HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | strken's commentslogin

You absolutely can. Whenever you send a PR that you want approved to the guy who approves everything, you're embodying the Sociopath mentality just a little bit. If you do it because you want to push the fix and help your biggest customer you're being slightly Clueless, whereas if you do it because you need to go home to your kids you're being a Loser. (Have I mentioned I think the nomenclature is stupid?)

The archetypes describe basically everyone to some degree. They're like a zodiac sign or an MBTI dichotomy or an OCEAN axis.


On the question of tinkerers, I'm reminded of the man who just copy-pasted the middle layers of an LLM on top of each other: https://dnhkng.github.io/posts/rys/.

Turns out you can just do that!


It sucks because of the input lag (for me). Probably the worst part (for me) is that 100ms of network latency is effectively random within a band of 50ms or so, which makes it difficult to compensate for and stops you building muscle memory as easily.

One can imagine a world in which Rust allows a `decidable` block and code has stricter guarantees within it.

I imagine it would be a nightmare to work with.


Software “engineers” aren’t responsible for their code the same way professional engineers are. Yet, I’d prefer the embedded system for the supermarket freezer were a nightmare to work with, over a society that is a nightmare to live in because of “cyber.”

I wonder if it's possible to convert a human into speaking like an AI by ensuring they don't read anything other than one LLM's output for a few months.

I’ve been thinking about this a lot… How long until humans start speaking like LLMs

I think we're going to have a much weirder and more conflicted future than people realise, given that at some point all the world's democracies are going to be populated mostly by the descendants of groups which have a lot of kids.

Yeah, sure, maybe some of us will Wall-E into oblivion. People already do that with opiates and video games and it's reasonable to expect more might do the same.

Do we really think the Amish are going to do that, though? They might even ban AI from providing goods and services to them. And then consider the kids of the Amish, who are not all going to be Amish but who might learn a thing or two and pass it along to mainstream culture. Then do that for every group that's still reproducing.


It'll take several generations for this sort of effect to happen. Say 100 years. I wish we also had 100 years to adjust to AI and autonomous robots.


We likely have more than 100 years to adjust.


It’s literally happening right now.


The Amish are overrunning America right now? Because it can't be Africans or Muslims, America is still 73% white.


People who have kids are replacing/outnumbering those who don’t.


In a process that takes multiple decades. Not particularly relevant in a conversation about AI.


In this thread, where someone was claiming that the fast breeding religious/ethnic folks were replacing everyone or something, it’s extremely relevant.

Nothing is new here.


I was saying that any group which has a lot of kids is going to have a disproportionate impact on the future.

I very carefully did not say "ethnic" or "replace" because that's just the great replacement conspiracy theory, which is mostly wrong and not useful or interesting. One group that's still having a lot of kids is the rich: Elon Musk has 14 children. Another is sperm donors.

Instead of replacement, what's going to happen is that the political movements of the future are going to be increasingly framed around these groups. This includes opposition to them as well as support.

I said this in reply to a comment about how humanity would rally together and resist a Wall-E future where we do nothing except consume. My point was that there are already people out there who are resisting a Wall-E present day, and if mindless consumption becomes even more tempting then they're going to inherit the earth.


Only if you include old people.


Muslim is not an ethnicity.


High birthrates from backwater groups are canceled out by high technologically embracing groups having increasingly long lifespans.

The singularity happening should imply significantly longer human lives. Some might argue that the first “immortals” are already born.


They sell reliable cars with a good AWD system and drivetrain and decent ground clearance.

If they sold reliable PHEVs or even BEVs with 220mm+ ground clearance and some branding around torque and traction control, and they had any kind of advantage over Toyota in that niche, they'd probably do alright in the "I don't want a Land Cruiser BUT" market.

(Yeah, yeah, EJ head gaskets, just don't buy anything with an EJ series engine.)


I've got a 2020 XV (Australian Crosstrek nameplate) and it has relatively few annoying EU-mandated safety features.

It won't start unless I've done my seatbelt up, which is annoying when I'm e.g. driving in a cow paddock at 10km/h and trying to get through multiple gates, but it doesn't do lane assist or have a driver-facing camera or anything like that.


...are you sure that Claude Sonnet writes code that you'd write?

For me, it writes code that mostly works, which is great. It insists on adding some of the least readable comments I've seen. It also likes to pad out the code to about double or triple what I would write.

It doesn't seem to have that little voice that says "hey, this approach sucks" so it needs the harness or the prompter to tell it to go back and refactor. Even Fable and Opus struggle with this.


> It doesn't seem to have that little voice that says "hey, this approach sucks" so it needs the harness or the prompter to tell it to go back and refactor.

Well, yes. For humans, the "this approach sucks" voice is still very separable from the thought process that just figures out the syntax and algorithms etc. The important thing is whether the overall system has this feedback and that it's having the desired effect. Better harnesses are progress in the same way that more capable models are.

And yeah, there's a wide range in the standards that programmers hold, in practice. Plus they don't at all agree on what's "better" than which.


Regarding the "this approach sucks" voice, there's an important difference between humans and AI which I've noticed and which I didn't explain well.

The general human approach to programming at most companies I worked at prior to 2024 was to head off in vaguely the right direction and refine the approach as we went. There might be a design and a plan, but at some point we just winged it and fixed our work after the fact.

This seems to be the worst way of getting an AI to do anything. They do better if they can one-shot an implementation from a clear spec then only need to fix bugs. Better models can handle a less clear spec but they still can't really iterate in a major way. To have an AI model build a bigger thing, you one-shot increasingly detailed specs and decompose them into smaller ones.


I can only speculate, but my guess is that this limit is pretty fundamental, yeah. However capable the models get, they can't read your mind. The kind of iteration you have in mind is difficult because they don't have a basis to iterate upon; to the extent that they could pretend, that gets into what people have been calling "taste".

And even if they somehow got better taste, it wouldn't be your taste. If that were acceptable, why bother prompting anything in the first place? At that point the system might as well choose its own projects entirely. But I don't think humans would want to live in that world; even if not paperclip-maximized, we'd eventually become an underclass.

That's assuming basically unlimited capacity for the models to get more powerful. If there are limits (and I hope there are!) then it'd be even more certain that projects continue to require human guidance.

But even despite that, I hope I don't sound AI-psychotic if I suggest: the models are capable of at least assisting with that spec-writing and decomposition.


This is basically just being a manager in the before times. "My engineer said X!" "Well, mine said Y!"

Which is fine, whatever, I guess this is how I pay the mortgage off instead of having any clue what the hell Claude is actually writing. Hopefully I can semi-retire soon and go study dunnarts or take up welding or something else that's more rewarding than this nonsense.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: