HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | sumo89's commentslogin

The thing about the Google AI overview that I find most baffling is how self-defeating it is. You kill the traffic to sites, the sites die, now you don't have anything for your AI summary to pull from. Also Google is an ad company, they're literally removing their own revenue sources by reducing clicks.

They know, they've always known. There was a post years ago back when AI was emerging from one of google SEO public relations people who basically articulated that what's happening now would kill the ad supported search model they'd been running since google was founded.

The issue is, OpenAI came on the scene and forced their hand. If Google doesn't do what they're doing then OpenAI or Anthropic becomes the new google search.

So they must adapt or die.

As to how new information gets into the LLM's, my guess is instead of being on the web it gets split up across multiple places. Youtube for edutainment, apps for controlled access to relevant specifics, but ultimately there will no longer be a single openly accessible text version of new information anymore because all the incentives to create something like that are gone.


Google's stock actually crashed because costs are up and ad revenue is down specifically because of the search results AI, but they still haven't learned.

Learned what? If that overview wouldn't be there people would just flock to Anthropic or ChatGPT even more than they do now.

Search and Ads on websites are getting eaten alive by LLMs. No one knows how to properly monetize AI search yet but VC funds don't care they keep pumping money into OpenAi and Anthropic

So either Google has to cannabalize their search revenue or get eaten by OpenAI and Anthropic while they figure out how to turn a profit.


The few times per week I still use google search, I basically have very specific questions and follow the link to the source...

Not to mention it costs them many times more to serve AI overviews than just traditional search results

"lying about their incomes" What? Say you don't understand the prime mortgage bubble without saying it.


Subprime mortgages were subprime because there was no documentation given to prove incomes/debt of the people they were given to.

The people who defaulted on their mortgages did so because they couldn't afford them. The reason they got a loan that they couldn't afford was because they lied about either their income or their debts while getting the no-doc loans.

The failures in process that led yo the industry allowing people to lie to them without verification is another part of the story but it's completely dishonest to act like the people getting the loans they defaulted on had no agency.


"The reason they got a loan that they couldn't afford was because they lied about either their income or their debts while getting the no-doc loans."

No, they were offered loans at incredibly low rates that would be unaffordable if they rose at all. A large part of the scandal was about how the banks were offering loans to people that couldn't really afford them not that people were lying to get those loans.


You aren't the target for arguing the SEC should delay the IPO, it's for investment vehicles like pension funds that take down the whole economy if they crash.


Pension funds don’t even need to wait for IPOs to invest in companies, and they have actual investment experts on staff, so I don’t really think that’s a major worry.


Then they shouldn't invest, no? That is the rational choice for them. When you are not sure and do not have an appetite for gambling, you move on.


If you want a recommendation I really like Merrell Agility Peak's or for something less run-y, the Moab.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: