HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | strogonoff's commentslogin

Ironically, naive physicalism may just be an expression of repressed religious impulses—people whose ancestors until now uncritically believed in %DEITY% simply transferred the sentiment onto the natural sciences.

Of course, natural sciences were never intended to make statements of objective truth; in that, it is orthogonal to and perfectly compatible with religion (many esteemed physicists were Christians). The whole scientific process is about making predictions of what would happen if you did X, observing an experiment, and coming up with known-wrong models as shortcuts to making more predictions. However, if you squint just right, those models seem like they just state facts (there’re atoms, and they are like little balls clumped into molecules! and because neurones fire, you feel things!)—much better than what philosophy could offer, which is mostly more questions for a mind starving for definitive answers.

So, just as their ancestors uncritically believed in %DEITY%, these STEM fans end up misinterpreting natural sciences as another religion and uncritically adopting the philosophy of naive monistic physicalism (which rhymes the most with physical models as yet in vogue) as their belief, even if it is about as scientifically unfalsifiable as belief in God, a world of ideas, or other imaginary nonsense.


Its the opposite. Religion starts on deliberately unverifiable absurdities as a reauired article of faith. Natural sciences deliberately tries hard to probe its limitations and find minimal axioms.

Physicalism or dualism or any other system may depend on certain axioms at its base, but religion fails to even put a fight at this level as a lot of it contradicts simple observation,.quite aside from thorny problems that might require getting into the weeds of metaphysics. Physicalism has yielded success after success for millenia. Anyone objecting to it has to show why they might win a bet thats been losing for millenia.

Regarding dualism like systems, idk they could be self consistent but even in descartes times arguments against certain formulations were made thats equivalent to asking today first disprove the conservation of energy.

Religion doesn't even try to begin being a serious philosophy of the universe by design. The natural sciences have conquered everything as of yet people thought was beyond it, thats not a religious belief thats a simple observation of millenia of past success thus requiring anyone betting against it to be the failing side until they can show some proof.


Religion exists at a similar plane to philosophy, in that it is within the scope of both of those to attempt to answer the “why”. The lines between some religious and philosophical views can be blurred, and—just like in religion—philosophical claims such as monistic physicalismc monistic idealism, whatever flavour of dualism, etc., are fundamentally unfalsifiable.

Natural sciences, meanwhile, only concerns itself with what’s falsifiable, does not care about the why, and as such does not conflict with either religion or philosophy. A number of prominent physicists are/were Christian because the fact that experiments show this and not that is more or less orthogonal to questions like “what is all this really”, “why do we exist”, “what is a good life”, etc.

Betting on one against the other is only possible if one either moves natural sciences to the rank of religion or moves religion to the rank of natural sciences.

Natural science doesn’t deserve the former. Even though it has its uses, it tends to fail miserably on things concerning humanity and human flourishing (unsurprisingly, because all models are imperfect maps, and a map tends to fail miserably for the purposes of understanding the map-maker).


You are forgetting one thing. Any philosophy has to answer to thr universe first. Some forms of religion and some forms of dualism are simply wrong without even going to metaphysics such as the kind followed by descartes as it violates the laws of thermodyamics. If it can't even do that, it has failed long before we may discuss metaphysics. The fight doesn't even reach the level of metaphysics before its lost in many cases.

Many people believe in many things, scientists tend to keep a different standard for religion than for their professional job. Its more of an acculturation than independently verifiable fact. If we reset humanity there is no guarantee the same religions will emerge again, but the same mathematical and physical laws will be rediscovered in some form.

Even if tested for human flourishing and human organization, religion has done mass murders and genocides. It is very clear which system causes blatant and destructive failures. Religion has failed miserably on your own criterion of human flourishing. The only meaningful chaange it did was mass murders whereas natural sciences have literally given life and improved life for millenia via medicine, agriculture, etc. No religion gave us the haber bosch process which avoided agricultural collapse for humanity. So if you have to claim religion is best equipped to aid in human flourishing then what are these?

At most you can say natural sciences axiom is the universe as far as we have seen continues to work as it did previously. Religions make far more absurd claims such as an infinite being who jealously watches everything you do. I don't know many religious people who deny the existence of a god of this sort, which is again not a metaphysical claim when they claim various supposed laws and rules this figure asked for. It is very much a physical claim, and one that no religion has yet been able to prove. If its wrong on such blatantly fundamental things, how couls you be sure it has meaning in other questions? You are playing a double game where religion gets to be just metaphysics outside of the level of natural sciences but also ignore that religion wants to play the physical game too and ties the moral views to the phsyical claims it makes. Religion can't have it both ways.


There is no need to hedge against accidentally coming off as luddite. We could all use a refresher of what it actually was, as compared to how it tends to be taught.

Luddism is often mistaken for irrational or uneducated “progress bad”, “screw technology”, “destroy machines”. In reality[0], many of them actually operated those machines (there is no dichotomy between “use technology” and “be a luddite”). Luddists were much more along the lines of “let’s be careful about progress”, as they attempted to negotiate with powers that be that while machines are used, humans are not fully superseded—crucially, keep earning livelihoods and feeding their families. If the other side refused to negotiate, machines could be destroyed in protest, and powers that be generally hanged protesters who did that.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddites#Peak_activity:_1811%E...


Beautiful essays are still written, LLMs be damned.

Luddism is often mistakenly looked down upon as “progress bad” and “screw technology, destroy machines”.

In reality[0], luddists were much more along the lines of “let’s be careful about progress” and “let’s negotiate that, while machines are used, humans are not fully superseded, keep earning livelihoods and feeding their families”.

If said negotiations fail, it does become “destroy machines”, but the way it tends to be taught to us, unsurprisingly, skips a crucial detail.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luddites#Peak_activity:_1811%E...


Words are a communicable but ultimately lossy map of reality, experience of which we cannot otherwise convey; if the goal, the final artefact is itself a map (e.g., a thesis), using writing at earlier stages is, in a way, beginning to sketch out said map.

We are social creatures, and wanting to impress fellow beings is part of the reason why we do original things.

When you made something public domain pre-LLMs, you generally could expect people to give kudos to you.

With LLMs, if you make something public and an LLM gobbles it up, not only you get zero credit but you also can’t convincingly claim to have come up with it (since anyone can just assume you used an LLM), and neither can anyone else (even if they have come up with it fully independently).

If you don’t seek any recognition for your original work, then that’s fine, but I suspect you might be in a minority.


I guess nobody is going to create or get recognition from anything new starting from today until the end of the world?


The world is not black and white.


I mean if information is decentralized, this is not far from the truth. Historically attribution was given because you could synthesize or create information in a way others could not, and it was useful to be able to trace things back to the source.

Now everyone can create everything, and the source is shared. You are adding to the pile of human knowledge and it gets processesed, that's it.

If you step aside and think about it from a holistic perspective, imagine a research project to find a cure for cancer, or the best compression algorithm, or whatever.

Who will find the solution faster:

1) Entities work in isolation, produce their results, gets attribution, and then it's integrated into other work.

2) Entities work in parallel, dumping their findings and work into a big pile that is continuously parsed and built upon.

The second approach does not discriminate partial or bad results, it does not place value on a specific contribution. It might be that two entities did partial solutions that only make sense together, and this is able to be synthesized on the fly.


Every documentary is inevitably deceiving; the only difference is whether the author tries to hide it.

> Very early on, I worked out that one of the most stupid things that they do on television is these things called cutaways or what used to be called “noddies” where, when you cut an interview with someone, you insert a noddy of the reporter looking noddingly at the interviewee to disguise the cut.

> I would never do that. I just cut and you can see what I’m doing, that I am actually cutting this person, or I will use music to push my argument.

> I mean, I have arguments and I have stories. That’s what television journalism has and you can either dress it up as “this is the absolute truth” or you can dress it up with me by saying “look, I’m telling you a story, all this is true but have you thought that it could be like this?” to provoke you.

> And of course I want people to agree with me because, you know, all human beings will, but I understand that my job is to push and good journalism should do that especially at a time of uncertainty.

> At the present moment, to go back to my original point, you know what you’re going to get with most journalism. So therefore you sort of switch off and you go “oh yeah, it’s a climate change film”. “Oh yeah, it’s a ‘bankers have done something ever bad’ again.” Therefore, you don’t look.

> It’s like if you’re showing a picture of the Mona Lisa. You don’t look at it. You just look at it as a pattern. You go, “oh, that’s the Mona Lisa”. I don’t know when I last looked at the Mona Lisa. I don’t think I ever have, because it’s a thing. And so much of journalism is a thing now.

— Adam Curtis


Benn Jordan analysed social media bot activity[0] a while back, and if the recent UK right-wing party social media engagement drop[1] after the Ukrainian strike on Yandex data centres is not enough then what is?

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZ5XN_mJE8Y

[1] https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/reform-figures-se...


[1] very clearly just cherrypicked some particularly popular posts from before the Ukrainian strike, and some particularly unpopular and/or very new posts from after.

Show me some graphs! Some actual data! Not just the 6 exact posts necessary to make the point.


There is no clear line that differentiates an intelligent system from a non-intelligent system that just happens to do something in response to some external input, unless the definition of “intelligence” involves something specific to humans (including to other animals similar to humans, since we share many traits)—which is also why that is, arguably, the only meaningful definition.


To me there are two mutually exclusive positions, with respective corollaries: that LLMs are either

1) conscious and able to feel in a human-like way, and therefore deserving the rights and protections that we grant humans (and in most developed countries even some other animals), including freedom to learn or, indeed, protection from abuse and inhumane treatment, or they are

2) merely unthinking tools, in which case them deserving any of the above is a ridiculous notion, and in which case, incidentally, no one should be able to defend the mechanical processes of ingesting people’s original creative work and repackaging it for profit at scale as somehow being equivalent to the sacrosanct activities of human learning and inspiration.

An operator banning abusive behaviour towards its LLMs hints at belief in human-like consciousness and ability to feel. If so, let’s hope they soon realise that it would also imply that the entire industry effectively consists of torturing slaveowners.


I suppose there’s also some de-anthropomorphized version oriented around not poisoning training data (or, alternatively, the real world) with instances of AI abuse. I believe there is ample evidence that AI detect and categorize this behavior (an AI “pain vector”) and respond to it. It would be bad for AI development if that paradigm were entrained.

As I write this it’s very hard not to feel like a psychopath.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: