HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | spiderice's commentslogin

> but setting it up to do that work correctly and safely still takes skill

For now. Not sure why you think that would last though. Obviously the big labs are going to make it easy to use AI both safely and correctly. It's already significantly easier to do that today than a year ago.


> Not sure why you think that would last though.

The failure modes of the LLM are still the same. Nothing has fundamentally changed, despite the UI and the harness showing significant improvements and outcomes.


I almost never hit the failure modes of LLMs anymore, they have been getting much more reliable year over year.

More and more it would appear the failure modes are a training data issue


> I almost never hit the failure modes of LLMs anymore

Of course you do. Just because you don’t see the LLM trying the ls command for the billionth time with the wrong arguments, just to be corrected by the harness, doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen. Of course I use the ls cli as an example. Could be any task. That’s what I mentioned about the harness and that’s why they shine in the fields with hard verification mechanisms and feedback loops.


I actually use my own harness that doesn't attempt to fix broke tool calls. Yes models are not perfect and they do make mistakes, but my experience has been that reliability has been trending only upward. I really can't remember the last time I saw a tool call loop.

(this has been my experience since ~DSv4 from April)


> I actually use my own harness that doesn't attempt to fix broke tool calls.

It’s not the harness that attempts to fix the broken tool calls. It’s the LLM.

> last time I saw a tool call loop

We are not talking about tool call loops


I completely disagree. The AI tools I've used from the big shops are happy to code visible features, but need real restraint to keep things in order.

I no longer really check the code, but I won't let any of them touch the database schemas. I modify the schema, the machine codes around my database. Same policy with APIs, even private ones.


> but need real restraint to keep things in order.

I second this. Even OpenAI's flagship models... the code I write by hand has much less entropy and is easier to follow than the equivalent AI-generated code. I think part of the software engineering skill now is knowing which pieces you can delegate to AI and which still need human input. I know many people who just YOLO it all and have AI do everything... but, this can hardly make for a stable system in my opinion...

And, I'll be happy to be proven wrong, because it will mean a significant amount of work is off of my shoulders. But I think we aren't quite there yet in terms of having AI code that lowers the complexity instead of raising it in a codebase.


I hear you, and I agree with you. But the response to this by leaders at my company would be:

> Why are you looking at the code? Complexity? What do you care? Let the agent handle that.


> Why are you looking at the code? Complexity? What do you care? Let the agent handle that.

Because when I don't look at the code, bad things happen. Outages, customer data is deleted, security issues.

I can hear the reply: "Why not let agents review the code?" - that's true, but at some point my boss is going to hold me responsible, and I'm going to have to answer for it. Both ethically and practically speaking I have to make the responsible engineering decision and actually own my actions.


Those are good questions, why are you afraid of them? Answer them and move on. You do have a convincing answer, right?

Check back in a year. Time is going to prove you wrong.

Your trust in the big labs may be misplaced. What do they rent you? A black box that cannot be inspected.

If you actually start looking inspecting what the boxes do, it is a scary place. The Chinese models are open source open weights and are trained on lies. This much can be proven. But the frontier labs have made it impossible to determine the provenance of their models. They have been fed with copyrighted works, but good luck proving that your copyrighted work lives in their weights.

In short, the frontier labs are operating opaquely, and that's very good reason not to trust them.


> If you learn the fundamentals properly, then AI will be a power tool for you. If you don’t, then it will replace you.

I don't get why people keep repeating this as if we have any idea. How do you know AI will be a power tool to those that know the fundamentals? How do you know it won't replace those people anyway? Why is knowing the fundamentals of computer science going to be the thing that keeps people from getting replaced by AI? You're just repeating something that sounds catchy, as if that somehow makes it more true.


Yea I agree. It's not about the fundamentals. The only thing that will prevent you from being replaced is your ability to provide value. Does knowing the fundamentals make you more valuable right now? Probably. But it's not because you know the fundamentals, alone. It's that, chances are, if you know the fundamentals you can probably provide more value than someone who doesn't. You put in the effort to learn the fundamentals so with that you can probably learn other things faster. You probably have a better work ethic. Etc.

But not necessarily.


I think it's very true. You can do so much more with a calculator if you understand maths, same with programming and AI.

And a computer can do way more than you with a calculator, because its a computer.

The same applies to CS fundamentals, and AI. You can be the best calculator jockey on the block and as mathy as you want, but a computer gonna out computer you.

AI is gonna outprogram you, l33tcode is dead.


CS fundamentals is not leetcode.

Pretty sure for a lot of these leetcode hard problems you end up having to implement red black trees and weird graph algorithms. What other CS fundamentals are you talking about?

Anyways, you get my point; the AI is more likely to know about and choose a better algorithm / data structure / scaling architecture than you.

Maybe you found a distrbuted project it sucks at today. But I think it'll kick your ass next year, or maybe the year after that. Either way, it is coming for us programmers and we'd best just try to learn to ride the wave. My impression is how well we can automate things or moreso, get the AI to automate things for us and claim responsibility for the success.

It's all managerial skills now.


For me fundamentals include more than algorithms, for example how a computer/LLM works, history, philosophy, HCI, networking, security just to mention a few things.

Yeah, and I'm saying that your understanding of how logic gates, history, security, or networking, philosophy etc. will in no way help you use AI as a superpower.

HCI might help, because honestly there's a lot of human judgement in that, but AI will tend to try A/B test that out. It's good for sweeping changes.

The rest? I think it goes in the bin. It's cool to have built a 4 bit adder by hand, or understand wireline protocols, or how aleph one smashed the stack for fun and profit, but I suspect your understanding of fundamentals of a perceptron vs. a modern deployed attention head llm works are very very very different.


Education isn't just about learning how to use an AI. Good fundamentals should give you a foundation as to why you should (or should not!) build something and how it should be built. It should expand your horizon as to what is possible, and what harms you can potentially cause when building software.

Knowing how things work is just essential to be able to be critical and question just about anything. These AIs are built by companies with incentives and objectives, and you need to be able to be question them.


Again, how do you know this? AI is going to get better than you at every single one of the things you just mentioned. All of them. And not just a little better. Way better. So how do you know that you're tiny knowledge is going to give you an advantage at guiding the big knowledge?

The fundamentals you have shape what you think is important and what values you have. The less we know and the more we rely purely on AI, the more we concede to the values of whoever built the AI and the biases they chose to bake into it. There is no guarantee the AI will have "better" values, as there is no such objective measure.

Who is even to say that the future should just be us talking to AI? That might not even be environmentally sustainable. But again, without studying that you wouldn't know nor even care to begin with. The AI won't bring it up either, as it will just be completing whatever you tasked it to do.


To expand, I’d throw software engineering fundamentals in there. How to build software products on a team, and maintain them. If you don’t have that then it doesn’t matter how much code you can generate, it’ll all be garbage.

Yes product managers and such can build programs using AI. They cannot build software if they don’t understand how to design systems and how to deliver.

That’s not to say that product managers and such are screwed, they can learn. But code jockeys are similarly screwed if they don’t learn the big picture stuff.


I think you're right, at the moment software engineering is somewhat important because that's how agents work, but at some point instead of .md files it'll be machine readable agent code. Another language for in the llm-land FUBU.

The only skill that is going to have any value is social ability, which is going to suck for the huge percentage of computer people that have autism.

It's because doing high quality work requires deep understanding. It's that expertise that lets the user prompt accurately enough to hit the right spot in the model's vector space. That model _has_ the expertise, but it manifests only by giving it the right inputs, which differ across tasks.

No, it really isn't. If you think a 0.1% of writing being "poisoned" is going to trick AI, you're wildly underestimating AI's capabilities.

Research showed AI training could be poisoned by as few as five documents in a training set of millions.


Oh? People keep parroting that but the small detail missing is that there needs to be enough volume of correct information to counter your adversarial disinfo. Otherwise the LLM is one agentic call away from stating it as fact.

Has anybody argued against your second point? Feels like a straw man.

Oh god forbid you commit a "social faux pas". Way better to stick to the approved messaging.


It's ok a lot of places. Consenting adults gonna consent.

Perhaps you should get your comments peer reviewed then? Because between you and the author, only one of you made a fool of themselves, and I quite enjoyed the article.

I guess you just peer reviewed my comment then, thanks.

> I fucking hate Musk, I didn't use to

Yeah no shit. You started hating him when you learned that he voted differently than you lol


Considering he's personally responsible for the deaths of over a million people across Africa and Asia, most of them children, and that his motives largely seem to have been 1) preventing legitimate investigations into his companies and 2) white supremacist domination, I'd say that his voting pattern is the least of my concerns.

Nobody normal believes this though, just Reddit/Bluesky/conspiracy type websites.

You just presented the argumentum ad populum fallacy:

https://www.logicalfallacies.org/argumentum-ad-populum.html

And you claim that a top professor at the Harvard School of Health and Pulitzer-winning journalists are "conspiracy types". So, no, your position is not credible.

https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/usaid-shutdown-has-led-to-hund...

https://healthjournalism.org/blog/2026/07/how-pulitzer-final...


You've fallen for the "appeal to authority" fallacy where a single credentialed person believing something makes it true.

There are 1000 credentialed scientists. 999 think X. 1 thinks Y. One cannot say that Y is true just because that scientist has qualifications.

You are welcome to your beliefs and should be free to express them, but not free from criticism of them if they are on the outer fringes.


Go ahead and present evidence to the contrary. I'm listening.

That's... not how any of this works? You're the one making extraordinary claims, therefore it's you that needs to prove extraordinarily strong evidence. This is Conspiracy Theory 101 stuff.

Nope, this is glaringly obvious to any half-educated person.

Do you think the world spends billions on public health for shits and giggles? What do you think happens when you stop providing basic vaccinations and life-saving healthcare to tens of millions of people?

You have provided no theory or explanation that supports your alternate reality in which parasites exit the body willingly, infections manifest their own antibiotics, and contagious viruses eradicate themselves. Yet somehow, you believe this. So go ahead. Make any attempt at supporting this insane conclusion.


For me, it was “pedo guy” that made me wake up to what a piece of shit he is.

Voted differently? No idea who he votes for.

Perhaps it had more to do with, erm, you know, his history of attacking people, mistreating workers, spreading misinformation, promoting far-right conspiracy theories, misleading investors, and using his power to interfere in politics and even international conflicts ...

And that's just clearing my throat ... horse trading? disowned by his own children? comments by his ex-wives, the list is endless, actually ...

The guy's evidentially a twat.

Fool you once, shame on him, fool you 25,429 times ... shame on you.


First of all, I'm not American, so I don't vote in the same elections.

And second of all, I'm from a society where people don't instantly hate each other because of most of their votes.

I always assumed that Musk was a centrist liberal but with libertarian or maybe cooperatism right wing view on economics. That didn't make me hate him.

When he started to full on spiral down the alt-right pipeline, and started to re-tweet every bit right wing conspiracy nonsense, absurd lies and slander about immigrants and transe people. That's when I started to hate him.

And even more when double and tripled down.

And then even more when he literally trie to do private negotiation with Putin because he know better then everybody else trying to sell the Ukrainians down the river just so he could be the hero.

And then even more when he literally does Nazi salutes like a 14 year old edge lord and pulls the 'its just a joke' haha bullshit.

And then even more when he spends 100s of million, more then any other donner in US history, trying to literally outright buy himself political position like magic the gathering cards, as if democracy was his to simply own whenever he wanted.

If you don't hate him after this, just because 'he votes republican' then you are almost certainly also minimally a facist and morel likely a neo-nazi or so brain-warped by politics that you should seek mental help.

I hope for you its the second thing.


Culture wars come up in every Gleam thread. How often do you see culture war comments in a Rust, Elixir, Javascript, Etc thread? Essentially never. The Gleam founder's bigotry is a distraction at best.

I dunno about the others, but the icon for the Rust discord is the Rust logo superimposed on the pride flag, so they are not subtle about their position on the topic, and it has therefore been a topic of discussion in that community.

The reality of online spaces is, you can either make Nazis aware they're not welcome at the door, or you can let them know when they start making trouble. Either way, if you want to keep your online community copasetic, eventually you have to tell Nazis to fuck off.


What bigotry?

I’m out of the loop.


They said smugly, before continuing to scroll Hacker News


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: