HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | staticman2's commentslogin

I thought the major benchmark companies always get advanced access to a model, which presumably is not done via bedrock.

For what it's worth, the median human is 31.1 years old. I wouldn't call something older than the median human "very recently, culturally."

> For what it's worth, the median human is 31.1 years old. I wouldn't call something older than the median human "very recently, culturally."

That’s cute. Now try searching for the median age in developed countries, where people care enough to make up revisionist history about minor culture debates? (nevermind, I did it for you; it’s around 50)

More to the point, what’s the human lifespan in first-world countries? (average lifespan in the US is almost 80)

(All this is a tongue-in-cheek way of saying that perhaps disparaging people for being older than you is not such a bright idea. I know it’s hard to believe, but we’re not going anywhere for a while.)


The person you're responding to isn't disparaging you. They're simply stating their opinion. That's all a judgment about whether something is recent can be.

Fine, that’s fair. It’s not explicitly disparaging, it’s just implying that facts older than you, personally, can remember are irrelevant. I don’t know what to call this, but none of the words that come to mind are positive.

Someone on a parallel thread explicitly called the 1980s “ancient”, so whatever.


Read the thread again. I think you've misdirected anger at GP (Skeletor guy) towards me and others.

I hope your day looks up.


The only thing I was "disparaging" was your grasp of the standard meaning of phrases such as "very recently, culturally".

You could have avoided the issue entirely by using clearer language like "in the last 40 years."

The idea that I was claiming things older than me are "irrelevant" is nowhere near orbit of anything I wrote.

(Also I don't know if you are American but I am and the median American is around 39.4).


I didn't use the phrase "very recently". You did.

I said the word is recent, linguistically and culturally. I said it was "fairly new". I also said when it was popularized, in terms of actual decades (70s-80s).

You've chosen to die on this particular hill of whether or not something is "recent". I don't know why.


As far as I can tell this conversation has gone on because you've also chosen to "die on this hill". Have a good day.

I'm calling the analogy police on you.

"He wrote it himself" doesn't analogize to "give a friend a ride".


Why did you write "scientific consensus"?

As I understood it science does not understand consciousness currently and it's entirely a philosophical matter.


I wonder why my consumer Gemini app has Argon and 3.8 flash with a pro plan but so many people here don't have that.

Is the issue that consumers get it sooner or is the roll out random or locked to some other factor?


I have Carbon in my consumer Gemini too. I have a Google drive storage upgrade that I pay for that I assume is bundled with it - it's the only thing I can think of as I've certainly not gone out of my way to do anything special to get access (and so far, it is free for me to access it this way)

In one case I had to upgrade my Antigravity GUI to see new models, I guess because of an API change.

At the same time, the CLI saw the new models without any change. Possibly that was just because my CLI install was newer than the GUI one. (Edit: oh, it's because my CLI autoupdates. Autoupdates for the GUI on Linux in an AppImage is... messy.)

Edit: But in this case:

> Gemini 4 Carbon is available via the API in Google AI Studio and Gemini for business for all paying developers and enterprises

I.e. Seems to be API only right now.


I found out when I opened Gemini app on phone and it showed Carbon Medium as default

Actual Pro plan have Argon. Pro plan through Promotional deal (like Jio in India), Trial, Edu plan don't have access to Argon.

In true google fashion the situation is a total mess.

The gist of it is that there are many different "Pro" plans, and the model access/quota depends on things like whether or not you are a workspace "Pro" user, whether or not you are a discount/promo "Pro" user, whether or not you are a 3rd party "Pro" user, and then also beyond all that what country you are in. Common examples of these gimped "pro" plans are Pixel "pro" plans that came with pixel purchases, and Jio "Pro" plans which are discounted plans available through a telecom provider popular in India.

But if you have a normal Google account, and pay the full $20/mo, and live in a country that doesn't have tight regulations, you'll get the proper Pro account.


Out of curiosity do you know if results would be better, the same, or worse if this was done from a harness?

You can simply ask Gemini directly what it knows about you.

That's brave. I can't help but wonder what dystopian things happen to our data behind the scenes, and what processing/blocks exist to display a different reality of the situation to us.

One scenario could be if they nudge it into answering the above question incorrectly, to encourage the user to correct it, especially where it triggers an emotional response. For example, getting their basic details wrong along with sexuality.


I meant to ask Gemini what it knows about you as a test to see if it has personalization on and if it is looking at your drive or email.

Gemini- if it knows anything about you- would be employing some sort of RAG- I didn't mean this as a test of what Google knows about you overall.


It's not scary at all unless you think stocks are a riskless asset expected to always go up and bonds and bank accounts are for suckers.

No, it's probably scary even for those folks.

Most obviously, the economy tanking usually means a recession and unemployment doesn't care what you're invested in.

The long-tail risk is that the US and China are heavily exposed to this risk, and the US gov't is already having to pay out more for bonds. A big hit to the economy could raise that even further, and we're not in the best state as a nation to tackle the intricacies of "we spend more than we can afford to, but we can't afford to borrow more money". That seems likely to end up where France currently is, and they appear to be trending towards a crisis.


Theoretically hedging would only work if the A.I. firms are not already priced for taking your job, right?

I have no opinion on whether they are.


I think they are actually underpriced relative to "taking away" jobs. I personally believe ant at 1-2T is pretty reasonable if you consider claude to effectively be the "best devtool of all time," aka it literally writes all software for you.

I think (somewhat arbitrarily), to get to higher valuations, you are going to have to disrupt more than just the software business. Which is what most labs are trying with finance, biology, chemistry, law, etc. That might be enough for a few hundred billion in TAM more.

I think to get to a ~5T+ valuation, then we have to start thinking about AI meaningfully displaces classes of jobs, maybe in the single digit %'s. As in, _global_ SWE headcount starts going down, but revenues for software companies as a whole go up.

I think for ~10T+, you definitely need meaningful job displacement across most white collar sectors.


Claude is in (potentially) a price war and research and development arms race with OpenAI and Google, and potentially other labs, so I don't think it's necessarily a given to price it as the company with the "best devtool of all time".

I'm being sarcastic as to the specifics but didn't productivity go down 199k because the 200k engineer is now replaceable with a 1k subscription and will soon be fired?

Literally the output of the labor dropped to almost zero value?


The subscription didn’t do any work though. It didn’t magically create a new knowledge worker any more than a lawn mower in a shed cuts grass. The output of the labor massively skyrocketed in value. If you fire that dev, who do you think will use Claude?

This instead is a concern for newer devs. There is now no argument for bringing on the cadre of workers you’d need to do all the hand-jamming, testing, and reviewing, learning how to code in the process.


> If you fire that dev, who do you think will use Claude?

The remaining 10% of devs that I don't fire. How much software do I really need?

Anyway, I know there are some flaws in my argument, it was just a thought experiment.


If you’re the CIO/CTO/etc. obviously you wouldn’t be fired, but any other position is useless down to the dev.

Dev teams should be leaner now, with maybe at most a director as their manager up to executive level.

As for ‘how much software do I really need?’ Well, what sort of company is it? Do you have internal applications to support your orgs? If you seriously need to ask ‘how much software do I need?’ Then you should just fire yourself.


I don’t think your point is meritless, but this is specifically a discussion about that top-10% dev. The one doing this type of work is not the one who will be let go.


I know a lot of people think that the AI tools level the playing-field, but we aren't experiencing that. The guy that did this translation is doing more tickets than the other 4 software devs combined. And it's not because they are low-effort tickets. That's also on top of the 6 hours a week of meetings he has that the other devs don't.


I wonder if seniors are all that safe.

Some bean counter will want to replace the principal devs with juniors since Claude can do all the work instead…


Productivity can be measured in many ways. Neoclassical economists will tell you there’s only one.

In this case, is the change of this software from one language to another/framework to another even valuable?

Example: if I manufacture $1,000 worth of some illegal drug that will potentially turn a normal functioning adult into an addicted criminal, how shall we measure my productivity?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: