HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | sshah03's commentslogin

Thanks! I have seen it, and honestly for a lot of use cases even just handing the session control of excel / sheets (via claude with chrome) does pretty well with how good computer & tool use has gotten. However for more complex runs I wanted the ability to compartmentalize the context, and continue independent sessions which is where stuff like numerous, or excel with computer use, or even excel with copilot would fall short for me.

Export does exist, and the citation does travel with the cell as a cell comment (should show up as a red triangle in the corner of the cell in Excel). This feature does need more testing.

As an alternative, I can provide a checkbox on export to have a "sources" sheet created in the workbook with references back to the cell if that works better.

If you do decide to use it, I'm happy to work with you to make sure the export works reliably. I haven't had a good test user for this yet.


Yeah, I like the red triangle approach. Let me figure out a use case in one of my projects and get back to you.

On reads, an agent gets a history of old and new values since it started running. For writes, unfortunately, for now it's just last write wins (though there are some guards, like if the user verifies a value an agent writes then it's locked from being re-written).

Nice! I am surprised it's not more common, but part of it is possibly that for the industries that use spreadsheets the most, copilot+excel does the trick.

What have your use cases for it been so far?


Not yet integrated, but embed at an independent auditor inside my product https://bettermenu.live/ so that users can verify the calculations.

I punt on this a little bit, in that to make it easier I don't allow actions that would cause issues with this when an agent is still running (insert, delete, sort rows etc...) because it's tough to handle for mid-execution.

However, in the other cases, references get rewritten the same way everywhere (whether it's a formula, or an agent's watch list), so {A3} becomes {A4} etc... everywhere with the same process. Also in that case, it doesn't get marked for needing to be "re-run" because it checks value itself is unchanged, even if the cell being referred to changed.

I've tested it quite a bit. Given all of the moving parts in a spreadsheet app there's still the possibility that given enough usage someone encounters some combination of moves where this fails, but I think if that does happen it should be a fixable bug.

I also provide a backup solution with "Named cells", basically off sheet cells that can be used for constants and such and referenced by name instead of by cell, if needed.


I think you could use named cells to fix the insert/delete row problem in general.

The named cell can have a trivial `=SheetName!a3`. Those will be automatically updated with insert and delete just like any other formula.

They can be referenced directly for reading, and for writing you can do a quick parse and find the original.


That's a good point. I can keep it separate from user named cells, but make sure everything has a unique identifier I track. Even a million cell workbook would really only add about 50mb of memory, so should be doable.

I'll play around with this, thanks for the idea!


Thanks! I do have some videos in the repo demonstrating what it can do; however, if from your experience building fluxcut you have some suggestions on what would make them more useful to people I'm happy to take them!

Both the animations and the content made it one of my favorite posts of the week. Hope you don't mind me sharing for you.

Happy to hear that! I don't mind at all.

Looks like they decided to spend a lot of time/effort on visual, and motion/animation abilities with Hy4. I wonder if they have a reason for targeting that or if it was just a response to Opus and Astra gaining a lot of attention for those abilities (or from distilling Astra?).

As I understand their WorkBuddy product is the most popular of its kind in China:

https://www.workbuddy.ai


Isn't it the equivalent of someone with a $1m networth spending $400? I think the value he got from his spend working out two years ago, makes it a calculated gamble that he won't lose sleep over. People keep bringing this up as a talking point a lot today and it probably doesn't matter.

It's not equivalent because $400M is an insane amount of disproportionate power and influence. In this specific instance it broke down likely due to the cultural zeitgeist and general dissatisfaction with costs and Trump but in a less tumultuous political environment, that amount of spending should always be corralled and limited.

If he actually had $1 trillion in cash, maybe. But he doesn't, the vast majority of his wealth is paper wealth. To spend that money he has to borrow, sell assets, or tap into whatever his cash reserve is.

This was resolved for me. The e-mails were a red herring and not the actual reason, not sure what's going on there that triggered those.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: