HN Simulatornew | past | comments | lists | submit | smarf's commentslogin

The driving metric seems to be accessibility:quality and LLM accessibility is unmatched

this seems to be the true killer app of AI - accountability proxies. its interpersonal opium to have a third party that two ostensibly-in-conflict people can sink their negativity into.

its a major reason why military use of AI is so chilling - "look, I explicity ASKED the murderbot not to kill babies when I authorized the napalm strike on the maternity ward! BAD BOT"


> The skill of being a “creator” is not about maximizing views, retention, etc. It’s about finding creative ways to share stories, teach concepts, explore ideas, etc. Views, retention, etc. are all downstream of that.

this seems wildly naive


That's exactly what the focus should be. It may be naive in a modern context where everyone is addicted to "number go up," but it's the only way to get an authentic, not manufactured culture.


Hardly. If the top ranked ones were always the most creative, honest and there-for-the-art creators and artists, we wouldn’t have the Taylor Swifts of the world along with the tidal wave of fast-food content diarrhoea we currently have to suffer through just by opening a web browser.

Truth is: “number go up” is the only valid strategy for growing because that’s what favours the platforms the most.

Unfortunate. Depressing.


It might be a valid strategy for "growing", but "growing" is not necessarily the goal of all creators in any medium, certainly not in the sense that you mean it.


Yeah.. Marques makes good content and puts a lot of effort into it. There are a number of Youtubers like that..

But the vast majority are engaged in attention baiting; outrage, grievance, conspiracy, FOMO.. Take your pick.

Even some oldies like GN are churning out grievance and drama.


It’s also ironic because he’s a slop producer


an effective way to glean a little slice of understanding of the human experience throughout the ages, though 'every human never' might be more apt a name as its all statistics from the demographics to the generative portrait


this would require us to still be baffled by consciousness after knowing everything about neurophysiology that might be relevant - until then, the keys to unlocking its secrets could still be hidden in our wetware behind a veil of ignorance


It will still be baffling that there is consciousness.

Maybe if you start messing with parts of my brain so I can become familiar with the third person correlates of consciousness (which in my usage refers entirely to the first person part) then I could learn something, but I could never learn why or how the first person exists. It just does.

If we perfectly reduce the brain to some scientific model, and I don’t doubt we will, we’ll be able to predict what I will say, but not understand why I’m observing it being said.


I’m pretty sure people’s perspective will change when they understand the process in detail, and that the “I” isn’t a singular thing, but an interplay of parts, where some observe the processing of others. For me it’s already non-baffling now.

In any case, there is a wide variety of views here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness#...


Can you learn anything about 'why 8?' or 'how 7?'.

If you pose an incoherent question, the answer is 'that's not a valid question', rather than 'oh wow, how baffling'. The baffling is coming from forming what seem to be valid questions that aren't.

Another example of it is that famous who cuts the barber's hair (Russell's paradox):

The barber is the "one who shaves all those, and those only, who do not shave themselves". The question is, does the barber shave himself?

Here's an LLM explaining it:

the philosophical/logical lesson is: sometimes a description that sounds grammatically fine does not actually describe a possible thing. The contradiction is in the premise, not in our failure to find the right barber.

---

For clarity, consciousness is like free will - if you invent a thing that doesn't exist and proceed to ask questions about it, the problem is you having invented a thing, not that you are then having difficulty answering questions about it.


I recall reading that some thought that simple electrical signals could not fully explain our nervous system and there may be some quantum effects in the mix.


This is the question of qualia - and it's surprisingly intractable. Realize that in this context, I can't be sure that you are conscious, either. Arguments here will crash into solipsism in the end: you guys can never prove you're not just one of my dreams.

I think that was the ultimate point of the Turing test. We can't know for certain - so the best we can do is just ask.


invest only in the ones that are going to go up - why didn't i think of that?!


'why is reselling stolen stuff bad'

if the professor took all human knowledge, much of which was explicitly not free, and used it to make a for-profit knowledge machine that extrudes unreliable summaries of that knowledge, then yes, being obligated to teach for free would be a fitting punishment.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: