And I hope you do, since you are relying on them to live.
In any case, in my experience, the greater people’s understanding of natural history and their ability to name the organisms in their environment, the more likely they are to see, appreciate, and value the rich mosaic if life around them. The benefits of that are grand for the individual even if they don’t bother connecting the dots on the science.
Colloquialisms are great. But suggesting we all permanently adopt and maintain a state of ignorance because a certain subset of humans had a term, I dunno.
"Tetrapods are descended from fish, so in a break from the long tradition of grouping all fish into a single class (Pisces), modern phylogenetics views fish as a paraphyletic group that includes all vertebrates except tetrapods. To treat fish as a monophyletic group, one would have to classify tetrapods as a clade/subgroup of specialized fish, which would make "fish" and "vertebrates" synonyms."
Hm. I don't think there is anything wrong with having terms defining paraphyletic groups. I don't think we need to treat fish or plants for that matter as a monophyletic group necessarily in order to avoid misinformation. The group that includes algae and plants is monophyletic after all, but I don't know what that has to do with the original point.
"Are algae plants?"
"Yes."
Is incorrect. That it once stood as the best available information is interesting but not relevant to the veracity.
That this feels like such a representative statement is disheartening. Remember, in a functioning free-market (behold. bow.) negative externalities, like socializing the burden of reduced air quality resulting from for-profit enterprises, are considered inefficient (boo. hiss.) and deleterious. Even people with jobs have to breath air.
Of course there is a cost to everyone and the cost is dirtier air. Articles like this don't mention or strongly deemphasize the fact that everything is a tradeoff and a recession or stagnation of growth has horrific consequences as well. No one sees the jobs and welfare that could have been created if environmental regulations were less onerous.
light penetrates in useful intensity for photosynthesis to about 200m so that seems like a decent cutoff for "deep sea" for the purposes of discussion around the unique communities there
Except that much/most of the life in that top 200m regularly commutes into the depths in pursuit of food/shelter/temperature. We all like sea turtles. Leatherbacks regularly dive to well over 1000m.
The article is presented as propaganda and the media format is trash but it raises good points. Still it fails to point out growing use of insect, plant, and byproduct feeds. It also fails to mention that feed conversion ratios in farmed fish are better than any of the land animals commonly farmed, so overall i/o is about as sustainable as it gets for animal husbandry. We also fail to recognize that forage fisheries have short generation times and are easier to measure, so maintaining healthy stocks is easier than trying to do the same with wild caught pelagic fish. Sustainable fisheries are beautiful resources. When managed and informed properly they can afford more production than would otherwise happen under maximum exploitation. They require science based management and compliance of course. But there are a lot of success stories as we have adopted fisheries science and I find it annoying that these articles send people to despondency rather than to grounding their consumption choices in science.
The research project they linked in the article [1] talks about 700 sardines needed for 1 farmed salmon which is not a great i/o but supposedly there's a shift away from fishmeal towards soy, algae, insect protein, etc to where fishmeal is more like 15% of farmed fish diet. Note these are wild fish as input so the notion of farming distinct & preserving wild stocks isn't accurate. Per the comments, there were plenty of NYT readers who were not aware of the downsides so I'm not as critical about it as you. Besides yield there's other considerations like disease spread and genetic degradation to wild stocks, sealice, pollution spillover, and so on.
I hear you. But 700 anchovies per farmed salmon is not meaningful without considering the number of sardines per wild salmon. Eating higher in the food web costs one way or the other. It is all about relative impacts of producing food people want to eat.
> How does the value of LLM-produced 100% branch coverage compare to no-LLM 100% branch coverage?
This is such a salient question. Sometimes (definitely not always) the test suites produced by LLMs are so trivial it's scary. Coverage can be an illusion for sure.
I have been seeing such trivial shit getting submitted and deleting them from the test suites, but it's disheartening to see that the devs didn't have the better taste to see those LLM "tests" are so trivial they border on noop before submitting them...
What new or existing metric would better assess test coverage than line coverage and branch coverage?
I wrote a tool called tert - I guess it's called an agent harness now - to run various test runners and log test output and coverage output to disk. FWIU stripping spaces from JSON does save tokens. It seems like feeding coverage lines-missing maps into the prompt results in better output, better LLM-authored tests.
"Refactor these tests for maintainability and coverage. Use fixtures, mocks, and parametrization"
You can write tests that cover every line/branch without actually verifying the code does what it’s supposed to. Relying on (unreviewed?) LLM written tests that provide coverage may not be a great idea.
We try to use types as much as possible. And if we can't, then lint rules, etc. Basically, get everything as far left in the SDLC as we can.
And, if/where we need tests, we write the source so they are few, high value, and complementary. Like actual unit tests, not complex with stuff like mocks just to generate trivial coverage.