HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | stetrain's commentslogin

The markets saw Nvidia as an increasing risk before the actual decision to fire him, so that doesn't seem to be the single incident causing uncertainty. That risk and uncertainty already existed whether or not he resigned or was fired.

I never claimed it was a single incident. Risk profiles are an ongoing metric that take in myriad factors. Some weighted more than others. Losing the co-founder and CEO of 30+ years would have a heavy weighting, causing uncertainty until a new CEO has proven the ship is steady. Of course, the potential AI bubble is a factor too. But, losing your experienced CEO just before a potential popping of said bubble is also an extra factor to add to the risk metric.

The share price slide happened before the resignation. Uncertainty, sure, but if the only change were that Jensen had not yet resigned as of today, that uncertainty would still not be resolved.

Wasn’t the story being circulated in advance of that?

The story of the affair(s) and the Chinese spy were, yes. My point is that those stories and uncertainty seemed to have done most of the share price damage so far. The actual act of pushing out Jensen resolved some of that uncertainty. If everything had played out the same but the board had not pushed him to resign, I'm not sure things would be resolved any better currently or in the near future.

There were talks from the first hour whether Jensen would survive this. That he was fired came as no surprise to the market.

Elon Musk has intentionally surrounded himself with companies that he controls or effectively controls via a board of friends and family. There is no one to hold him accountable for anything except the government, which is why he has been working so hard on gaining influence there too.

I find it interesting to see so much blame being directed at the act of removing one person who may have been holding up trillions of value in the stock market, rather than at the market and industry conditions that led to so much value being supported by one person in the first place.

I agree. I certainly don't believe in the efficient markets hypothesis. HN AI glazers certainly do though.

More modern battery chemistries are less hazardous as well. LFP for example is both cheaper and more stable, just at the cost of energy density. Which might be fine if you have a giant ship that can handle a large volume and mass of batteries to save on fuel costs.

TFA specifically said volume is the last thing a ship operator wants to sacrifice. Volume used for batteries is volume that cannot be used for cargo.

A huge amount of volume is already used for fuel and the engine. 2 million gallons of fuel for a Panamax is around 7,600 cubic meters.

A TEU is about 38.5 cubic meters. So that works out to about 200 TEU. A Panamax can carry about 5000 TEU worth of containers.

So all the fuel is about 4% of the cargo capacity.


Elon Musk has no accountability. He has effective control over the boards of his companies. Shareholders know that the value of their shares is predicated largely on this one man, so removing him would destroy their value.

Government could hold him accountable, and some of those gears have been turning over the last decade. In response he has spent a lot of money trying to steer elections and gain the influence of the ones in power to try to avoid accountability from that direction as well.

The double standard is that if you play capitalism well enough you are shielded from the consequences that others would face.


If a single person was keeping the market from a recession, then that itself is the issue, not the removal of that person.

not necessarily. One athlete's performance can be the difference between a team winning and losing. One general can make the difference between winning and losing a war. No risk also comes with the downside of no reward, artificially constraining high achievers so we dont become too reliant on them just means everyone is equally low achieving

Trillions of investment across people's retirement accounts being vulnerable to one heart attack, stroke, or car accident isn't resilient.

Or the publicity about the affair put a brighter light on the thing that was already "widely known" and increased the need for a response.

Those are effectively the same thing.

> Why, for example, all the Musk's "extravagances" are not ground for a CEO termination?

This has less to do with the relative social morality of his behavior, and rather that he has more control over the boards of his companies, and his personality represents a larger percentage of the perceived values of his companies.

Meaning that the desire and leverage for shareholders or the board to actually punish him is significantly less. Shareholders would potentially be evaporating trillions in speculative market value that is not backed up by Tesla or SpaceX's actual business fundamentals.

And any shareholders who disagree with his behavior have had plenty of time to leave and take their earnings by now, which means that the remaining shareholders are a self-selecting set who is okay with his behavior as long as it keeps making them money.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: